They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (2025)

Table of Contents
TXT MD References

TXT

They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (1). . . . . . . . ia.J
u:c.Dn> Of' STIIJ.WATD COOJff'T-tiOCJUl(JIICS
l.[...]
They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (2)They Gazed on the
Beartooths
by

1964

They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (3)[...]COPYRIGHT

Content of this volume may be quoted, used or reprinted by a[...]ta.
However pennis ion must be obtained from the author in the event some
of the material should be utilized in a project or program that would result
in financial gain of any kind.[...]DITION

PR I TED IN THE U ITED STATES OF AMERICA
BY THE REPORTER PRI TING lit SUPP[...]

They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (4) TO THE PIONEERS[...]In ppr ·ati n Of Th ir ff rts.
They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (5) Table of Contents

Chapt r 1
E RLY HI TORY OF THIS RE ................[...]THE EMBRY0....7

Chapter 3
TOW Ir[...]91

hapt r
PH E O IE L PROJ E T OF MY TI C L KE. ............................[...]

They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (6)[...]..................... 107

Chapter 12
LEGE D OF THE STILLW TER.......................................[...]1
HERE \ AS THE DO 1 I OF THE GRE T '79"................................ 141[...]. · ........................219

hapt r 17
THE OF

They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (7)[...]ry difficult task to prepare an acknowledgment to the many fine people who
have o g nerously helped me in the preparation of this book, as well as recognize the sources
of information which have been used by quotes or possibly plagiarized descriptions. Despite
th fact that the territory included in the subject matter is small, nevertheless the history,
legends, etc., involves many names and incidents and places.

The greatest source of information has come from the files of the local papers, The
tillwater Bulletin (1893); Columbus Express (1 95); Tri-County ews (1901-1910); The Colum-
bus ews (1910-1964).

The "7'¥' story arises from many sources. I have seen and knew most of the cow
poke of the early days whose biographies are written herein-S[...]nes. From interviews or correspondence I got some of tlie facts of the
"dying day "operations starting about the turn of the century. This group included " osey" Ben
Cowen, Paul Case, Pat 01<ane, the Armitage boys, Johnny Bye, John Coston, Jack Mc a[...]knew ick Dickin on for 15 years, and saw him load the last
shipment of "7'¥' stock in 1915 from Merrill (and not withou[...]Mrs. Clara Brag , county clerk and recorder of Garfi Id County, where the last year
of th "79 w r pent on th Bi Dry gave me r fer nc s a[...]cowboy . Mrs. Gen va Highland not
only ve m fu u of h r fin book "Big Dry Country' but I profit d fro[...]uc-
c or to John Cl.c y) in pr vidin th al re ord of 1 93 and th John Clay letter. Hat
off to th infor[...]from th h atland . b tract
Comp ny. Of cour I u d th tillwat r b tract Company fil all th tim , with ry
m rnb r of it for co-op r ti~ with very demand. I appreci t[...]. op rat d.

t int r ting of my narrator was "Doc" el on th - ear old cod[...]lert. ac mat and bri ht a a doll r. H ga e m mo t of
of im and Bill Rob rt . nd furni h d the f ct for "Th y Call d It D ad I n'

I h r by apologiz for th hr vity of my r vi w ro, Indi n agenc having
more or l cover cl om of th event that h pp n d in th hort tim it e, i ted outh of
b arok e. My r ason for doing this i that prob bl more ha b en print d of thi tribe than[...]

They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (8)any other in the northwest. It would be impossible to comp te with th magnifi nt hi tory
of the Crows that was written and published by Mark Brown, lta, Iowa, in hi r c nt b ok
"The Plainsmen of the Yellowstone." Subject matter, or m ntion of thi Indian nation app ar
on nearly 100 pages of this historical book. Every phase of Crow lif find comment-habit ,
morals, intelligenc[...]ory and habita from
their earliest recognition by the "whites" until pre ent day location, inc1uding the fa t-changin
borders of their reserve is authentically described. Their a[...]some xciting and thrillin tori .
Anyone the least bit interested in the history of these red men should by all mean r ad Mr.
Brown's valuable, factual, praiseworthy summation of the Crows.

I got some material from the same sources as Mr. Brown; "Chronicles of th Yellow-
stone" by Topping; the Historical Library at Helena; and portion of the Lewi & Clark records.
"History of the Yellowstone alley" carries some data and vital statistics used; I also nitched
some of the material published in bulletin form by Dr. Thomas Marquis , as well as hi tory
of Tom LaForge, a close friend of Bill White and Col. llen. The anders "Hi tory of Montana"
published in 1885 carries much of the statistical data used. Lindermann's "'Plenty oup[...]nd there is considerable self ati faction in the fact that I knew per onaUy and a
intimately as any kid can, e ery on of th pion er biograph d in thi volum ·[...]on rabbit or
sage hen for om of h r \ ond rful \I l h cak or coo[...]lab I d "Jirah 11 w h
out of of hi poem , \! hil I publi h d the olumbu I had m __ ·
Major to , ome of the arly r rvation information i cr dit d. I
Billy" H[...]" in bu , nd I a b r of
ho ' quart tt that ang \ h n[...]lo a1
chapt r a grant d olumbu org niz r of th impro d rd r of cl M n. Th horn
tepe wa n m d "Pl[...]lu
tribution in th ourc of information and ad ic , for[...]. P. ath
"Handbook Of The Y llo

, nd o to each nd ery one of you eontrihutor . and to tho who[...]

They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (9) Chapter 1
EARLY HISTORY OF
THIS AREA
So much has been written, authentically, of the it was the property of, and controlled by the r d men.
explorations of Montana in general, and the Yellow-
stone valley in particular, that it would be imprac- The success of the L ewis & lark journ y did,
tical to review it, except briefly, and only concerning however, open the yes of th nation on th e great
this immediate area. In 1641 DeSoto, on the Pacific orthwest. Immediately behind th em came v ral
coastline, claimed it as a colony for the Spanish em- other "safaris" into th Rocki s,[...]Long, Colter and others duplicat d th trail of 1 06,
crossed the Rocky Mountains after having ascended but did not turn out as succ ssfu1ly as their sponsors
the Missouri River from Fort Berthold and estab- had hoped. But th e knowl edge of this country did
lished a claim to this great wilderness in the name attract more and more trappers and hunters , and the
of France. In 1762 this extensive region was ceded wolvers, the buffalo hunters and th e fur seekers rap-
to Spai[...]tab-
France. apoleon Bonaparte sold it to the United lished along the Yellowstone, th e ear1y ones b ing
States for fifteen million dollars and the deed to The at Fort nion and Fort H nry at th mouth of th e
Louisiana Purchase was signed in December of 1803. Yellowstone, but non came upstream b[...]mouth of the Big Hom, which after many trial
The first successful expedition sponsored by the prov d to be the extr m limit of navigation for
U.S. was known as the L ewis & Clark. These offi- steam propell[...]d to
cers left St. Louis pril 8, 180~ and reached the send in troop to prot ct th trading po t , and
great falls of the Missouri June 14, and the conver- ubdu Indian upri ings, but a a matt r of fact th
gence of the three fork of that river on July 27. hi tory of the Y llow ton wa not one of mat rial
After naming these forks the Gallatin, Madi on and progr s until th nd of th i ii War, a far a
Jefferson, they navigated the last named as far as xploration from th[...]t th
they could go, and by eptem b er had crossed the or party.
Rockies to the Columbia. On 1arch 23, 1800., they
started on the[...]they divided into thr partie - a of xploring th a
one took th north line along th 1 1[...]y that had gon back w vithin a pan of O ii a
down th e Mi souri.[...]d to be · Bould at
The third party took a r ute that put th m on Riv re tar t. L d
the Yello\! stone and thu tarted th hi tory of the th y ar am llow to h d
Y llo\! tone all y. Th notes of th party r ad that of owder Rh ing , hich he folio cl
they sp nt a \ eek in the vall y about wh r Young to its confluenc[...]am to th
Point i located, and h w d boats from the giant mouth of th Ton at ~1ile th nc to
cotto[...]r w along th river. Th y joined th mouth of the Ro Riv r r yth. II
th other groups at the mouth of the llow tone in wa a port man and h[...]nting o good that arri d a long tim " until
the ntire trip they lost but one man from illne s h got ick of th port and , nt ba k to t. Loui ,
in 1 04.[...]and adven- In 1 3, on pril 9 a party of 15 men , 1 cl by a1 -
turesom white o-call cl mou[...]ewis & lark but they w r
few and far betwe n, and the ' llow ton ou ntry explore a portion of th e Ycl low ·ton ar a for th
was th e source of great profit to the hard wre - purpo of di overin g gold min and locati11 ~ town
t[...]
They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (10)2 THEY GAZED ON THE BEARTOOTHS

plendid growth of cottonwood and the valley opened and how important a part thi[...]les in width, "with good soil and plenty in the rapid expansion of our natural resources after
of room for farming." (This was the same area where the railroad came through. In that publication, in
the Clark boat had been made.) May 5 they were[...]n to a general history is a section devoted to
at the mou th of the Big H om , and the expedition biographies. Yellowstone was one of the 14 counties
a cended thi river. Here the Crow Indians attacked, at this time, bordered by Gallatin, Meagher, Fergus
tole and hara ed the party with such continued and Custer Counties. aturally the mining areas had
f rocity that they abandoned the project and returned drawn many prominent residents, while this was still
home by the long and tedious route through the the land of the Red Men and a few scattered cattle
south pass and[...]barons, and a sprinkling of homesteaders who had
While the Stuart party was camped on the banks filed after the . P. came through. In the biogra-
of the Yellowstone, where Columbus now stands, it phies of the other ten counties appear over 2,000
had it first serious trouble with the Indians. A band write-ups of their citizenry, utilizing 373 pages. Five
of about 30 Crow Indians appeared and proceeded[...]ed to Yellowstone County, covering
to investigate the camp . n uneasy night was spent 37 names. Of these 37, J. I. Allen, Ed Cardwell, W.
as the invaders, who were cited as the most cunning H. Claussen, Charles Countrym[...]thieve in Indianland, man aged to steal articles of man, Isaac Hensley, Olof Lafverson, W. H. orton,
all kind . By morning the Crows began to do some Ben Pearson, R.[...]les Rugg and A. E.
stand by Capt. tuart prevented the party from being Parker voted in Park City[...]here, and Dr. Will Ailen and Judge Goddard
The failure of the tuart exploration put a quietus were weekly vis[...]s _missions.
on further research until 1874, when the citizens of Most of these men are biographed in "They
Bozeman determined to open up the Yellowstone Gazed On The Beartooths" but the following are
area with a road to the head of navigation of the condensed briefs from the above mentioned pub-
river and thu open "the most direct route" connect- lication:
ing with the pre ent terminus of the orthem Pacific PARKER, A. E. Born at[...]. Came to Montana 1876 driving freight lines
port of gold di coveries on the south side of the between Bismarck and Coulson until the railroad
Yellow tone between the Rosebud and Powder Rivers came through. Filed on a ranch at Rapids in 1883,
attracted a lot of adventure ome men, and they 160 acres[...]hed Quinn's
ranch (which wa about three mile west of Colum- PETERS, R. W. Was b orn in[...]hey to Coulson in 1 1, and followed the railroad to
I ct d offic r and t out in earn t[...]here h filed on a ranch and b -
"On F b. 13" wrot the r cord r, "w tart d down came post ma ter at that station. Married one of
th north id of the Y llowston with the mouth of th H nsley girls, E l i on Oct. 6 l 2.[...]River our objectiv , as we pr um d that the H nsley Bro . in th ir proj cts.
the riv r could hav b en navigat d thi far." But YO G, Alonzo J. am to the Clark's Fork
like th tuart party, the Indian w re too tough for Bottom in 1 77 he[...]al o a po tma t r at thi offic . H v a corre-
way of Fort . F. mith and return d to Bozeman. pondent of th Billing H raid for fiv y ar .
"Th r ar no gold min along the low r Yellow-
stone nor the \Volf mountain , but mo t of u b lieve Thoma P. IcElrath' "Hand-book of The Yel-
that th re is gold in th Big Horn mountains,[...]low ton Valley' publi h d in 1 0, gi s th fol-
the valley land will have to be irrigated to produce" lowing stati tic :
was the concluding r port. "Li ut. Long made a car fu l c n u of th pop-
n army report of 1 75 stated "With th xc p- ulation of th all y from B n' Landing to Fort
tion of th Countryman ranch, there is no saf habi- K ogh. Th population in the ction included in
tation b tw n Fort Bu[...]ar bitt r and ho til , and th route is of distanc . Of the 215 w r mal propri tor of
frought with xtr m danger."[...]developm nt. cultivation , 2.3, 3.5 h ad of cattl on pa tur range ,
Th · nd rs dition of "The History of lontana" &15 hors s and 201 h ep.[...]

They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (11)[...]THEY GAZED ON THE BEARTOOTHS[...]Under a title of "Agriculture" the Yellowstone
FROM BOZEMA TO MILES CITY[...]"As early as 1877 some of the scattered farmers
Hoppers -----------------------[...]along the Yellowstone were proving the value of the
Benson's Landing ··-········-·····[...]bushels of oats on ninety acres which the govern-
Hunters Hot Springs --··-······--[...]other raised 35 bushels of wheat ave. on a twenty
Big Timber ······-·[...]acre, and yields of 50 and 60 bushels of soft wheat
Sweet Grass ·············[...]"Garden crops do equally well and in 1879 theofof
Johnsons --···-----····---·-----···---[...]wild plum, buffalo berries and choke cherries. Theof marvelous flavor."

The Last Battle with Indians in What Is Now Stillwate[...]Battle cross on the ice, and follow the trail of th tol n
horses in the now. The cro sing was about three
in Hails[...]miles east of Park ity.
While a few skirmishes with the Indians have[...]Lew et ranch and I d tha
of them have been too serious. The chronicl of had o of his h Th· d th local
Lewis and Cla[...]y decid d to join and track
camped on the ground where Columbus now stands,[...]wn, and Mr. w a f w n igh-
a b and of Crows, who were clever arti ts of thi v-[...]to go along.
ery, sneaked in and took 24 of the exp dition's hors
from under the noses of the guards. ot a shot or[...]h Ba in w t
ser Creek, about the time of " he ·p Dip" when a of th Big day and all
few Indians invaded the pasture of r. Keiser (K y- night.[...]t
ser) and escaped with t n h ad of poni d pite th[...]hors "th a
but could not pursue the in aders becaus th ir[...]ton g light wh
The most serious engagem nt was known as th[...]a ,
battle of the Hailstone Basin, which occurr d in 1[...]big r n t of[...]trail.
"On February 16 a small band of row Indians
under Chief Plenty oups crossed the river from[...]i in th party whom th y
of horses that had been tolen from th m . It was[...]1 th t tarted ho ting. J Tat
v ry cold. The river wa froz n ov r so they could[...]

They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (12)4 THEY GAZED ON THE B EA RTOOTHS

Owens got b hind ome rock . bullet nipped The men were tired, no sleep - too cold to sleep
Ow n ' che k. When the Indian thieves saw the so they had to keep walking and moving a[...]ed running night to keep from freezing. On the way home they
for th cliff , wh re th y had an advantageous posi- came to the Bill ackett ranch west of the Big Lake,
tion . On Indian was kill d and another[...]l riding wa a stallion biscuits most of th morning and filled th m up as
b longing to my[...]When the party got to Park, Dr. Rhod s anted
Ow ns wa kill[...]d Indian to whittle on, o my olde t brother,
The Indian , five in number, stayed in th ir Mar[...]what \: a left was buried on
b low until daylight the s cond day, wh n they were our ranch. It was not a ery good burial as our
abl to go where the d ad member of th ir party dogs kept digging him up and scatt ring the bones
were, and when th y reach d them shortly after day- around our yard.
light, th y found that the bodies wer frozen stiff. Plenty Coup had scalped the dead Indian and
Th ey put them on pack horses, and two of the party took th scalp with him to sho th other Indians
started back, while the Crows and others found their of what he had done - anoth r coups.
stol n horses and started back to Park City, th re The thieving band were Pi gan Indians, possibl[...]

They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (13)THEY GAZED ON THE BEARTOOTHS 5
They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (14)6 THEY G A ZE D O N THE B EART OO T HS

Dame Nature Created Many Stations for Indian Signalling

Back in the old days of ·the Louis-
iana Purchase the native American In-
dians were using smoke signals as a
means of rapid communication. The
Crow tribe was very adept in this art,
an[...]stations they were able to cover a range
of over two hundred miles, as they could
observe activity in most of their area on
both sides of the Yellowstone between
the Big Horn and Boulder Rivers. Loco-
motive Butte and Battle Butte in the
Lake Basin were such vantage points, as
w[...]called Tip-Top) Butte,
and Youngs Point along the Yellowstone.[...]enemy tribes, once they were stationed
on the flat tops of these formations.

LOCOMOTIVE BUTTE IN BIG COULEE
AREA OF LA.KE BASIN

They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (15)[...]WATER COUNTY ...
A COMMONWEALTH IN THE EMBRYO
(Columbus News Christmas number 1913.[...]peated attempts to have a new county
A flash of the scalpel, a few gentle strokes with[...]established failed in the legislature, until a bill wa
the brushes, and Dame ature was again at the task
finally introduced which 1 ft the matt r of th crea-
of creating the universe. But on this occasion she
tion of a new commonwealth to the people re iding
was in a playful mood. She had be[...]within its confines. The p ople of the segregated
dustriously for a time, and had resolv[...]districts immediately act d on the proposition and
a most restful and interesting part of the work.
on the 15th of March, 1913, an election was held
So in this gay spirit she started. A range of which placed Stillwater on the list of Montana coun-
mountains appeared on the surface of the earth, a ties by a larger percentage th[...]by its enthusiastic adherents. Columbus was named
of them as "the prettiest in the world," excelling the as the county seat, being most centrally located.
famous Alps for beauty, their grandeur pleasing the[...]ary lines Stillwater County has
visitor more than the wonder of the world renowned
some of the choicest land of the Treasure tate. It
Yellowstone Park. They were rou[...]tributary districts. To t orth i the reat Lake
slopes according to the whims of ature at that par-
Basin, a sag in the gen nd cape, that xt nds
ticular m[...]country on the north.
throughout the region lakes were added to beautify
tion of th county on t o
the landscape. The mountains completed, th sculptor[...]hit B a
started the foothills, gradually sloping them to m t
of dry Ian th a t ,[...]e, with rolling hills and small utl t of ke Ba in ton and the
ater courses. Anoth r crevice in th form of a railroad, · n th[...]-
mighty ri er v as created· then a gradual lin of ley and K i[...], a big b nch, and a gr at ha in t of r i an th r gr at pan of
was the r sult of an ind ntur in th urfa of the g ntl rolling hill , kno n a th Hunt}[...]dat peopl chri t n d th moun- a t of th tillv at r is th han Rid f rtil
tains Beartooth range; th tilh at r Ri er the f pr du · pr iri , hill .
accumulation of th tr am which found th ir sourc arok tillw t r and
on the north slop of th mountain chain· th larg m t th Ro bud again bran hing in th
ere ic wa the Y llm: stone Ri r s parat d from \ st Ro bud, th natural draina of th uth rn
th Lake Ba in by th Lak Ba in Di id . part of th ounty. Th till at r h ad[...]L dg Pol and R k r k all h Ip to w 11 th
the Y llO\: ton . t a di tance of 40 mil on th
olum of th tilh at r b for it finall m t th
w st v a Big Timb r county seat of t rass,[...]h ame mileag a t took one into Billing ,
the busine s c nt r of Y llov stone ounty. Thirty- Part of 54 town hip ar in lud d in th rnunty
ight miles to the south wa Red Lodg , county at a total of 1112 320 acr or 1 7 mil . Th
of arbon ounty. B ing outlying di trict , th[...]
They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (16)8 THEY GAZED ON THE BEARTOOTHS

amounted this year to $4,554,997. In spite of the the up-river farmers and businessmen took the jump
fact that a great deal of expense was created in on the Countryman- orton-Montana Cattle Co. the
starting the wheel of government in the new country, latter knew that it would be futile to try to bring
the taxes were just a trifle higher than in the other another small county into being, and so the project
counties from which it was segregated, and with was abandoned. Then came the regime of J. B. Annin
the initial expen e of nearly $50,000 eliminated in and Pat Lavelle as commissioners for Yellowstone
future years the tax rate will probably be the lowest County, and the fact that this pair came from the
of any county in Montana.[...]ded them time to give further study
n idea of its rapid growth since the introduc- to a new county, with their home town as the
tion of the dry farming principals can be gained county seat.
from the census reports. Six years ago there were
approximately 2,500 people in what is now Stillwater;
the present conservative estimate is placed at 5,000.
Of this portion over three-fourths obtain their liveli-
hood from the soil. Columbus, the county seat, has 750
people; Park City boasts of a population of 400; Ab-
sarokee, 200; Fishtail and Reed Point ab[...]Lusty at Birth
This can truly express the creation of Stillwater
County. For no commonwealth, created t[...]ng
career in gaining its final designation as one of the
counties.
From the start it appeared that basic reasons
made it a "natural" for the establishment of a county
in the area of which the confluence of the Stillwater
and Yellowstone Rivers was a key point. Back in
1875 this was the main stagecoach stop for many
miles of the main Yellowstone Trail. Far up the
Stillwater, mining propertie promised practical de-
velopment, with "pay' cuts of gold silv r, copper
and nickel showing up in many mining hafts, or
placer sluic . There wa the story of the wire gold
and the gold nugg t attributed to Pretty Feather;
ther were deposits of low-grade, but ch aply mined
coal both to th nort[...]tillwater
Valley; there were vast for sts of virgin timber· there
were sites already r tain d[...]ects; lim stone deposits in abundanc , and
plenty of water for irrigation of the many wide,
fertile valleys that comprised the Stillwater watershed. In three dillerent e ion , he battled futility for the creation
of tilh ater ounty-at la t ucce .
To th north was th domain of the old Se enty-
ine (The Montana Cattle Company)· and its proof
that the mountain ar a gra s and climat a ideal[...]blu -print
for th live tock indu try. Ev n before the dry lander stag wh n Ir nin a el cted enator from his
came, it was known that the liv stock industry of coun on bruar · 1907 introduced a bill
this area was economically sound, as long as the for t oo t t[...]from arb O\ ston . The fol-
other fateful winter like 1886- 7.[...]Ea ton ;
trails , there was little doubt but that the re idents, county clerk, G or[...]K rn; county a nd clerk of
a go" of a gov rnment made up of thems Ives. court, Harry \ rig , J. R. c nn tte
The dream reached back as far as I 9 or about dams, up rint ndent of h Peabody,
the time Sweet Grass County was born, but when[...]

They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (17) THEY GAZED ON THE BEARTOOTHS 9

and public administrator not named. The area was print the names, would, if carried out, be against
somewhat larger than the confines of the present the peace of this community and would do no good
county, and the assessed valuation was nearly three at this time. If the tim does come when publica-
million dollars.[...]tion should be deemed necessary, w have the de-
aturally, the project drew bitter fire from each tails of the whole miserabl scheme."
of the three counties involved. The Big Timber Pio- However, on March 2, 1909 the Stillwater County
neer said: "A majority of the people realize that bill was beaten 16 to 6, following onslaughts by Sen-
the benefits to be derived from the new county ator Meyer of Carbon that "his county was small
would fall to a favored few, and the results would enough and the new bill would have detach d too
not justify." much property. The residents of the proposed[...]tricts, even in Columbus, were anything but a
The Billings Gazette reports: "At a meeting held[...]unit in its favor." Said Sen. McDonnell of Sw et
in the Billings hall Saturday night, some 60 men[...]se;heme back d by a
were in attendance to oppose the proposed new few who have real estate to sell, or political fortune
county of Roosevelt. Chris Yegen was elected chair- to gain, and very few residents of the area in my
man and J. H. McElroy, secretary, David Fratt, and county favor the measure." Three similar mea ures
others offered donations of $50 to fight the cause, to create new counties failed in the senate that session
and the Hon. Charles L. Harris assist~d in' making of the lawmakers.
some unkind and unjust remarks concerning Sen.
Annin, and some of his "selfish co-horts." But the sound logic that would create a county[...]along these lines nev~r waned. And so we reach the
B. A. Harlan, of the Joliet Journal, took the fol- 1911 session, when one of the early bills, presented
lowing pot shot: "The Journal man notes that there by Senator Murray of Beaverhead (through the influ-
have been some very foolish propositions presented ence of Mr. Annin), was for the creation, agaii:i, of
by people generally, in regard to dividing our county Stillwater County, with the same foes of Meyer and
by legislative act. First came what is known as the McDonnell ready to resist, while by the time Yel-
Annin move to carve out a new county from Carbon, lowstone had withdrawn in favor of it er ation.
Yellowstone and Sweet Grass, and make Columbus Ho ever the work of County Buster MacKay was
the county seat? Preposterous! Sure, but for the un- shown by the fact that 17 county di i ion m a ure
adulterated[...]had b en pr nted to th s nat , which practi ally
the Annin folly skinned and packed as an embalmed precluded passage of any one.
beef. It is the Glidden deal to create another county How v r the tr prompt th
from the east half of Carbon and the west half of drafting of r r whi h would
the Crow agency."[...]opo ed new
The voice of the protestants prevailed and after county to v[...]t d vot , and
went down the drain by the senate vote of 13 to 9. 0 p r c nt t[...]four million
Stillwater County with practically the same ar a and would not b t an
valuation as s t up in the previous Roo ev lt oun on . ifty p o t r
bill. This time the officers named were: . L. Thom- county aff[...]er commi ioners; tion t b
J. . Brannon, cl rk of court; J. R. Park r tr ur r; of each coun d.
Art nd rson assessor;[...]for llw
Th bittern of th 1907 battle was urpas ed mas g i an
by the enate fight for this bill. Th Red Lodg from e of n t ed
Pick t charged fraud in the p titioning promotion: county and a commi raf d-
"It may b that the ditor of the Tri- ounty w ari of th n w t lat n
is[...], but which was r ally int nded with a er w of ha and
for ounty di ision w[...]jol . Fina1ly u number o
and th names of th m n ho did th work ar okayed by th nty ommi ion r in
in pos ssion of thi offic . The nti aff[...]

They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (18)10 THEY GAZED ON THE BEARTOOTHS[...]
They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (19) THEY GAZED 0 THE BEARTOOTHS 11

Grass, with the election set for March 15, 1913, and YELLOWSTO E
the following officers named:[...]...................... 22 26
Clerk of Court, Gus B. Iverson; Assessor, J. R. Par-[...]..... .
ker; Attorney, B. E. Berg; Superintendent of Schools,[...]itter op- S EET CRA
position from the county seats of Red Lodge and Precinct[...]For Against
Big Timber, and the paper at Broadview. In much Ir[...]............................ 29 2
the same fashion as the proponents circulated peti- ye .[...]5 0
other field teams opposed to the move, and some Merrill .......[...]1
pretty vicious activity took place the few times the Reed Point ........................[...]........ 10 13
in fact, sponsored the new county as a better asset ibs[...]......................... 0 12
to the Midland Empire. How well the tillwaterites[...]For gainst
worked was shown in the official oting: TOT L ...[...]had ju
b n ompl NI " the norih id of hi

They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (20)[...]13

The Columbus ews noted: "Jim Lavelle, alias[...]963 ti-
Paul Revere, made some ride to bring in the returns mate is 5526.
from Stickley. The difference b etween Paul and Jim
The surprising feature in analyzing th figure
was that the form er's horse kept right on a-clattering,[...]is that in 1913 only 1,200 of the 5,00 w r r gi -
while the latter had a runaway, broke a single-tree,[...],500
and a neck-yoke before he pulled through all the
residents. An analyst has point d out that many of
snow drifts into Columbus. 0 0 0 Dan Woods is the
the newcomers were large family group , with minor
only man we know of who deliberately voted him-[...]children. Further, it was claim d that som of the
self out of a job by voting favorably. He was a[...]t filed and did n t hav sufficient
deputy sheriff of Yellowstone. 0 0 0 The only sun-
time of residency. Add to this the fact that the few
shine of the past 10 days was available last Satur-[...]ldom vot d.
day. For 10 hours "Old Sol" smiled on the birth of
Stillwater County. Lucky omen ." The voting strength was pretty well distributed[...]in 1914 as the following registration list shows: Co-
On Mon[...].51, Park City 136, Merrill 37, R ed Point
tached the county to the Sixth Judicial District, and[...], Busteed 36, Lake Basin 3.3, tickley 9, Harrison
the Secretary of State at 10:10 a.m. that morning[...], Gibson 47, Flaherty Flat 50, Irwin 67,
recorded the creation on his books at Helena. The[...]annex room with fireproof vault
got started, and the edges of some new desks pre- Consolidation of ~istricts as listed in 1962 shows
pared for lots of heel-warming later on! Columbus[...]ty 342, Reed Point 128, Rap-
After many years of patient, hard work, Still- elje 115, H ar[...]The school census (including children one to[...]n six) has varied through the years. In 1913 th county[...]had 2172 names in this group for 43 o/c p r cent of
Stillwater County is one of those areas where
the total population. In 1920 when th c nsu num-
agriculture is the main occupation, so population is[...]were 3510 juv nil for
affected chiefly by the whims of the tillers of the[...]46 ~ . Pr ently 1963 h w 2fXJl which
soil. Of course the homestead boom played its part[...]figure for about 36 o/< •
in determining the number of person within the
county confines. In 1905 the area comprising thi
county had an estimated 2100 peopl , mo t of them
on irrigated farms in the valleys. Th north sid of
the river was under the operation of stockgro er ,
probably a dozen rath r large outfi[...]g
crews accounted for more than half of th r idents. Y ar of · n pared t[...]aried with th s asons. those of
The census of 1910 shows that about 1,000 n - .[...]lu
figur to 31 . Only 96 of thes er registered 1 .u[...]v d n arly 5,000, with a pot ntial oting
strength of nearly 1 . Factual} , voted in th
el tion[...]7 r gist red oters and an timated population
of 5600. The regular decad n u show th fol-
lowing figur , with the p ak in 1920 to . In
1 30 th figure was[...]253. Ten ,7
year lat r th count of nos r aled 9 , hich ha of
aw th start of a le ling off proc . By this tim 75 o in .
most of th land had b n pro ed up. and th land[...]rth 21 124 50
iffs sal , and gone on th ir ~ ay. The 19 0 figur ars b for , n t too[...]

They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (21)14 THEY GAZED ON THE BEARTOOTHS

head. ow numb r , how ver, increased during the Columbus Has Had Many
50-y ar[...]Cemeteries
h ad for a total of $175,595 to 35,102 head at $60
per anim l for a um of $2,141,463 ineteen sixty- Like many[...]o frown on sheep in- several cemeteries. The first recorded burial was
er a ingly through the pa t five decade . Wool was a stagecoach dr[...]ile 1963 selected about half a mile north of the courthouse
how d a wooli population of 21, 64 at $6.40 for and contained ten graves when it was abandoned
a fi ure of 139,222. Hog and oth r livestock rose in favor of a new site on the north side of the hill
from $5,05 to a ix-time figure of $30,792. from which sandstone was obtained for the quarry
operation. It was here that the first Memorial D ay
ar and other motor vehicles show the most service was held at the tum of the century. Among
fanta tic gain . In 1913, 53 autos were on the assess- those pictured are pioneers like Wong T[...]llen, Pat Lavelle,
m nt rolls at 13,6 0. Today the county boasts of Jimmy Hedges> and Col. orton.
3,455 motor vehicl worth 1,729,532 for an increase
of 12260 % in valuation and a 61.6 to l ratio in[...]we t of town, all the bodies whose identity was
number . The value per unit has increased from known, were moved to the new burial ground, but
$244 to 500.[...]originally interred.
The growth of the values in public utilities is
likewi e astounding[...]railroads,
etc., were valued in 1913 at $77,864. The figure a
half c ntury later was $5,45 ,0 9 - 70 times as great.

n item of inter t cone ming the increase in
car , clipp d from The Tri-County ews, October
1, 1903:

'Th fir t[...]had om from Michi an and was
hound for th t t of a hin ton. Many of the
children, an a lot of rown-up , w r nt rtained
by it app a[...]

They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (22)[...]ABSAROKEE -
Stillwater's Inland Town
"The Crow reservation once occupied all the land
now surrounding Absarokee, with the agency build-
ings on the ranch now owned by Jack Pear on. The
present townsite was homesteaded by S. T. Simon-
sen, now of Joliet," and in relating some of the earlier
history of the town Mr. Simonsen also says:
"I left Castle,[...], one team and wagon and one horse
and buggy, for the reservation on October 4, 1 92.
Robert Jackson occupied the log house on land now
owned by Ross & Runner, where we set our tent.s
until the reserve should be opened, which occurred
on the 15th. On that day my wife and I set stakes
on the comers as near as possible with location no-
tices and mo d our t nt right back of v h r the
old log hot 1 now tands, v hich v a th fir t buil[...]ng it th fir t building on
v hat is nov th it of b arok . Th n t thing
to do as to g t a po t offic , hich ith th as i t-
ance of orton of olumbu v a tabli h cl and
op ned for bu in on January 13, 1 3 and gi n
the name bsaroke m aning 'our p pl .' t th
sam tim I[...]t app ar-
nc b for th puhli ' throu h th m dium of it
ov n publi ation. In th olumn of thL pap r i H 1.[...]
They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (23)16 THEY GAZED ON THE BEARTOOTHS[...]of its various clubs and societies. Although not ess[...]everyone is interested in some movement of a social
character, and the place itself is known far and wide[...]spread hospitality invariably extended to the stranger[...]The Dorcas Society, organized in the interest
of the church, is a thriving society which includes[...]practically all the women of the community. The[...]The Study Club, organized by Mrs. Hugh Campbell[...]last year, has completed a year's course of study and[...]ify in the near future for admission to the Federa-
tion of Women's Clubs.[...]part in the affairs of the community. The Carnival[...]permanent basis for the purpose of promoting an-[...]nually a harvest festival and carnival like the very[...]have come by no reason of the value of the taxpay-
ing property but in spite of it. Since its organization
the Absarokee district has been hampered by having[...]but the public spirit of it citizens has amply recom-[...]the charact r of the citiz ns of the to n.
found, mor or I s crip- The church is on of th old t organizations
tion of (h variou social or[...]m po .. town. m mb r hip of ix a a ongr gational church. Rev.[...]ar that th Jo ph Pop had charg of th church at olumbus
ca i a[...]hat tim and conduct d r gular rvi in the
to th t ch bu[...]led with faith in its con- Th story of th E ri · oon
tinued imp[...]ing
o m ntion is mad in olumn of th publish d it fir t i u[...]ound us; proph ied at th tim that th to\' n of b arok
of famou vall y and th pl of th wa not larg nough to warran such an[...]n to our ing but th faith of th O\: n rs of th pap r \: a
tr ams and canyon in a[...]t d b
sent th town its If from oint of its va- publishing two pag only but oon fou[...]it to th reader bsarok , th town of On of the I ading f ctor in th gro" h of b-
its size in Montana; ok , in t of th arok and th de lopment of th urrounding
Stillwat r-Ros bud v country i the " lidg t" larv I mill horn of "Thor-
Although r mote from railroad,[...]
They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (24) THEY GAZED ON THE BEARTOOTHS 17

This industry was started the first of December One statement is often mad that[...]ar and has been in constant operation since, the best town in which to trade in the tate. On
part of the time night and day. The original build- condition which has brought[...]30 but this soon proved too small for istenc of the Absarok o-Op. tore. This store
the rapidly growing industry and the structure has was organized as a coop rati[...]d to 40 by 40 with engine room and ago, the principal stockhold rs b ing farm rs and
platforms in addition. stockmen of the surrounding ountry. The ompany
took over the only store in Absarok e and proc d d
The mill is equipped throughout with the[...]ing the buying and selling of grain and other pro-
Mr. H. L. Raiff, president of the orthwestern Mill[...]rehous s, and mor store room
Construction Company of Billings.[...]several lots until it now own a large
Before the mill was built many thousands of and valuable property. It has b n a great factor in
dollars were being sent out of the community for building up the town, furni hing at the same time
flour. ow the grain is grown in our midst, the a market for produc and a place to buy supplies
freight charges out and in are saved, as well as the of all kinds at reasonable pric s. Hugh ampb[...]and elevator charges, and several profits. is the manager, having held that position for four
In fa[...]ution to Rockefeller for gasoline and lubricat- The old Co-Op. is a landmark in Ab arokee and
ing oil, while the additional returns from our fat may it alwa[...]Absarokee got along with only
people concede that the mill will save each year to
one store, but as the town grew and the country
the community its total cost.[...]p(}d it became a promising field
One feature of the town which appeals to the for the establishment of anoth r m rcantile hou e.
traveling public is the excellent hotel accommoda- The C. W. Sparr Company located her but in ab ut
tions. The Jay Hotel is a two-story structure of brick two years H. L. Torgrimson backed up hi f[...]rge verandas and fitted with every modem the town ith his pock tho k and bought them out,
impr[...]Trad-
cold water and steam heat. F. E. Jay built the house ing mpany.
in 1912, close to the site of the old log hotel, and
The Pi pho Pharma y tak ar f th drug
with the assistance of his wife conducts an up-to-
busin ss in thi part of th country anct in additi n
date hostelry.[...]. Pi pho
Three restaurants also cater to the inn r wants r gi t d phannaci t, i th r and a
of the hungry public. Th Elk afe is conducted[...]m
and bak ry is just across th corn r; furth r up the
str t may b found th l x entch rooming and
eating hous . Don't be afraid to vi it the town -
you ill alway find g d ac mmodations.
Th real financial · ommunity · auged
by th amount of bu acted i
bank. b arok[...]far- ight mad tab-
Ii hm nt of a ba ho ha n it
th ir undiv[...]. .
Our bank, doing bu in under th nam of t
Thomas \ itt "' o., bank r: , is orga[...]rtn r hip with unlimit d r pon ibility on th part
of it tockhold r . It i a matter of prid that thi g neral fo[...]ri .
it on of the trong t in titution in th tat a itu-[...]

They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (25)18 THEY GAZED ON THE BEARTOOTHS

b for the town ite wa established, there has not after the land had been purchased from the Crow
b en much of a change of population from that par- Indians and thro[...]flock · to occupy practically every square foot of not until 1905 that Siver Simonsen decided to plat
the b 'nchland · and many of the e moved into b- his homestead for a townsite. The survey was com-
arok e upon ·elling out or r t[...]23 that year and immediately
for trebling in the population and homes at this the sale of lots began. A short time later P. H.
dat . No tow[...]r and was instrumental in getting
·iv . De pite the fact that the little "burg" (Absaro- the town laid out, with Main Street about parallel
k e wa de cribed as a po toffice on Stillwater creek, to the Rosebud River. In 1912, September 7, Mr.
35 mile northwe t of Red Lodge, and 13 miles Hawkins laid out Hawkins Second, and the next
outhwe t of Columbus, which is the nearest bank- year added some more of the river area in Hawkins
ing and hipping point on the . P., in the publi- Addition Number 3. His next contribution to the
cation "History of the Yellowstone" in 1905) has[...]Riv-
n ver incorporat d, it nevertheless has all the essen-
tial of a mayorized city. Through volunteer sub- erside Addition, 4.05 acres of which was left as a
criptions and improvement d[...]arden
now ha a fire-fighting ervice covering most of the Homes Addition September 24, 1928.
t rritory in the mountain valleys with equipment and[...]While "P. H." was the biggest planner for the
voluntary manpower far exceeding the ordinary in-
corporated town. For year the town has been elec- town, others had a hand in making expansion of
trically equipped through a Montana Power service. its boundaries. In 1914 Joe Mason tacked on the
Recently, the thriving little municipality installed Mason[...], and - in 1918, on Feb-
water and a sewer ystem. The residents pooled their ruary 6 Harry Ellis surveyed lots for Rock Rose
fund to blacktop the principal streets. In 1963 a ddition. T[...]Davidson ddition; then February 8 1951 the Lehn-
Main tre t boa t of very kind of business ers opened a tract along the Rosebud for homes.
ential to th trade of uch an area, with plenty The Weast Addition by "Jerry" Weast is the latest,
of comp titian handl d in uch a friendly way that[...]s.
er tch cl from th bu in ro t r but plenty of
n w op ration with up-to-th -minute method are
availabl to v ry kind of a cu tom r. Th town
v n boa t of two b nk .

ar four hur[...]cili · r most of
th ton s ral[...]em Fr nk Jay,
Platting The Town ite of b arok[...]t.

bsarok e, th famous litt1e "inland town of th FIR
Yellowsto[...]

They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (26) THEY GAZED ON THE BEARTOOTHS[...]the plan had to b abandon d.
For the past 24 years the history of Absarokee[...]aint in d by oluntary nt r-
has largely been that of her schools.[...]ly no district in Montana has had such hall of th b arok o- p rati Trading om-
a st[...]one has had. pany (now th printing offi of th tillwat r n-
Perhaps because our community s[...]h following y ar, in th
struggle covered a period of almost 20 years. sition, a district was r at d aft r a h aring h Id
In 1905 the people of our village voluntarily by the ounty superint nd nt of ar on ounty of
from their own pockets secured enough money to[...]h b arokee wa then a part. Th di trict had
engage the services of Miss Gladys Kelly, now Beas- the distinction of b ing th mall t in th tat .
ley, rece[...]sota, to r otwith tan ding it enrollm nt of 1 pupil it wa
teach a short term of school in a small log house obliged to uppl m nt it apportionm nt by ub-
loaned by the late S. T. Simonsen. This building scripti[...]mon y-making
is still standing as a paintshop at the back end of acti iti uch as <lane , bazaar and dinn r .
the Bickford property on Grove Street and is known t this point a group of s v n worn n organiz d
as the oldest house in town. It was hoped that as the 1. B. Club, st pp d in and by unflag ing £forts
a result of this enterprise a school district would added nough mon y to th g n rou gift of dis-
be set aside but it was not until a longer s[...]standard.
In 1906 when the town-site of b arokee as In 1909[...]was h Id
offered to donate a two acre tract on the hill ide at in a large log t by P. H.
the end of a pos ible extension of Grove tr t pro- Ha kin . · ed by M.
vided that the three districts adjoining th villag L. .
sit[...]h both a ommon
and a high chool. Howev r, th hop of th
munity were d f ated b oppo ition from a f
They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (27)20 THEY GAZED ON THE BEARTOOTHS

(stone-cut) was erected during the summer of 1910. to Absarokee as well as so many "transfer" pupils
The ntire co t of the building was met by dona- from other districts that it became necessary to add
tion of land, labor and money, ranging from $1 to[...]more rooms and four teachers were employed.
$500. The M. B. Club gave $500 and later gave lib-[...]The establishment of a high school in 1913-14
erally to furni hing and[...]called for another era of great money-raising activi-
year later this club got water to the school ties on the part of the M. B. Club and the school's
ground , fenced , and planted a double row of 212 most loyal supporters. Though not immediately placed
tree around the chool block. Every tree flourished on the accredited list the first Absarokee high school
for y ar , wh n the greate t misfortune the school was held in the little cement house that stands adja-
ha met befell in the form of a hail storm which cent to the main entrance of the high school. Fresh-
killed all but a few of the trees. The trees we now man and sophomor[...]were given here under
e tanding are what remains of this splendid effort the direction of Veronica Piepho, principal of the
to give our town a beautiful school campus. Some[...]grade schools. When Alfred Baken, Albert Johnson
of them are shoot from the hail-destroyed trees and Mr. Shepard were trustees the cobblestone high
but the larger one are tho e which escaped the school was erected. To satisfy those patrons who
fury of the torm. From them we may picture what preferred to see the building parallel the county
the original planting might have become. road the new building departed from the cardinal
Occupation of the new two-room building re- points adhered to in the construction of the first
sulted in so large an influ of "school year residents" b[...]

They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (28) THEY GAZED ON THE BEARTOOTHS[...]
They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (29)[...]THEY GAZED ON THE BEARTOOTHS

ments, so the name of Columbus replaced Stillwater
COLUMBUS[...]-Birth- of the Yellowstone was slow in getting settled. It[...]was borderland on the north side of the Crow Res-
There i probably no town (or city)[...]ervation, and there were constant raids on the area
that had a more pectacular career, or more h[...]" on an incorpo- as soon attack the white invaders. This ever-present
rated name than did the county seat of Stillwater. danger didn't appeal to many prospective home seek-
From 1 75 when the Countryman stage station was ers, who high-tailed it over to the Gallatin or other
known as Stillwater, until its[...]07, points farther west. A history of Montana, 1885 edi-
it name was changed every time the whims of a tion, states: "A detachment of the 7th Cavalry pro-
merchant moved his stock of merchandise, or a new ceeded up the Yellowstone in 1875 to Mission. They
business app[...]er a single person between Coulson
two miles we t of town; then an Indian trading post and Mission except for the folks at the Countryman
was listed as "Sheep Dip," and it was not until the Ranch trading post at Eagle's es[...]ous route."
named it Stillwater that the town's location attained Inco[...]n't last long, how- many years the town's progress was leisurely but
ever, as the . P. had already listed a Stillwater,[...]erative in pro-
Minnesota, on their main line and the similarity of viding voluntarily for the improvements in living
Minnesota and Montana led[...]e, orton tore, (Line Building).
South of Trac k: Alec Countryman home, Wylie home,[...]

They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (30) THEY GAZED ON THE BEARTOOTHS[...]mediate need for imposing tified with the development of our little city. more
town ordinances and legal observation of same. respected and progressive citiz n does not resid in
However, the population gradually over-taxed any community of our great stat . oldier with a
the local facilities, and the citizens decided that th~ record of brave deeds in upholding the honor of
painful time was here for incorporation. Followin[...]fitting and prais worthy, then, wa
a proclamation of election of incorporation, 73 Co- the r spect sho n thi honorable citiz n y t rday
lumbusites went to the polls and favored the move, by our ot rs in lecting him the initial mayor f
as compared to five opposing. The first town election olumbu ."
took place[...]or pu d
Pat J. Lavelle was named the first mayor, and sam , that now comp t of olumbu
selected to serve with him ere: Id rmen, Fir t of it b long d to · orton
Ward, Hen[...]d, · th d own-
The population of the incorporat limits as m[...]cl 15, 1 .
the honorable Patrick La II , " ho \ a y t rda[...]
They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (31)24 THEY GAZED ON THE BEARTOOTHS
land, adjoining the Countryman property, and laid June 30[...]di-
as County First Town (Stillwater). As soon as the tion, S. D. McDonald.
survey set the corners, the buildings were moved September 26,.[...]onto lines to correspond. This required shifting the L. Kyle, L. C. Heicksen, A. L. Graham[...]two George Morrison, trustees).
of the frame structures that had served as a store[...]18, School Addition (Trustees
and saloon. Luckily the old Gordon Hall was on the District No. 6). ·
new lines which the final . P. survey had established. Then lo[...]e than its eral years, but in March, 1940 the Knox, Hecken-
share of additions and subdivisions. On March 21, l[...]e Countryman platted Countryman's First to the old Annex Addition. Other additions were:
Addition, and Sam C. Hunter offered the Hunters November 12, 1947, Charles Hamlet Additiqn,
Addition to the southeast corner of the town in April Charles Hamlett.
of that same year. That gave everyone sufficient[...]uart Addition, Harold Stuart.
building lots until the Horace Countryman estate October 6, 1952, Town of Columbus Annex
in June 1899 platted Countryman Second Addition. Mountain View Addition.
The next move was made by J. B. Annin, who wanted[...]uary 5, 1953, Second School Addition (Dis-
to see the town growth go eastward and he platted trict No. 6).
the Annex Addition October 9, 1902. Since then, 21[...]July 3, 1956, Huff Addition by Clete Huff.
to the town's borders, as follow: May 6, 1959, Industrial Site, -by· Town of Co-
May 31, 1906, Myers & ice Addition, Albe[...]on. was founded, writes in a special edition of the Co-
March 7, 1907, East Side Addition, W.W.[...]Assn. Ad- "There was a low rich strip of land about two
dition, A. Carter, E. B. Thayer and Con W. hundred yan;ls wide and had an area of several
Doyle (trustees). acres that extended from the city water works down
the Yellowstone River to where the river bends south,
September 19, 1910, Myers[...]Hamilton built a log house to trade with the Crow
September 2, 1911, Knause & Becker Addit[...]er. lived in a log house at the lower end of that strip and
June 10, 1913, Norton's Courthouse Subdivision, cultivated it and raised a crop of vegetables for two
Wm. H. Norton.[...]years on it then he built a frame addition to the log
July 22, 1913, Goode's Subdivision, Solon L. part and it stands occupied today, the oldest house in
Goode.[...]1, 1914, Mountain View Addition, E. B. The winter of 1879-80 the snow fell breast deep
Thayer and L. D. Dixson. all over this valley, and the hunters from Eagles

TOWN OF COLUMBUS ABOUT 1910

They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (32) THEY GAZED ON THE BEARTOOTHS[...]ile and a quarter from Bank and was called the "Palace Saloon." The Montana
Columbus on the flat' abc;>Ve Keyser Creek on the Saloon was Culver's old site.
bank of the Yellowstone River would go down the Judge Abbott built the frame store next to Cul-
valley and out near the bluff would shoot antelope, ver's saloon, a general store, and sold out to Martin-
skin them and take the hides back in the evening and dale, who I bought out in the fall of 1883, that was
sell them for $1.00 per skin at the Eagles Nest store, on the site of Judge Simpson's stone building. Eagles
and gamble the proceeds. There Allie Bailey was Nest[...]d near
clerking for Mithoff and Koffman, who were the the store on the bank of the Yellowstone River with
traders at Crow Agency on[...]a large eagle's nest on its topmost branches. The next
still can be seen ruins of that agency, and where I year changed its named to "Sheep Dip" that got its
traded for them. The Crow Agency moved from Mis- name from the booze that was sold there, and when
sion Creek in the spring of 1875. That spring W. H. Dunn, Lee and Babc[...]they built a two-story brick
store to trade with the Crow Indians where the ranch building where now Al Thomas has his ranch on Key-
of Walter Quinn now is, and moved to Columbus in[...]ere by John Peck.
1880 where Horace Countryman in the winter of 1880- Thinking the ' .P. survey would build the tracks where
81 built the old log hotel where the .P. side track they had surveyed, a town was started, three saloons
now is, just north of the .P. depot. John Johnson were soon up, and as the liquor was about the same
"Liver Eater" hewed the logs for the hotel and there as at old Eagle's est, they retained the name · of
Horace was postmaster and there the stages would "Sheep Dip.' By the _way, that was some booze that
stop with their load of mail and passengei:,s. And in was made there. A blacksmith shop, a hotel and a
the fall of 1882 the trains stopped, and the stages were few dwelling houses and a harness s[...]W. H. orton had his log store Jones west of that town. "Sheep Dip" was a lively
built that now is the property of Dr. Line, the store burg, believe me. Drinking, games of chance, gam-
was afterwards planked over. Then a saloon of logs bling and a hurdy gurdy joint, all open, ran 'til after
was built on the comer across from the First ational the .P. track passed below that town, and it ceased[...]in the town for about 30 years, running a laundry. He[...]over on the flat n ar where the bridge is, and wh re[...]Countryman was hi f of the town of Stillwat r,
the big log hotel belonged to him, the toll road, th[...]brought him a revenue of hundr ds of dollars w kly,
the toll road one day brought him over 300 dollars an[...]the nightly poker gam was worth from 65 to 75[...]dollars, and Horace didn't have to play for it, the
hole .in th tabl won. M al at the hotel w re 50[...]boys had the tirn of their liv dancing, and m n and[...]to att nd the <lane and enjoy th big f a t. Frank[...]Lamb rt, Jo Porter and "O rland Joe" drove the[...]about the fir t one to locate with his family in town,[...]he built his house on the om r aero from Chad y[...]the hoot of owl and yelp of coyot nightl and the
East Lytle E levator (top).[...]ontana Elevator (bottom ). followed by the whit s far into the north lands. Th s
They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (33)26 THEY GAZED ON THE BEARTOOTHS

incidents are but a few of the changes that happened there has been but a short period during the town life
in locating the town of Stillwater, now Columbus." that homemade[...]0 0 available. The Harris cheese did a thriving business
Columbus is strictly a run-of-the-mill small town, until ill-health caused Herman[...]tories" evad-
which means that a large percentage of necessary ing inspection by the Booze ' Beer section of the fed-
commodities are purchased locally. at[...]ced flour.
can be no booms, business-wise, unless the unexpected
But the real boosters of all business was the open-
happens. Since the first home was built here about
ing of the quarry in 1900. This brought forty families
1881,[...]to Columbus, many of whom stayed for many years.
precinct cast 53 votes and the log school house had
Equally important was the establishment of "Timber-
11 students enrolled. ·w hen the new rock schoolhouse[...]d in 1897 some 55 youngsters names were listed on
the roster. By 1900 the population was placed at 178.
Today it is approximately 1,280-the same as the of-
ficial 1960 census. In 1893 Columbus had four
gr[...]ut about 20 are operat-
ing today. That same year the Tri-County ews car-
ried five saloon ads-today th[...]oday. In 1893 two denominations
held services iri the Gordon Hall-today there are six
churches availabl[...]is now Stillwater County had one
weekly newspaper-the same as today, although at one
time there were six. In 1893 Wong Toy baked the
first bread for public sale-there is one bakery today.
The unusual group of "small business" enter-
prises that arise in a town this size have made their
appearance during the years. Early days saw at least
one Chinese laundry in the town. One time there[...]nt eight, left to right: Billy Harper,
kitchen in the rear of his mother's restaurant where Malcolm Wo[...]Center: Walter
he did an overflow business during the holidays, and Quinn.
had a few particula[...]id prolapses in ewes, and an instrument
to repair the damage in case they did throw a womb.
He sold 200 of these "tubes" at a net profit of one dol-
lar each. In connection with his ic and[...]e could, and many times did, cure
and smoke a ton of pork at a time. Farmers eagerly
sought this outlet. Two brick yards operated for sev-
eral years, and the town once had a plant manufac-
turing conc[...]

They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (34)28 THEY GAZED ON THE BEARTOOTHS[...]Many presidential trains have traversed the
Northern Pacific since the line was completed in time
for the 1884 campaign, but the last one to stop at[...]Columbus was a brief stop by the one featuring
Theodore Roosevelt, on the Bull Moose ticket, in 1912.[...]as he had made an original appearance in the fall of
1904. At this time the train was a four-car affair with[...]guests at the brief receptions held on the train between[...]When the train whistled that morning nearly
1916 FOURTH OF JULY PARADE, COLUMBUS every able-bodied man was on hand to cheer the hero
Etta Weatherson, Candace Shaw, Elizabeth Blakeman helped of San J aun Hill. They proved their sincerity by an
get Prohibitfon over the hump in 1916 fall election.[...]pilot plant making
chromic acid, was operated by the Mouat Industries
for a few years, but is now idle on a "stand-by" basis.
As the nearest rail point to the great Stillwater
and Rosebud valleys Colum bus finds a lot of direct
shipping, esp~ially grain from three large elevators,
and calves and lambs to the eastern feeder markets.
This business had been curtailed some by the estab-
lishment of auction markets in Billings, where truck-
ing is the quickest route to a sales outlet.
With excellent water supply; fire department
equipment for a city of 5,000; many good service
clubs and a happy social[...], Columbus
folks probably live a little higher on the hog than
most communities.[...]ROOSEVELT CAMPAIGN, 1904

And the very small turnover of busineis establish-
ments is indicative of the fact that those who have It was the proud honor of Jamie and Burtie An-
"branched out" for themselve[...]nin to furnish trout for a breakfast for the members
with their · enterprise as they share in the economic, of this expedition, their Dad having been notified by
substantial progress of this wonderful "small-town." Senator "[...]gesture toward the president. The kids carried out[...]Another highlight of the campaign visit came
from the President to Hank Calhoun in the nature of[...]when the Roosevelt cattle venture in the western
breaks of the Medora-Little Missouri was at its peak,[...]and Mr. Calhoun was a top hand. The train was de-[...]layed an extra five minutes while guests heard the[...]W. M. Snyder, editor of the Tri-County ews,[...]noted in the next issue of the paper "For once H. J.[...]

They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (35) THEY GAZED ON THE BEARTOOTHS[...]The Columbus Pipeline
In the early days of the valley adjoining the
present townsite, small tracts of land were irrigated[...]would flow upward of three hundred inches, and was[...]a home for trout and ducks that wintered here. The
ditch that supplied the quarry with water, extended
to the Dan Nice farm and was sufficient for gardens[...]on the Dave Penman and Tom Triol homesteads. A[...]westside ditch wet down some hay land on the[...]bring water to the valley. To help with the project,
he set up the Cee Columbus Climb Club, pointing out[...]that plenty of water would make good business for the
town. And so the Columbus pipeline was conceived.

Burt Annin, Jesse Fraser plant flag on Sheep Mountain north of
Nye, 1904. They called it Point Ted[...]for a Republican presi-
dent!"
Appearing on the back platform with the presi-
dent were Senator Carter, Justice Theodore Brantly,
Judge Loud of the Yellowstone District Court, and
Bill Lindsay, Gle[...]reporters and a
couple other candidates.
At the extreme left of the picture are two kids,
the author and his brother, Burt. We had just pre-
sented the official train with a big catch of trout. The
President showed his appreciation by having his s[...]prominent publicity
by publishing in their ad in the Youth's Companion a
picture of the string of fish and a brief account of the
incident.[...]Jan tt , Mr. and Mr . Clarke. Mr. Clarke had
The boon buddies of schoolboy days, the Fraser the fore ight that brought water to the olumbu area.

and Annin brothers, further displayed their patriotism
and hero worship of President Teddy by making a Contracts wer let for the con truction of a pip -
camping trip to the mountains and planted a flag on line that found it wat r our in th hane ditch
the top-most point of She p Mountain just north of which tapp d the tillwat r about six miles south f
ye. This was an exciting xperience. In scaling the olurnbus, and gain d el vation until it wa suffi i nt
bluff from the front we encountered a ste p break[...]iphon r ach d from
which we conquered by boosting the lightest one of the ditch at a take out point lightly southwest of
the foursome on my shoulders and he managed to[...]mething over a mile later wa div rt d
wiggle over the edge. We then tied our overalls to- to a series of large tanks on th hill ju t north of the
gether and made an overall rope by use of which we quarry. It wa a 24" woo[...]arri d
all got over. Jess Fraser and Burt planted the flag, 110 pounds of pr ur . It had a ri er to cross, and
and Charlie Fraser rustled ballast for the Eocene oil tracks to tunnel und r.
can in which we anchored the flag , while I took the ·when the town , as incorporated, on of the first
picture. We later found we could have gone[...]untain she pl town, and in 1908 the contract was let whereby the

They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (36)30 THEY GAZED ON THE BEARTOOTHS

a survey of the damage. In the swift current, Vollmer
lost control of the boat, which slammed sideways into
the south pier, and capsized. After some effort Mr.[...]Thomas crawled on the pier, from which he was res-[...]the boat. ear the Dick Potter home on the banks of
the river he told Mr. Potter that he would be able to[...]land the boat safely farther downstream. He battled
the swift water for nearly an hour. The News again
says: "Farther down the stream Lorie Harris was[...]to the river bank, to bring the boat home. Harris and[...]a Mr. Zimmerman saw Carl coming down the river
near the Henry Rosean ranch, four miles from the
accident. They tied the lines together, but could not
reached the man. At this time Carl loosed his hold
on the boat, and was floating, with his head down
on one of the oars, apparently resting (for he was a[...]strong and skillful swimmer). He heard the man
groan, and clutch at his heart. The head went under
the water, and reappeared several times before he[...]sank from sight. John Altop and another man, in the[...]when his head bobbed above the river for the last
time." His body was found by the Sitzman boys near
"pipeline" was tapped and mains of sufficient size in- Park City on a sandbar on July 12, ten days after his
stalled to service most of the town. Even without drowning.
sewers, this[...]During the winter the log piers were replaced by
as the old wells were filled in and abandoned. About[...]new ones of concrete, portions of which still remain
the same time a small pumping unit was installed on
in the river channel. The pipeline was replaced short-
the banks of the river, tieing on to the new city line[...]ly thereafter in time for service for the 1913 crop
in the event something would happen to the pipeline.
year, at the same time water was restored to the city
The spring of 1908 saw water on 400 acres of new
irrigation, and still plenty for town use.
Things went well with the project until 1912. The
pipeline log piers were just below the old piers of
the bridge that crossed the Yellowstone. When this
bridge was replaced by the new one southeast of town,
with the weight off the bridge piers tlie center one
shook loose during the June highwater, and lodged
against a pipeline pier, tipping it in such a manner
that the pipeline was dislodged. The Columbus ews
of June 27 reads:
"At seven o'clock last Friday morning, that por-
tion of the Columbus Land & Water Co. pipeline that
was suspended over the Yellowstone River, fell to
pieces with a loud crash, and the disjointed sections
fell into the swiftly flowing waters below. Very few
persons witnessed the disaster, but it was heard all
over town and speculation was rife as to what had
caused the peculiar noise. The strain crushed the
building that housed it on the north side, as the tube
pieces drifted on the cables toward the north bank. In
ten minutes $6,000 worth of damage had been done."
A week later, Al Thomas, director of the com-
pany and Carl Vollmer started out in[...]

They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (37) THEY GAZED ON THE BEARTOOTHS 31

mains. In the· interim the auxiliary pumping system Stone Quarry History Reviewed
had provided for the town water system, but could
In the days when new industry was essential to
not suffice for the 1912 crops. the welfare and growth of a community, Columbus
By 1915 the town was "on its own" as far as the came into its own with the opening of the stone quarry
water system was concerned, and the pipeline was in the bluffs a mile north of town. Ben Hager, an old
only an irrigation system, which was generally pleas- contractor of rock work, had examined a lot of out-
ing to all concerned. Ice had posed as a problem croppings along the Yellowstone, and finally decided
during the winter months, when only a small inflow that the accessibility and quality of the Columbus
was needed for town use. Leaks d_eveloped that caused stone was the best spot for his enterprise. As early
huge icicles and a constantly shifting weight on the as 1896 he had a small crew of men getting out rock,
pipeline. The endless job of keeping the line clear at all requiring slow, manual labor. The task was not
20 degrees below zero wasn't a happy one for water- so great, however, as the sandstone had a straight-line
tender, Ira McClure[...]ic cleavage, which made breaking and sizing the product
to photographers who got some wonderful pictures. easier than normal. The local stone barn and the Co-
After several years, a deal was agreed upon with lumbus Mere. Co. were early products, as was the
the Merrill Ditch Co., whereby their ditch was to be Grade School, and later, all the stone structures on
extended around the bluffs west of town, to provide Main street.
water for an even larger area than under the original But the big operation of the local quarry was
system. Later this project was completely revamped started when the 1899 legislature appropriated funds
by the Montana Water Board with a bigger intak~ and for the construction' of the state capitol, and the con-
ditch of sufficient capacity to cover all the available tractor who got the bid made a deal with Hager &
irrigable land. The pipeline was salvaged across the Co. for stone from the Columbus quarry. P.H. Hawk-
river, and the staves and irons dug out of the ground ins, local correspondent to the Billings Gazette, issue
all along the system. Only the cabled catwalk re- of October 6, 1899, writes: "The present year is a red
mained, a swinging foot bridge which was used only letter year ·in the history of Columbus. This is not
by people out for an aftern[...]ers a speculators boom, but a development of the vast
crossing -over to the Jungle Club (a social group of resources of the country. The bluffs to the north,
the town at that time) and their barbecue pits and[...]found to be the best sandstone in the state. The capi-
But the Columbus pipeline had paid for itself! tol building of Helena is being constructed of it. 1-[...]

They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (38) 32 THEY GAZED ON THE BEARTOOTHS[...]STONE QUARRY, 1900, LOOKING SOUTH

ready a spur of the railroad is being laid, and the vast ing material beyond capacity. The State Capitol
derricks of Hager & Co. are placing the stone on the Building at Helena, the federal buildings at Butte
market." and Helena, the original federal building at Billings,
As the business grew, Ben Hager saw a profit in hotels at Forsyth and Havre, the Missoula and Havre
the future and sold out to Mr. Frank, of Helena, who high schools, the Masonic Temple at Missoula and
organized the Montana Sandstone Company, and of- many other public buildings as well as private institu-
fered the quarry for lease. Frank had contacted Mike tions, awaited the delivery of stone for construction.
Jacobs in Chicago, who had just completed the stone The Montana Sandstone bought back the lease and
work on the Art Institute, and persuad~~ him to look Mike Jacobs was given a green light for any and all
the place over. In early 1900, "Daddy" Mike, J. B. types of operation. He was able to employ local
Annin and[...]people, which he did at all times, for the ordinary
immediate expansion. (In 1906 Mr. Jacobs became the manual work, but he went back to Chicago t[...]-Italians who were declared to be
First came the construction of the buildings the finest artists in America. Louie Corti, Pete Petosa,
necessary to house the saws, planers and rooms in Anton J acobucci, Victor Rocci, Joe Angeroli and
which the masons could work; also the hoists, power "Old Mike" himself, to name a few of the top stone
arms, cables and drills needed to get the rock blasted, cutters that served.
cut into proper sized "roughs" and moved to the inside. Building material was not the only product of the
Then came the building of a railroad spur to the quarry. Highly ornamental facades, and[...]ocks. Within less than to add_ a final touch of beauty to brick, frame and
a year the plant was ready for full capacity, and the concrete structures was in high demand. Cemetery
early big shipments consisted of six to ten flatcars monuments and headstones found a ready market,
of outside waste stone used for .P. rip-rap, as the and some of this beautiful handiwork is seen today in
beautif[...]busy period that at its peak saw play at the World's Fair, which later sold on the
72 men on the payroll, and a demand for the build- grounds for $700.00 and was the inspiration for orders

They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (39)[...]THEY GAZED ON THE BEARTOOTHS[...], started which threatened again to delay the project.
,,,,-; •~I[...]in the Boulder-Butte area that was putting out an[...]weather and tremor than did either the sandstone or[...]limestone. The special session was adjourned until[...]the session voted to use "Montana products" but gave[...]the job to the granite company on a compromise basis.[...]Much of the Columbus machinery, planes and saws,[...]were moved to the new spot, and a big portion of the[...]terials were fast coming into the construction picture[...]~">; with the evergrowing use of steel. Wages had in-[...]creased, freight rates were higher, and the skilled
Mike Jacobs, Mrs. Anton Jacobucci an[...]aturally, this competition reaped its
that kept the expert cutters busy for two years. Then[...]toll.
there were the grindstones in all shape and sizes
which developed into an astonishing volume.
The turning point of the quarry operation came
in 1910. The State of Montana had outgrown its
clothes and an annex was needed for the capitol. The
legislature appropriated $125,000 for the project and
called for bids. Figure as he could, Jacobs could not
budget this low. Another bidder was the Bedford,
Indiana, Limestone Co., and their bid wa[...]high, so all bids were rejected. Sen. Bill George
of Billings and Rep. J. B. Annin of Yellowstone Coun-
ty, who had worked untiringly for the use of Colum-
bus stone finally got sufficient support from legisla-
tors to have the Governor call a special session of the
legislature to develop a new appropriation that would
cover the expense of the much needed addition
in Helena. Again the Bedford Limestone was bid
lowest, but tests in the laboratory at Bozeman proved
it to be inferior to the Columbus stone and a fight[...]The 1 as d mat rial was n v r r tum d; th track[...]the soft thud of th st 1 bit and rawhide hammer[...]of the m n who had arv d the lion h ad at the[...]Halbau r to in estigate a re-op ning of the quarry.[...]Thumbs down! But Mike Jacob and The Montana
BOOM POLE FOR QUARRY[...]Sandstone Co. had had th ir day of prosperity and
to right : Orrin Carey, C. M. M[...]community use. Th ucc ful operation of th busi-
................ , ....[...]
They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (40)34 THEY GAZED ON THE BEARTOOTHS[...]Park City, at one time, was the second biggest
town along the central Yellowstone, as witness an[...]the 1885 edition of "The History of Montana":
"Park City, 23 miles west of Billings, on the Yel-[...]inhabitants. The location is singularly beautiful. The[...]Rugg, justice of the peace; F. R. St. John, carpenter;[...]and manager of land sales. An irrigation ditch 39[...]miles long is now contributing its wealth of water to
the village and neighborhood."
LAVELLE HEADSTONE At the general election in the f~ll of 1884, Billings[...]nd Stillwater 67.
ness for nearly two decades was the contributing fac- The growth of that locality from the time the
tor in the growth and progress of Col um bus through above was written until the birth of the county is
some mighty trying times. reviewed in the Christmas edition of the Columbus
ews, December 12, 1913:
The men that worked at the quarry were . gener-
ally a group of younger men and quite a few of them
unmarried. It was durmg this time that the local PARK CITY, A Town of Trees
opera house was built, to insure a better place to "With but an occasional glimpse of fields here
dance, or see road shows or silent pictures. Many of and there in the narrow confines between the hills and
the boys were good sportsmen, and the town had a the river, the tourist is not particularly impressed with
talented ball club, and good bowling teams, and some the agricultural possibilities of the great Yellowstone
happy days were left behind when the quarry closed Valley until the roar of the train going around the last
down. bluff dies away and the passenger suddenly notices[...]s entering a valley which gradually spreads
The use of Columbus sandstone did not entirely until i[...]easured by miles, and its value by
disappear with the formal closing of the quarry, how- millions. nd at the western entrance of the wonder-
ever. Before the last hoist was moved, and the saws ful district, nestled behind the protecting bluffs rests
crated up, Pete and Henry Petosa produced a stock- Park City.
pile of rectangular blocks of the stone in various sizes
to be used in their newly established monument busi-
ness. The father and son did most of the work, and in
the final years were aided by another son, Chris. For
nearly 30 years after the shutdown, the gravestone
workmen turned out several hundred cemetery mark-
ers of various sizes and designs that nearly rivaled the
massive pieces of the early days. The Columbus Ceme-
tery carries upward of 100 monuments and markers
that were created in Columbus. Other localities came
here for this merchandise and the business flourished
until the stockpile was exhausted, and the inefficiency
of hand labor made it impractical to use this product
further. The tools and equipment, as well as the hous-
ing of the Petosa Monument Co., still prevails at its
original stand on the highway a block south of the east[...]A town of over 200 then.
They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (41) T .HEY GAZED ON THE[...]CORNER OF PARK CITY ABOUT 1900
Left to right: Olney Taylor shack, one of first buildings; two-story Lon Russell saloon;[...]keted from some railroad center. Valley Creek was
the trip in the prairie schooners, settled in this region. the natural geographical outlet of the Basin. Park
It was to be their future home, so th[...]City was at the mouth of Valley Creek. 70,000 acres
and made what improvem[...]of non-irrigated wheat land are now pouring their
beautify the little city. A section of land was donated harvest through the doors of Park City business houses.
to them, and things st[...]Park City boasts of many improvements. Though
manner. The railroad soon came through and estab-[...]not incomporated, L11e united efforts of its four hun-
lished a station. The bare, sandstone bluffs north of[...]dred people have created all the conveniences to be
town inspired the officials to christen the place Rim-[...]found in the small modem town. It has one and a half
rock, but not so with the persons who had planted[...]miles of cement sidewalk, more than any oth r town
sprigs and started a city of trees. Bravely they clung[...]in the state in proportion to it size. A wat r system
to the name Park City, and Rimrock finally disap-[...]has been installed by subscription, and the Park City
peared with the list of unused titles. This was un-[...]Water Company tablished. Of this concern, J. A.
fortunate inasmuch as the general manager of the .P.[...]Russell is pre ident, and B rt Harri , s er tary. The
resented this stubbomess on the part of the home-[...]water is tak n from the big canal north of town, and
steaders, and in retaliation he changed the location[...]deliver d by means of underground lat rals to all
of the proposed railroad yards and shops from this[...]parts of the town. The cond largest b t dump in
townsite to Laurel.[...]the stat i the one at this point, thou and of tons
When the first great boom brought by the com-[...]pped annually to market at Billing , 22 miles
ing of the railroad had died away, things likewise be- down the vall y. Th Chamb r of Comm re ha been
gan to lag in the young city, the colony dispersed,[...]lks
dividing their property among th mselves, and the the water syst m, has also b n in trum ntal in plac-
greater part leaving the district. There was a stagnant[...]t lights in th littl municipality, which
lapse in the business life of the town for 15 years,[...]are also maintained by public subscription.
and the ambitious aspirations of the founders sank[...]Two faetor , which are great asset to the town
lower and lower. Just as they had about give[...]are the flour mill and 1 ator. The el vator was built
hopes of ever making a prosperous city, the sugar two years ago by the Russ 11-Mill r Company, on a
beet factory came, a[...]site which the Corwin Comm rcial Company released
lished. 10,000 acres of ature's choicest land became[...]to them. It has a capacity of 40,000 bushels and
a source of constant revenue. Simultaneously, almost,[...]handles the bigge t grain shipments in the county.
the theory of dry farming was launched and proved The flour mill is now being built and will be produc-
successful. To the north lay the great Lake Basin area ing breadstuffs in the early spring. Th company
with its fertile soil, the products of which had to be owning the mill are all local people.
They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (42)[...]THEY GAZED ON THE BEARTOOTHS[...]dise store in the busy little Stillwater County town.[...]Although in business of this kind but a short while,[...]Mr. Stoltz has built up a flourishing trade. At the[...]present time his window displays are symbolic of the
metropolitan thrift of the place. Mr. Stoltz is now ctn[...]his 11th year in the community, having run a lumber[...]yard previously to following the mercantile pursuit.[...]Sayles, one of the old timers of Park City. Mr. Sayles
is another of the live merchants who saw the great
possibilities of the town when the sugar beets and
PARK CITY STA[...], janitor and watchman. One
of the few that didn't "go broke." In addition to the above enumerated business[...]rk City furnishes work for three hotels, one
The Park City State Bank is a thriving institu-[...]store, and one coal dealer. A church af-
exposes the prosperity of the farmers when its state- fords a[...]or three different denomina-
ment shows a deposit of $160,000. The capital and tions. The .Park City School is one of its best assets,
surplus amounts to $25,000. Bert Harris has been the being a beautiful, artistic br[...]seven teachers are employed to handle the grades and
been acting in the capacity of assistant for the past three-year high school cou[...]ions active in
Harris and John Chapman constitute the board of Park City-a fire department which is fully enough
directors. The bank is well equipped, and shows[...]and hose to compete with a fire
every indication of a bigger business for the coming of the proportions liable to start in the city, while the
year.[...]es music for all occasions, often making
One of the enterprises of the city is the Corwin side tours to Columbus, Laurel, or up the Clarks Fork,
Commercial Company> of which Representative John[...]started a drug Among the congenial old timers who have af-
store in Park C[...]filiated their business and social interests for the past
creased the business until now he handles every de-[...]oned Henry Steers and
partment. Mr. Corwin is one of the best boosters of "Dad" Searles, two of the first colony; Sam William-
the city, and at times has been an officer of the vari- son, of the Park City Hotel; Joe Gulde, the jolly man-
out commercial organizations of the town, among them ager of the meat market; Eugene Peck, the "bee man/'
being president of the Chamber of Commerce. It was whose honey exhibits have won him fame the state
the trust and service which he has shown the people over; W. L. C. Mitchell, Jack Cole, Joe Bassett, Forest
that made him the choice of the county convention for Young and Will Loffer, all of whom have found
Stillwater's representative at He[...]who have spent many pleasant hours in the busy little
business is the Park City Mercantile Co., conducted[...]with life as they find it there, would be to list the
partments of a general merchandise store, owning a name of every man, woman and child.
building 130x24 feet, which is stocked full of high The living conditions and city improvements have
grade merchandise. Mr. WelJs has been with the firm kept space with the business developments of Park
nine years. B. F. Harris is one of the old timers of town. Those little twigs planted so many years ago
the Yellowstone, 19 years of his life being spent there. have responded to the productive fertility of the soil
At all times he has been a leader with a "Better Park until they now tower above the business and residence
City" for his motto. The Commercial Club has his section of the town in great numbers. Their green of
name on its roster of presidents. He has been promi- the spring, their summer shade and their many varie-[...]eing named as chair- gated colors of the autumn season have their aesthetic
man of the Republican committee of Yellowstone. At effect on the people. Their branches afford a stage
present, Mr[...]six-year commissioner, from which the birds sing their cheery greeting to
chairman of the Stillwater County Board, and the the spring, and offer their autumn carol of prosperity
They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (43) THEY GAZED ON THE BEARTOOTHS[...]37

and plenty, before they leave for the southland. The
many beautiful lawns join with the trees in softening
the harsh touch which is so often found in connection
with the life of a small town. The effect of the grow-
ing plants and trees has brought about the environ-
ment of contentment to the residents so that there
have been many beautiful homes erected-more than
in any other town of its size in the state.
But the one factor which has made the town what
it is today is the unity of spirit which has been dis-
played at all times by the residents. It was the fact
that they all worked in a body which made possible
the flour mill, the elevator, the water works, the fire
department, Stillwater County, and every other enter-
prise which makes the town. Although the men have
been of different political beliefs, in spite of the fact
that they have been competitors from a business stand-
point, the slogan from the start has been "Park City
First." There are no poor people in Park City. The
affiliation of community interests has made it possible
for everyone to share in the prosperity of the village,
has brought about friendly communication[...]first school was built in 1886. Some thirty years
the outside towns, and has instilled a spirit of peace later the first high school graduation occurred,
and happin[...]rs than other consolidated districts is one of excellent stand-
it did nearly 80 years previousl[...]is renowned for its facilities and free useage to the
ture for any great expansion. Presently its popul[...]blic as well as its own people. Its fire
consists of the local merchants, retired farmers, or depar[...]ly adequate. There is no
men who are employed at the railroad shops or oil jealousy or selfi[...]shops, stores, a saloon and
postoffice. Its glory of other days in reflected in the It is possible that living in a town like this is
spirit of its citizens. The tiny town boasts of a finding life at its best.

They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (44)38 THEY GAZED ON THE BEARTOOTHS[...]
They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (45)[...]THEY GAZED ON THE BEARTOOTHS[...]Some of the Kids in Classes
of 1904 Later Played in the[...]
They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (46)40 THEY GAZED ON THE BEARTOOTHS

REED POINT
Although the Lewis Guthrie family had a store
and postoffice in Reed Point about the turn of the
century, it was not until dry landers started to flock
in, that any thought of establishing a town came to
mind. So it was not u[...]ite. Fif-
teen months later, John S. Campbell got the same idea
and located Campbell First Addition. As[...]6, and Campbells
Third Addition, July 2, 1917. On the Guthrie side of
the street business was booming too, so Lewis and
Sophia added a new Guthrie Addition, July 7, 1916.
In the ..midst of this rivalry B. G. Brockway came in
with the Brockway Addition, December 7, 1914.[...]and of course, the chairs and spitoons were moved up
so the fellows could continue "sawing their wood or[...]- MRS. A. L. GUTHRIE had done with the other one.

In a report to a meeting of the Pioneers of Mon- We now were working quite a cre[...]Mrs. Guthrie read a pretty fair history on the grocery side, a woman clerk in dry goods and
of the town of Reed Point, partly devoted to the hats, and an assistant girl in postoffice. While Mr.
operation of the store and postoffice, as follows: Guthr[...]k binders and Deering
Mrs. Guthrie's History of Reed Point mowers. Our machine[...]e, 80x.40, with a We were carrying a full line of shoes for men, women
full basement right in front of the old building about and children, also overs[...]In the meantime, we built a real nice residence.
postoff[...]We then built a large garage, the 100x75-cement floor
and shining-a cement approach[...]also
a fine big coal and wood stove just in case the steam We were buying flour and salt by the carload
heating would not be adequate for the very cold days using the old store for a storehouse.[...]

They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (47)[...]THEY GAZED ON THE BEARTOOTHS[...]REED POINT, 1918

All the while we were petitioning the commission- 0 ,
ers to build a bridge across the Yellowstone to the[...]had raised a headgate holding back flood waters,
the rush could not have been more definite. People
rushed in-professional folks and in all walks of life.
Emigrant cars containing household goods an[...]s,
two elevators and many small stores. In short, the
town sprang up overnight and turkey red wheat was
the crop. It was being stubbled in or whether it was[...]to 70 bushels and grew
everywhere it was planted. The women are to be
praised. Many of them left good, comfortable homes[...]J. M. Hiner won a car as a prize on
A bushel of turkey red had won first place at the his bushel of wheat. So our Commercial Club put up[...]a sign below the depot very conspicuous, "Business[...]these settlers on the dry land, for haven't we seen the[...]cattle trail for miles for water in the dry years?"[...]harvest time the grain wagons would be backed up[...]a quarter of a mile waiting their turn at the elevator.[...]Deeney, -- -----····· Drew. · though the farm rs summer fallowed, still the dry

They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (48)42 THEY GAZED ON THE BEARTOOTHS[...]all in vain. The good women who had so courageously come
1918 we could plainly see the "hand writing" and to help with such enthusiasm[...]er to have held back husbands for such a move.
the doom that faced us. It was a general bad time and we had to see the
1919 was the driest year ever known until this finish, which to us was a placing of thousands and
one. There wasn't enough moisture to have wet a thousands of dollars in bad charge accounts and
light blanket[...]take them
accounts and get out. Soon we gave up. The people out except as one volunteered to pay[...]So I say this is the way we went into the store
and the way we went out, via drought!"
The farms were worth nothing and of course, the 0 0 0[...]
They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (49) THEY GAZED ON THE BEARTOOTHS[...]petition or too much expansion. The town was on
FISHTAIL the homestead of John Mauer, who filed on the land[...]03, leased
"Fishtail, a country postoffice on the West Rose- to Tunnell, and finally sold to Mason in 1907.
bud, 20 miles southwest of Columbus, the shipping
and banking point. Has stage to Absarokee and Co-
lumbus." This is all the "History of the Yellowstop.e
Valley," published in 1907 had to sa[...]RAPELJE
As a matter of fact the postoffice was established Rapelje fared a little better, due to the fact that
in that spot about 1900 when the new mail route went it was the "end of the line" for the .P. and therefore
in that direction to service the many new home- enjoyed a trade area of several townships. It replaced
steaders of the Fiddler, Fishtail, and Rock Creek areas. the earlier established town of Lake Basin, with its
At that time, Stressley Tunn[...]was postoffice and store, a short distance to the east. The
an early postmaster. The Columbus Mercantile Co. town is situated on the homesteads of Alfred Chris-
bought this spread in 1908, and "Benny" Banks took tensen and the Secords, and on June 4, 1917, Mr. and
over the operation. A saloon, blacksmith shop, hotel Mrs. Elroy Westbrook filed for record a plat of the
and livery barn completed the business roster at that Town of Rapelje.
time.[...]"Rapelje has everything!" is the boast of several
It was not until March 7, 1913, that Joe and Addie · of its very loyal citizens. Two groceries, several ga-
Mason made a successful application to plat the Town
of Fishtail on a small tract of land which Joe owned,
and he boasted that the climate is so good, the water
so pure, and the fishing so excellent that in all prob-
ability we may be able some day to become the
county seat!"
Business-wise, Fishtail is about the same today
as it was then, but at least it doesn'[...]many re-
tired folks believed what Joe said about the natural
environment. The school system is vastly expanded in
the elementary grades. Local business was fortunate
in having the first access to the trade of the men and
women which the chrome development brought to the
upper country, as well as the construction and opera-
tion of the Mystic Lake power project. However, the
present business picture does not warrant either[...]ad quat to m t th d mand of th farm r and
stockmen of that r gion. The v ral I ator handle
a tr mendous olume of grain, and Rapelj i con-
sid red one of the bigger hipping point in r lation
to it size, in the state. Mail s rvic is mo tly handled[...]
They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (50)44 THEY GAZED ON THE BEARTOOTHS

RAPELJE, MONTANA, 1918

truck to the Billings outlets. The Rapelje High School
has a high scholastic rating[...]MOLT
has developed outstanding basketball teams. The con-
struction of oiled roads into Columbus and east to When the railroad came into the Basin in 1917
Molt may detract some from the volume of business several townsites were platted. One of these was the
on Rapelje's main street eventually, but there will al- Town of Molt, situated on a tracf of land donated by
ways be room for the present business establishments Mr. and M[...]the postoffice of Stickley.[...]victim of the close proximity and oiled roads to Bil-[...]lings, which precludes much hope for expansion of this[...]handle the large volume of winter wheat grown in the
eastern portion of the fertile Lake Basin.[...]"The postoffice was originally Stickley, located on
the present John Leuthold ranch. It was established[...]in 1909 and Jesse Keefer carried the mail without pay[...]moved to its present location, and the name changed[...]smith shop, bank, etc. Today the business roster lists
only the Molt Farmers Elevator Company and the[...]only seven dwellings occupied, beside the teacherage,
used during the school term.[...]one of the top communities in our nation in the pur-
chase of War Bonds per unit of population during[...]World War II and rec ived a citation from the Secre-
tary of the Treasury to that effect. nother oddity is[...]It wm still b a happy home to the f w of us still
Upper: Elevators a[...]

They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (51) TH E Y G AZED ON THE BEARTOOTHS[...]. .
to plat the pre ent to,. n of Wh at Ba in. For a while o af[...]th and th II Th la t platting of c ·
Still ater came in for some lot uhdi i[...]y Ed F llo,. s on th e so 1th \\ ork.
sid of th riv r above bsarok e. Th Billings Poly-[...]1920, but n v r officially platted th em. , lore of this occurred on Fchrna 20, 191[...]ut up into lot howev r nearly platted the town of ringtim , h po t-
thi[...]er and called "Foust" acr ag . officc of terrill, wl h 1at M d in 1 93.
They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (52)46 THEY GAZED ON THE BEARTOOTHS
They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (53)THEY GAZED ON THE BEARTOOTHS 47
They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (54)[...]schooner" and hit the overland trail for Marysville,
Columbus owes its scenic suitable location to the California, where he spent 12 years mining, milling
foresight of Horace Countryman, its founder, and a and doing construction work.
most important personage of its early history. On the move again, he went north as far as Vir-
This[...], stock and operated a moved his family into the Philipsburg area where he
built the first silver mill in Montana and commenced[...]he spent several years on the move-to the Flathead[...]about two miles outh of bsarokee, Countryman had
i ion of a new business venture. In the fall of 1873[...]tract of land three mile we t of Columbus, where he
et up the fir t trading po t tag coach top and[...]Buford at th mouth of the Y llow tone.
Th building was strongly built of log , with loop-[...]hol s for sharpshoot r to meet any attack from the[...]ar against th more p aceful rows, a w 11 as the[...]wh r he could k ep a mall supply of commodities
a ailable to the Indian trad at all tim s, a th river[...]two mil down the ri r. To me t thi comp tition,[...]th bluffs west of olumbus which was us d for a[...]
They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (55) THEY GAZED ON THE BEARTOOTHS[...]~. ,..., ,. ,-, • r

into a state of safety (and charged a toll fee). There "It[...]hat h had a pr tty fair
was a natural ford across the Yellowstone near his id a of , h r th Indian w r g tting th ir whi ky
well bui[...]which was used going supply."
to and from the newly established agency, but for
the benefit of foot travelers, he swung ~ cable with II tory al <lane of that
a suspended basket across the river, capable of car- ar a, , uring t[...]and t ch ha im of ir liv .
cents per person, but increasing tr[...]. to th idd
new source of re enue and in 1882 he built a cata-
maran type ferry across the river just a t of where Foot f
the bridge is located. He was also er dited ith[...]lac
having platted at least thr addition to the to" n, n all ·[...]·1 of
starting in 1891. In 1 93-94 he and Joe K m built
a toll bridge across the river.[...]: "Liver-Eater Johnson and Jack raft h d
the logs for a hot 1, completed in 1 2. It was r c- But ountr ma ' ro ity and
ognized as on of the best ating places b tw n dov n-and-out[...]h so ial c n- t with hi
ter for the area." of b ing ri t[...]d n
"Countryman was chief of the town. In addition tu in th a
to the hot l, he owned the toll road and f rry, with 1 , it o, d[...]s a sideline. These nterprises yi Id d hun-
dreds of dollars weekly."[...]e ting in ntory li t d om 00 it m ,
"On day the ferry brought in o r 200. The including a barrel of high t grad \ hisk at 52.50
nightly poker gam too[...]75, and Horace and board and bar ac unt of many w 11 kno n
didn't have to play for it-the hole in tabl was cu tom rs ar ing from 10 nt to 5. P. H. Ha -
always the winner. He charged four bits for his kins, admini trator, who clo d th tat g d
meals, and the bed were pl nty high."[...]

They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (56)[...]THEY GAZED ON THE BEARTOOTHS

One of the interesting events which marked the Muggins Taylor, a scout attached to the 7th
thrill-packed life of this pioneer was a ride of nearly Cavalry, had left the battlefield area and headed
200 mile pony-express[...]in carry- for Bozeman to spread the news of the annihilation
ing th news of the Custer ma sacre from his stage- of Custer's command. When he reached Columbus,
coach[...]he was exhausted.

ome of the inventory of the e tate of Horace Countryman. Creditor claims left a net estate of
about 3,000. The "old man" had given away most of hi hard-earned dollar to d titute friend ,[...]

They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (57) THEY GAZED ON THE BEARTOOTHS[...]d by a band ALEX COUNTRYMAN
of Indians, and but for the fact that he managed
to guide his horse to the junction of the Big and Alex Countryman, four years younger than his
Little Big Hom Rivers, where the supply steamer, brother, Horace, was born at the family home in
Far West, was waiting for orders[...]Cleveland, Ohio, February 18, 1828, and crossed the
Taylor could have been overhauled and killed. S[...]to California with his brothers Horace and
ing the steamer, Taylor began firing his revolver[...]living
and shouting, which attracted attention of the sol- in the Yuba River area, panning gold, he was mar-
diers on the boat. Seeing these armed men, the Sioux ried to Mrs. Catherine Plitspler Kern in 1860, to
band retired to the hills. Noting Taylor's condition, whom were b[...]Jr.,
. Col. Wm. H. Norton, who was a reporter for the
Helena Herald, condensed the report that Taylor
was carrying and sent Countryman to Fort Ellis to
put the release on the wire, and to report that Tay-
lor would spend the night in Stillwater. Arriving
there he made a verbal report to the officer in com-
mand and then drove on about three miles to Boze-
man. The telegraph line was down, so he picked up
a new mount at the stagecoach stables and pro-
ceeded to Helena.
About noon, when Andrew J. Fisk, reporter for
the Associated Press, and a writer for the Helena
Herald, were scouting for news, a dirty,[...]"Countryman, old friend, what in God's name
is the matter? What has happened?"[...]1 Mr. Countryman and a
command all wiped out on the Little Big Hom by nephew, Charles (son of Eli Countryman) came to
the Sioux."[...]in Montana. Alex moved his family onto
When the messenger had been sufficiently re- a homestead a mile east of Columbus. Charles took
vived by refreshments and a brief rest he told the up a claim on what is now a portion of th city of
story as it had been told to him by Muggins Tayl[...]ginal town ite. H got a
which was concluded with the lines "Curley, the d d to this tract in 1884.
Crow scout, was the on\y person in the battle who Alex ountryman died in hi horn in Columbus
escaped to bring the news. He said the firing was D mb r 19, 1 6. His wife, who[...]Pennsylvania on eptemb r 14, 1912, remain d in
the tearing ~f a blanket."[...]orth
Dakota, and official notification was sent the gov-
ernment.[...]TRYM
Reporter Fiske, however, had one of the bigg t On of th ons of ountryman was
"'scoops" of his career due to the pluck and endur- Dani 1, born in Jan ill , in Octob r 6, 1
ance of Horace Countryman.[...]abeth Payne wer married in operating the ranch of his , r .
a small town in Illinois. Four ·girls and two boys R on the W t Ro bud, January 9, 1910.
were products of this marriage, and gr w to ma-
turity in Columbus[...]ie, A rath r humorous incid nt i told of Danny
Margaret Quinn, Lizzy Woody and Rebecca R e[...]Dan was on a lazy mul , and
He was high in the Masonic circle of pioneer days. his dad on a fin hor . Th mul dra[...]Danny about not g tting th
January 15, 1898, at the age of 64 and was buried mule in motion. Th y wer attack d by a bunch of
at his own request in Deer Lodge. Indians who cam whooping toward the pair. Their
They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (58)52 THEY GAZED ON THE BEARTOOTHS[...]appearance aroused the sleeping energy of the mule,[...]really "lit out." As they passed the galloping horse[...]George Countryman was one of Alex's sons, and[...]helped on the farm east of town and eventually[...]er. One daughter, Vera, was born to the Country-[...]married the widow in 1901.[...]of his relatives and progeny ran afoul of the law[...]on several occasions, and his son, Henry, was the
victim of one of these tragedies._ Henry was born
in the Deer Lodge valley in 1867 and came to this[...]area with the family in 1873. As a lad of 19 he be-[...]Gibbons, and they were married in the Log Hotel

THE COU TRYMAN FERRY (1882 TO 1894)[...]Located just East of present bridge site. Left to right: In fro[...]

They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (59) THEY GAZED ON THE BEARTOOTHS 53

in Columbus in 1886. He purchased a portion of ways carried large d nomination bill , but b for
the land that had been homesteaded by his cousin, using any of th s he xhau t d his tock of 5 and
Charles, and built his own log cabin south of the 10s and count d out 100 ilv r dollar and[...]Here were born two sons, Wil- erable mor of th chang in halv s and quart rs.
liam and Horace,[...]n an altercation that away.
started over the ownership of a horse, but was in
reality a jealous rage, a fig[...]un from his hand and shot him dead. A
trial found the killer guilty of second degree mur- WILLIAM T. HAMILTO
der. He was released from the penitentiary after
four years of "good and valuable behavior." This[...]Billy"
reprieve brought an indignant protest from the citi- (Author's note: It is ith con id rable no talgia
zens of Col um bus and Mr. Countryman proceeded that I write the saga of ncl Billy Hamilton. I
to dispose of his property here and moved away a firs[...]nd's death Rose moved her mas program in the old n hall in 1 94. I had
family to Butte[...]married. She died at just rendered "Rock of " · a kit in which
her own hands there in 1905. Both of her sons were ettie Port r (13) had[...]ut cross, her filmy whit dr ss ti d with the gleam
established good citizenship records in lat[...]H tapp d m n th
and Bill spent a hitch in the penitentiary (term back and aid, "Littl boy, you did ry 11. 1-
shortened because of his youth). Clara presently lives way rem ber[...]and me for catching a tring of trout for Pre ident
Bill Countryman was appointed by the federal Roo evelt on his pr id nt[...]and worked und r h
Rev. Joseph Pope in the Butte area as an in p ctor n[...]and laid do n a $1 ,000 bill, with a sly wink
to the boys gath red around. Mulvihill w nt to hi
safe and came back ith the coin bo . Tommy al- 0[...]form d a compan for th I urp of migr ting,

They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (60)54 THEY GAZED ON THE BEARTOOTHS[...]the Rockies and plains where he was to spend the
balance of his life within their sight.[...]Just before the Civil War broke out, William[...]again set up in the store business. While there he[...]was elected a territorial sheriff of Chouteau County[...]years he moved to the Yellowstone Valley with the
intention of establishing a trading post, but Indian[...]fighter, for another 10 years, most of the time as a[...]Something of "Uncle Billy's" character was[...]Stough, staff correspondent, parts of which follow:[...]set an example the direct opposite of that of most
of the many would-be old timers, and has kept out[...]of print if he could. For notoriety loving scouts,[...]the limit set for the average mal), but is still straight[...]only catch him talking or thinking of old times in
Author of "My Sixty Years on The Plains." Personally sold and
autographed most of the books. the west. That he is an American by heart, if not[...]by birth is evidenced by the tattered flag whose[...]d from above his cabin on
his uncle being captain of this company. When this the Yellowstone, whose green waters whisper up all
un[...]ether to go to America or kinds of things to the "castle" window.
India, the captain's ballot broke the tie and the bark
which the men had bujlt spread sails and landed in[...]l Hamilton came to be
ew Orleans. In any event, the name "Indian' was an Indian in every respect of practice and habit.
to apply to Uncle Billy.[...]and followed their customs in every way even
The family went on to St. Louis, after traveling to those of costume. (Ed. note: Col. Allen always
many of the states, and settled there, where Mr. said-"Uncle Bill" lives with the Indians-I live off
Hamilton received five years of education, being them!) He was widely known among the various
unable to always attend school because of an asth- Indian tribes, and uni[...]advice from a doctor "Dad" The Indians always said he was the only white man
Hamilton arranged to have his son[...]they ever knew who could ride over the plains, day
train destined for Independence, Missouri, under the in and day out, naked except for the breech clout,
guardianship of Bill Williams, an experienced moun- and never be burned or blistered by the sun.
tain man who knew Indians, sign language, and the
Uncle Bill took his stay in the California gold
arts of trapping and hunting. These two were compan-[...]for gold. He pushed to the wilder north and the
the basic sign language, and was to become the most
mountains filling various posts in the army as scout,
proficient artist in this line in the entire west.[...]Benton that he recounted an affair worth men-
by the 1848 gold rush days and spent about five[...]er constitution and greater powers of physical endur-
the wife and baby died in childbirth, ·and a sad,[...]ce. His feats in this line are quoted today along the
They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (61) THEY GAZED ON THE BEARTOOTHS[...]for him to brace up er agreed on a trip to the mountains, and wh n
after a whirl with the boys by getting into a red they rode into the Stillwater canyon they rode by
hot sweat, then stripping naked and jumping through the camp of "Skookum Joe" And rson and A. S.
a hole in the ice into the river. This he learned from Hubble. Uncle Bill just grunted in answer to their
the Indians, but he was the only white man that greeting, and when h[...]d, "Skookum
kept it up as a pleasant pastime, and the old-timers Joe is the biggest liar in Montana." He was not too
now tell[...]e, either, with whom he had pros-
offended by one of Hamilton's pranks, challenged pested on the East Boulder as early as 1 69, when
the frontiersman to a duel. In a country where duels[...]Fort Benton.
usually begin · synchronously with the challenge this
When the prospectors "holed up" for the winter
struck Bill as rather funny, and he accept[...]me to old "Eagle est'' and camped in a
ly, naming the conditions himself. They were to[...]cabin there. One morning the horses failed to show
fight that night by moonlight in the street. Both[...]re all day. That night, when
naked into a hole in the Missouri river ice, four[...], two Indians
holes having been cut for each man. The entire town[...]ack signaled them to leave their guns
turned out. The Frenchman was game, and stripped
outside the door before they entered the cabin.
and took the plunge into the icy water. As the water
Brother heard nothing then, until one of the Indians
reached his waist, he decided the first hole was
jumped out the door and grabbed his gun, Mack
enough, and he cra[...]swung an ax, the Indian dropped hi gun and rode.
"Get into yo[...]urried inside where he found ncle
was standing in the water with his head just show- Bill with the other Indian backed up against the
ing. "Get in, or I'll claim the fight!" "Then take wall. Uncle Bill had laid his cheek open and was
your old fight," chattered the other, "I won't fight reading the riot act to him in understandable Crow,
this way[...]d ran which translated about like this:
up the street in the moonlight, Bill chasing him
and swinging his sword as he uttered yells of tri- ''You think Old Crooked o ( ncle Bill's In-
umph. Worthy of the wild days and the wild men dian name) i getting too old. Think again! If those
of the west! poni s aren't back tomorrow night I will dres the
other side of your face." It was an old Indian trick[...]th m and wait to collect a re-
of Hamilton ward. Th hors[...]the guns were I ft at ol. 11 n's wh r m m r
ext to the Rosebud Lake camp, and his orig-
of the tribe pick d th m up for th own rs who
inal spot in the ye City Basin, the home of the
had se n enough of iry, crafty ncl Bill.
McDonald Bros. in McDonald Basin wa a most
fa ored rendezvous of William Thomas Hamilton. I r m mb[...]is famous frontiersman, c rtain boundary line of th north part of Park ounty,
portions of hich follow: happ[...]l r ek wh re he was trapping, and wa d light d
in the summer of 1 3. He had just returned from to m et th old Indian fighter with th gr at r pu-
Washington as a witness in a tar Route mail line tation. In th cours of the i it th urv yor said
case, and was dressed like a[...]a little he had com t, hoping a chang of climat would
narrow-rimmed, wide- band d straw hat. He had help hi rh umati m. "I tak car of my a lik
looked upon the win when it wa red too often, th India[...]deal, so with th aid of hi rodman and ncl Bill
\ bile in the east he had secured the ag ncy th y fix d up a fir pit in th nt r of a "bath~
for a drive-well proposition and during[...]mall
August was busy putting down driv -wells up the saplings in. a circle ti d tog th at[...]all th tarps
lings. These ells were quite a sourc of annoyance and blank t that th y had. Th y[...]ards, as they were not atisfac- with a bunch of round bould rs about th siz of
tory to the farmers. a man' h ad, that had b n h at d out id to an
In the early summer the old scout and my broth- intense h at; then th y pul1ed the flap tight and
They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (62) 56 THEY GAZED ON THE BEARTOOTHS

waited until they were a lather of sweat. Then Uncle
Bill suggested the next step, which was to plunge • ' ,,[...]~ l,\.l~ "''\ '~;' I \( ~ i 1
into a pool of the water of Fishtail Creek, big enough
to submerge them. Uncle Bill went first and the ( ~l._ '4'\W.. ".t,, l (h \\ \[...]turn. I am inclined to think he
never completed the survey l It's certain he gets a
cramp every time he thinks of it. Of course, this \ ,.J""'-<\[...],

In his days few men would refuse a drink of
good whiskey, and Uncle Bill was not of the minor- ~ t5~t ~--[...], ~ .,,, ~N. - -~t
ity. One night he came in from the mountains and I\.'.~ - ' ·l C l. -
decided to camp across the river in the brush above
the old ferry. He must have gazed long on the bottle
before he went to sleep. The next morning Bill White
came to his camp and tried to rouse him, but couldn't
so he went across the ferry and told Col. Allen that
Hamilton was dead. They quickly returned to the
tent, and Col. jounced him up and down until he
was out of breath. "This is a hell of a way to treat
a corpse that's still warm, but what can we do?"
he said. He resumed this crude treatment and the
corpse opened his eyes. "Hello, Colonel, what are[...]you can't let a man die if he wants to."
This was the end of his camping out as he built a
shack on the north bank of the river that winter.
This was to be his winter home the remainder of
his days, but he rarely failed to spend at least six
months a year trapping and hunting in the mountains.[...]MACKAY D "U CLE BILLY" HAMILTO
did a good job of making it. He also could cook
meat with the b st of them , using as flavor a com-
bination of weeds and bark that he had learned from mong the venturesome homestea<lers who came
the Indians, and he wouldn't let the secret be known. into the East Rosebud in 1901 was Malcolm S. Mac-
All in all, though, he wasn't the succ ss as a chef kay, who filed downstream a few miles from the
that he was as a trapper. " ncle Bill" had his fa[...]men hav , but he was courageous and brave, the trapper's official base during the season. Uncle
honest and straightforward, warmhearted and a lov- Billy was a great admir r of this eastern tenderfoot
able old man with many fr[...]." advantage of Mackay's friendship to make him his
errand boy. The attach d reprint is of a note by[...]W.T.H. to his b nefactor anent a purchase of sup-
"Uncle Billy" ed Lots[...]groceries in 1902.
of Tobacco[...]Mr. Mackay, in later years, transplanted the
While rather temperate and careful in his ea[...]king, ncle Billy Hamilton used consider- the rugged old trapper had m ant.
able quantities of tobacco when available, sometimes
roliing a cigarette, but more often enjoying a pipe. A lot of the f llows who know the rrand boy,[...]Bill Mackay (who now
He would cuddle a small quid of chewing tobacco[...]runs this fine cattle spread), get a chuckle out of
for an entire day, removing it while he ate, and the dignified alibi, which was written many years
res[...]us quo immediately after com- later, when the tenderfoot was a res rved, well-
pleting his dining. thought-of business man of r w York City.

They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (63) T HEY GAZED ON THE BEARTOOTHS[...]The flag flew all the time over this.

"UNCLE BILLY" HAMILTO AND th close of school, o that it would look nic for
"[...]th Fourth of July.
This was a big day in th life of th chool[...]d up a mall cannon (whic had
One of the most substantial, if not the most g d from th army for ju t uch an ion)
pretentious, was the cabin (or "Castle" a he pre- black[...]uilt by ncl Billy shook th town. Ev ry hour of t day th t r
Hamilton about 1883, one of the first four perma- th cannon would b fir d,[...]a grand · blast in ju t un-
b come the village of Stillwater. It was built of do t · ho ncl Billy would ha
hewed logs, a roof of six inches of sod cov r d with n '\) of t w · h
clapboards and winnedg , a crude[...], and unti r -
connected to the big room with a swinging slab[...]rth.
i s w re always k pt cl an and ord rly.
The author a on two occasion a ictim of The a t Ro bud
a Tom Sawyer deal, which had be n rigg d up by F ire of I 99
Prof. P. H. Hawkins who also Ii d on th bank[...]tl ' · ·
of the Yellowston just across th road from th[...]ad got fairly dirty h
on the outside. Mr. Hawkins sold nd Billy th f
id a of whit washing it, and aroused enough patri- i
otic spirit in the ighth grade class at chool that t]
th[...]

They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (64)58 THEY GAZED ON THE BEARTOOTHS[...]breech clout, come out of the smoke on a dead[...]gallop, driving three other ponies toward the edge
of the lake. He quickly dismounted and ordered us[...]to get buckets and carry water to save the cabin -
fire had already set the corral poles blazing. We[...]carried water as fast as we could, and by using the
shovel a lot, and the water sparingly we finally got[...]a fire band around the cabin, and it was damaged[...]grimed by smoke and dirt, the hair on his arms and[...]body singed in his frantic efforts to save the cabin,
and his blasphemous mutterings about the men who[...]mighty proud of us and our help_ in the water sup-[...]back, exhausted from running the major part of the
three miles that separated them from the camp when
they noticed the fire.
Incidentally, that was the worst fire in the his-
tory of this part of the Custer National Forest. It
spread to the west ridges separating the Rosebuds,
swooped down the Black Canyon, and the east wa-
tershed of the West Rosebud, and then turned back[...]downstream, wiping out thousands of acres of tim-
ber, and putting the lone homesteader in there at[...]that time, Tommy Jones, out of the cattle business,
nearly, as fire destroyed the buildings and trapped
and burned the major part of his small herd of cattle.[...]back out of the camp, due to burning stumps and[...]boulders still so hot that the horses wouldn't try
Top adults : L. B. BanJc[...]Cabm. crossing over or on them.
TART OF EAST ROSEBUD DISASTROUS FIBE[...]some business affairs in Washington, Uncle Billy
said that he cried bitterly at the ravages the man-
in 1894 to about 108 acres of the lake shore. Here[...]ever got over it, and while he did retain own-
in the cattle business, and prospect. The care of
ership of the premises, he never again enjoyed this
these prem[...]a drug store for a while, but heartsick from the loss
had one time ordered burned by the Indian police he finally sold the tract in 1905. It has since be-
because it was supposed to be on the Indian land. come one of the wonderful summer homelands of
Our family group was granted the privileges of this the state, and nature has helped erase the scars that
cabin for a week vacation of relaxation, fishing and need never have been had Smokey the Bear been
huckleberrying. We had been in camp onl[...]effective in 1899.
night and had enjoyed the pleasure of a campfire A clue to Armstrong's intentions concerning East
dissertation by Uncle Billy of some of his earlier Rosebud Lake is indicated in an item in the Billings
days. Toward noon the following day we saw that Gazette, October 26, 188.5:
a fire had started across the river about a mile down "Major Armstrong, ex-agent of the Crows, came
stream, and a terrific wind was blowing toward the to Billings last evening. We understand the Major
lake. The oldsters had all gone berrying up the river intends to remain on the reservation, and has a fine
leaving the three small boys of the group at the ranch picked out, with a squaw man to hold it down
cabin, to fish in the lake if we wished. Uncle Billy until the reservation is open to settlemene
told us that the wind might carry the blaze across
the river, and went down to check the fire. Sure
enough, the fire started and spread swiftly and reach- Uncle Bill Hamilton and the
ing the grassy pasture around the corrals within Sign[...]Bill, naked except for a One of the many accomplishments of William
They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (65) THEY GAZED ON THE BEARTOOTHS 59

Thomas Hamilton was his knowledge of the sign LESSO TE[...]signs. In his illustrations and descriptions of the In-
his 60 years on the plains, and he was finally to be dian sign language, in many instances, is voluminous
called "The Master of The Signs." He is said to have and not to the point in teaching students a quick
been able to c[...]t knowledge in acquiring proficiency in the sign langu-
five tribes of northern Indians. age. In many instances his mode of describing move-
The Columbus school kids were among his pupils. ments of hand and fingers differs from mine. I taught
Prof[...]awkins was never hesitant about in- him the first sign he ever knew in 1876. He was ap-
trodu[...]ersions to his teaching sched- pointed Chief of Scouts at Fort Laramie that year,
ule. When he as[...]s chief in name only while he remained with
teach the students the sign language, the cautious the army. Scouts reported to him, he being on Gen.
In[...]ve at Crook's staff.
least 15 lessons at the Tri-County ews office to be 1. Close three fingers and thumb of right hand,
printed when ~pace was available.[...]ont,
When school opened in September, 1905, the horizontal. Move arm from right to left, as
first lesson appeared in the ews. Here it is: pointing to a body of men. Crook index finger
LES[...]downward and draw back to body quickly-
The following signs are made with fingers held in "Afraid of people or a man."
same position, via; three fingers placed in palm of 2. Put edge of . right hand to heart and move
right hand, first[...]hen up to chin. 3. Make sign "afraid of people" then place thumb
"Enough."[...]in palm and throw back of hand over to right
2. Throw back of hand over, then back to posi- wit[...]4. Put edge of right hand to heart, close both
3. Move han[...]tion in front of left. "My heart is strong. I
5. Bring hand[...]front 18 inches palm down, A D THE L ST LE O -13
move right hand back down, under left with I want all of our enterprising youth to memorize
a sweeping motion forward, arms length. "Go- the following ign . It will expedite learning the sign
ing to war."[...]OUR - A IMALS carefully the following. Many signs by hand in ame
1. Ext[...]ng r , thumb placed on first
up to palm of left two or three times, (indi- joint of middl fing r, ind x breast high,
cating beaver striking the water with his tail pointing outward[...]right and ind x fing r horizontal,
3. Ends of the three last finger in right hand of bring right hand toward I ft ith a quick mo-
palm, thumb on first joint of middle fing r, tion, bringing th nd of inde fing r to th
index vertical held 18 inche in front, wav nd of thumb. "Knowing uch to b th ca e.'
hand[...]deer." zontal, and bring the hand in a circular mo-
4. Third and little fing r in palm of right hand, tion in front and to th right. "I b lie e.'
ends of middle and index fingers placed sid 5[...]ontal, place ame on wrist
by side, ends of thumb placed on nails of of l ft arm and touch arm thr or four times,[...]e hand from right to left in a half the time."
circle movement and flip fingers off of thumb 6. Throw right hand over to right, with ind
as hand reaches extreme left of the movem_ent projecting. "Th other on[...]eer. "Black-tail deer." the course in sign language.-Wm. Hamilton.)

They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (66)60 THEY GAZED ON THE BEARTOOTHS

This brought on one of the most interesting extra- "I desire to say[...]ion that these
curricular maneuvers ever known in the Columbus mines were discovered and worked more than 20
schools. Every Friday afternoon the last half hour years ago by Mr. Hubbell and others before the reser-
was devoted to sign language, with assigned lessons vation was ceded to the Indians by the government,
on which to practice over the week end. Because of and 14 years ago by Anderson and myself, the present
space needed this subject was taught in the school occupants; but by false testimony offered before the
yard. On first appearance a by-passer would suspe[...]af and dumb ~chool, or a very different the effect that there were no mines or miners working
kind of calisthenics. It was new and we worked hard on the reservation, this section was included in the
at it, but after about a month of it, the students started Crow reservation, and Mr. Hubbell and a number of
a new approach to the project. They developed some others were compelled to leave their property, and
new signs of their own, and slyly conversed in the have remained absent until the recession of this por-
classroom with their new mode of communication, to tion of this reservation to the United States. We did
the distraction of others and extra alertness by the not return until the line was surveyed and we were
"Perfessor." One of the most popular girls in the class assured our land was off the reservation."
was asked a question by the teacher. She answered
him in the new sign language and was told to leave Hamilton Was Slow in Acquiring
the room. Frank Shane, who was part Crow, and American Citizenship
knew some of the language of his mother, punched One of the things that surprised and astonished
the writer in the nose when apparently I had got Uncle Billy Hamilton was the sudden realization that
mixed up. Some of the older modest girls slapped he had to be a naturalized citizen in order to vote or
some of the older boys because of their signs. By way hold office, as of the year 1894. -Called as a witness
of a holiday proclamation at Thanksgiving, Prof.[...]lings, over a mining matter, he
Hawkins abolished the classes in Uncle Bill's pro- was challe[...]t was great while it lasted! the fact that Hamilton was two years old when he[...]came to the United States, he was nevertheless not a[...]Major Armstrong ably the shortest length of time ever utilized he be-[...]nited Stateser as a Tri-County News clipping
The following item in the Billings Herald, March of October 6, 1894 shows:
20, 1884, shows that the agent and Hamilton were
bitter enemies in their e[...]of the application.
A long communication is published from "Uncle
Billy" Hamilton in regard to the burning of the miners "Damn fine thing," said the veteran frontiersman,
cabin near the mines on the Upper Stillwater by the "Hope they don't disqualify some of my actions as
Indians under orders from Major H.[...]Benton, and a deputy in other law
Indian agent at the Crow Agency near Absarokee. enforcement-to say nothing of throwing out an elec-[...]at "but maybe I should ask for a refund of the poll taxes
they sneaked onto the reservation was "maliciously I have pai[...]nd that they came and went by broad day-
light by the nearest route, "Before we went on the
claims," Hamilton writes, "we obtained from Major[...]"Uncle Billy" Jobs Wong Toy
Blake who ran the lines last year, a map showing con- W[...]east three credit, he developed quite a sense of humor. On such
miles off the reservation. The cabin burned belonged an occasion he saw Wong Toy fishing through the ice
to Jack ye and was nearer the reservation than the near the Hamilton. Toy was doing right well, and just
other three, two of which were owned by McDonald tossed the fish on the ice as he unhooked them.
and myself, and the other by A. S. Hubble and "Shook- "Catchin[...]taining bedding, mining supplies, hole in the ice, and was apparently not gaining any
and gener[...]"chased
that his police did not find and destroy the other me across the bridge and as far as the White ranch,
three."[...]

They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (67) THEY GAZED ON THE BEARTOOTHS 6[...]Perhaps the biggest contributor of early days to
the development and advancement of Columbus, was
from[...]Col. William H. orton. "Colonel" (this was a fic-
The Tri-County[...]December 24, 1847. He worked on the farm all sum-
May 26, 1908 mer and got short-term schooling in the winter months.[...]private in the fall of 1863 with the 50th Illinois In-
fantry and later transferred to the 60th Corps of the[...]ill and did not join his army
In services at the grave in Mountain View Ceme-
tery, Col. J. I. Allen, who was supposed to have been
the closest friend of the old scout and warrior, made
Residence of W. H. Norton, Columbus, Mont.
the following remarks :
"Kind friends, you all knew him, as did many
tribes of Red men. His life was one of adventure,
excitement and peril, while in government service as
scout and guide and following the calling of a trapper,
his years were passed. He roamed the hills, plains,
valleys and mountains-prospecting, hunting, trapping,
trading and warring with the Red men from the Mis-
souri River to the Pacific Coast, all over the Great
orthwest in the old buffalo days. He came and
pitched his camp on this river-the Yellowstone-and
built the home he called his castle. Here he has lived
among us for 27 years (since 1881) and here within
sight of the snow clad Rocky Mountains, and beside
the river he loved, we lay him down to his last sleep
in his silent home of rest and peace. But not for-
gotten!"[...]again until h participat d in h rman' march to the[...]th re. He was must r d out aft r taking part in the
Grand Revi in Washington, at th bas in Loui -[...]without any mat rial lo of lif or li t k until th y[...]camp of 1500 iou , rapaho and h nn Indi-[...]to st al the tock, but Mr. orton and his ten com-[...]hours th attack rs succ ded in tampeding all the[...]
They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (68)[...]THEY GAZED ON THE BEA R T OO TH S

Smith, this little crew had but 35 rounds of ammuni- The Crow agent, Dexter Clapp , sore because there
tio[...]was too much booze being sold to the Indians, got an[...]executive order that closed the northside of the river
Teams soon arrived and moved the party to[...]to settlement, so they went out of business. He then
Virginia City, Montana. orton a[...]worked for the government for three years, but when
tried fannin[...]the northside was again opened to settlement, he
tables with their last dollar in the venture. Grass-[...]filed on 160 acres, which is part of the Columbus
hoppers completely wiped them out. Bill[...]townsite, and built his own store in 1883 (where the
freighting contract and made good profit. He then[...]w stands). He operated this store for a
went into the mining business but with varying suc-[...]Billy Garrigus, and went
cess and in 1875 came to the Countryman stage stop,[...]into the sheep business until 1899. He then partially
wher[...]retired on his 200-acre farm adjoining the townsite[...]sembling the anti-bellum type of architecture. Here
ber of killed ia ..&imalecl a& three ba-[...]born on the Isle of Jersey, England, and came to
oa• day i11 the hllla. cut off from water,
GREAT BATTLE WITH[...]America with a sister when eighteen years of age.
The couple were domestic employees in the east for
THE INOIANS.[...]less a recluse, and her only association with the town
IUL CUITAR'I COMMA~D moat of their killed. Tbt NllllUIDI of[...]was as member of the Ladies Aid. Following her hus-[...]big to &be mou&b of th• LiW. Bona, outside her household[...]to the community. She died in the local hospital,
CUSTAR KILLE·D![...]all tbe anr,a of &b• killed aolctien. which her husband[...]offloen killed. 'l'la• whole of &b• Cu-
Thr86 Hundred Dead[...]tar family cti•d at ~• laud of their
Left on the F ield. column[...]wu Dot kDo,na. one-time correspondent for the Helena Herald, and
Both the adJut&At ud .......-, major rewrote the Muggins Taylor official notice of the Cus-
Oen. Cuetar•• Two aroth.,e, a[...]Countryman> the telegraph wires being down. It was[...]the first press realease of the tragic battle. When Yel-
up the u&tl1 B orn from Ha moet.la.
f!p,dt1t I>WJ)Olcll[...]representative, and was again named as the first rep-
boDa. arrhed laen lut :,i,[...]IIODl&Da) 1--. &a.
u ~ -p, of a bout t wo tboo- tn, coatrm• cbe r[...]o t e &laick- ~ eoauuod a& JI.no. Wlaeu the Ia-
_. portl p. Nodliq ia[...]obd likt a
IJYD ol &be opentiou of thia c1.. ... ...u, ,,.._[...]iD • uamnr n 'rioe. TIie .-a ,,..
the c:S.d. llaj?t Beno oo mancled[...]Joou Nrioa .
dtt Jo,r p.,rtiOD of lbe CUip. OltDC'al[...]WIN

'1JW ..a Dol ou of lda ~ I Wlled.
hess release prepared b[...]

They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (69) THEY GAZED ON THE BEARTOO T HS[...]He served as postmaster at Columbus for a number of
years, under Republican administration. Fraternally
he was a Royal Arch Mason. He was on the board
of trustees for several years, and an early day council-
man. He was local commander of the Billings G.A.R.
at one time.
Mr. Norton was[...]everything for Columbus. He subdivided a portion of
his property into town lots, and sold them under[...]rage building in Columbus. For half
price he sold the site for the present courthouse. He
helped finance the early operation of the stone quarry,
and invested in the local opera house, the creamery
and a midget flour mill.
"He was popular, progressive, honest-a real citi-
zen," said the Columbus News in its obituary

WILLIAM H. WHITE[...]Agency,
January 16, 1939. Miss Julia, a daughter of Chief
Crooked Foot of the Crows was born in the Stillwater
Valley in 1862. She passed away in her[...]me WILLIAM H. WHITE FAMILY
the parents of William H. Jr., Mary E. "Mamie,"[...]mie."
Minnie, Frank and Ada Montana.
This is the condensed biographical data on two of as he told it to historian, Dr. Thomas B. Marquis
the important makers of history of this area. A reads:
reader can then trace some of the events of his life
as he narrated it to reporters. F or ins[...]H brought i
I grew up as a farm boy with a couple of families in compani s hi infantry from Fort haw, Montana
Washington County, Indiana. Louisville, Kentucky, to the Y llowston in Mar ril our
was the trading center of that region and in the four troop of ca alry, un oved
autumn of 1872, when Mr. Cathcart went there to[...]·oin . W
to see more of the world I had taken all my be- th n mov[...]ting on bo f of
tention, which to me was a symbol of Abraham Lin- Indian troubl . map
coln, so I went to the station wher it hung. It was his d ision f[...]to go up Rose-
a recruiters office, and despite the fact that I was not bud r ek, wh b would g u
quite of age, the sergeant swor me in as a oldi r of Big Horn and Littl Horn. Our four troo f
the nitel States. We first were assigned to J Her- cavalry arri d at h of · Horn t
son Barracks, St. Louis,[...]th u . t
Wyoming. In May, 1873, our company of 225 men morning wait[...]hil ant Bradl
Bozeman. I was a memb r of F Troop, 2nd Ca alry and his 12 mount[...]and all
During this period Mr. Whit had the frightful fore s had b n kill h · d that
experience of vie ing th Custer Battlefield the day night camp d at a h y now
after the Custer massacre, as well as having the pain- tand . W saw hu f a k as
ful duty of helping care for the dead and wounded e w r going into[...]o in his ngage- came, w turned in for the nty of
ment of that same period. Some of his description, sentinels on guard.

They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (70)[...]Pages From the Personal Diary of William H. White
Written During the Days of the Custer Massacre[...]
They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (71) THEY GAZED ON THE BEARTOOTHS 65

The next morning we could not see an Indian[...]saw many strange dian University-one of the first Crows to be ducated
looking objects on the hills east of the river and about th re.
the same time saw a large moving group of men and In 1911, they sold th ir r[...]four miles southeast. When moved into one of th fin r r sid nc in Columbus,
we contacted them we learned that they were the wh re he work d at odd jobs in partial r tir m nt.
mounted cavalry of Major Reno and that there had After the death of his wif , h moved to th Crow
been a fierce fight with the Sioux and Cheyennes for Agency and became a guid and cu todian of th
two days previously. Their first question was:[...]did not possess the natural stoical instincts of her tribe.
It was then that we knew the report at the mouth
She was a student and lover of natur that imp 11 d
of the Big Horn was true. The objects we had seen on[...]er to enjoy life by her own tandards, rath r than
the hill that morning were corpses of Custer's com-[...]own people. Her obituary
mand! Upon investigation the sight was terrible~[...]reads:
Bodies were all stripped of clothing, mutilated and
dismembered beyond recognition, a display of human "An Indian by birth, Mrs. White at all times
savagry beyond belief. Most of the bodies were never prov d a true Christian[...]a charming mother,
But our job was to move the wounded 53 soldiers
ever blessed with the inherent love of the wild. Out-
of Reno's command. We had no tents or material for[...]of mercy whenever an mergency arose.
were many aband[...]s. In these tepees, still intact, we found bodies of The editor of The Columbus ews, (who was Jim
dead Indians, arrayed[...]ese Annin at that time), who has be n a pet of the de-
bodies we tumbled and moved to get the robes and ceased for nearly thirty years, is but on of hundr ds
poles> which when lashed together, then tied to a of fri nds who express our r gr t at her untimely
mu[...]atisfactory litter on which death and xtend to the berea d our d epe t sym-
the wounded could be moved slowly, but surely." pathy."
It was while on an expedition out of Fort Ellis Mr. Whi 1· i e was[...]. White saw a pretty Indian to a point of ·n traight-laced," who d cri d mok-
maiden near the Countryman trading post. This ing, drinking, ar ing- n om typ of dan ing.
daughter of Chief Crooked Foot became the future His firm faith wa own in th lo ing of many not
Mrs. Whit , shortly aft r Sergeant White[...]night thr
wedding this pair worked at the newly tabli hed f da · a nt of thi a ,
Crow gency headquarters and manag d[...]our t, pla d o
table for the agency mploye . a ing all th ir ag[...]o an allot-
ment they had s 1 ct d on th south id of th Y 1-
lowstone wher the olumbus bridge was lat r built.
Th ir home wa a s[...]ountryman
f rry wa their only public m ans of cro sing th riv r,
although Ir. V hit , an p rt boatman, ro d ha k
and forth daily whil he work d on the building
being con truct d in th illage of tillwat r. hortly
ther aft r h b am a ociat d wit[...]tt r
housing on th ir farm and u ssfully op rated the
layout, one of th ir proud ac ompli hment b ing th
announ[...]

They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (72)66 THEY GAZED ON THE BEARTOOTHS[...]and later chief -of scouts under General Hamey. Pease
then held the rank of Lieutenant and was known as
"MAJO'R" PEASE one of the outstanding frontiersmen of the territory,
(Written for this volume by L. W.[...]nfested with hostile Red men. His acquain-
author of "Footprints Along the Yellowstone." "Gay" tance among all the tribes made him an invaluable
was the son of Dick Randall, who came West to the representative of the government. He acquired a fair
upper Yellowstone in 1884, and was a well-known knowledge of the Indian sign language and could
pioneer, and the "father" of dude-ranching .in Mon- converse and understand the Crow language. Many
tana. Mrs. Randall is the grand-niece of the subject of times he was called on to become a buffer betwe[...]icle.) the friendly and unfriendly tribes. Through his in-[...]fluence, the Crow Tribe became friends of the whites
which lasted through the years. He was cool-headed,[...]a man whose uncanny faculty of sensing trouble long[...]cal situation. His knowledge of wilderness and plain
and the Red men and their ways made him a dean of
frontiersmen and a life-long friend of the Indian.
He came to Montana Territory with the Scotch[...]seven years before the time usually accepted by his-
torians as marking the opening of Montana Territory.[...]kota Territory to Margaret Wallace, the daughter of
a Crow woman whose husband was of Crow and[...]In 1861, Pease entered the Yellowstone Valley
and was one of the organizers of the fur trading com-
pany known as the "LITTLE OPPOSITION" because[...]it was in competition with the American Fur Com-[...]and in 1863 joined with the orthwest Fur Company
which soon after bought out the American Fur Com-[...]The "LITTLE OPPOSITIO COMPA Y" oper-[...]ated successfully all along the Missouri River from[...]Fort Benton to Fort Sully. Trading with the Indians
MAJOR FELLOWS D. PEASE[...]and disposing of these on the steamers coming up the
"Many of the historical facts, and the part that Missouri with supplies in the spring.
"Major" Pease played in the early development of Pease had now acquired the title of Major among
Montana, particularly as it applied to the Crow In- his acquaintances. He remained in[...]as special agent to the Blackfeet country. During
David Fellows Pease born in Tioga County, Penn- those years along the Missouri and the Yellowstone,
sylvania, March 7, 1834, was the eighth child of a among the Indians, Major Pease's life was filled with
family of 15 children. He left home at the age of adventures that would fill many volumes.[...]Gray. For a half- Then he took over the position as first U.S. Civil
dozen years he found employment wherever and Indian Agent for the Crows at Fort Parker, Montana
whenever he could i[...]ays gaining Grant dated February 8, 1871. The newly created
valauble experience and knowledge wherever he went bureau of Indian Affairs had just been transferred
and at whatever he did. Gradually he drifted, always from the Anny to civil, under the Department of
West-into Dakotc~ Territory and the Indian country. Interior.
Fello[...]
They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (73) THEY GAZED ON THE BEARTOOTHS[...]and justly proud of his many offspring, who are[...]on the Crow Indian Reservation.[...]deavors, as a man that did more for the Indians than
any other white man. Through the documented of-
ficial letters between him and the Department of In-
dian Affairs are revealed for the first time, the per-[...]Montana Territory, 1870-1873. The letters portray the
forebodings of a man who sensed the coming of In-[...]that later culminated in the tragedy of the Custer[...]acting secretary of the Interior Department on Sep-
ing, a cool head and knowledge of the Indians for tember 20, 1873, to bring a delegation of Indians
any man or numbers of men to cope with. Fellows D. (Crows) to Washington, D.C., which he did success-
Pease had all these[...]and be- fully.
came an invaluable agent for the United States as After Fort Parker was abandoned and moved to
well as a lifelong friend of the Crow Indians. He was the Rosebud, Major Pease in the spring of 1 75 to-
one white man of the few that they trusted because gether with[...]t plans to form a colony which was known as the Fort
that the terms of the u:eaty were lived up to. Pease Expedition, to establi h a proposed head of
Through the years Pease was Indian agent, he navigation on the Yellowston River at the mouth of
was cognizant of a two sided ituation that existed be- th Big Hom River. This idea had come from a
tween the government in fulfilling their treaty agr e- r port of G n ral Fo rtm nt
ments, and the Indian's side. He saw from the start that the voyag of th r y ar
that the Indian was being cheated in many ways. H e had proved the llo he
knew the Indian's ways better than any army men, mouth of th Big Ho ed
or his superiors, the commissioners in Helena, and in th opinion that owing k
Washington, D.C. Pease was hailed by those who and island and · om of n
knew him during tho e y[...]bly than any Buford to th s nt of w ·_
other white man.[...]rous Mi ·ouri
I have in my poss ssion copie of all th corr - from Buford to . Hi judgm nt wa undoubt-
spondence betw en F. D. P a and the up rint n- dly corr ct although opportunity as killed by nt
dent of Indian Affairs, who ere his bosses. These in[...]t I
Fort Parker, the original headquarters of th Major
Crow Tribe, that was situat d on the Yello stone abs nt
River, about ten mil s east of the pr nt town of whil h[...]r dy to
of an old adobe wall to mark the spot, wh r much abando rt wh n o the
important history of Montana was nacted, and which r . object of thi for I fir t
very little[...]bl · buff r with th · n the
lajor F. D. Pease's life can be record d with the wh fu r \ t and a trading with the In-
many daring men that helped to tame the W t, his dians in ral, until Majo[...]many hardships and exciting ad- a boat load of uppli and ultimat ly for using the
They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (74)68 THEY GAZED ON THE BEARTOOTHS

post as a base for operating the gold fields of Wolf After finishing elementary school, Lee[...]n known to exist, but which to this day at the Indian School at Carlisle, and La Vanita en-
hav[...]d from Mansfield Normal at Mans-
Ultimately the fort was abandoned, and soon field, Pennsylvania.
after burned by the Sioux supposedly. The Major In 1883, the son returned to Montana where he
consequently, had to store his boat load of supplies cut and supplied hay for the railroad contractors. He
at Fort Keogh.[...]never married and died in Seattle, Washington, about
Later he tried mining a while but he[...]aVantia became an accomplished musician
this up. The establi hment of Fort Keogh, 75 miles and teacher, and in[...]done a good service in influencing The long, eventual life of Major Pease ended Oc-
the Crow Tribe to cast their lot as friends of the white tober 20, 1920. He was laid to rest in the Rosebud
men rather than an aggressive alliance with the Sioux. Cemetery in Absarokee in the heart of the country
When the meeting was held to form a townsite that he loved so much, and had done so much to save
of Miles City, among other men, he was chosen to it in the heritage of the Crow Indians.
direct the company of Matt Carroll and Paul Mc- Mrs. Randall adds another interesting bit of his-
Cormick. That same year, William T. Hamilton tory to Major Pease. Part of a letter from her reads:
(Billy) and Major Pease[...]eral years ago we visited Harriet Mallon Clark at
the present site of Columbus. the ranch on the Boulder River, south of Big Timber.
Later Pease became interested in developing the She told me she had a letter written to her[...]in Wister. In it he acknowledged that one of the main
the Bozeman Coal Company. characters, or THE main character in his book, "The
When the town of Livingston was laid out, Pease Squaw Man" was Uncle Dave Pease."
saw the opportunity for a new business there. In 1882,
he established himself there in the Livingston Coal
Company. Then in 1883 began the manufacture of
lime. He was an associate with a Mr. Myers under
the name Myers and Company. The first lime kilns
on the orthem Pacific west of Duluth were just a
few miles south of Livingston, on the Park branch.
Then Pease became intere ted in a brickyard and
manufacturing plant under the firm name, Decker and
Company, one mile from Livi[...]rable learning as a boy in Pennsylvania and
along the long trail of pioneering. He was an avid
reader, e cellent penman, his command of grammar
was above average.
He had ambitious[...]tion in eastern schools. His oldest son, Leet, at the
age of 8 and his little daughter, LaVantia, age 6, were
taken to Minnesota to the Major's oldest sister's. A
poignant story was told of the separation of these
children from their mother, Margaret Wallac[...]children and loaded them in a small
boat and down the Yellowstone to a steamer. Imagine
the grieving mother following along the rocky and
brushy shore along the river as long as she could see
them, carrying in her arms the youngest son, George.
After a year with the Major's sister in Minnesota,
the children were taken to live with the grandparents, Over 4,000 people watched 1[...], at Osceola, Pennsylvania. the Jubilee honoring their return in 1919

They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (75) THEY GAZED ON THE BEARTOOTHS[...]keep down hostile Indians, but to select the final sit
JIRAH ISHAM[...]scout and interpreter for General Miles. Part of his
The following item from The Columbus ews, duty here called him into the Dakotas and eastern
January 4, 1962:[...]Montana Territory for almost two years.
"In the most beautiful comer of Mountain View As a "white collar" man Col. Allen worked as
Cemetery near Columbus, shaded from the hot sun clerk foi: Major Clapp, who was superintendent of the
of summer by a spreading tree, is an unmarked grave. Crow Agency headquarters on the East Rosebud,
The solid green turf that shields the sepulchre be- south of Absarokee; at the same time he "doubled" his
trays no information-only memory of a group of working hours as an employee of Mithoff & Kaufman,
veterans and friends recall who was buried in this who had a trading store at the agency.
hallowed spot nearly 30 years ago. The Colonel became a merchant on hi own be-
The occupant was born in Buffalo, ew York, half, and in 1883 bought his own little store in the
December 20, 1839, but was moved to western In- village of Stillwater (Columbus). Here he held forth
diana a[...]hat nature has to teach. He became for the Vaughn-Ragsdale building. For nearly 40
an expert[...]t at detecting years this establishment was one of the most interest-
tracks and trails, and from experience became able to ing, and most frequented of the town. Early settlers
deal with the outside world, be it man, beast or depended upon him for the "nick-nacks, novelties and
weather. And he finally chose for his home the great notions," as he so advertised his stock. The town kids
orthwest, where his talent could be s[...]fast-moving item, and many a quid of it bounced
As a young adventurer, he boarded[...]Benton, from which porium. His place was the source of a scant supply
point every moment of his earlier life was filled with of magazine of the day, "Grit," "Police Gazette," "At-
excitement, labor and many dangers. Arriving on the
"Emerline" at his destination, he spent his first Fourth
of July at the Joe Hill ranch a few miles from that
town. (This[...]t

the Yellowstone Valley after his first wife had died.
ear the present town of Columbus, in 1872, he mar-
ried a Crow woman, and lived on the creek that now
bears his name, five miles south.[...]buried on a hill that overlooks his
ranch, while the remains of another old Indian grave,
that might well have b en his wif ," hangs in a pine
tree near the top of the ridge, some two miles from
the present road.)
At a dance, he met WilJiam T. " ncle Billy"
Hamilton for the first time, and th ir paths cross d
many times in the near half c ntury that followed.
Gradually this man tr kk d ov r the mountain
into the Yellowstone and sp nt sev ral y ars trapping
and[...]m times alone and ome-
times with a partner. Part of this tim h as official
supplier of wild meat for the crew that wa building
Fort Pease, and for some of the army detachments
operating against Indians in this region.
At the time of his death, he was the last living
survivor of the Sioux attack on Fort Pease. During
this time he had b en an official scout for the Major
Reno command, and sp cifically as igned to the de-
tachment of Lt. Doane, whose proj t was not only to[...]

They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (76)70 THEY GAZED ON THE BEARTOOTHS[...]but a passing 20 words about the town of Columbus,
where the author spent his last years.[...]Oftimes our subject's words were given the poetic[...]more than half of which have appeared in The Co-[...]Gallant and gracious in the presence of white[...]relations with the ladies with the red skins, he never-
theless knew the thrill of romance. He could dream,[...]couldn't he? As witness by the following lines:
"Then in my dream I saw the mountain stream,
COL. ALLE STORE BU[...]Silvered and glistening, with the moon's bright
Judge George Simpson, Columbus[...]s-blending
porary publications. His bed consisted of ten buffalo With summer breeze that fanned the glinting
robes and a big sack-like pillow slip th[...]y). In hot weather Swayed foliage of the trees-rocking birds to rest.
he used but one robe to cover him, but as the days Beyond dark shadows of the wood-bright in
grew colder, he reached the ideal maximum of five Moonlight's glorious sheen,[...]Silent as ghosts, E'en as yet I view the
As a citizen he was most loyal and generous-[...]sts around;
citement, pleasure or advertising for the tiny town in Like startled fawn with[...]live. He had his own ever-changing The trail, sped to streamlet's pebbled shore:
political beliefs, and his religion was one of complete stood
faith, without specific designation. He was the most Where ripples kissed her sun-browned feet.
demonstrative of the towns patriots by constantly dis- Untamed
playing the flag nearly every day of the year, and
booming a toy cannon every 4th of July, until the town
council declared its noise to be a public nuisance (as
they also declared anent some of his sanitation prob-
lems!)
As a retired cit[...]ed California
to live, where he stood three years of disinterest and
monotony of relatives. He then returned to Columbus,
where he spent his last days as an employee of the
town, in charge of the information bureau and muse-
um on main street wh[...]ained for
hours to hear his delightful recounting of his many
years as explorer, Indian fighter and pi[...]an
excellent diary with compact notes (which were the
source of a book compiled by a niece shortly before
his death, but published about 1946. This book has
been the basis of this article.) He also loved to write,
and put into exciting prose many legends and stories
of "Livereating Johnson," "Little Dog," "Wild Rose,"[...]he carried a little resentment and sadness
due to the fact that his older idol had published a
book, "My Sixty Years on the Plains" in which he
never once recalled the name of the "Colonel," and CO[...]
They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (77) THEY GAZED ON THE BEARTOOTHS 71

Dusky maiden! Radiant spirit o' the night! seen old Colonel practically every day that we have
Her mantle off; the tawny beauty cast, with been in town, a[...]met
Raiment lightly clinging to fair waist, the lithe, him. ext to the Countrymans, Colonel is the "father"
Agile form! Soon came warm perfumed wind of Columbus.
to toy . His wanderings located him here in the early 80's,
With hair, the round form to caress, daintily kiss[...]tionery shop where he still holds out. The little shop
impassioned[...]as a meat market, was one of the aristocrats of the
telling[...]hut, and to the person who views it with an eye of
Whilst the dark-eyed, tender, sweet voiced[...]civic price it is a menace to the business beauty of
maiden[...]Main Street.
Implores! From orbs of night looks up, with
arms[...]siness connected with
Upraised, appealing to the moon, bathed in "Colonel Allen's." It breathes of Montana history.
Her silvery light. 'Oh Moon, fair moon,' Around the old wood-burning stove in its sawdust
she cries base the "old cronies" of the town have gathered for
Grant to me this boon that I may lover win! nearly 40 years. The patrons of the "free heat" have
Fleet footed; hunter, keen of eye, a brave been representatives of every type. In '95 it was the
Fearless with all foes! A lover, fond and true! cow-punchers of the Dun Looie gang that, tiring of
Grant this O Moon-my lonely heart's request! the game and brawl of the saloon, would gather
Still near the vision bright, entranced I saw 'round the fire and sing songs or tell stories; or it
H[...], coax, lightly toss might have been one of the ladies of the south side
Kisses from finger-tips, heavenward e'en to who would purchase here a bottle of her favorite per-
The beaming moon! Eager, low stooping, a fume, or stake herself to a can of talcum powder,
branch pausing in her purchases to pass the time of day with
She took, fond omen of desire; poised; wished; the gang there assembled '(for rem mber, back in those
Then cast it on the water. Through glittering days the best of us were none too good, nor the worst
shower[...]too terribly bad); later it wa th quarryman or the
Of silvery spray, the branch I watched; drifting, wool hauler by summer and th wint r trapper who
Darting adown the rapid current of the stream, dropped in to ay "h llo" to th olonel and njoy
I turned to meet the Indian maid-when lo! his hospitality; while today it i the r nd zvou of the
Mist clouds arise; my dream is o'er;[...]rk and void." ments in the mail, hurry to th pla to complain of
their lot and longingly pin for, and r call the won-
derful times of th "Good old days."
"Colonel Alle[...]a
"It would be unfair in an edition of this kind to tand and oth at ht
pass over the pioneer history of the town without · again;[...]ed
trend of thought.[...]h r adth ap ; ard
getting at the history of olumbus, we are going to
the i "hid[...]of hu d to bring[...], pani av rted,
Our first hazy recoil tion of the Colonel dates the li ation and[...]-day sucker" with has b " g pot" of individuality and id al .
an anise s d in the middle of it. Since then we have And it is a peculiar fact that a bunch of bananas cured

They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (78)[...]THEY GAZED ON THE BEARTOOTHS

by the aroma of "Dixie Queen" and fireside jokes were ed a dollar watch. "I haven't a watch/' said the store
always just a little richer, the peanuts just a little more keeper, "but I can sell you a fine pair of gum boots,
savory, and the candy just a little bit sweeter than or maybe a copy of the Police Gazette." Colonel has
that purchased anywhere else in the town. handled, in his time in the business, about every[...]commodity known to the merchandise game-and then
It used to be a sta[...]some. For every purchase Colonel would throw in a
the Colonel was approached by a customer who want-[...]" EARING THE E D OF THE TRAIL"

They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (79)[...]COUNT
BEARTOOTH MINING HISTORY
The present standby status of the operation of Eater Mountain in Gallatin County"-which was the
the chrome development affords an opportunity to extent of the legal description.
review as authentically as possible, the history of the
The next transaction shows a sale by ye to the
mining in the Beartooth Mountains and the Stillwater[...]whereby he gave
watershed. It is claimed that in the early sixties some
possession of Mountain View, Red Bird, Rough Rock
prospectors h[...]aims 1 and 2, and 4 to 9 inclusive, together with the
bilities, but there are no records of much success. The
remaining 2,500 inches of placer water which he had
next rumor tells that a[...]claimed.
scouted for the elson Story organization, and at one
time claimed a toll road around the bluffs west of Two weeks later, the Stillwater Mining Company
town, also ventured into the Stillwater Basin. He, too, sold these claims to the Minneapolis Mining and
abandoned extensive invest[...]tals, other than gold, would development, and the construction of ye City started
be found in these mountains.[...]diately.
Factual history, however, starts in the spring of In 1933, Jim Annin wrote a story of thi mining
1883 when Jack ye and Jimmy and Jonas Hedges camp a he had heard it from the Hedges family, Bob
gave credence to the many rumors and moved into Hudson, John Turco, Del Seeley and others who were
the Stillwater Basin in earnest. press report issued authority on the bu y days of the bustling camp. H re
in the late fall of '83 reads: it is:
"Jack ye and the Hedges brothers arrived from "But r[...]. ch th riv r b low
lead of copper-bearing ore 630 f et ide. Further-[...]n acr
more, they had traced it across the two forks of the on it abl start u on our trip up th
Stillwater for a distance of fifteen mil s." foll v a r[...]in this area, but th found rs had don a good
job of assuming own rship of th richer appearing
rock; records show that o er[...]itted his findings to old fri nds and r lati
with the result that th till at r mmg ompany
was incorporated that summ r, and by th pring of
1885 had sold stock nough to g t their min[...]
They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (80)74 THEY GAZED ON THE BEARTOOTHS

buildings which were once the housing of the Crow of the commissary, the assay office of the Minneapolis
Indian Reservation personnel. Our roa[...]Mining and Smelting Company, owners of the camp.
that takes us up the West Rosebud, thence along the Far up on Verdigris Creek is a big frame house con-
divide to Grove Creek where we hit the old Bridger ducted by two girls engaged in the boarding and lodg-
Trail over to the Stillwater. Narrow is the road .along ing business, and the noon call for chow is generously
sharp grades, and the dangerous hairpin curve, and responded to by many miners of the camp. Down
across the bridges that Joe Kern and his crew are[...]"Old Suis," quarter blood Indian provides for the im-
cator, the official 'freighters' for the new mining town. moral life in her new location.
We came to the bank of Verdigris Creek (Big Thing Over by the river is a log shack where Lee Lute
or Silver Creek) and reach a hump in the road from is running the first non-union laundry in Stillwater
which we can see the city of ye. County, at such times as he is not prospecting. The
It is built of one street, running east and west rest of the town is a nondescript mess of frame and
and here all the business of the town is transacted. log houses with a few canvas-frame shelters for the
Here are six saloons of frame and canvas, all of which newer residents of Nye. Higher up on the mountain
are destined to be destroyed by a ew Yea[...]eplaced, but half as many, the many prospect shafts being driven in the search
of more substantial logs and building material. Here for valuable ore.
is the big store owned by Tommy Ross and you can An inventory of the personnel of the camp re-
buy anything from toothpicks to rubber boots. At the veals between three and four hundred men, with the
end of the street we can see the fine frame buildings peak of population in 1887.[...]

They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (81) THEY GAZED ON THE BEARTOOTHS[...]75

George Emory, Minneapolis attorney for the com- ment from the locally constructed mill on the West
pany, was a frequent visitor, and Messrs. Griffith and Fork that brought all the lumber supply out prema-
Cole came to inspect the works on many occasions. turely, except for the larger booms and cedar timbers
Jack Radenick acte[...]as book and time keeper. Jimmy The smelter was modem in every detail and
Hedges tended the commi~sary, and directed the cook geared to handle low-grade ore that had been tapped
shack. The biggest saloon and gambling joint was i[...]by Jerry Toohey, who later came only did the Minneapolis concern have good prospec-
to his death in Red Lodge via the bullet route. Other tive volume, but several[...]able to supply ore.
each with a spread. Ladies in the camp were scarce. It looked like a very Merry Christmas to the folks
Mesdames Mushback, Toohey and Seeley were the who had placed their faith in the ye City mining
first three white women in camp but later on many districts-the new Butte of the worldl
of the miners sent for their wives. At the height of the[...]been working in the Stillwater Basin area, and over
necessary, church unknown and officers of the law
the range from the new mining town of Cooke City.
unwanted.[...]Their paths finally crossed.
The company worked industriously through the
Nye City wasn't a part of the federal domain in-
next two years. Despite the fact that the rock was[...]east of that boundary, on Indian lands included in
faults, or seams of rich ore which represented many
the Crow Reservation!
graduations of copper, such as copper-nickel carrying
as high as seven percent of the latter; some copper, Appeals were file[...]ying from IO to 50 percent cop- to see that the smelter would function, the area de-
per. There were also small amounts of silver and veloped, and the Crow tribe enriched by such opera-
traces of gold. Private prospectors were also coming tion! The government was adamant and Congress
up with some[...]etermined in its regulations and laws prohibiting the
tended areas. exploiting of tribal lands for such purposes. A dead-[...]line for removal was set, and within the next year the
By Christmas in 1887, a small type smelter[...]plant was qismantled and all the equipment, materials
been assembled, -well in advance of schedule, due to
and supplies faded down the long torturous road to
weather conditions. The company had anticipated
the village of Stillwater. Over $200,000 in actual cash
that movement of the heavy machinery, metal pieces,
losses to the concern which went bankrupt with this
pipe and other materials from the railroad point of
venture; the wasting of grubstakes and years of sav-
Stillwater to the mine site would not be possible until
ings; the sweat and toil of five years spent usele sly;
after the high water, despite the fact that much of
the despondency and futility of honest labor and hu-
it had been delivered to the rail head. Fording was[...]man endeavor-all this was a mockery of those who
dangerous, and nearly impossible with the heavier[...]visioned another "richest hill on earth!"
pieces; the ferry could not handle these type loads, and
the normal ice cover could not hold. Old timers recal[...]s, drifters and tim-
that 1886-1887 winter. After the first of the year a bermen stuck around for a few months[...]n a chinook, then several w ks p arances the camp was a "gho t." Later on, as set-
of below zero weather. The crust of ice that formed tler took up land in the valley, som of th logs and
wiped out many stockmen, alld found f[...]rks were salvaged for ne homes and build-
percent of Montana's cattle and horses starved to i[...]logs that lay in the clearing of the mountainsides,
were all that r main d of th lost city that might
It was a boon for the freighters. Ice bound trails[...]have made history if the urv y tak had fitted the
and roads made it possible to use bobsleds instead of
pattern!
the heavier wagons, apd a rate of travel nearly twice
normal. Every available sled was engaged, and crude Th final r cord of y City was entered when
new ones built. "Del" See[...]in operation stated that "at least eighty percent of the judgment deed for $12,255. H held the property for
heavy, unwieldly equipment was hauled up the new several years, watching the operation of the individu-
trails of the Stillwater River from its confluence with als who crune in, after the Indians ceded the land
the Rosebud, and in less than one-half the time that in 1890, and mine-staking was again within the law.
the mining company had anticipated." At the same And there were a few[...]

They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (82)76 THEY GAZED ON THE BEARTOOTHS

VERDIGRIS (OR ILVER) C[...]

They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (83)THEY GAZED ON THE BEARTOOTHS[...]
They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (84)78 THEY GAZED ON THE BEARTOOTHS
Billy Hamilton, John Willis and others, who remained Girl to Albert 'f. Irwin the day after Christmas, 1902.
to open new shafts, and test the rugged mountains October 30, 1901, Camp Hugheston-H. Enge-
for an exposure of the wealth therein; Most persis- moen, of Minneapolis, one of the stockholders of the
tant of these was Lee Lute. The story is now con- old Nye Company, was her~ looking over this prop-
fined to newspaper reports of that time, as follows: erty. We are happy to think that they are still con-
The Stillwater Bulletin, August 26, 1893: Nye[...]ing their mines. He was much pleased
News Items-"The Jackson Mine, purchased from at the outlook of the camp.'
James Hedges a short time since, has show[...]P.
in silver and nickel. This mine is located on the east Hughes has uncovered what is thought· to be the
side of the Stillwater one mile from Nye, and a little mother lode of this district. The lead, as it shows at
west of Bill Hamilton's mines. Mr. Lute has employed the end of the tunnel is about four feet in width,
John Willis[...]fifteen foot growing wider as he gets in. The ore resembles a
tunnel, after which he will take[...]copper glaze, and copper i~ clearly visible to -the
He will send samples to Livingston for assay, and if naked eye. The assay shows large amounts of gold
satisfactory will ship the ore to Omaha for smelting. and silver.
Mr.[...]strong to pay for work-
prise and could well be the first millionaire in the ing."
Stillwater Valley.[...]Tri-County News, January 29, 1903-"The breath
Should the shipping of the Nye City ore prove a of the new year seems about to transform the mining
paying proposition, as it no doubt will, that camp field of Nye, through the indominable energy of the
will quickly take on new life which will be a great mining companies, all of whom had almost expended
boon to the town of Stillwater and the surrounding all their means in developin[...]perties. As
country. That there are vast deposits of rich silver, fortune favors the brave, so with these miners whose
copper and nick[...]an be no doubt, and all that is required to bring the were to all appearances greatly against them, they
camp to the frDnt is the same spirit of enterprise dis- continued developing their pr[...]ts. They attracted moneyed men who employed
The Columbus Express, July 11, 1895: "Lee Lute,[...]Companies were
days ago from an extended trip to the mountains at organized, capital advanced, officers elected and
the head of the Stillwater. He has located many claims more men employed in sinking shafts and running
of great promise, also a marble quarry and some won- tunnels. The results gave unbounded satisfaction to
derful petrifications." the projectors. Another company is about to be or-[...]on: «Camp ganized with an abundance of capital behind them.
Hugheston is tucked away in the mountain range that There are many other valuable properties at ye, just
follows the Stillwater River, forty-two milet southwest awaiting money for development. When such occurs,
of Columbus, and six miles from the ye postoffice. farmers of Carbon County will find a market for all
The mountains are giving up some of their hidden their products and a second Butte will appear.
treasure to· the sturdy prospectors, whQ. would not Since last week, information is at hand of an-
yield to defeat, but continue on regardless of outside other rich ore body, uncovered by William Hibert who
prejudice that shadows this place. The click of the has considerable means of his own, is a man of more
heavy hammer on the drill, and the echo of the giant than average intellj_gence, and is n[...]exploit
powder is daily heard speaking in a voice of thunder his property, have faith it will justify him in the near
to indicate that the work is still going on, revealing future. Dan Ross, a few miles above ye, has opened
the hidden metals."-J. P. Hughes. up a rich body of gold ore and has headed east to
J.P. Hughes was an old prospector of Old Mexico interest needed capital. ye[...]that
and Cripple Creek fame who accidentaly heard of deserves our attention. Fislitail Creek, Red Lodge
the Stillwater mining district while on a casual visit Creek and the West Fork of the Stillwater, have re-
in Billings. He built one of the better homes in the cently shown outcroppings pf grea_t promise. The
valley at that time, in the immediate vicinity of ye most pr9mising mineral belts exist in the Beartooth
City. He hired help lavishly, as long as his hard- Mountains. As millions of idle capital is awaiting in-
earned funds held ou[...]was about broke vestment, I consider it the duty of all men who have
again (a fate of many prospectors) but refinanced his the welfare of Eastern Montana in mind, to let the
operations to run him until the final test, some eigh- outside world know the advantages to invest in this
teen months later, by selling nine of his claims- the mining area.-Wm. T. "Uncle Billy" Hamilton.[...]amount, Buckeye, Effie Ellis, Emma The lure of the gleaming wealth of metal still had
H., Hoosier Boy, Wilhelmin[...]
They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (85)[...]THEY GAZED ON THE BEARTOOTHS 79

the Boulder to find hidden placer that kept him good Lute and his crew, the prospectors finally banded
with his creditors; "D[...]together for a practical trial shipment in the summer
Hawks Creek (so named for him); John Willis and of 1904. Taking true samples from each of the several
"Gus" Oetjerdes were partners in a drift[...]h potential massive production,
such promise that the latter got shot and Willis got they sacked up from five to ten hundred-pound units
five years in the penitentiary, as the partnership ex- from each claim and made a six-ton shipment of ore
ploded. "Skip" Johnson, noted Deadwood prospector to Omaha for smelting. The results were disappoint-
came out and reported that the place had a future; ing. In no instance did the final production live up
and Nels Soderholm left his Cooke City store in to the assay analysis, and in no case would the value
charge of his wife, while he spent a few weeks in the of the ore warrant production under conditions that
area[...]existed at that time!
had interested some of his countrymen in the new The old patented claims of the Minneapolis Min-
venture and the Tri-County News of October 15th, ing and Smelting Co[...]Jim Annin and his father purchased some of them
Nye, where he will inspect the property of the Chi- from Park County for tax title, with a view of develop-
nese-American Consolidated Mining and Milling Co." ing one of them, known as Stillwater Placer o. 2 into
Still inspired by the faith and persistence of Lee a public campgrounds, inasmuch as i[...]a mile of the Stillwater River-a most beautiful spot[...]was manifested in the ye area mines. As it pro-[...]gressed and gave promise of a long drawn out affair,[...]William M. "Bill" Mouat, a nephew of the presi-
dent of the pioneer Minneapolis Company became in-[...]terested sufficiently to look over the abandoned prop-[...]mining experience in the early camp of ·Maid n and[...]Mr. Mouat spent th b tt r part of his life in[...]t nsi ar a of th B artooth . He not only utilized[...]group , including th r s rch departm nt of g ology[...]final nclu ion r that th r a ots of or , but[...]p I nt probl m of h not[...]BENBOW MINE CABIN, 1913
tart of chrome rninin1 in the Beartooths on Rock Cre k. years, exc pt[...]

They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (86)80 THEY GAZED ON THE BEARTOOTHS

,. . ,[...]

They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (87) THEY GAZED ON THE ~EARTOOTHS 81

a few helpers to complete the necessary assessment
work to hold the claims.
Then came World War II and the sudden need
for chrome. Columbus and the Stillwater valley
bloomed overnight-new business -houses and homes,
a paved road to the mill site of a new mining venture
that far exceeded that of 1885, a job for hundreds of
local farmers and laborers, and a happy, far flun[...]The biit millinit plant is due to be removed.[...]built for 200. Lloyd Badgley's store had piles of[...]lation consi ted of jut-ja d ]d Pro p ctor Bill Mouat[...]uat. Japs had chok d off th hrome

The jut-jawed discoverer of th hr me.

prosperity in gen ral. Then victory for the lli s, and
no further ne d for our xpensi ly mined chrom
But let an article from one of the popular magazin
of the day tell th story:

"Ghost Town, 1943"
"The handsomest ghost town of orld War II-
Mouat, a 15 million inv tment in chrom - at on a
shelf of ontana's B artooth Mountains last e k,
all but[...]es w r unscratch d. o pa-
tient had sl pt in the sl k new 50-b d hospital, fitt d
with X-rays and[...]dozen boy and
girls shouted down empty corridors of a choolhou

They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (88)82 THEY GAZED ON THE BEARTOOTHS
The big ,t ram line that carried the ore from the mine
to the mill, nearly a mile down the steep mountain[...]was sold to a firm in Brazil; the houses were pur-[...]chased in big lots by speculators for the greater part,[...]and hauled to new foundations; most of the buildings[...]and installations found other ownership, and the large[...]pile of 102,000 tons of milled chrome dust became
smaller as the heavy ~ inds down the canyon whisked
it on downstream. The government tried to find an[...]concern, to try to make use of it, but no effective[...]and the United States began to assemble its natural[...]with a stock pile of 900,000 tons ordered by the gov-
ernment, and American Chrome the contractor, to be[...]-new development.
that remains of town of 700. The operators, hoping to find a product that could[...]endure competition of other markets, put in a pilot
supply from the Philippines; the azis blocked the smelter. The chrome was of such low quality, that
Mediterranean route from T[...]ial gain. And
periled shipping from South Africa. The government when the stockpile had grown to the contract figures,
moved in with old Prospector Bill. the operation again folded up.
At Mouat, Metals Reserve Co. cleared away the An estimated $27,000,000 ha[...]ds since
hillside, honeycombed it with six levels of tunnels, the chrome business came to the valley. Much of
perched a mill twelve stories high in the canyon be- this has gone into the hands of local people and home
low. Mouat would supply two-thirds of U.S. needs, enterprises. These recipients regret that at this writ-
and never mind the cost. ing, the contractors are being investigated by a sena-[...]profits
tion workers and mill hands crowded into the five made in the interchange with the government of this
rows of new grey clapboard bungalows "downstairs' strategic material.
by the mill. Another 1,000-workers, wives and chil-[...]And once again a mountain of chrome ore, which
dren-moved into the upper town, planted grass represents an outlay of 65 per ton for recovery, is
around their houses a[...]dormant, subject to the vagaries of the winds, await-
But Allied victories in orth A[...]pped
again more cheaply than Mouat could mill it. The Iron Mountai[...]off to work in orthwest of Mouat mine lies Iron Mountain, the
Butte's copper mines. The Anaconda men who oper- most re[...]ation for Beartooth hidden wealth.
ated Mouat for the government went back to their[...]searching and testing an outcropping of iron ore.
after production began, were guards, maintenance Core drilling proving that the deposit was on an
men and their families, an occa[...]assessment work, which is heartening to some of the
Following the collapse of the chrome mining ac- old timers, whose faith is still firm , and would go
tivity, the War Assets Administration proceeded to[...]shovel if Old Man Time
liquidate its holdings at the mine and mill at ye. had[...]
They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (89) THEY GAZED ON THE BEARTOOTHS[...]rifle in the line with his pursuer and dusted a couple
ANDERSON of rocks at his feet. "Get the hell out of here and[...]"Got" a long 12-mile trail back to his
One of the early prospectors of the Stillwater own base. Interest in "Skookum's[...]great-
mining area, and one who seldom "came out of his ly lessened.
shell" was Joseph "Sko[...]x,
it is thought that it followed his living with the Chi- and in this congenial spirit boasted of the rich mines
nook Indians along Puget Sound, and le[...]had discovered► and practically given away. His
of their language while following the salmon fishing favorite was about a mine at[...]od," and his behavior while with them The buyers, he claimed, took out over a million dol-[...]s that lars. He also claimed to have hit the jackpot near
his name was derived from a variety of salmon bear- Castle, and again got a pitta[...]m that monicker. of the biggest liars west of the Mississippi."
"Skookum" Joe was born in Norw[...]. Line, really ill.
and like many others learned the sea and fishing "Doc" advised him to go[...]venturesome he operation. "Skookum" left the office. Three days later
boarded a freighter, bound around "The Hom" to he returned and said he was rea,dy to go. He con-
Seattle where he was not of age when he landed in fided to Dr. Line that he had removed his claim
Puget Sound. Tiring of fish smells, he yielded to the stakes, got rid of all his specimens, buried the work-
news of gold in the Rockies, . and the next known of ings and destroyed the assay reports. Dr. Line escort-
his exact whereabouts was when he, Ansel Hubble ed him on the train_ to Billings. It was the last trip
and others arrived in the upper Stillwater in 1883, to I. D. O'Donnell's, and his first and last to a hospital.
searching the elusive gold. Using the old ye camp He died within a week.
as base he prospected the area for many years, work- Shortly thereafter, Col. Hughes, who had moved
ing the Lake Plateau, Placer Basin and the head- into the ye mining area, claimed to have found what
waters of the west fork of the Stillwater. must have been ·~skoo[...]alone, and his friends were was "a big seam of gold-bearing ore." "Another damn
few. Among these was Dr. L. M. Line of Columbus, lie," said Uncle Billy· and[...]y supposed to keep Skookum healthy, heard the news. As it turned out, they both were
but was a[...]is right.
closest friend was I. D. O'Donnell of Billings, who I. D. O'Donnell was the only man that actually
grubstaked the prosp~tor, purchased the small knew whether th claims w r worth anything or
amounts of gold dust that "Skookum" managed to eke not, and his attitude would indicat that th y w re
out from the river bottoms, and submitted the better not!
looking ore specimens that the miner took to O'Don-
nell's home for assay. Anderson came out of the
mountains in the late fall, and spent the winters either
in Big Timber or Billings, but would venture back
with a new grubstake when the snows started to melt.
He would make about three trips to Billings during
the summer, driving a team of pack horses attached
to a light surrey to Columbus where he would leave
the horses, visit Dr. Line the required length of time,
then on to I. D. O'Donnell. Everything was[...]secret- even his benefactors were pretty well in
the dark as to the place$, time and value of his opera-
tions. One time John Willis, an old-ti[...]iving near ye, sneaked behind "Skookum" almost to
the top of Iron Mountain, in the hope that he might
get a clue as to where "Skookum" had his claim,
which was drawing attention, because of reported[...]
They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (90)84 THEY GAZED ON THE BEARTOOTHS[...]by one and escaped over to the East Boulder. He
A man who claimed to be the first. white child never "killed" an Indian,[...]on, a tattoo signifying service
must have been in the early '30s, for he was well past in the navy, on the back of one hand and piercing
maturity age when he reache[...]ne. Hair
first venture into Crow country was with the ill-fated and beard, a goatee, were snow white[...], that paused at what is now elled on foot most of the time, with a walking stick[...]Timber, a distance of 60 miles, between breakfast[...]is shown by the fact that the big nickel mine on East
Boulder, Hubble Gulch and the abolished postoffice
of Hubble were all named for him. He died as he[...]lived, a real "Mountain Man," at his cabin on the[...]but a rough-and-tough go of it while life lasted.[...](From, the book, "Jirah Isham Allen"-Mary A. Finney)
The fight was between 300 Sioux warriors and[...]friends of mine. It was one of the most desperate[...]Indian fights against odds I ever heard of happening
in the early days of Montana, and was also the long-
est in duration. It was early in the fall of 1875 that
this trio of brave and fearless trappers were on a[...]small tributary to the Big Horn River. They were[...]r-
This groups purpose and success is narrated in the ing surrounded by brush, willows, cherry and small
chapter devoted to early history in this volume of cottonwood. Some trails ran through the thick brush,
"They Gazed On The Beartooths," and his prowess but their location was so secluded that no one on the
as an Indian fighter is described by Col. llen later in outside could s their camp, only when the smoke
this article. from their campfire ascended.
Most of Hubble's exp rience in this area was as Their horses were staked and hobbled in the
a miner. When "Uncle Billy' Hamilton moved south[...]ile country
from Fort Benton, he became a partner of Hubbies in was an ideal one. They were distant from any white
prospecting the headwaters of the Boulder. About settlement, for outside the little garrison at Fort Pease,
1883, in company w[...]where I was located, for over 100 miles the country
moved into Old ye City, shortly after the ye- was inhabited by Indians only. This unequal battle
Hedges group had announced the opening of a big took place less than a year befor[...]battle with these inhabitants. In telling the story of
the fight to me, Hubble, as I now remember it, said:
"Pioneer Memories" published by the Sweet Grass "One afternoon I was down the creek alone,
Pioneer Society relates:[...]for beaver, when to my surprise I
"While in the Stillwater district Hubble once heard several shots in the direction of our camp. I
stated that he was chased up the Stillwater and to started at once up the creek, and had not gone far
the top of the Myers Creek divide by seven Indians,[...]
They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (91) THEY GAZED ON THE BEARTOOTHS[...]take shot at me when I shot him and hur- the East Rosebud, where we told the story of our
ried on. Cocke and Woody were tying up the horses fight to Gen. Clapp, the Indian Agent, and others."
so the Indians could not stampede them. Then we[...]Hubble died at his ranch on the Boulder Riv r in
we~t into the thick brush and the fight was on in[...]Sweet Grass County. It was a lucky fight for the
earnest. The Indians as well as ourselves had plenty[...]Crow Indians for the big Sioux war party were on
of ammunition and they fir~d volley after volley int[...]eir way and intended to take many Crow scalps and
the brush. One by one they killed our horses, then[...]ponies, (this is what they told afterwards), but the
the firing ceased a little and a few braves came[...]three trappers killed so many of their bravest war-
creeping through the brush on the game trails and[...]riors that it made their hearts sick and sad and the
we would take our time for a dead shot and as the[...]rd to relate
fell others would retreat to safety. The Indians con-
the sorrowful story to their tribe. ·
tinu[...]That this little party of three men showed won-
All through the night the Indians kept a con-[...]The early spring of 1877 found Hubble and
I asked Hubble if he[...]Horse and a band of hostile Sioux were on their way
''We worked[...]a trench for his protection and it was saw the trappers horses. They rounded these up and
well we did so. They had decided their mode of at- drove them away, and fired many volleys into the
tack during the night and at sunrise the next morn- brush which they were sure was the trappers camp,
ing they came en masse, and from three sides they then rode away. Hubble was not at the camp at the
fired several volleys cutting down brush, also the time but saw the activity of the Sioux. Hearing no
small trees.[...]"We understood in a short time, by a cessation of did not go to camp, presuming that his partner was
shots, when they intended to creep through the game dead, but started toward the Yellowstone where he
trails to us, and, as the day before we shot them down met some trappers. He told them what had happened
and as they retreated the shots and war whoops were and his belief that Cocke was dead. After a week or
heard again and the zip, zip, zip of balls flying over two they decided to go back to the camp. grew-
our heads. All day long the Indians kept this up until some sight met their gaze. Th re was poor C ke,
about the same time as they made their attack the day kneeling er ct, his rifle had fallen across his kn , a
before, then they moved off to the hills and the firing bullet hole in the forehead b tw n th ye , and £iv
ceased. However,[...]and buri d
venture far enough to go over to where the braves him n ar th pot wh r h wa found.
had fallen and secured two war bonnets and a num-
ber of scalps.[...]Hubbl for I a ing amp
"Hearing nothing more of the ioux, after dark we and not oing to h th[...]i ht thing or
preparations for our journey w 1 ft the place afoot. not, and J might hav don ju t what Hubbl did,
A few days later we reached the Crow Agency on I kno not.
They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (92) 86 THEY GAZED ON THE BEARTOOTHS[...]Lee Lute did not become a millionaire and the
SAGA OF[...]to town, built a small house, and was the town's best
LEE LUTE and only laundry operator. The mine had in reality[...]paid him fairly well (mostly by sale of shares of stock)
Among the original old-timers of Columbus was
and the urge to return to his Oriental home overpow-
Lee[...]ny Columbus friends, journeyed to Frisco and some
of his homeland, to be an instructor in Chinatown an[...]s later Wong Toy got a letter stating that
fringe of the Barbary Coast. Lute did not like the[...]y, but had contracted a fever and
placid monotony of such a future in a land of such
was very ill. (A later message from one of Wong
exciting opportunity, and resigned his missi[...]Toy's sons stated that Lute had died within the year.)
come a prospector in the gold fields of Nevada and
the silver leads in Colorado. About 1875 he came to Lute provided one of the many mysteries con-
Virginia City in Montana, and two years later arrived nected with the babyhood of Columbus. One day,
in Columbus to become the leading pioneer in the when Lute was in the mountains, Wong Toy received
search for precious ores in the Stillwater watershed. a message from a fellow: countryman, a Mr. Lee of
Billings-, that stated that a group of Chinese from
Frisco, were in search of Lee Lute, and said that he[...]should be warned because their visit was one of vio-
lence. Wong Toy took Don Rosner, a neighbor of
Lute's on the south side, into his confidence and ex-[...]Francisco and the_house of Lute was one that was[...]alarmed for the safety of his friend. Don told "the
Chink" to let him know if and when the visitors were[...]A few days later, the miner came down from the
hills and was told of the situation, and advised to get
back out of reach. The victim rejected this idea, and[...]project in the person of "three-finger" Dickson, a chap
who drove the stage on the lower end of the route[...]that the men had to come on "The Dinky," a three-
car local on the .P. and planned to watch this angle
of the entry. Lute stayed in the Rosner workshop, and
LEE LUTE was to be hidden in the attic through a newly cut[...]pdoor in case he had. to flee.
An article in the Tri-County ews of 1903 states: For two days Dickson watched the train, prepared
"Lee Lute, the scientific geologist, who for several to signal Rosner if anything happened. The third day
years has been prospecting in the mountain areas of paid off, two men got off, one carrying a suitcase, and
the Stillwater and Rosebuds, came to town yesterday the other a long leather case. They asked where Mr.
in the company of Mr. Hughes, who is organizing a Lute cou[...]-
mining corporation for ye City, bearing samples of ing to escort them to his home. In almost[...]i-
ore which he had taken from a claim which most of ble English they explained that they were friends of
the mountain sourdoughs think may be_the "mother Lute's people in China, and they had a present for
lode" of the vast deposits of this area. There is little him. At the house, Dickson drew his revolver, just as
doubt but that Lee Lute will be the first millionaire Don appeared at the door with a shotgun, and told
due to the high grade of the ore which will be taken the unwelcome visitors to "Stick 'em up,"-this lan-
f[...]guage they understood! The next demand was that
They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (93) THEY GAZED ON THE BEARTOOTHS 87

they start walking west> and fast. The hatchetmen it on account of Lute's potential wealth in the mining
started to protest, at first with pleading[...]. "Three-Finger" pointed to a boul- tive victim of strongarm robbery; or was it (as most
der about 50 yards down the road> drew his revolver peace officers suspected) just the work of a couple of
and hit the rock. He then pointed to the shoulder of criminals who had found the picking too thin in
the larger invader and signaled the startling informa- Frisco and sought greef)er pastures for their nefarious
tion that the next bullet would go there. The men occupation?
reached for their grips, but Rosner allowed-as-how
the luggage might weigh them down on their journey, The long case carried a saddle carbine, a long
so they had best leave it. Another motion of the bayonet-type sword and a Derringer pistol. The suit-
revolver got the men in motion, and they started up case had normal clothing and a packet of unidentified
the road with the gunner a short ways behind. They drugs. All of which would lead to the theory that
planned to follow as far as the bluff, but the guards they were professional highwaymen.
got[...]k Craft and another rider were in But, of course, they could have been tongsmen,
town from the Cardwell ranch seven miles west and bent on death!
upon hearing the story, they offered to act as a re-
lief detail and escorted the bandits as far as Merrill Lee Lute left Co[...]dressed to W. H. orton,
train that was stopped at the siding. and dated at Hong Kong[...]that these same two had arrived safely here the 18th of September. The steam-
intimidated a Chinese lady in Billings for money; they er for inland China sails the day on the 19th of Sep-
tried to strongarm another countryman in Liv[...]well. I will
but were chased off and finally one of them was iden- write you again what I know in my country. Please
tified as a victim of a knifing in Butte. attend my litt[...], your obedient servent. Lee
play quite a part in the early Frisco Chinatown); was Lute.

They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (94)[...]NA METEOR"
There was a period, shortly after the turn of the Ten machines converged on St. Louis to[...]olumbus, Montana, was a focal point for the prize. Among these was the machine of Santos
for the scientists who could see air travel a reality DuMont, the noted French balloonist with his ship
within a decade or two. The person who attracted that had startled all of Europe. The most expensive
this attention was Thomas Chalkley Benbow, and the ship, one that had cost $65,000, was owned by its
item of interest was his airship. This "vehicle" had[...]nationwide acclaim. much like the Benbow rig, except in price, and had
ten times the lifting power and twice the motor ca-
As early as 1901, Mr. Benbow had dreamed of
pacity. The simplicity of the Benbow machine and
and started work on a model of his specifications. It[...]row" exceeded only by Baldwins exhibit, the "Cali-
motor to give elevation, direction and speed. fornia Comet.''
Finance of course was an initial problem, as Ben- The Tri-County ews of September 29, 1904
bow was a struggling farmer li[...]"Honorable Patrick Lavelle, who returned from
the American avigation Company, with $30,000 St. Louis the first of the week, and who is a stock-
stock pledged, $5,000 in cash-enough to permit Mr. holder in the company, said that the 'Montana Meteor'
Benbow to go east and join the forces of ·Professor will make another trial flight very shortly at the expo-
Carl Myers, the nationally acknowledged balloon sition[...]ee entries left. They are
expert in America, with the resultant trial at Frank- Benbow, Baldwin and Francis Conteaur of Paris,
fort. And then for a period of six months there was France. Ben bow is the only one to date who has
nothing but experimentat[...]e a trial entry and he seems to
and a gas mixture of greater versatility. Apparently be in a fair way to win the regular prizes for this
both of these objectives were attained, for the next event.
issue of the local Tri-County ews reads: The first recent trial flight convinced the World's
obody who has seen Benbow's machine Fair officials and others as to the practical dirigibility
can doubt the ingenuity of his idea, and when experi- of the ship. The engine still does not have sufficient
enced men h[...]power, but we are sure to remedy that
doubt that the machine will work. There seems to be within the next few days."
a good chance that the airplane may win a prize at An A.P. dispatch ovember 3, 1904, reads:
the St. Louis World's Fair next year, but win or not, it "Floating gracefully in the air at an average
seems sure to be a paying invention. few days height of 50 feet above the heads of several thousands
ago a Texas fair association made an offer of $1,000 of spectators, T. C. Benbow made a successful flight
a day for exhibition flights of this machine." yesterday. The big cigar-shaped balloon with a bur-
When a grand prize of $100,000 was offered for den of cabin, motor, machinery and operator remained
the winner of the best machine at the World's Fair, aloft for 15 minutes during[...]concourse from St. Louis to Wash- rected the prow of th ship in all directions of the
ington, the Benbow people went to work, really. They compass, then slowly d scended to the ground near
increased the size of the motor again, used a new the starting point." On I ovember 22, 1904, the St.
lighter metal, to decrease the weight, and a larger Louis Post Dispatch s[...]order to carry more "After remaining in the air at a height of over
fuel for longer flights. He built a more substantial 2,000 feet for 45 minut s, a part of which time the
cabin, and a more perfect steering rudder. machine was propelled by its own motor power, the
They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (95) THEY GAZED ON THE BEARTOOTHS[...]r, operated by its inventor, T. C. Ben- The damage to the craft was considerable and
bow, was brought safely to the ground three miles Benbow did not have time to make another flight for
south of the Fair Grounds. Benbow said a leak de- the official entry, and the grand prize. The Baldwin
veloped in the gas line that made it impossible to ship with its more perfect construction and power
return to the concours.e landing in the face of a stiff only made two trial flights, on the second of which
wind, and the loss of power, when the motor died it broke its moorings and was lost in the darkn ss. It
out, made it necessary to steer for[...]yond further competition, thus eliminating the last
This was the beginning of Benbow's bad luck. On entry in the contest.
his next trial, with the machine in perfect running But Benbow[...]reinforced motor for extra power, he had run the concourse as he had done before, for $500
circled the concourse, directing the machine perfectly, daily for a flight. Before the fair gates opened, he was
when he decided to take the 15-mile test course. He starting on a flight, but was prevented from going up
ordered the guy lines cut and was raising up over the by the enforcement of the Jefferson guard, on the
grounds, when an anchor snagged and the balloon was grounds that the flight could not be made until the
entangled in the wire walls of the enclosure, where gates were open to the public or until the fair crowd
the wind whipped the carriage mercilessly. The spec- was big enough to warrant payment of the flight.
tators expected him to be thrown out of the carriage This was the end of the Montana Meteor. The
at any minute, but he was equal to the emergency gas bag was deflated, and the motor and cab boxed
and cooly came down a rope to the ground, while up and shipped back to Red Lodge. Baldwin also got
the gas bag remained snagged hopelessly."[...]
They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (96)90 THEY GAZED ON THE BEARTOOTHS

not so stringent and unfair. The "stalls" were emptied of the meet. After the guards had deterred him from
of airships. one of his flights, one of the St. Louis dailies quipped:
In reading the many news releases, Benbow with "Oh, don't you remember the airship, Benbow;
his small ship, his persistence and simplicity of his The airship that tickled the town.
craft, won a place in the hearts of the fair-goers, The airship that never once needed our smiles,
second only to R_oy Knaubenshue who was the hero And cared not a whit for[...]

They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (97)[...]ly for a moment, then with a mighty crash
pay for the blunder. Like the wind, passenger four all was over. Two men w[...]while more and valuable property destroyed. The price was paid.
swiftly yet, number five was thundering along the This was about five o'clock Saturday m[...]ere its crew expected to make October 4, 1902. The spot where the accident oc-
the meet. But number four had never halted at Rap- curred about 10 miles east of Columbus. ews of
ids, and about a mile east, where the track makes a the tragedy was taken to Park City, and surgeons were[...]lings, Columbus and Livingston.
one brief moment, of what seemed certain death-an- Fortunately two surgeons were on the train and about
other train bearing down on him and his doomed all that could be done to make the wounded com-
They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (98)92 THEY GAZED ON THE BEARTOOTHS

fortable was done at once. An engine[...]raig and trip. His body was crushed in the mail car and burned
Line went on it. Many from this place drove to the to ashes. Engineers Vaupel and DeGroat> Fireman
scene during the day. Loucks, Express Messenger Lewis, Brakeman Ken-
When the first carriage from Columbus arrived ney, D. A. Brace and son, Robert, and Mother Superi-
at the scene there was little left of the five or six or Ameidens were among the injured."
baggage, mail and passenger cars that w[...]0 0 0
the fire having devoured everything except the steel, The collision between the two passenger trains
iron and other fireproof substances. The sleepers and was insignificent, however, to an[...]that oc-
coaches remaining were pushed away from the burn- curred almost six years to a day later, and within four
ing cars by the passengers and section men. The loco- miles of each other.
motives, both large, powerful specimens of their kind, About eight o'clock in the morning of Saturday,
were telescoped together and almost tot[...]September 25, 1908, westbound freight 1287 and the
The strange thing about it was that both locomotives[...]ific Flyer Number 16 met head-on near
remained on the track. Young's Point, resulting in the death of 21 men, and
Fireman J. A. Campbell on number four was injuring 43-the greatest tragedy in the annals of Still-
caught in the cab of his engine and crushed against water County.
the boiler, then burned. Mail Clerk Andras Lundwall Engineer Willard Smith was rated one of the
took George Van Winkle's place on number five, to smartest engineers of the orthern Pacific line and
allow the latter to hear Sousa's Band in Billings. But the ranking member of the freight division. His con-[...]

They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (99) THEY GAZED ON THE BEARTOOTHS 93

ductor, James Hickey, was also a veteran of high John Powlas, an employee at the local quarry, Miss
rating. On January 14, 1909, they were indicted for Bertha Wolfe of the school faculty, Fred Robertson,
voluntary manslau[...]County At- Mrs. Hodson and three others. The first three were
torney Harry L. Wilson and released on $5,000 bonds instantly killed in the wreck, and Miss Wolfe sus-
to await trial, until such a time as the injured Smith tained sprains and bruises-the others escaped in-
could testify. His story was t[...]could juries, but had a ghastly story to tell of the tragedy.
easily reach the Young Point siding, but that the heavy Dr. L. M. Line, railroad physician,[...]e to a five husky section hands and made the 14-mile run in
stop 100 feet east of the switch, when he saw the less than 30 minutes, where they helped w[...]t arrived by rail from Bil-
jump and then "joined the birds" himself, breaking his lings to which city the dead and injured were im-
leg and later bruised a[...]t on a concussion and shock that Among the dead was Ora Babcock, fireman on
hospitalized him. "The two men were released from the passenger train and well-known in Columbus; also
the railroad but escaped punishment at their hearing[...]is brother, Abraham,
Ten persons had boarded the train at Columbus, was so shocked by his de[...]a stroke
among them Col. H. Hodson, Loren Stewart of Dean, and died the next day.

They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (100)[...]PHENOMENAL PROJECT
OF MYSTIC LAKE
Not being familiar with one of Stillwater Coun- of the lake, where it is to tap the tunnel, is over 25
ty's greatest assets, the Mystic Lake power plant, or feet, and the vent is to be sealed off with a coffer
at least[...]as it is shot through. This is said to be
review the construction and operation of this unusual, the most hazardous and exciting part of the project,
phenomenal project. And so we turn to The Colum- and the effect of the blast, to the lake and mountain
bus News files for details of the story. area, is creating much[...]l will be taken
alive, with his outcries against 'The hand of man rav- from the fish in the lake.
aging the beauties of nature to appease the God of When the water leaves the bottom of the lake it
Gold; or if some of the so-called conservation special- hits the six foot tunnel, 1,100 feet long. Where the
ists could visit the Mystic Lake project, they could tunnel pierces the mountainside, the water will be
get food for a publication where th[...]content. For there is no doubt about along the face of the mountain for a distance of more
it-the construction of the new power plant eradicates than one and one-half miles. It is then reduced and
the West Rosebud Falls, one of the most beautiful in
the state. This has been the objective of mountain
climbers and the lovers of nature's beauties, ever since
the Indians first discovered it. In three years the hand
of man eliminates something nature has taken millions
of years creating-six hours after the charge of dyna-
mite exploded in Mystic Lake the last continuous
stream of water will have passed over these falls, and
they will be only a beautiful memory to the thousands
who have seen them on a gay summer day in their
rainbow-hued glory. Hereafter, only the muddy
waters of the spring flood period, or the overflow of
the torrentous mountain freshet will grace the water-
way of the scenic West Rosebud to dance a moment
on the granite crest before plunging over 100 feet to
crash onto spray and mist in the giant chasm below.
But inasmuch as the power which does away
with the falls will pay one-million-fold back to man
the loss of its aesthetic beauty, let us look at the
project itself.
One reason for reviewing the plant at this time
is because early next month a charge equivalent to
more than a carload of dynamite, will be exploded at
a spot in the bottom of Mystic Lake, to shatter the
lake bed and "tie on" to a six-foot tunnel through the
rock. On this maneuver hinges the date of completion
of this plant. Incidentally this is the second time in
engineering that a lake has been tapped in this man-
ner, the other feat having been accomplished in Italy
seve[...]ive expert
from DuPont Company will be in charge. The depth WE T RO[...]
They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (101)96 THEY GAZED ON THE BEARTOOTHS
They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (102) THEY GAZED ON THE BEARTOOTHS[...]rilling and fantastic
inch point, at its entry to the powerhouse. Here it than th pi tur d chal t on the wi Materhorn.
will split to prop I two Pelton whe[...]no unb arabl hard hip .
One has to se the project to appr iate its tre- The " hooting of th lak " came off about for -
mendous scope, and the difficulty of its ngin ering. ca t, although d lay d twi , to th di appointm t
Millions of pounds of powd r were nee ssary to blast of many who had tramp d into th ar a to th
a six-foot road on the ste p mountainsid , on hich a spe tad .[...], pt mb r 30, ho
train railway could parallel the wood n conduit. Hun- happ n cl, and Th w of O tob r 2 rep r
dreds of tons of c ment wer used in the anchor "With m t of th Montana Pow r official
blocks and bulkheads of the artificial water cours . pr nt, in luding Frank . K rr, g n ral manager;
The work nee ssitat d the building of a fift n mil M. E. _Bu k g n ral up ri[...]k and camp fa- w kly, a w ll as doz n of sp tators, th big ' hot'
cilities. It required a little town at the campsite with that tapp d Mystic Lak wa tou[...]aft moon.
shops, supply depots and storerooms. On the moun- Th fini hing touch and th grand climax of two
tainside, which heretofore was for mountain sh ep year of marv lou ngin ering wa this charg of
and eagles only, have sprung up stables, mess hacks 3,000 pound of nin ty p r ent dynamit , th equiva-
and bunkhouses, projecting over the chasms on their 1 nt of a carload of comm r ial dynamit . The ex-
They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (103)98 THEY GAZED ON THE BEARTOOTHS

MYSTIC LA[...]

They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (104) THEY GAZED ON THE BEARTOOTHS 99

plosion put a column of water almost 250 feet into
the air, and sent rocks of all sizes through the heavy
50-foot cap of water, and up to points 500 yards away.
One rock[...]ctrician, who,
with his wife, had come to witness the show. He saw
the missile coming his direction and pushed his wife
out of its path. The rock hit his outstretched arm,
breaking and lacer[...]led six hundred
feet and struck within a few feet of Mrs. Charles
Hazen to bury itself several feet into the sandy beach
of the lake. The bank presented a mad scramble of
people running here and there in an effort to dodge
the shower of debris, while the water spout deluged
the movie man and Mr. Buck, who pushed the switch
for this fantastic engineering feat.
Deputy Warden _Dick Richards, representing the
State Fish and Game Commission to report the dam-
age to the fish in the lake. He reports but four dead
trout floating on the surface, but states that many
more might have been sucked into the outflow
through the tunnel.
But one feature entered the affair to mar its en-
gineering perfection. A bulkhead had been placed in
the north end of the tunnel, where it was to connect
with the wooden conduit, for the purpose of forming
a cushion again the shock. The concussion tore out First Manager-For man.
the lower part of this bulkhead, which in tum, re-
site at the plant. This is d tail d in th March 5, 1925
leased a four-foot diameter stream of water that shot
issue of The ews:
out as through a hose, to cut a new course t[...]"With the · a of
the rocks and trees of the mountainside. The unex-
Montana Whit ti
pected addition to the waters of the river, swelled[...]ic Lak p t lo
the stream until the footbridges along the pat-h were[...]m
submerged or washed out, and the third and second[...]t two
lakes filled to floodstage capacity. The effect of the[...]ling con d
newly-created vent in the bottom of the lake, was
of g
almost immediately reflected on the beautiful West[...]Rosebud Falls. They at one started to dwindlt•. The[...]h n
charge was fired at three in the afternoon, the morn- l d ju t a t
ing sun found the falls extinct. vf 1923, a giga r
The two powder pockets in which th charg was
placed, were almost fifty f et below the er t of
Mystic. Even after blowing out what remains of the
north side bulkhead, it will take 12 to 14 days t[...]hat head, it is estimated, and until
then work at the lake end of the job will be sus-
pended.
The charge was placed in a by-pass to the west
arm of the Y-shaped tunnel through which Mystic is
to drain. When th water has lowered to the level
of the artificial outlet, work will be conducted on the
east arm of the Y. This will b encased in a coffer
dam , with headgates, sere ns and control heads for
the wat r to be f d into th conduit."
Some idea of another f ature in this project, was Typical of the hundr d of camp who u e faciliti at th
head of 1y tic. L eft to right : Paul 0 ' eill, Tommy Fo vedt
the freighting of supplies from Columbus to the town- Paul Ro ean and[...]

They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (105)[...]THEY GAZED ON THE BEARTOOTHS

east railroad spur, and warehouse[...]Having satisfied themselves that the plant could
erected. The contract involved seven two-ton trucks, handle more water than what came through the tun-
three five-ton trucks, and one two-ton truck. The nel in the bottom of the lake, the Montana Power
five-ton trucks averaged 11,200 pounds per load; the Company went to work constructing a dam at the
two-tonners 7,520. The biggest months haul was in mouth of the lake, some three hundred yards below
August, 1923 with 1,306,256 pounds; the next wintry the original tunnel intake. After several months this
month of March, cut the tonnage to 156,850 pounds. project was[...]a good feet long, and a maximum height of 30 feet. An addi-
tonnage was developed primarily due to the new tional 42-inch depth can be added to the lake by the
hundred-thousand dollar road-the last fourteen miles use of splash boards with which the overflow from
of the route to the lake. the lake can be pretty well controlled. This dam has
The actual figures show a total pf 11,652,166[...]onsiderable area to Mystic Lake and estab-
pounds of materials, or some 5,826 tons. In round[...]fixed shoreline.
figures this included 1,700 tons of lumber, one-third of The latest development at the plant occurred on
which was the wood staves; 1,160 tons of steel, of September 16, 1960, when the plant went on semi-
which half was used for the penstock pipes, and the automatic control, and the normal crew of eight op-
balance for cleats and bands. The two Pelton wheels erators and maintenan[...]weighed 108 tons, and 135 tons to three.
of generators were loaded and hauled, the largest Despite the fact that the normal flow of the
single piece of equipment being a transformer at 35 West Rosebud has been changed, and the beautiful
tons. This had to be loaded on a truck[...]falls obliterated, nevertheless, a constant crew of
with a "helper" power unit in front of the tandem. fishermen, campers and outdoor lovers enjoy the
In all, a total cargo necessitating 200 freight cars -a nd beauty and wonders of this region, somewhat aug-
gondolas was used in the power project. mented by the courtesy and generosity of Lyal Piatte
Cn March 20, 1925, Bill Rohan, who had charge and his company directors.
of the work for Winston Bros., got a clearance dis-
charge, and the plant was ready. M. E. Buck then
pushed in a switch that started a "pilot" job of 2,000
watts of juice throbbing through the system, as a
stream of water reduced to an 18-inch head into the
Pelton wheels from a six-foot intake tunnel exert[...]a
human body with needle-like force quicker than the
fastest known projectile. The full volume was gradu-
ally accomplished with a maximum of 40,000 horse-
power.
William S. Spratt, a long-time employee became
the first foreman and remained boss-man for twenty-
o[...]VEN SCENES AT MYSTIC PLANT
field and Lyal Piatte, the present director of opera- Top-Pipeline around mountain.[...]of tram, plant camp, surge tanks. Bottom: Inside plant the
tions.[...]

They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (106) Chapter 9
SAGA OF CARBON STOCK
PROTECTIVE ASSOCIATION
The year 1961 became the sixtieth anniversary of retary and Dana F. Cushing, treas[...]an organization that played an important part in the bow, George Burton, 0. 0. "Baldy" Anderson, W.
development of Stillwater County-the Carbon Stock Archie Adams, E.[...]yle became
Protective Association. This consisted of the cattle- the original board of directors. The purpose was to
men of an area that was bounded on the east by provide protection[...]breeding stock, better range equalization and
and the Clarks Fork River to the Yellowstone, thence better cooperation in the matter of sales and shipping
west to the Sweet Grass County line, including all of cattle. Dues were one dollar per year and an extra
the territory remaining in Carbon County to the five cents per head for numbers over twenty.
foot of the Beartooth Mountains within the watershed Proper, legible branding was one of the mandates
of the Stillwater and its tributaries. to the membership. At that time the area which now
Joe Kern was named the first president, with compr[...]- ty-five brands recorded with the state office of the[...]state-wide basis, at the end of 1900. The fast influx
of settlers is indicated by the fact that the first brand
book put out by the association late in 1901 showed[...]recordings of over one hundred new cattle owners.[...]In 1944, the Beartooth Stock ssociation put out[...]hundred and thirty-five names- the tate Livestock[...]Checking back over the brands r corded in 1944 as[...]against 1900, th books how that twenty of the[...]original early brands are still in use by member of
the families that fir t recorded th m.[...]verson, of heep Dip, was grant d th u of a Dot L
on the I ft ribs. Thr month lat r th Montana Cat-[...]ti Company register d th famous 79 to go on the[...]wards (to look omething like a BL) on the left hip.[...]In 1883, Jim M nd nhall r ord d a brand, the 2[...]making it th old st brand of continuous use within
the county.[...]ECTIVE carried th profil of a human fac , omplete with[...]
They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (107)102 THEY GAZED ON THE BEARTOOTHS

Family Brands still[...]

They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (108) THEY GAZED ON THE BEARTOOTHS 103

seared the outline of a horse's head on the wide left Ed Cardwell had marked his stock with a long slash
ribs of the dogie. A lady's leg, below the knee stood that ran from the top of the left shoulder to the lower
out on the right ribs of cattle that belonged to Mollie part of the left thigh-this in 1886. Away to the east-
Loffer of Park City, and Andy Miller of the same ern end of the state in 1884, Teddy Roosevelt, was
locality sele[...]branding six thousand cows with an assortment of
his expression of bovine ownership. Frank Bern, who three brands-a triangle, an elkhorn or the Maltese
hit the Limestone Butte area in 1894 just used a plain[...]Cross, on the left ribs. For the greater part, however,
B E M on ,the le£t ribs. Ira Whitten, first breeder of
registered Durhams in this country, merely punche[...]brands that could be run with
out a round hole in the center of the right ear to let a straight bar, if the complete brand was not in one
folks know the animal was his'n. In the meanwhile, piece.[...]

They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (109)[...]HIT COLUMBUS IN 1894
Among the very faint memories of early days in ment to be found in Butte. He said that offers had
Columbus was the visit of Coxey's Army in Colum- been made to pay the railroad company for their
bus, toward the end of April 1894. This group was transportation to St. Paul, which offers were refused;
composed of laborers who were protesting the wage that they were honest workingmen on a peaceful mis-
scale paid miners and laborers in the Butte area, and sion to Washington in the interest of silver. ·
was organized in conjunction with a[...]ment Before he had finished his speech the deputies
in the northwest labor centers. The proposal was to came running down with drawn guns making their
"March to Washington" and present their case to way to the engine, the army jeering and making de-
Congress. They also[...]fiant denunciations as they passed forward. In the
gold to silver as the monetary base would be most meantime, the Coxeyites congregated in the cab of the
helpful to many of the Rocky Mountain States. The engine and car adjoining, and when the deputies drew
Stillwater Bulletin of April 28, 1894 reads: their guns on the engineer attempting his arrest he
"The announcement that the Butte contingent of hurled curses at them and dared them to shoot. The
the Coxey Army, numbering 648 men, under com-[...]was intense and a riot was looked for, but
mand of General Hogan, would arrive here at 7 before anyone had fully taken in the situation the en-
o'clock Tuesday evening created considerable excite- gineer pulled wide open the throttle and amid shout-
ment among our citizens, many of whom remained up ing and cheering by the Coxeyites, and glad demon-
all night expecting them at any hour. The army, strations by the citizens the train went flying east-
however, did not arrive here until 8 o'clock Wednes- ward, leaving the deputies outwitted and looking
day morning, the delay being occasioned this side of crestfallen.
Grey Cliff by their running out of water and their The army had gone but two miles when they en-
inabil[...]nk, which had countered an obstruction on the road, which was
been ordered emptied by Supt. Finn. They then ran quickly removed, the same being replaced after their
the engine to within two miles of this place where, passing where they had f[...]deeming it
with a single bucket, they commenced the tedious the wish of the company that they leave the road in
task of carrying water from the Yellowstone. They the exact condition they found it. o sooner had this[...]uring sufficient water to en- been done than the hired "bloodhounds" were again
able them to run to the tank at this place, where they upon them, but owing to the road being left in the
took water and returned to the army which had been "exact condition" they were again foiled, and it was
left three miles west of Reed Point. some time before[...]steamed into Col um bus with tion to remove the obstruction and continue the chase.
flaunting flags and loud harrahs and were enthusi- Arriving at Park City the train of commonwealers
astically received by the entire populace who gave halted amid the shouting of the army and cheering
cheer after cheer, wishing them a safe journey and of the citizens, who warmly greeted them upon all
success in their mission to Washington. They stopped sides. Speeches were made and they were almost in
at the water tank and had been there but a few readiness to start when the Butte toughs bore down
moments when a special con[...]nother unsuccessful attempt
marshals pulled up at the depot. At this juncture to effect their capture.
Cunningham, the orator of the army, stepped forward The next stop was Laurel, where the low hire-
and addressed the assembled citizens, denouncing in lings again made an attempt to arrest the engineer in
scathing terms the armed thugs who had been sent which they were foiled by the bravery and prowess
from Butte to effect their arrest, stating that they had of the industrial army, who would rathered have suf-
looked into the muzzles of their guns while waiting fered a thousand[...]upon them ; that they did not propose The Coxey Army left Butte at 2 o'clock Tuesday
to be taken by thugs, rounders and the toughest ele- morning, capturing an engine out of the .P. round-
They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (110) THEY GAZED ON THE BEARTOOTHS 1[...]with a crew and attaching it to a with her. The soldiers lost no time in boarding their
box car f[...]waving the army moved down on Livingston.
At 6 o'clock in the evening a train of U.S. deputy The train stopped in front of the depot, and
marshals numbering 65 left Butte in pursuit of the Cunningham addressed the crowd from the top of a
army.[...]. He said that his followers were not burns,
The train bearing the army made passenger time as reported, but honest workingmen out of employ-
to Bozeman, running the last 25 miles in 28 minutes. ment, who had decided to go to Washington in b e-
On arriving at Bozeman, the coal cars were exchanged half of the unemployed of the country. He stated that
for box cars, and bedding[...]cave-in had occurred in forcibly seized the train only when the railroad re-
the Muir tunnel the night before. There was no fused to carry them for a consideration. Citizens con-
trouble of any kind, the army being well behaved. tributed a large amount of clothing and provisions.
Several thousand pounds of provisions were donated From The Billings Times:
by the citizens of Bozeman. After coaling and taking At the depot it seemed as if the whole popula-
water and a rest, the train pulled out with flags fly- tion of the town had turned out-men, women and
ing at 10:05 a[...]children-to welcome the army of the commonwealth.
Arriving at Timberline, the train was stopped Cunningham of Butte, a man with a rich Kerry
and the engine, with a delegation of men was sent to brogue, and a tongue, that would stamp him as an
the tunnel to investigate the extent of the cave-in. orator in any assern bl~ge, made[...]ess in
There was found to be about 20 cubic yards of dirt acknowledgement of the welcome of the citizens of
on the track near the eastern portal. Immediate and Billings. He alluded to the fact that they were peace-
decisive action was determined upon. The engine able American citizens, bearing the American flag,
was sent back for the train and soon the men were and seeking to go to Washington to present their
gathered together at the obstruction. It was decided grievances in person to the American Congres . That
to clear the track. Men went in search of shovels, but they had not one man in their army who was not an
could not find any. Finally the men discovered where honest working man out of employment. H pointed
the section gang had hidden their tools under an em- to the armed deputies walking down th track and
bankment[...]teen shovels and characterized them as the off-scouring of th gam-
two dull axes were found. ling saloons and brothels of Butte. The crowd
They divided themselves into relays of 15 men and hooted, hissed and groan d at th d puti , som of
then went to work with a will. For 25 feet the track whom were recogniz d a x- onvict fro[...]and pimp and rounders. Th d puti s march d
number of timbers. Th clay was something awful st adily down past the train until th y r ached th
to shovel, yet men wad d into the thick, slimy mass engin . Th n they call[...]work. With th dull axes they managed, the I ad r, and in a f w econd th firing b gan.
by ha[...]r fir d. One unoff nding and p a ful itiz n,
the top of the bank crumb! d away and slid into the harl Hardy, wa hot through th lung , and fell
cut. This was discouraging, but the m n w nt hearti- groaning to th ground. Th n th citiz n of Billing
ly at work. For ix hours the men work d away in the took a hand, and with bar hands prun on[...]mud and ston , and cha ed th m out of th city.
liable to fall at any time. Th r was still thr e f et of ornrnonw al r, who nam wa not 1 arn d, was
mud on six feet of track and th r t of the tunn 1 hot through th fl hy part of th arm· McMahon of
entrance was cov red by from six to 12 inches of the Butt and a numb r of oth r had th ir h ad era k d
stuff.[...]in d with th working-
Getting up a full head of steam, J. B. Hannon, m n
the engineer, back d into the tunnel 300 feet· then Th wound d w r ta v r to Dr . · hart
with the whistle blowing and bell ringing, h charg d[...]d wound , and rl
th ob truction. The ngin tood the shock nobly, the Hardy was t nd rly car will proba di .
great wave of mud was shov d over and ahead of the ft r th fighting th fir b II rang and[...]falter d th man thought to b an alarm of fir , but it wa onl a all
at the throttle put on a littl more steam and th[...]uppl water to th commonw .al
victory was won. mid the che rs of 400 rn n old 542 ngin , , hich th y qu[...]d dragged her train ultation th y cam to the con lu ion that a fr h
They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (111)106 THEY GAZED ON THE BEARTOOTHS

engine would 1:,}e the proper caper, so they brought down to the depot. There they were hooted and
down o. 464,1 the hog of the Rocky Fork branch, jeered until it became[...]upled her on. Then after speeches from Cun- the railway company to take them anywhere out of
ningham and Hogan the engineer, James B. Harmon, Billings, excep[...]ngine
let old 464 raise her whistle with a series of blood- took them down to Huntley to wait for No[...]rieks, and she steamed slowly out amidst The Coxey train was captured at Forsyth Wed-
tremendo[...]nesday night by the troops from Fort Keogh. They
The deputies stayed up by the roundhouse until surrendered without resistance and will be taken to
late in the afternoon, when their special was backed[...]

They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (112)[...]IT
DEAD MAN'S CANYON
Between the White Beaver divide and Sweet W[...]s and dives
Grass Creek is a wide coulee that was the original sprang up along the stagecoach routes with the com-
route of the stage lines between Miles City and Boze- ing of the railroad, there was probably none as sorbid
man. How it acquired the name of "Dead Man's and vicious as the Nordstrom-Bill Brady spot between
Canyon" is told by Frank elson, or "Doc" as he is the West White Beaver stage station and Howie. Here
better known to the old timers of the Gallatin Valley, _in the summer of 1883, Al ordstrom built a small
and some pioneer[...]verted into a cafe-bar operation,
Nelson was the son of Mr. and Mrs. John W. and operated by B[...]e was who openly practiced infidelity with the regular stage
reared to manhood with the smell of livestock in his coach traffic, as well as the gandy-dancers and con-
nostrils and a lariat in h[...]asso- struction workers who were completing the .P. line.
ciated with Nelson Story in the earliest Montana Within weeks the vile reputation of this place spread
cattle days, and later had a fine herd of his own. along the valley. The bodies of two .P. workers
"Doc's" brother "Beaver" (so-called because he was were fished out of the Yellowstone, a short distance
once caught swimming with a bunch of beavers in a away and several other messengers disappeared. A
pond near one of their dams) eight years older, be- freight cargo was held up in the near proximity and
came a top cowhand, and a model to be copied. the driver shot through the head.
"Doc" hit the saddle in earnest when he was eighteen, The crisis came when Charley Farley, foreman of
but instead of sticking to one outfit, he preferred to the "79" on East White Beaver sent one of his men
play the field as a representative, or "rep" of various to join a herd of cattle coming in from the Gallatin,
cattle barons, which earned him the cognomen of but he never joined the drive. Whereupon Farley,
"The Repping Kid." At one time he worked a string Sam Garvin and a new hand by the name of Pat
of cattle with Bill Hart, famed cowboy star of the
western movies, an<;l his greatest thrill came one day
when a fan from Montana met Hart. The filmdom
hero, hearing the word Montana, asked about the
"Rep Kid," and when he found they had a mutual
friend , he heaped the highest praise on "Doc" and
remitted his affectio[...], nearing 97, lives in a rest home in
Bozeman, in the hallway of which is the picture of
Russell's "Bronc to Breakfast." "Doc" proudly boasts
that the famed cowboy artist had accepted a ride by
Mr. elson, as the inspiration for the painting, al-
though he maintains that he could h[...]newspaper ac-
counts will verify) in his stories of early days, as he
was when witnessing or hearing of them first hand.
This is the way he related the story to the writer
of "Dead Man's Canyon" of how it got its name (al-
most identically the same as had already been heard
personally from the lips of Charley Farley- the only[...]FRA K "DOC" NELSON
difference being in the identification of Patterson). Who told story o( D[...]
They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (113) 108 THEY GAZED ON THE BEARTOOTHS

advised the Brady woman to leave as soon as day-[...]the stairs under the trap door!"[...]Brady's body was buried just across the road,
and the grave was marked. A stage driver, some[...]flowers on the mound of earth, and paid for a pole
enclosure around the grave.
But the affair did not end here, although the joint
never operated again, as Nordstrom heard of the in-[...]While holding up at the line camp of the "7~' on[...]rode into camp. (Ramsey was the first deputy of
Yellowstone County when Jim Ferguson was the first[...]the name of Patterson in your crew. A Mrs. Brady was[...]in the mess tent," answered Farley.[...]"Ask him to come out," said the officer.[...]him," was the answer.[...]to the door.[...]please come along quietly. We know some of the
details of this deal, as well as the caliber of the Brady[...]UND GRAVE ROTTED not in danger of being found guilty in this Brady[...]deal, but I just don't dare appear in a court of law.
BURTON SMITI:I STA DS IN RECESS THAT WAS The only way you will get me there is as a dead man."[...]on Brady. Mrs. Brady By this time the members of the line crew had
was alone in the saloon when the trio entered, and gathered round, and loyalty to one of their members
Farley stated that he would like to[...]ent.
little. At this time Brady returned, entered the room,
"O.K.," said the deputy. "You have us highly
and sensing trouble,[...]utnumbered, but I am coming back with a possee
on the wall at a comer of the bar. Two shots rang
big enough to take in the whole damned "79" outfit
out and Brady dropped dead. As Mrs. Brady reached
for the rifle, Patterson "winged" her slightly, and held if necessary." And they turned into the twilight to-[...]ward Billings.
her at gun point while the other two searched the
premises. In the supplies they found a quantity of After their departure the crew went into a
"knock-out" drops, as well as a couple loaded billys huddle.
cached under the bar. Further investigation showed a[...]ood as a lost soul," explained
trap door in front of the bar, that dropped into a cellar Patterson. "There is something of a court record that
below, from which a tunnel ra[...]h up with me if I were ever to
fore emerging near the bottom of the gulch. This ex- appear in anything as public as a witness stand."
plained the possible means of getting rid of the The cowboys finally agreed that the best way to
victims who were slugged or drugged. Patterson then get rid of the mess would be to get lost for a while.

They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (114) THEY GAZED ON THE BEARTOOTHS[...]l be for• Dot" Wilson, west of the "79" range. One day a rider
gotten," Farley advis[...]delivered some stock cows and a few horses from the
''I'd go if I had a good horse," said Pat. "It's north country. In the string was "Roan King!"
probably wisest." The rider also had a message for Beaver and his
"Roan King" comes into the picture. associates, from the cowboy who had borrowed the[...]atterson had reached Canada without inci-
In the fall of 1879, while the Montana Cattle dent, and went to work on one of the big cow opera-
Company ·herds grazed near the Nelson ranch in the tions, under the direction of dominion officials. He
Gallatin, a trader from Ne[...]ice that he was immediately rec-
one hundred head of horses. "Beaver" helped the ognized as one of the best cowhands ever. Within a
visitor a lot, caring for the stock and herding them, short time, the government asked him to become a
as well as helping break a few head. When the supervisor and inspector for the province of Alberta.
horses were ready to be sold, the owner offered to He declined and insisted on hanging on to the job he
pay the lad. No charges. So the man again made had, wher[...]l.
''Beaver" an offer. "Take your pick," he said. The After much ineffectual coaxi[...]d roan, three years old. ed," for the job, and was to be given public recogni-
"You can[...]It was then that the ex-"79''er got busy. He tried
"He's mine, or no horse;' said the Nelson youth. many sources and[...]getting mounted, he rode him- of stock was to be moved south toward the Judith
rode him to a finish-rode him into such submission Basin country. He contacted the foreman and was
that the horse actually nuzzled his conqueror, when[...]promised that "Roan King" would be delivered to the
he reached for the bridle. He was never known to[...]son, the Two Dot spread was the point of delivery.
"Beaver" was with the "7rf' crew when Ramsey[...]on reached his decision. for the return of the horse, and congratulate him on
"You take 'Roan Ki[...]he received a government document in
you get over the border, send him back the first return. A few days b[...]that gentleman was· found shot through the head in

"A BRONC TO BREAKFAST"
The rider is supposed to be "Doc" Nelson; that[...]

They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (115)110 THEY GAZED ON THE BEARTOOTHS

his bunkhouse. Only this time the notch in the handle to see what all the shooting was about, was seriously
of the revolver had not been cut. The gun was still wounded. Despite the efforts of a posse, and swift
clutched in his hand. action by officers of the law, the home-breaker was
\Vhen news of this suicide was relayed to sher- never apprehended. But the description of the man
iffs in the Montana Territory, the pieces began to fall who had instituted this bizarre tragedy fitted that of
in place. In the early spring of 1883 in a Nevada gold Pat Patterson!
field, a[...]killed his vin, nevertheless brought peace of mind to this pair
spouse, but in the melee that followed the husband who also carried guns when a trio of "79"ers brought
was also shot to death, and another man who had come an end to the hell hole in "Dead Man's Canyon."

They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (116)[...](Roahen Photo)
TO CATHEDRAL PEAKS. THIS WAS THE LAND OF WEELUNA.
They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (117) Chapter 12
LEGEND OF THE
STILLWATER
"Note: Why they s[...]truly Indian, and yet her hair, jet black, was of a
its mad sprint for the Yellowstone-why people should[...]was always a vague
mystery to me as a child. And the.::1 one night I
listened to the tale while seated around the campfire.
An old Indian squaw was the narrator, a weathered,
worn old woman, bent and wrinkled from the cares
of three score and ten years. Yet in relating the tale,
at time her face would take on a light as t[...]sed
in her details.
It was so long ago, that the legend is more or less
blurred in the lapse of time that has transpired since
that night around the glowing embers, so that now it
appears to me as but a vision in the midst of flying
years-a something that at times is plain,[...]a faint recollection, or perhaps a mere phantasy of the
mind. To transmit the thrill of the myth may be im-
possible for me, but as I recall it, the ~_tory was told
as follows:
"Many centuries ago, long before continental
civilization had known the mysterious realms of the
western world, a tribe of Indians made their home
WHERE THE WATERS SLOW THEIB MAD RUSH
in the beautiful Yellowstone Valley. There were dif-
ferent from the general breeds of Redskins, inasmuch TO THE SEA TO BECOME . . .

as theirs was a peaceful exi[...]LM AND UNRIFFLED . . . SILENTLY SORROWFUL"
obtain the necessities of life by their skill as hunters
and trappers, while their idle time was devoted to the
enjoyment of living as their ethics and dispositions
saw fit. The summer months found them on the great
grass-laden prairies to the east, where they followed
the buffalo, taking robes for their tepees and beds, and
food for their winter larders. In the fall, they loaded
their horses and travoises and hied themselves toward
the feeder streams of the Stillwater, where they stored
their goods and made their encampment for the snow
period of the seasons. Game had been abundant, and
the tribe prospered for many moons beneath the
snowy caps of nature's sentinels.

They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (118) THEY GAZED ON THE BEARTOOTHS 113

refined than those of her sisters; and her voice was search of game, animals or birds necessary to prevent
sweet music that lacked the harshness characteristic of starvation in their camp. For three days they s[...]iful girl, her in silence, but to no avail, as the snow got even deep-
lithe body taking on graceful[...]ound tracks in
tion, and her toneful words became the spokesman the fresh snow, revealing that there were elk or moose
for her heart full of love, friendliness and happiness. nearby. A sho[...]they came upon an elk
Her presence shed soft rays of contentment and peace herd, floundering and tiring in the snow, so weak
wherever and whenever she entered a tepee. They they easily fell prey to the rejoicing hunters, despite
called her Weeluna-"The Little Moon." the use of the makeshift weapons.
With the passing months the father of the girl The first great storm that had so nearly left the
made it known that some young Indian could claim camp lifeless, was the only one of the year, and from
her for his own, and many suitors of the tribe at- that time on there was plenty of food and hides for
tempted to win the maiden's hand. And so much in the tribe. But the mad, desperate effort on the part
love with W eeluna were the young braves, that each of Weeluna to save her people, was too great a strain
was jealous of the others. Dissention and squabbles on the huntress. Although she combatted her illness
arose in the camp, until a mild form of disobedience bravely she slowly grew weaker. The first flowers of
and warfare was started.[...]e to herald her wedding day,
As days passed, the trouble increased, and dark instead brought[...]heart fare-
who might luckily win Weeluna's hand, the rejected
braves would avenge themselves. The medicine men
watched the insurrection and sadly shook their heads,
but did nothing other than remain quiet and await
the choice of W eeluna and her father.
Her decision was fi[...]ly hated by his fellow tribesmen
who were jealous of his expert marksmanship, his
powerful build, speed and _endurance that made him
the finest hunter of the tribe. It was the late autumn
season when this wooing took place, and although
Nemidji desired the wedding ceremony before winter
set in. W eeluna pleaded to wait until the world again
burst into birth and life in the spring.
The announcement of the mating brought on such
a great uneasiness as the tribe had never known,
which culminated one night in a secret meeting of the
rejected lovers. Plans were made to rob the camp
with the first snow. The storm came after a beautiful
Indian summer. So carefully did the avengers do their
work that one morning those who[...]g brave gone. Surplus robes
and furs , stored for the colder weather to come had
disappeared; what spea[...]were left had
b een broken and rendered useless; the horses had
gone with the plotters and all the food stores had
been stolen and taken away.
D esp eration reigned . How could the old men, the
squaws and p apooses hope to live during the winter
without food, clothing or beds?
In the midst of the turmoil, W eeluna proposed a
hunting trip by the girls of the camp, but they were
unwilling to face the storm which was b eginning to
attain severe depths, and heaping the snow to cover
BUFF ALO JUMPS IN THE DAYS OF WELUNA
hidden crevices and trails presenti[...]

They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (119)114 THEY GAZED ON THE BEARTOOTHS

river. Here the moving mass stretched across the
narrow canyon, blockading the stream, while the body
of Little Moon drifted with the receding waters be-
low the barricade.
The skies cleared as rapidly as they had darkened,[...]and the moon cast a swallow, pale light, revealing the
damage by the fury of the storm. At the camp a
young boy watched the lowering waters, and while
gazing in fright at the awesome phenomenon of na-
ture, he saw the body of the girl drift into a quiet
pool. He sounded the alarm, and the grieving N emid-[...]The moonlight touched the still smiling features
of the dead, with a wonderfully soft light, as her lips[...]with fear and grief, Nemidji sprang into the pool to
rescue the haunting remains of his beloved.[...]Just as he reached her and turned toward the
shore again, the huge wall of debris gave way behind
the impounded waters, and with a wild rush the on-
coming torrent engulfed the two, N emidji being
swirled into the abyss with his sweetheart tightly[...]The swifly flowing current washed out great
patches of earth and trees, widening the course of the
river, and cutting a lake for half a mile. As the flood[...]water receeded there remained a bayou where the
speed of the water was absorbed and distributed into[...]riffleless flow through that portion of the stream. The
tribe called this the hallowed place, Stillwater, which
is the Stillwater as we know it.
BOX CANYON OF THE STILL WATER Prosperity again came to the people. The unlucky
curse, possibly brought on by the fierce love of Wee-[...], was displaced and every autumn
well. Gently did the women watch over her body, season saw the encampment on the Stillwater in the
while the old men grieved their hearts out for emid- midst of peace, happiness and contentment.
ji. In a great[...]is changed. Domestic animals feed
leading down to the river they placed the remains of quietly on the grounds where the deer and elk were
Little Moon, amid sorrowing splendor-the last token once on the alert for their stronger foes; great fields
of love from the camp. of green and golden yellow have replaced the grass-
ight came on, following the service that had land and browse of long ago. White mothers croon
taken the most precious thing in life from the village. to their babies in houses built among the trees where
A flash of lightning followed by continuous thunder once Weeluna wa1 packed as a papoose on her
was the initial appearance of the storm. Two hours mother's back.
later it was raging-one of the wildest the mountains But Mother Nature remembe[...]increasing. Rain ages ago, and has told the t>tory to her waters and
fell in torrents, washing down in great volume in the things to which she gives lifo. No plant or flowers
every gulch and coulee and from even the sidehills, at have ever returned to the spot where once stood a
the foot of which was the camp, barely able to with- great fir tree[...]to release a pre-
stand this flash flood. High on the ridge a great cious charge to the wild waters. For in this place the
boulder loosened and came rolling downhill. It[...]e always quiet. They pay their last homage
struck the fir tree in which Weeluna had been buried, to Weeluna, the Little Moon, as they tip-toe breath-
uprooting it and crashing it into the mass of mud lessly by in the moonlight, placid and clear, calm and
and rubble where the body of the bride-to-be tossed unriffled, silently sorrowful.
violently on the crest of the 5lide, until it reached the -Jim Annin, Columbus[...]

They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (120)[...]The Creation As Told By[...]Jack Rabbit Bull
TRADITIONS OF Jack Rabbit Buffs ideas of the creation are ex-[...]emely crude. He says he has heard that once there
THE. CR,OWS[...]istorical from information The Creation As Told By
obtained from Fat her I[...]ooish" and others.) In the beginning the earth was covered with
water, and the only living things were two spirits of
unknown form who floated upon the water and a
The Creation large bird resembling a duck. Once as the two spirits
By Buffalo Cali[...]and one said to the other, "This is a bad way to live.
At first the earth was covered with water, and I am tired of all this water. Let us make dry land
the only living things were fishes, animals that dwell that shall be a home for other creatures." The second
in the water and water fowl. After a while the Great spirit assented, and they called the duck and ordered
Spirit, wanting dry earth to tread upon, sent a bird him to dive down till he reached the bottom of the
down through the water to bring up some earth, and deep and bring up from thence a quantity of earth.
the bird succeeded in obtaining some from the bottom The duck went down as commanded, but, though he[...]e a great way, he returned without having reached
of the deep. This the Great Spirit took, and of it
the bottom. He was sent down a second time and
create[...]go deeper, and this time stayed longer,
tell, but the land commenced to grow and crowd the and finally returned with his mouth and f[...]t last only creeks and rivers with sand. One of the spirits took the sand and
and lakes were left. And thus it has eve[...]h he
mained. I then remarked to Buffalo Calf that the took a portion and scattered it around over the water.
Sioux say that the Great Spirit took the earth brought o land appear d, however, and then the second
up out of the water and blew it over the water when spirit cast some of it abroad, when land appeared all
it became dry l[...]right, that around them. A second time he threw the dust, when
is the way he did it." After the earth was made the the land grew larger and they ceased to throw the
Great Spirit created man and land animals and grass dust and walked on the land they had made. Then
they called aloud and in the West was h ard the cry
and trees, everything, in fact, on the earth except
of a wolf and present~y he appeared and, coming
stones. The Great Spirit did not create the stones, but from the West, joined them.
the stones grew of themselves. Stones are still grow- Then the spirits said to the duck, "Go in that
ing, for the Crows often find things turned to stone di[...]t is not yet large
that were once something else. The gum that runs enough." And th duck went to the south. In like
from the pine trees turns to stone. I asked Buffalo manner they sent the wolf to the west to make new
Calf how the Great Spirit created man, but he said land there. Then the spirits waited and after a time
he did not know. the duck returned and said the new land was made.
They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (121)116 THEY GAZED ON THE BEARTOOTHS

Afterwards the wolf returned and made the same manded him to do the same with the woman and all
report. Then as the duck had first returned the spirits animals. So he opened the eyes of the woman and
went first to the south to see what he had done, but the animals and all were able to see.
they were dissatisfied with the land, for the duck had Then the man and woman began to live together,
left too much water in his land, it being full of ponds but as they had no house and did not know how to
and lakes, and even the land was low and marshy. make one they dwelt in the hollow logs and trees.
They then went to the west to see what the wolf had From this time forth men and wom[...]with that land and told multiplied upon the earth, but all the human beings
the wolf that he had done well, for there were plains dwelt in hollow logs. The buffalo made war upon the
and rivers and mountains forming a country beauti[...]nd drove them forth and
to behold. Then they told the duck to go and live in were very fierce so that men were not able to with-
the wet country he had made and permitted the wolf stand them. At last the buffalo killed a man and de-
to dwell in the finer country made by him. voured all of him except one arm.
When all this had been done the spirits took the When the spirits saw this they were displeased
dust of the earth and rolled it in their fingers and cast and one made a bow and another made arrows and
it upon the ground and it became a man, who ran a gave them to the first man and said to him: "It is not
few steps and groped blindly, for though he had eyes right that the buffalo should kill and eat you, but
he could not open them and saw not. Then the spirits that you should kill and eat the buffalo, for they were
took more dust and formed a woman, who did as the given you for food. Take this bow and arrows and
man had done. Then in the same manner they made slay them and eat the flesh." So the man took the
animals and all creatures that live on land of each, bow and arrows and shot twice and ki[...]faloes. Then he shot a third time, but this time the
that they could not see. Then the spirits told the buffalo was only wounded, but the herd took flight
man to open his eyes but he could not and they and the wounded buffalo tossed the arm of the man
opened them for him with their fingers[...]

They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (122) THEY GAZED ON THE BEARTOOTHS 117

ran away. Until then the buffalo had no hump upon till it reached the summit of the range. From this
the back, but the arm they carried away became a point[...]ll buffalo have had a hump through the most beautiful valley they had ever seen,
upon the back.[...]sweet, long, green grass and shaded with
As the people increased in number upon the an abundance of luxuriant timber. Upon both sides of
earth the spirits divided them into tribes, but as yet the river, gleaming through the foliage, could be seen
all spoke one language. But at last the spirits spoke numberless white lodges, stretching up and down upon
down from above the earth calling all the people to- both sides of the river till they were lost in distance.
gether, an[...]had assembled, they gave each This was the Spirit-land and these were homes of the
tribe a different tongue and none understood the dead. Innumerable forms of spirits who had gone
tongue giveri to the others. The spirits also appointed before them were seen walking about or reclining
the place for them to dwell and then commanded all among the trees and all seemed peace and happiness.
the people to shake hands together. There were people The Crow warrior gazed upon this scene with
of all colors there but the white people stood nearest delight and, as his wife had preceded him many years
the spirits, and the spirits said so as to be heard by to the Spirit-land, he hurried forward, anxious to have
all: "All people are dear to us, but the white people her again by his side. As. they neared the village, a
are dearer than all the rest and we command you to spirit came forth to meet them and directed each to
live at peace with the white people." Afterwards he the lodge he was to go. The Crow bounded into the
commanded them to disperse and the tribes spread lodge where he had been told he would find his wife,
themselves over the land. and, tr[...]e approached her
This, says Little Face, is the creation as originally with beaming face but she only looked at him sternly
believed among the Crows, but of late years they had and asked, "Why do you come here? It is not your
learned to doubt some parts of it, especially the form- time. You are still young and our children are now
ing of man and woman out of dust. Intercourse with left without a protector. Go back and take care of
white men has introduced many ideas into this myt[...]ere. But this is grown old, then come to the houses of the spirits."
undoubtedly the idea of the creation held by them He turned sadly away and commenced to re-
before the whites had any dealings with them as[...]father. the sound of many voices engaged in weeping. As the
To the above, Little Face subsequently added[...]him and ere
that all people, good or b3:d, go to the same place. long the bandages in which he was confined were
He knew of nothing which prevented anyone from[...]to a tree in grave clothes after the manner of Crow
burial. Great was the wonder and delight of his[...]riends to find him restored to life, and rapt was the
The Land of The Hereafter[...]attention with which they listened to the recital of
'What I am going to tell you now," said Little what had befallen him in the land of spirits.
Face, "the Crows have no two talks about. In many[...]nt beliefs, but in this we all back from the home of the dead, who confirmed the
believe alike. And as far back as the Crows have any account of his predecessor in all respects. When he
knowledge this faith has been the same among them." entered the lodge pointed out to him he found his
A long[...]flight from his body his two wives, one of whom had been divorced from
he was for some time[...]ss and found himself then sat down by the side of his second wife and
traveling towards the south along a well-beaten and received a dish of the food eaten by spirits. It ap-
pleasant trail, which bore the impress of naught but peared to be pounded buffalo meat and sweetened
human feet, with cuts and ravines across the trail, with sugar· and was delicious to the palate. After the
which it appeared no trouble for them to leap. Th[...]to find himself on earth
and he found himself in the company of another de- surrounded by fri ends who[...]ht limp, being lame. Being bound The heaven of the Crows would thus appear to
for the same place, they journed together, and at last be a place of rest and peace, where, free from sorrow,
found that the two trails came together in a pass pa[...]xiety, they pass their lives in luxurious
between the hills, which ascended higher and higher[...]

They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (123)118 THEY GAZED ON THE BEARTOOTHS

and, unlike most tribes, seem to have no idea of the the Crows the Wise Man. He was also distinguished as
presence of game, rendering the hackneyed term of a warrior and gained many successes ove[...]Upon one occasion he led a party of warriors against
the Bannocks and Piegans, who were then leagued[...]together. They found a camp of their enemies near
The Punishment of Sin
the Sweet Grass Hills (northern part of Liberty Coun-
The Great Spirit has commanded all people to ty), but as they appeared strong the Crows were
live good lives. They are especially enjoined not to doubtful of their ability to cope with them success-
steal from any one of their own tribe, but it is per- fully. Thereupon the Wise Man dismounted from his
missible to steal fr[...]orse, and, filling his pipe, said: "If my father, the
war. To those who do well, long, pleasant lives are Sun, lights the pipe with his own fire, we may attack
promised, but the contrary to those who do ill. The our enemies with assurance of success; but if he does
depletion of numbers and the wars that the Crows and not, we must retreat else we sha[...]ered is attributable to their dis- then placed the stem in his mouth and began to draw
obedience of the commands of the Great Spirit. Not upon it as if smoking. His warriors watched intently
only did the Great Spirit lay his command upon them and ere long saw a slight smoke rise from the bowl
in the beginning, but he occasionally appears even of the pipe. It increased in volume and presently the
now and enjoins them to correct lives. The Crows tobacco was seen to be on fire.[...]ear his voice but that he is not to be that the victory was theirs, for the sun had lighted
seen. the pipe, and they attacked their enemies without[...]ained a decisive victory over them.
The Spectre Warriors This is how the Wise Man disappeared from
among the Crows: He once saddled his horse and
When the Crows are engaged in battle with their[...]rode forth from the camp. It was a foggy spring
enem:es, a spectre ho[...]rning when one could see but a short distance and
of the ·r force to aid them in their fight. These horse[...]he was soon lost to sight in the fog. It was supposed
men are invisible to the Crows and they only know[...]that he had gone forth in search of his horses, but as
of them through the accounts of their enemies. The[...]ot return, search was made for him. His
Sioux and the Cheyennes say that they have repeated-[...]mp, saddled
ly seen them and that, however small, the forces of
as when the Wise Man rode forth, but he was no-
the Crows appear at first, no sooner are they joined[...]where to be found. The ground was examined but
by these ghostly warriors[...]was there any sign that showed where the Wise Man
The Sioux and other Indians say that they have re-[...]has wandered. In the opinion of the medicine men
peatedly concentrated their fire on[...]but one thing could have happened to him-the sun
and sought to entrap them in various ways, bu[...]remembered by the Crow6, and in times of difficulty
upon a distant part of the field. Who ·these allies are[...]or distress they invoke him and wish that he were
the Crows can not surmise, but they are not a little[...]still among them to lead them out of their trouble
rejoiced at their powerful cooperat[...]Tattooed Forehead's advent.)
The Flood
Little Face says that the Crows have always be- The Spirit of The Rivers
lieved that some time after the creation a flood came
that destroyed most of the inhabitants of the earth, but The Crows have believed from the earliest times
he is unable to give an account of it. He says that that all rivers and large bodies of water contain
after the flood the Great Spirit informed them that spirits or[...]ho are always hungry and
he would one day destroy the earth again, but in as ready to devour[...]mplished they do not know. On that account the Crows when about to cross such
The flood was occasioned by heavy rains that fell from a stream always throw food into the water first to
the heavens for many days.[...]and stripes of bright colors it will frighten the crea-
The Child of The Sun tures away and enable them to cross in safety. These
The Child of the Sun grew up to be a man, and creatures have of ten been seen by the Crows and
on account of his wonderful knowledge was called by are apparently of the human form except that they

They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (124) THEY GAZED ON THE BEARTOOTHS 119

are immensely corpulent with limbs of unusual size. The Horse in The Yellowstone
The latest instances of their appearance are in the
Tongue, Rosebud and Little Big Horn rivers. In the In reference to the horse that lives in the Yel-
former case, the creature was dead and the face par- lowstone, Little Face said this morning that we have
tially gone. Its hair was like wool. The one seen in passed the spot where he comes out of the water. It
Rosebud was swimming in the water and made a tre- is about three hu[...]ance as it moved. near the spot where the four cavalry horses were[...]drowned. Little Face says he has himself seen the
One of the three Crows who discovered it raised anima[...]gun to shoot it, but it suddenly raised itself in the Crows. He describes him as of a blue-earth (say a
water and looked so horrible[...]d his
in fright, and, with his comrades, ran from the spot legs and body like the stripes of a zebra. He had
as fast as he could. In the Little Big Horn three were also a black nose.
seen together, disporting in the water like children,
which, indeed, they seemed to be; that is, spirit chil-
dren. While the Crow who discovered them sat upon How The Crows Got Horses
his horse grazing at them in wonder, there came a Little Face says that in the time of his grand-
flash across the water like a flash of lightning that father the Crows had no horses and did not know
lashed the water into foam and dazzled the beholder what they were except through va[...]s horse that he reared and threw lost from the tribe. The squaws carried large burdens
him. When he recovered himself the spirits were gone, on the march and dogs were their only pack animals.
but the track of the flash could be traced by a muddy They had a[...]now, but as a whole
line. It is to be added that the Crows at first took lodge was too heavy a[...]ortation
him that they were spirits. They were in the lake at between two dogs. At last , after they had reached
the head of the Little Big Horn, which is described as the Yellowstone country in the course of their migra-
being two miles long and from a quarter to a mile tion from the southeast, they were visited by a party
of ez Perces, who saw that they used only dogs
wide[...]and told them of the larger and better animals pos-[...]if they would visit their camp. A party of the Crows
Stars, Moon, Thunder and Lightning did so, and there for the first time they beheld the
The Crows have no theory concerning the stars. larger and more powerful beasts of burden described
They are incomprehensible to the[...]aving first appeared to them out
them as spirits. The moon, they say, is a woman and of the water far to the southeast. They purchased a
wears a robe of elk skin. One of their medicine men few and set out with t[...]on the way, Little Face's grandfather, who was of
dreamed this a long time ago, and so it has becom[...]the party, had a strange and fortunate experience.
an article of faith with them. The thunder is an im- As he stood near the bank of a stream, a man clothed
mense red bird, who carri[...]in black from head to foot , rose suddently out of the
charges it, the heavens are filled with the roar of the water and stood before him. He demanded of the
report and sometimes the bullet shivers a tree, kills Crow what he w[...]me living creature or buries itself harmlessly in the swered that he was after horses. Thereupon the
earth. The flash of the gun is the lightning. strange creature gave a load call and from the woods
nearby pranced a hundred horses of all colors and[...]mostly fine animals. "Take your choice of the lot."
said he. Whereupon the Crow selected a handsome
How The Crows Obtain The animal of coal-black color. " ow mount him," con-
Article of Religion tinued the apparition. "They are strong and can carry
All the things believed by the Crows in their all that you may choose t[...]y circumstances till you gain your village,
tions of the Great Spirit and the requirements of the or it will be ill for you."
dreams have ever since been strictly observed. It is The Crow had never ridden a horse but lost no
thus th[...]ir hair or a finger in mourn- time in obeying the mandate of his strange benefactor.
ing, and so with all the practices common among Springing upon[...]as he galloped away, enjoying greatly the exhilarating

They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (125) 120 THEY GAZED ON THE BEARTOOTHS

motion and traveled along over hill and valley and the number. Here he camped above the fort and was
plain as never had Crow traveled before. As he rode, visited by men from the fort, who asked him what he
he heard the continual clatter of hoofs close behind wanted, but seeing that hi[...]ndly
him as though he was accompanied by a troop of they left him and returned to the fort. The chief
animals like this he bestrode, but they did not come trader then sent him presents of knives and tobacco,
into view and he dared not l[...]sh said that he did not want these and
not verify the hope that had sprung up in his breast demanded powder. The powder was refused, when
that the apparition in black had carried his generosity he threw the tobacco into the river. Finding that he
so far as to present him with the whole herd and sent was there for no good, many of his warriors left him
it galloping home at his heels. When it came night he and returned to the Crow camp. Others visited the
halted and dismounted and lay down to sleep, taking fort, but finding the doors closed against them at-
the precaution to lay upon his breast with his hea<.~ tempted to shake hands with the whites over the walls,
in the direction of the village that by no mischance, which their hei[...]tly
through a sudden awakening, should he gaze to the offended against these who favored the whites and
rear. In the morning he resumed his course, and after orde[...]r this
two days more travel reached home, and, to the Arrapooash fell in a battle with the Gros Ventres not
amazement of all the village, brought home one hun- far beyond Fort Benton.
dred of the large and splendid animals that were not
The following is an instance of his power as a
only to take the place of dogs as beasts of burden, but[...]. He once described two horses which
also to bear the Crows upon their backs in all their[...]he said he had been informed by dreams were in the
future travels. From that time forth the Crows con-[...]was otherwise peculiarly marked, the other gray of
since have they been without the aid of these useful[...]ture and a party of warriors accompanied him for
"because the man in black said that they could bear[...]that purpose. They approached the camp of their
it."[...]the two horses with which they escaped. When it[...]grew light enough to make out the color of the ani-
mals, behold! they were the very horses described
Arrapooash, Rotten Bel[...]n but not so great as Long Hair. His
medicine was the thunder. He had dreamed what Arrapooash was a great friend of the white people
the thunder was and carried something representing and even the trading post at Fort McKenzie was re-
it, but what it was none of the Crows ever learned. garded highly by him wi[...]ding,
Once when Rotten Belly was camped with some of however, the Blackfeet were supplied there with arms
his peopl[...]them and ammunitions, he complained that the white men
that the Great Spirit had been talking with him in a[...]ing him success in making captives if mies the means of killing them and requested that the
he went in a certain direction. A number of warriors sale of arms and warlike stores be discontinued.
joined him and he led them into the Judith Basin Finding, however, that his remonstrances produced
against the Piegans. Here while looking out from no effect and that the Blackfeet still purchased these
the hills they discovered some 60 persons approaching[...]and under-
on foot, which Rotten Belly pronounced the people took the expedition already mentioned. When he
promised by the Great Spirit. As they came nearer camped above the fort the whites visited him and
it was discovered that they were all women of the requested him to call at the fort but he refused to
Piegan tribe. They were ea[...]o and told them he was no longer their friend.
26 of the youngest and handsomest, the Crows re- It was then that the presents of knives and tobacco
turned to their country. A part of the women escaped were offered.
on the way, but the most were carried to the Crow The following is another instance of his foresight
village and adopted into the tribe. Three of these as a medicine man. He dreamed one spring that there
women are yet living with the Crows (1875). was a gray mare with a red face in the Piegan camp,
Arrapooash once raised a war party of some 200 who would that year give birth at[...]ng to colts. He resolved to possess himself of this mare as a
do, led them against Fort McKenzie on the Missouri present for his squaw, and, telling of his intentions
(at the mouth of the Marias). Little Face was one of in his village, asked for volunteers[...]

They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (126) THEY GAZED ON THE BEARTOOTHS 121

He was laughed at when he spoke of the promised but securely sheltered in their doubly strengthened
birth of two colts and was asked when such a thing lodges, the Crows feared nothing, and after a time
had ever happened. No, it was impossible, no mare the storm passed by and they were left unharmed.
ever[...]d that Arrapooash to his wondering band, and the next day
all would turn out as promised and final[...]his orders they remained in camp. All understood
of warriors consented to accompany him. The camp now that the storm had been brought by Arrapoosh as
was found, the mare captured, and found to agree with a punishment to the Gros Ventres and in anxious ex-
the description Arrapooash had given her except that pectation awaited the developments to follow. A con-
she was lame, and in time she gave birth to the two stant watch was kept in the direction of the Gros
colts, thus once more confirming before his people the Ventres village, for all felt sure that the day wou]d
greatness of Arrapooash as a medicine man. bring a delegation of the repentant people, and, sure
A still more striking instance occurred under enough, the sun had scarcely passed his highest point
Little Face's own observation. Arrapooash was once in the heavens when a numerous party on foot and on
upon a visit with the River Crows to the lower Gros horseback was seen approaching the camp. They drew
Ventres or Ah-mah-chay. While there the Gros Ven- near and it was seen that the principal chief of the
tres stole from him a favorite bay horse and upon Gros Ventres was at the head, leading the bay horse
demand being made for him failed to giv[...]y wroth, and, after up- followed a number of men with pack animals carry-
braiding them for th[...]the Gros Ventres' chief thus addressed him:
"But[...]am
Arrapooash; you know my name but are ignorant of "We have done wrong and have been[...]ight
shall learn my power and what it is to incur the dis- there came upon us a furious storm of rain and hail
pleasure of Arrapooash." that soaked our houses . so that many of them fell in[...]d by his followers and camped could. The hail beat down our corn and pumpkins,
early in the afternoon. It was a beautiful day with and our fields that in the morning promised a rich
not a cloud in the sky or any sign of impending tem- harvest are now desolate, and where shall we look for
pest, but Arrapooash directed the people to secure food for the coming winter? But we do not complain
their lodge[...]re), bring you besides a large present of robes and other
setting the example with his own lodge. The day things, which we expect you to ac[...]your anger against us that we receive no further
the medicine of Arrapooash had deceived him for punishment."
once, when suddently from the interior of his lodge[...]To this Arrapooash made answer that he bore the
came four loud blasts upon a large bone horn he[...]Gros Ventres no ill will. They spoke the language of
carried. Said Little Face: "Your bugles make a lo[...]the Crows and he wished to regard them as brothers.
noise but they are as nothing to blast from the horn "I will accept your presents," he concluded, "and in-
of Arrapooash." The people heard the blast and ran, jure you no more, but you did well to curb my dis-
asking themselves what now is the matter with Arra- pleasure, for this wint[...]storms
pooash? When suddenly there came a tempest of of snow to come upon you as were never witnessed.
wind that set their lodges to rocking like the boughs I would have heaped it over your villages so that you
of a tree such a wind as the Crows had never known could not have escaped and must have perished. They
before but thanks to the precaution advised by are fools who incur the resentment of Arrapooash."
Arrap~oash not a lodge was overthrown. Ere long
the rain commenced to fall and the heavens seemed At this point Little Face said these were all the
to be pouring forth all their water, conv~rting every instances of Arrapooash' s skill and power as a medicine
ravine into a formidable river and turmng the low man of which he was personally cognizant that he
ground into lakes. But this was not all, f~r as the could remem her, but he had heard of another instance
rain slacked, tremendous hailstones came fallmg down which had been handed down by the old men which
in dense masses crashing against the lodges and was no doubt true. It happened when Arrapooash
bounding like balis all over the land; hailstones ne_arly was a young man, when the tribe was still on the
as large as a man's fist that no one could stand agamst, waters of the Arkansas River. The Crows were at

They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (127)122 THEY GAZED ON THE BEARTOOTHS

war with four tribes, viz., the Cheyennes, Arapahoes, white men who in his day visited the camp invariably
Powder People and Wolves, but the[...]ould stop nowhere else
erful there and not afraid of them all. when they could rece[...]t this was never refused to them.-J.H.B.)
village of their enemies higher up the river and it In connection with the foregoing sketch, the ref-
was resolved to leave behind the children and old erence to Arapooish (Arrapooash) by Washington
men and women and proceed against the enemy with Irving is interesting. In the "Adventures of Captain
all the young men and women and warriors able to Bonneville," Irving describes Arrapooash's account of
fight. As they were about to start someone addressed the Crow country as given to Mr. Robert Campbell,
the multitude and said: "You are fools. What do you of the Rocky Mountain Fur Company.
expect to do? It is vain to go against the enemy[...]fore we accompany Captain Bonneville into
without the guidance of Arrapooash and he is not
the Crow country, we will impart a few facts about
am[...]this wild region and the wild people that inhabit it.
now and persuade him[...]We are not aware of the precise boundaries, if there
The Crows thought well of the counsel and sought are any of the country claimed by the Crows. It
Arrapooash, where he sat silent in his lodge, paying appears to extend from the Black Hills to the Rocky
no attention to the warlike preparations around him. Mountains, including a part of their lofty ranges, and
They stated their desire that he should lead them embracing many of the plains and valleys watered by
and awaited his answer. When it came, it was not the Wind River, the Yellowstone and Powder River,
favorable to their wishes. "Why," they demanded, the Little Missouri and the ebraska. The country
"will you not bear the pipe for us?" "Because I do varies in soil and climate, there are vast plains of sand
not like the composition of your party," was the reply. and clay, stubbed with large red sand h[...]e, it possesses warm
giddiness will be productive of mischief." "But you springs, coal mines, a[...]Let us give the account of the country as ren-
and we will not listen to a refus[...]chief, to Mr. Robert
"as you insist and as I wish the Crows success over
Campbell, of the Rocky Mountain Fur Company.
their enemies I will[...]must kill or injure a single bird during "'The Crow country,' said he, 'is a good country.'
our march upon the enemy's village, otherwise harm The Great Spirit has put it exactly in the right place;
will befall us."[...]of it, whichever way you travel you fare worse. If
The required promise was made and the expedi-
you go to the south, you have to wander over great
tion started. All remembered the injunction concern-
barren plains; the water is warm and bad and you
ing the birds and were careful that not even by acci-[...]meet with fever and ague. To the north it is cold; the
dent should one be injured. It was in ·the spring and[...]rs are long and bitter and there is no grass; you
the young birds were just beginning to fly, rising in[...]not keep horses there but must travel with dogs.
the air, fluttering a few yards, and then sinking to[...]What is a country without horses?
the earth again. It happened that one of these young
birds fluttered past a young squaw, who afterwards '"On the Columbia they are poor and dirty,
became the mother of the present Chief Blackfoot, paddle about in[...]worn out; they are always taking fish bones out of
unfortunately killed it. The circumstance was report- their mouths; fish is poor food.
ed to Arrapooash, who went to the spot and for some "'To the east they dwell in villages; they live
time gazing at the frightened girl in silence. "It might well, but they drink the muddy waters of the Mis-
have been more serious," he said at last, "b[...]s bad. A Crow's dog would not drink such
that for the killing of the bird that one life shall be water.
lost; but this girl's brother will fall in the battle we " 'About the forks of the Missouri is a fine coun-
are to fight at the village." try; good water, good grass, plenty of buffalo. In
The expedition then moved on and in due time summer it is almost as good as the Crow country, but
reached the village. Here they fought a fierce battle in winter it is cold; the grass is gone and there is no
with their enemies and routed them with great loss, salt weed for the horses.
but the only one killed among the Crows was a young " 'The Crow country is exactly in the right place.
man, the brother of the girl who struck and killed It has snowy mountains and sunny plains, all kinds of
the bird with her riding whip. climates and good things for every season. When the
(In reference to the known friendship of Arrap- summer heats scorch the prairies, you can draw up
ooash for the whites it is to be remarked that all under the mountains, where the air is sweet and cool,

They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (128) THEY GAZED ON THE BEARTOOTHS 123

the grass fresh, and the bright streams come tumbling two bands have their distinguishing names and, had
out of the snow banks. There you can hunt the elk, the advent of the white man among them been de-
the deer and the antelope when their skins are fit ferred[...]probably
for dressing; there you will find plenty of white bears recognized by us as two distinct t[...]ain sheep. the Crows and Minnetarrees, the Gros Ventres and
"'In the autumn when your horses are fat and the Arapahoes, the Pawnees and the Arickarees. They
strong from the mountain pastures you can go down are now called the Mountain Crows and the River
into the plains and hunt the buffalo, or trap beaver on Crows.
the streams. And when winter comes on, you can
take shelter in the woody bottoms along the rivers;
where you will find buffalo meat for your[...]CHARACTERISTICS OF
cottonwood bark for your horses, or you may winter
in the Wind River valley, where there is salt weed in[...]THE CROW INDIANS
abundance. Crows Most Peaceful of All
"'The Crow country is exactly in the right place. Indian Tribes
E[...]nd there. There is no ot only were the Crows the richest nation in the
country like the Crow country. rorthwest, they were also the most peaceful, even
" 'Such is the eulogium on his country by Arap- among the[...]hese more ferocious enemies,
Separation of The River and but for the greater part they preferred peace.[...]ical publications and government docu-
After the split upon the orth Platte, when the
ments all point out the fact that from the very first
Minnetarees left the Crows and moved to the Man-
contact with them, they were received by the Crows
dans, no further division occurred until the time of
in friendly fashion. That they were also the best edu-
Arrapooash and Long Hair. These men wer[...]cated of all the tribes was demonstrated in the in-
and though living on terms of friendship with each[...]tellectual manner in which they participated in the
other, each aspired to the ascendancy, and the follow-
treaties with the United States.
ing of the tribe was divided between them. The larger
number and better class of the Crows adhered to This friendly willingness to negotiate was of
Long Hair, but the following of Arrapooash was mutual advantage to both Crows and the Indian
rather more than one-third of the tribe. For a long Bureau. Apparently their chiefs foresaw the inevitable
time after this tacit division was made the two bands -that white man's greater numbers, materials and
continued to dwell together, but in time the jealousy wealth more than outmatched the ill-equipped In-
grew greater and they would freq[...]g to
several months, sometimes for a year or two, the band fight for survival. In addition to this the Crows were
of Arrapooash frequenting the prairie country between badly outnumbered by the warring tribes that con-
the Yellowstone and Missouri rivers, while Long Hair[...]They were particularly hated
led his followers to the old familiar haunts at the foot by the roving Sioux. In 1865 the Sioux chieftains at-
of the mountains, where game was always abundant t mpted to form a federation of Western Indians.
and they were enabled to provide for their wants far Only the Crows dissented, without which tribe the
better than in the lower country. These bands still alignment[...]occasionally came together for a short time, but the an enemity that was "to-the-death." aturally, and
feeling of jealousy and distrust is still rife and re- practically it was far better to join the white man,
union in spite of the desire for it entertained by the than to fight both the whites and reds.
present chiefs is quite problema[...]his sound investment in unity certainly paid
The vice of intemperance is prevalent among the off. The Crows were favored by getting more assis-
River C[...]are poorer in horses and alJ tance from the government. More than one military
the necessities of their condition, which induces the man serving through the Indian wars stated in effect
Mountain Crows to regard them with contempt, while that "the close friendship of the Crows, and the avail-
the former are jealous of the greater wealth of the ability of their warriors to help the soldiers; plus their
latter, and b esides there are many renegades among knowledge of the country and habits of the warring
them from the Mountain Crows who are ashamed to tribes by the scouts or "wolves" working under mili-
return to[...]direction, was worth more than a whole army
alive the feeling of envy, jealousy and mistrust. The of regular soldiers."

They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (129) 124 THEY GAZED ON THE BEARTOOTHS

The result of this coalition was that the Crows and was spending his first 4th of July in Montana,
were never charged with many murders of white men. 1862, which ended with a dance." This dance was
Sanders 1885 "History of Montana" lists most of the held on the Joe Hill ranch. There was a mixed crowd
killings by various Indian tribes, of which less than at the dance-Indians, half-breeds and white women.
four percent were charged to the Crow tribes, both I remember "Uncle Bill" H[...]e and he
Mountain and River. Those recorded while the agency was surely celebrating in his usual c[...]ow Creek in 1877; James gallantly greeted the ladies. The dance was a huge
Hughes murdered at the Frank Quinn ranch July 5th success. The ranch owner, Joe Hill was to become a
or 6th, 1875. James Hildebrand was killed south of long-time friend. He had just married an Indian
the agency July 27, 1875 but it was never fully estab- woman, and the dance had doubled as a holiday-wed-
lished that i[...]ding celebration. When she died he moved to the
was the first person buried in the agency cemetery. Yellowstone Valley, where i[...]arried a Crow
Bob Hudson once pointed out to the writer the woman> and they lived on the creek that now bears
graves of two white men who were killed between hi[...]February 25, 1889, and was buried
Rock Creek and the Stillwater. The story was told on a knoll that overlooks J[...]nvolved a doctor and a prospector who namesake of this old frontiersman now lives at Crow
were on t[...]tacked by Agency (1926)."
renegade Indians. The motive was not known. The Mrs. Hill died at the Crow Agency and her re-
party that buried these v[...]mains were given an Indian burial in a cluster of pine
that the bodies were completely intact and nothing trees near the grave of her husband. The McClana-
was missing except the doctors medicine case. An- han children, and some of the neighboring youngsters
other version was that the[...]on these premises a few years later, as well as the
off their reservation property. o such report ever dried bones, after the scaffolding had fallen to the
went to agency headquarters. And so the truth of this ground.
mystery may never be known. The cleanliness of the Crows was perhaps the
In July, 1875, "Mexican Joe" was killed, an ac- reason that the epidemics of small-pox did not pro-
count of which is credited to Col. J. I. Allen much duce the high death rate that prevailed in other tribes.
as follows: "The adobe fort at the Butcher Agency The worst epidemic recorded was general through
had about been completed and Dexter Clapp had the Western tribes in 1937, when an estimated 12,000
ordered the timber crew to go to work on a small of the 40,000 Indian population succumbed to this
creek a few miles north of the post to get out logs disease, which had been unknown among the redmen
for the agency buildings. White Chalfee had a crew until their contact with white fur traders and trappers
of eight men, with work stock and supplies camped after the turn of the century.
on the creek. A few miles below Mexican Joe was[...]869 claimed 1400
herding cattle. Suddenly a party of Sioux appeared, from the joint villages of 8000 between the dates of
and tried to steal the work stock> horses and mules, December 1869 to May 1870. In 1877 a spread of
but were only able to get away with 12 head, befo[...]thought this might have been
being driven off by the guns of the loggers. A little a mild form of smallpox) hit the Butcher Creek
later the crew heard shooting to the north, and felt Agency and the Crow lodges on the reservation. Pa-
that the Indians had found Mexican Joe and his cattle. tients that could be moved were brought to the
The next morning they went to investigate, and found agency; others were treated with the cure-all "Sweat
the Mexican lying dead in the creek. The cattle were baths" and treatments by their ow[...]lodges. The death toll was reported at over 400 of
Colonel Allen and Tom LaForge were both in the approximately 3000 Crows during the eight months
agreement that all the timber of this area was cut that it raged.
on White Bird Creek, which is where the dead man
Dr. Marcellus was the health officer at the agency
was also found . However, in the mixup the small[...]tall gentleman of commanding physique," but his
Colonel Allen has narrated some of the details superhumane efforts wore him down until he fell a
which led to the naming of Joe Hill Creek, five miles victim to Brights disease, which ended some weeks
south of Columbus. Mr. Allen had crossed from Fort later in a grave in the agency cemetery. Allen de-
Benton to Spring Creek in the Deer Lodge Valley scribes his death:

They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (130) THEY GAZED ON THE BEARTOOTHS 125

"When I returned to the agency I was informed kill the woman, but he did no violence to the man
that Dr. Marcellus was hopelessly ill and that he was involved. And the Grows were noted for the good
watching anxiously for me. He said he couldn[...]rocque writes: "They (Crows) are not so stupid
to the end. Although to acquiesce would interfere[...]to humor him and please his fancy, I took
him out of doors. He wanted to see the agent, but he Denig observed that "the man are decidedly pre-
became so delirious in the night air that I had to pick possessing-perhaps the handsomest body of Indians
him up and take him back to bed. All the while he in North America. They are all s[...]coaxing, after he was not so praiseworthy of the women, in fact his dis-
settled down, and that was the last time he left his dainful description was a far cry from the type of
bed .... The last day, the one on which he died, he Crow women known by the early pioneers of the
turned himself around in his bed and his gaze fel[...]Larocque wrote of them: "Both sexes are very
mine. He was too far g[...]clean, washing and bathing every morning in the
sees such a look of gratitude as that which passed
river, and in the winter in the snow, with a kind of
over his countenance. For a moment only he was[...]th."
rational. This was three p.m. At two o'clock the
next morning a terror-stricken shriek pierced the The Crows had one very undesirable trait-one
solemn stillness of the night-a shriek that I could that had them justly recognized as the "human pack-
not erase from my memory for many months. I rats of the Yellowstone." They not only delighted in
hastened[...]ofessional and very gainful
breathed his last and the pitifully tortured body was practice of it. As stated before, they pulled a raid
at rest." on the Lewis and Clark expedition when the party[...]In the early spring of 1866, Nelson Story had
Early Pioneers started a string of longhorns from Texas and became
Appraise Crows the first importer of cattle into Montana. It was not
Francois Antoine Larocque was in charge of a until December that he finally halted for the winter
British party that was sent to survey and investigate near the mouth of the Shields River, having lost a
the northern portion of the territory involved in the startling percentage of his stock, mostly from depreda-
Louisiana Purchase. While his group explored the tions of Indians. While Sioux and Blackfeet were
Yellowsto[...]excellent records, much credited with most of these losses while in Montana
of which concerned the Crow tribes. Mark Brown's and the headwaters of the Powder River in Wyoming,
"The Plainsman of the Yellowstone" draws some con- some of the Story lineage still residing in Park City
clusions from the Larocque report, and papers written are telling that on at least two different occasions the
Crows drove off some of these animals w bile they
by Edwin Denig (1850).[...]were slowly grazing along the Yellowstone and in
"They were good-natured, f[...]hat was loose
groups to smoke and visit, and even the children and available.
played in groups[...]ts gone,
In comparison with their neighbors, the Crows the crafty Indian having made a quick and silent job
were a kindly people. The crippled and decrepit of "swiping." Survey parties were almost always sure[...]e short something after they had enjoyed a
spared the lives of the women and children which friendly visit with these original "Americans." The
they captured. In fact, they were usually so kind[...]and egotistical they got into Crow-land that the crews building the
people-Larocque called "jealousy" ... their predomi- grades and laying the tracks had to set up night
nant passion. Murder was almost unheard of-a hus- guards to be sure of having all their groceries and
band might shoot the horse of his wife's lover, or work stock the next morning. And even after the

They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (131)126 THEY GAZED ON THE BEART OO THS

homesteaders had officially taken over, there were
many cases of thievery perpetrated by the nearby
THE CROW INDIANS
residing redskins. AND THE AGENCY
They were fast and clever, inhibited[...]83)
stealth, and very careful in how they "cased" the area
of their operations. They were also smart enough to As stated in the "acknowledgment" section of this
limit quantities to such amounts as they could safely volume, the chapter devoted to the Crow Indians and
handle and not be too severely punished in the event their relationship to the history will be limited. It is
they were trapped. merely a summary of the history, characteristics, and
type of living that featured this particular tribe.
In their raids against other Indians the Crows of-
times resorted to bloody battles and killings, but it is The relationship as far as the government of the
startling that few cases are of record where they United States was concerned, came with the Louisi-
have caused or suffered death losses in their thievery ana Purchase in 1803, when most of the territory used
exploits among the whites. by the Crows at one time or another was in that tract
of land.
Some of the records shown in Sanders history,
Certainly the earliest explorers along the Missouri
reveals that "On June 13, 1868, the Fort Smith Crows
and the Yellowstone encountered this breed of In-
made a dash at Hugh Kirkendall's mules grazin[...]dians. Lewis and Clark records mention of several
Fort Ellis and drove off 34 of them. The savages were
encounters with them, one of which involved a horse
pursued by Major Horr and the mules recovered. The
stealing foray while the expedition was camped near
Indians lost three of their number."
Columbus in 1806. In the account of Hunt's Expedi-
In claims filed against the government for the tion in 1811, appearing in volume 9, (19[...]ne reads on pages 250-251:
$19,036 was charged to the Crows in the overall total "Travelling generally to the southwest, they
of $155,646. reached and crossed the Little Missouri, traversed the[...]across several tributaries of the Yellowstone. On the
30th day of August they encamped at the base of the
Big Horn River. Here the party first encountered
the Crow Indians and though they received the whites
with professions of friendship, Mr. Hunt seems not to[...]when once more out of their neighborhood. He was[...]many of the men purchased horses on their own[...]account, so that the number was increased to 125, all[...]in good condition for the mountain travelling ahead."
Page 288: "The number of horses to the lodge
possessed by the various tribes about 1830 was: Crows[...]5, Flatheads and ez Perces 5, Assiniboines 2. The
Assiniboines were regarded as the poorest Indians of
the Upper Missouri and held in great contempt by[...]surrounding tribes. The Crows were the wealthiest."
The earliest treaty of record was proclaimed
February 6, 1826, for "the purpose of perpetuating
friendship between the United States and the Crow[...]It was not until September 17, 1851, that the
Laura Flanshal gazes through ri[...]

They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (132) THEY GAZED ON THE BEARTOOTHS[...]took definite steps to create Indian reser- the Grant treaty the Crows had signed another agree-
vations. At this[...]hrough Indian Commissioner P. Brunot in
involved, of whom approximately 2800 were described which they "ceded all of their lands on the Yellow-
as Crows. The land claimed by the Crows was 5,842- stone waters to the government; in return for which
000 acres, and described as "The country commencing they were to have the Judith Basin and $200,000 per
at the mouth of Powder River, up to its source, along year." Grant's action rescinded this short-lived agree-
the main range of the Black Hills and Wind River ment.
Mountains to the Geyser Park at the headwater of the
Yellowstone, down the Yellowstone to the mouth of The Crow nation was divided into two units,[...]shortly after coming into the Montana area. The
Twenty Five Yard Creek; thence to the head of the
River (or Prairie) Crows represented the group that
Musselshell, down the Musselshell to its mouth; thence
lived in the northern and eastern portions of the
to the head of Big Dry Creek and down to its mouth."[...]reservation and at the peak of their population num-
The domain of the Crow was cut down substan- bered approximately 900. The Mountain Crows, as
tially by a treaty negotiated[...]their designation implies, made their homes in the
eral Sherman and Crow chieftains which limited it to mountains, foothills and valleys of the Big Horn and
the area bordered on the east by the 107th meridian Beartooth ranges and numbered about 2150. A survey
from the Montana state line to the Yellowstone, west taken in 1868 included both factions and listed 520
to include all the land south and east of the Yellow- men, 745 women, 349 boys and 349 girls. From 1864,
stone again to the Wyoming line. This, later on, each t[...]M. Matthews, agent
brought such a complaint from the Crow tribe that for the Mountain Crows, and J. P. Cooper, for the
on January 31, 1874, President Grant established the Prairie Crows, each served until 1869, when the two
Crow Reserve along very much the same lines as had tribes were brought under one agency. E. M. Camp
been declared by the 1851 treaty. A year prior to then became the Crow agent, and was replaced . Sep-[...]
They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (133) 128 THEY GAZED ON THE BEARTOOTHS

tember 9, 1870 by[...]was Fork, Rosebud and Stillwater Rivers. Most of these
James Wright, who served a year and resigned Octo- were later forced to "lease" from the Indians, or evacu-
ber 4, 1874 to make way for Dexter E. Clapp. The last ate. The present boarders of the Crow Tribe's reserve
agent to reside in the Butcher Creek Agency was was established in a treaty of March 3, 1891 and on
Major Armstrong who had the longest tenure of any October 15, 1892 all of the ceded portions of the
Crow Indian agent to this date.[...]vation was thrown open to homestead entry.
The first agency was ordered built in 1868, and[...]me- lion acres to a stingy area bounded on the east by
thing happened to these plans for the earliest log the famous old 107th meridian, thence along the
buildings wre built at Mission Creek under the regime south side of the Yellowstone to the mouth or Pryor
of Major Pease. The first buildings burned down and Creek, up Pr[...]ced by adobe. to the Big Horn River and on up that river to the
Special Agent G. F. Milburn left Washington, Montana state line.
D.C., May 10, 1883, to make arrangements with Major The Crow Tribal Council now handles the affairs
Armstrong to have the agency moved once more. This of about 3105 Crow Indians (or breeds thereof) that
time the present site was selected at Crow Agency on reside on the reservation and 1459 who live elsewhere,
the Big Horn River, south of Hardin. The sale of the but are still eligible for federal payments of various
buildings of the Old Crow Agency was completed kinds from the Bureau of Indian Affairs. Of this
August 13, 188.3. It has existed at this place for over group there are 2288 men and 2276 females. Of the
80 years. off-the-reservation number 687 reside "near" the res-
After the headquarters had been moved to Butch- ervation-the balance are "far away" registrants.
er Creek, Ag[...]getting an
extension approved that added a strip of land about
40 miles in width from the 107th meridian to the Locating The Crow
Crazy Mountains. This was approved October[...]1875. Observers stated that Clapp was so angry at the A man who had been a general in the Confeder-
establishment of saloons and dives along the stage ate army during the Civil War, Dexter E. Clapp was
route north of the Yellowstone, to which the Indians the man who was credited with the establishment of
had easy access, that the only way he could put them the Crow Agency south of Absarokee. This practical
out of business was to make it a reserve. The remon- man had taken over as Indian Agent, replacing James
strations of stage lines, busin~ssmen and others along Wright, who had resigned October 4, 1874. It didn't
the stage route brought its cancellation about six take this practical official long to figure out that the
months later, on March 8, 1876.[...]s action had its effect however, on what was the east, and becoming a serious threat to the de-
to be Columbus. Horace Countryman (who was one velopment of the upper Yellowstone Valley. A move
of the prime objects of Clapp's hatred) and William to a more central portion of the agency would provide
Norton were forced to close[...]a stronger position, by bringing it closer to the pro-
the Countryman stage stop. tection of the military posts along the lower Yellow-
With the coming of the railroad, the domain of stone, and provide a speedier access to Crow warriors
the Crow rapidly diminished. In 1880, a treaty was[...]land for livestock
made that would surrender all the land north of the and agricultural development. Clapp also found too
Yellowstone River. This was ratified, and the land many whiskey vendors near the Mission Agency, and
thrown open to settlement in 1882. The same year thought that the move over 70 miles eastward, might
the western end of their former range got away, do away with this problem. As it turned out this
when the government made a deal whereby the idealism never materialized. His plan was bitterly
Boulder River became the western boundary of the opposed by Bozeman residents who felt that the pro-
reservation. This same ceded strip included[...]tion provided by nearby Fort Ellis might be
chunk of the reservation west along the Montana state lessened-also there could be a loss of business with
line from the headwaters of the Clarks Fork, includ- the Indians.
ing most of the Beartooth Mountains and the potential Clapp's judgment however, was[...]was given orders to move the agency to its new home
The confusion over this particular districting in February, 1875. In his list of employees were Tom
caused many headaches for home[...]and Mitch Buoyer who had been scouts and
pectors. The Old Nye City mining venture was set dispatch carriers, and were quite familiar with the
up on the assumption that their property was on this type of a place desired by Agent Clapp. They select-
cede[...]armers and stockmen took ed this spot on the west bank of Butcher Creek a few
up claims along the headwater streams-the Clarks hundred yards from where it emptied into the East

They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (134)[...]THEY GAZED ON THE BEARTOOTHS[...]ing started early in March. The new move to the Big Horn did not mean that
By April 1, some of the buildings were ready for the Crow Indians had abandoned this territory. It was
occupancy. When the original log buildings at Mission not popular with the redskins who had learned to love
had burned, they[...]d by adobe bricks, and this part of the Beartooths. This land abounded in
this same material was used at the new Crow home. wild game and fish; chokecherries and huckleberries
The stockade was about 250 feet long and nearly 30 grew in profusion; the streams were providing some
feet wide terminating in a round two-story "fortress" of the best trapping in the West; there were the mak-
that provided vision and firing area in all directions. ings of kinnikinick and the herbs and berries used in
The main stockade also carried loopholes every few their "medicine," all native to this area; the climate,
feet for use of the riflemen in case of attack. The soothed by the soft chinook in the winter, was beyond
other buildings and corrals were of logs and poles, compare.
except for the one which was the home of the agent.[...]Chief Plenty Coups
It was a two-story structure. The cost of this move
of wanting the reservation moved solely because it
was budgeted[...]uld be closer to his home on Pryor Creek which he
the operation so efficiently that several thousand do[...]to spit plum seeds"
lars remained to be used for the general fund in[...](this creek being infested with the sweet wild plum
mainstaying the agency. Clapp resigned shortly after[...]at grew along its banks and bottoms). Second gen-
the Custer Massacre, and was in business for himself[...]eration individuals tell how the women openly cried
for a brief period.[...]y had to leave this particular region and move to
the agency to the Big Horn River site in 1883, the the more open area oi the Big Horn to receive their
buildings and some other assets at the Butcher Creek gratuities.
agency[...]. D. Pease, who During the interim from the time the agency
also selected his own allotment including the land moved until the land was opened to settlement in
where the buildings were on and in the immediate 1892, many of these Indians selected their allotments
vicinity,[...]his home for many years. in the land that was still theirs. Many others made[...]INDIAN CAMP SOUTH OF BRIDGE 1908
For many years the Crow Indians came from the Crow Agency at Hardin to revisit the beloved land of them and their anceston.
They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (135) 130 THEY GAZED ON THE BEARTOOTHS

this their "camping groun[...]and a heavy single braid hanging from the back of their
fishing forays for food and recreation. Even after the heads. One of the girls had light hair and all were
white men had t[...]ed to come -back to good looking. I told the old squaw I liked the looks
visit with white friends, or some of their own kin of the girls but could not take one because I had to
on the allotted claims. go with the soldiers."
The Crow nation was a long time in forgetting 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
the glory of the Beartooths and their happy existance
here, despite the trouble with the Sioux, Cheyenne
and Piegan tribes. And the fact that they had been How the Name "Crow" Was Established
deprived of a land that was a rich source of food The Crow Indian word, or sequence of syllables,
forced them to make greater demands fo[...]Ab-sar-o-ka, was wrongly interpreted by the earliest
sustainance. white men students of this language. The story is that[...]an Indian in sign language tried to spell out to the
Bits of Interest From The Allen Diary white man the tribal name, · and in so doing pointed[...]to a bird. This happened to be a crow, hence the
"It is interesting to notice how the Indians pre-[...]rked Tail Bird."
from five to ten pounds. Holding the piece of meat They took this name in early days[...]they will speedily slice it in thin pieces the magpie or blue jay that lived in that portion of
as long as the piece of meat will. allow; after all is cut the Indian territory. The white man won the endur-
and sliced, a green willow frame is made in the shape ance contest over the name, and it has since been
of a lodge with slanting sides, and a fire is built inside. Crow Indian for all negotiations with the Indian
One layer of meat is slid on this frame until half Bureau.
roasted, when it is taken off and placed in the sun. 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0

Fresh slices are then placed on the frame until all is In order to avoid confusion the Stillwater River
done. All the pieces are then placed in a case made was named Buffalo-Jumps-Over-The-Bank River by
of buffalo hide, and whenever camp is made the meat the Crows (probably from the fact that one of the best
is taken out of the case and placed in the air and sun buffalo jumps in the Crow area was in the Stillwater
a few days to keep it from molding and spoiling; Canyon near Nye);the Yellowstone was known to
after that it will keep sweet for a long time. It is then them as The Elk River; and Pryor Creek was Arrow
cased and se[...]0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0

"The summer of 1872 was warm and fine, so an
order was made for[...]A rather amusing story comes from the Arm-
caught by the dam when it came downstream. I strong regime at the agency. His sister was employed
threw one stick in the stream, and the others did the as a teacher in the little log schoolhouse that served
same, but that was all that went down to the dam. the children of the white employees as well as the
The wild strawberries and wild girl picnic lasted two[...]tend. One day
weeks and was a failure as all said the wood lodged Miss Armstrong was shaking an older, bigger Indian
and sank in the creek bends, waterlogged." girl for a misdemeanor, and while resisting, the culprit
0 0 0 0 0 0[...]engaged her fingers in the teachers hair. A sudden
"One day on old Cheyenne squaw came into the jerk and the entire mass of hair was pulled off and
bell tent where I was writing-and after I had given dangled in the pupils hand. She had never heard of
them all they wanted to eat, the old squaw said, "I am a wig, and started s[...]heir aside and headed for home. She swam the Rosebud
parents were killed by the soldiers. Look at them, River to her tepee on its west bank, instead of using
they are good girls, and they say' you are good or you the bridge a short distance away. "I've scalped the
woula not have fed us; if you will give me a mule[...]told her mother, and hid
horse, you can have one of them. Do you live in under a huge pile of buffalo robes. She was fright-
Crow country? I answered in the affirmative. Then ened so badly that she would not return to school.
if you will pick one of these girls I will soon to visit Embarrassed and humilated by the incident Miss
you,' said the old squaw, thinking that this tempting Armstrong concluded her work in the agency as a
inducement should seal the bargain at once. The girls teacher that same week, and[...]

They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (136) THEY GAZED ON THE BEARTOOTHS[...](Back of Ci~ar Box Lid)

Authentic pictures of the old Crow Agency dur- long building extending south is the warehouse. The
ing the short nine years it was established on Butcher[...]reek, which runs
Creek (so named because this was the official slaugh- through the Indian and white cemetery." This nota-
tering plant for the Crow tribe government fresh tion is painted on the top of the lid, with the date
meat allotments), are few and far between. There "1883 on the Rosebud."
may be some left buried in the archives of the Indian
Bureau, but most of them, if any, have been the This picture was autographed and presented to
victims of old age and time.[...]eForest Brush." This prized cigar
A lid from the empty box of D. Hirsch & Co. lid is the property of Arthur Campbell, son of Hugh
"Principes" brand cigars, was the "canvas" used by Campbell, who was the "farm" instructor for the In-
George DeForest for a picture of the agency "fort" dians at the agency at that time. The colors are still
and compound. He describes it "The long building clear, the dimensions authentic and the painting is
with door in front (east) is the traders store, and the proof that this little-known artist ha[...]

They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (137)132 THEY GAZED ON THE BEARTOOTHS

PROFILE OF CHIEF PLENTY COUPS-LONG TIME CROW RULER[...]

They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (138) THEY GAZED ON THE BEARTOOTHS[...]When the wars were over, and fears of attacks
CHIEF PLENTY COUPS[...]settled down to a life of peace and happiness on his
Aleek-che[...]ally attend his offical duties, sometimes in
The chief of the Crows best known by many
Washington, without relying entirely on an interpreter.
residents of Stillwater County was Plenty Coups. He[...]ecognized nationally when he placed a
was born in the Billings area in 1849, and died at his
wreath on the tomb of the Unknown Soldier in 1921
allotment on Pryor Creek[...]as a representative of all American Indians. His home
an Indian, 84. He[...]was a visiting spot for many notables, including
the Crow people than any single chief, despite the
Marshal Foch, early commander of the allied forces
fact that an earlier leader the great, famed Arapooish,[...]Roosevelt and others. In 1928 he gave part of his
lation between his tribe and the invading white race.[...]ds for
He became a chief when he had accomplished the re-
both the Crows and white people." His home has since
quired amount of "coups," about the age of 22, and[...]each year.
Iron Bull he was the final word in affairs concerning
the Crow tribe-a reign of over half a century.
According to the customs of his race, as a young
man he attained his first coups. He went into too
Crazy Mountains, to meet "The Persons" (mythical
figures) who would guide his l[...]and tell
them that I was now a man." To complete the ordeal
he then cut the first joint of his left index finger off
with a knife, and weakly trekked back to his lodge
(then on the Musselshell).
Fred Krieg, Billings historian, once noted that
"The title of chief is not hereditary, but must be
earned by completing four types of achievement:
1. Touch an enemy in combat-Ple[...]d
four times.
3. Be a leader (carry the pipe) in a war party-he
lead 11 times.[...]s five times."
While Plenty Coups was chief of the Crows dur-
ing its existence at the Butcher Creek agency, he spent
but little time th[...]his camp
along Pryor Creek or to spend a portion of his time
visiting other lodges and other chiefs of the clans
that comprised the Crow ation. He was one of the
few chiefs that performed a lot of "wolfing" or scout-
ing on behalf of the safety of his people, but always
came to the agency headquarters when summoned by
dispatchers of the agents.
Plenty Coups was married three times, but the
only children were by his first wife, and died at[...]rophesy by a medicine man that
"You will never be the father of a child-you will be CHIEF PLENTY COUPS
the father of your people." Greatest of the later Crow chiefs.
They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (139)[...]THEY GAZED ON THE BEARTOOTHS

He was indeed a great Crow-a great American!
In speaking of this noble Redman for whom he
had great admiratio[...]d, Col.
Allen has related:
Plenty Coups was the one man that could have
persuaded the Cheyennes to be the same friends to
the white man as the Crows were, and be racial
allies. Plenty Coups had completed a meeting with
American Horse, chief of the Cheyennes (not to be
confused with the Sioux-Ogalalla Chief American
Horse who was kille[...]s later there occurred an incident
that shattered the hopes of success. A head-strong
young Cheyenne man and a younger companion shot
and killed a white who caught the Indians butchering
a stolen beef. This renewed the wrath and vengence
of the military forces-the Crows could not reconcile
such action, and the gesture of peace and friendship
ended."
Although Chief Plenty Coups was the head chief
and general bargaining agent for the Crow tribe,
there were nevertheless subdivisions, as reported to
the government on January 27, 1885, from the newer
agency on the Big Horn.
Name of Chiefs Lodges Pers[...]............... 47 494
Takes-The-Wrinkle ............ 30 193[...]................ 27 153
Bear-in-the-Water .............. 24 138[...]120 AMERICAN HORSE CHIEF OF CHEYENNES
Spotted Horse ...................... 20 119 A friend of Chief "Plenty Coups".

Iron Bull ....... ..[...]116 Courtesy of Mrs. William Sutter
Medicine Crow ..[...]

They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (140) THEY GAZED ON THE BEARTOOTHS[...]I had not sent four of my men back to the Crow
(Page 228 to 337)[...]the Pecunies.
Chief Plenty Coups tells Frank Lindermann of
the Battle of Hailstone Basin: "They caught up with us late the next afternoon,[...]out camping and eating,
"One winter day when the snow was deep, our[...]hear them ·at all. I
Wolves came in and told us the Pecunies had stolen[...]hing on with my three men-Plain-bull, who is
many of our horses. I was camped with about 40[...]with us here, Strikes-on-the-head, the Big-sky-thank-
lodges on Rock Creek, and our hors[...]luck that no more than four white men were in
in the hills where they could paw away the snow and[...]our party. I saw they were a hinderance instead of a
get grass. Because of the slow days that had come to[...], if left to themselves, they would never
us with the white man, and the lack of long grass to[...]for trouble, as we always had had "In the middle of the night we came to the
when the buffalo were plentiful. We had to go out in headwaters of the Musselshell, and when the Seven-
the hills and catch horses to ride. That is the way we stars (Big Dipper) had tur:p.ed clear around Elk-kah-
lived now, like a lot of sleepy people whom anybody ceh-say (North Star) I saw· that two of my men were
might whip. far behind because of the condition of their horses.[...]d have to give them rest, and stopped
"Eight of us went out and caught up our best[...]to look for a good place. The wind had blown the
horses, the fastest and strongest. We expected the
ground bare of snow where I was standing. I signed
trail to be a[...]camping.
Anyway we started, and picked up the Pecunie trial
on Elk River. The water was frozen, so we crossed "It was well I did so. I had gone but a little way
on the ice in the face of a cold wind that kept it when I became suspicious of a place in the rim-rock
wiped clean of snow, which had drifted into piles out where the snow was piled about some boulders, and,
on the plains and along the river banks. stooping .low to get the sky between me and the[...]tle smoke that was from a fire nearly
houses, and the white men who lived in them told us dead. The Pecunies were near it, I knew.
the Pecunies, or somebody, had taken most of their
horses too. We talked to them as best we could with "Not daring to trust the white men to do the
signs and a little English (when we knew it was n[...]ttack
property. I believed them able to take care of them- them, if I can.' But I could not hold my white friends.
selves and agreed, which was one of the most foolish They were unmanageable, and got[...]id. charge the camp in that dim light.
"They began to show[...]had been pawing snow for grass telling you the truth; they began to yell, and I dodged
in the windy hills. Naturally their horses could travel[...]ut there sitting on
faster than ours, but because the trail was likely to their horses and yelping like coyotes.
be a long one I tried to hold the white men back, "They did not shout long. The Pecunies were not
telling them to save their animals for the trouble fools. I soon saw rifles poking over the rim-rock, one
ahead. They would not listen but rode on, while we of which spurted fire. Down went a white man with
walked, until their animals grew tired. Then the white a bullet over his eye.
men camped. When[...]they
wished me to stay with them, but I told them the "'Go back!' I called, making the sign. By my
Pecunies would not camp and that if w[...]looking foolish, until an-
as best I could, that the thieves were driving nearly other tumbled off[...]unable to go so far in a head. This time the two others moved a little. One
day as we could, i[...]der to
They said their horses were tired out, and of course fight. He was smarter than the others, but just as he
they were, having been ridden all day in the deep poked his rifle over the boulder a bullet struck the
snow. So I left them, wishing with all my heart that rock and glanced into his face. Hol The lead bullet
They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (141) 136 THEY GAZED ON THE BEARTOOTHS

spit and spattered, making a terrible wound that we heard horses coming-a doz n or more of them.
knocked him down in the snow as though finished. We stood up, but[...]g. White men began to
"I looked to see what the other was going to do shoot at us.
with hims[...]way afoot; as fast "I waved my hand-made the sign for 'friend'-
as he could go. Next I saw hi[...]e. I thought he bullets were kicking up the ston s around us and we
stayed there. feared they might kill the wounded white man. We
"I would have helped[...]front and P cunies shooting b hind us. We
to hold the Pecunies from getting away. I had not[...]thought if we shot up th hill at the Pecunies the
yet got a shot. Bullets chipped pieces from my[...]nie who, I knew, "I tied a whit pi c of buck kin on my wiping-
had done most damage to the white men. He had stick and stood up unarm d. Holding my stick high
seen the two Crows join us among the boulders, and with my right hand, I str tc[...]ast realized that I was only one man, and
good as the one he had left, and I made ready for una[...]fortunately one of them knew it. This ended the
"The others saw him fall, which made them wish trouble and we shook hands.
to move to the rocks higher up on the hill. When they "I led them to the spot where their friends were
started I made one of the best shots I ever fired, and, as best I could with signs and a very few English
killing one of them halfway up that hill, as easily as words, explained what had happened. While some of
though he had been just against my gun barrel. One them were examining the wounded man and the dead
of the others, who had a Winchester, began a lively ones whose bodies were now frozen very hard, two
spurt of shooting now, but they were in.a tight place, white men went out to find the man who had run
and knew it. Their guns were fast[...]uld reach their po- we could do toward killing the o~her Pecunies. (Pe-
sition, even in the higher rocks. However, our own cunies-ofte[...]rs; so, after sta- though their enemies declare the word to mean
tioning two of my men to hold the Pecunies where "scabby-face.')
they were[...]th Plain-Bull to see what "We crept up the hill from rock to rock, while
we could do for the white man whose face had been Big-sky and Strikes-on-the-head kept up their fire,
smashed. until we came to the tall ones body. Here Plain-bull
"We found hi[...]a snorting horse stood up and, walking to the tall one, counted coup
and bleeding badly. We carried him to a safer place, on him in the face of the firing up the hill. I took
dragged the two dead men together, and then went to the fellow's scalp, and together we set out once more
look at the trail left in the snow by the white man who to get the other whose body was still farther up the
ran away and fell down. We followed his tracks only hill. But the white men now began calling and
a little way, loo[...]Pecunie unscalped. I have felt sorry ever
back to the job of trying to get the other Pecunies smce.
among the rocks. "The white men had built a large fire, and also
"On our return we stopped again by the side of they had gone out and killed a white man's cow so
the wounded man, and while we were kneeling do[...]

They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (142) THEY GAZED ON THE BEARTOOTHS 1[...]RTHERN PACIFIC
had a f mor Crows with me instead of those white RIGHT o ,F WAY
m n.
'Whil w re ating, the whites who had gone[...]LAND
to follo th one that ran away came back with the The following story was related to the author by
oward. H wa unhit. Two bullets had struck his Joe Kern, and printed in The Columbus News, Janu-
fur o rcoat and on had knocked him down on the ary 18, 1923:
now. H had got up running and hadn't stopped for "Mr. Kern came to the Stillwater in 1880. It was
a long tim .[...]a remarkable season. Over the whole state the snow[...]aid deep that year, and from Dillon where he left the
' I my If had thr e holes in my capote and on[...]Mormon railway and staged it to the Stillwater it was
in my hirt, but my skin was not[...]very bad all the way. The stages ran about 60 miles
r und · rs and h lped the white men[...]ild-
o k th m aero s th backs of the
ings at the agency. The next summer a schoolhoune
h I[...]was built, and the big irrigation ditch completed.
I I[...]"The Indians still buried their dead on pole racks
"· wa so cold that the trees popped and th scent of the burial grounds on the point across
an mor than one w w re obliged from the Rosebud was often wafted to the agency
to i o warm th white men~ who where the men were working. The Crow agent then
w h h now in places was drift- ordered burial in the ground, and at first the cliffs
d r did w unload the horse along the river wer used for this purpose.
th[...]ng th stiff arms and legs "In July of that summer a council of the Indians
look d moonlight, sp cially[...]nt out to th chiefs who were all at a distance on the
Ir memb r. buffalo ground. Runners were sent to the Mussel-
shell, Judith Basin and along the Little Big Horn.
"It was a hard journey for these white men. Two Among the chiefs were Long Elk, Crazy Horse and
whole days[...]with little rest, took us to Plenty Coups. The last named had but a small num-
Park City, the white men's village, and it was there I ber of lodges under him, and was more or less unim-
lear[...]portant at that time. Crazy Horse was the war chief,
heart fell to the ground when I heard them crying a radica[...]"Col. W. F. Sanders represented the interior de-
only they had used their heads a lit[...]partment, Major Kelley was agent at the reservation,
to fight with white men."[...]len was issuing clerk for a trading company
(The description of this fight, written by Finch and Hugh Campbell was keeper of the herds and
Brown, appearing elsewhere, seems more and more issued the beef. The last two were more or less in
factual and tends to discredit the boasting of Chief an unofficial capacity at this meeting.
Plenty 'coups, one of his few faults.-The Editor.) Garbed in full war regalia of paint and feathers,
the chiefs and a retinue of 30 or 40 appeared on the
skyline just west of the agency buildings. Here they
paused giving the group gathered at the agency a
full view of their grandeur, and then swept down the
bluffs into the enclosure.
"Make it clear to your people," the interpreter
was ordered, "that the Iron Horse will pass through[...]that, we will speak of the terms."[...]tion regarding the right of way. Some had little to[...]say, and others were irrevalent to the subject matter.[...]been a former Crow agent, by the hand and led him
J. A. ALBERT ON VIEWS[...]
They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (143) 138 THEY GAZED ON THE BEARTOOTHS

to the middle of the circle. With a dramatic gesture
he threw off his fine robe and wrapped it around the
major. "Make this man our agent," he said. 'When he
was our agent we had plenty of rations and we want
him to be our agent again."
Plenty Coups was the only chief who regard d
the matter in terms of dollars and cents. He proposed
that the Indians be paid at the rate of $400 a lodge.
It was thought that Crazy Horse wo[...]my children to eat
as long as they live."
"The agreement was reached that $20,000 be paid
in annuties for the right of way, the pipe of peac
went around, and the chiefs signed by "the touch of
a pen."

CROW AGENCY
. . . jottings of a wanderer
"At a point three miles below Sheep Dip I was
ferried across the Yellowstone and took the trail from
the Crow Agency. The road winds along the course
of the Stillwater, a clear sparkling mountain torrent[...]retting seems emphatically to pro-
test against the name it bears. On either side are rocky
ledges crowned by groves of pine trees which greatly
add to the beauty of the landscape. Fifteen miles
travel on the back of a horse that I am sure didn't[...]Bob Hudson how remains of p-av of two men purportedly
have a joint in his body, wa[...]killed by Indians near ye.
pare one for the comforts and generous cheer that the
Mission affords.
The buildings are constructed of adoh~ and are lakes and limpid water courses, fed by eternal snow
built in the form of a rectangle inside of which is a fields, contribute to the charms of this highly favored
broad smooth court. On dismo[...]d
cordially greeted by Major Henry J. Armstrong, the other fish.
newly appointed agent, and after necessary ablutions, But the genius of this age honest labor, is pene-
was placed in care of Jack Mills who is in charge of trating even this wild region, which since the crea-
the culinary department. Jack proved faithful to his[...]wed in body and spirit. experienced in the excitement of the chase, or the
The Crow nation is one of the most powerful in hardships of war. I am informed by th agent that
Montana and is rich in all that contributes to the many of the Indians are already selecting homesteads
simple demands of savage comfort. Contrary to the and preparing to open up farms. The initiatory work
ordinary accepted opinion, the tribe is slowly increas- has already started at the Mission, 100 acres having
ing in number from year to year. The agent estimates been put under cultivation. The land is divided into
the total of men, women and children to be 3500, and plots of three acres each and are allotted to such as are
in the event of war 600 able-bodied, well-equipped willing to work. The task of teaching the Indians to
warriors could be put into the field on short notice. work is exceedingly vexatious, the first lessons begin-
Their reservation, which consists of 6000 square miles, ning with the harnessing of a horse. This learned, the
is one of the most fertile and beautiful sections of next step is to teach them how to attach the animal to
Montana and in itself constitutes an empire. Its broad a plow; then the manner of using the implement and
prairies are dotted by countless herds of antelope, thus on to the end of the chapter. The principal crop
while the magnificient Beartooth Range, stretching[...]hough this eason all
aero s its entire length, is the native haunt of great kinds of vegetables have been planted. The Indians
bands of elk and deer of various species. Mountain have shown much reluctance to begin work, but the

They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (144) THEY GAZED ON THE BEARTOOTHS[...]Leaned against a friendly lodge-pole;
one third of the braves will devote their energies to Gentl[...]staff comprises as genial and
int llig nt a party of gentlemen as it has ever been And her nam[...]Though her smile spoke friendly greeting;
ductiv of many pleasant memories that will not soon[...], "You are welcome";
fad away. Mr. C. H. Barstow, the clerk, has occu- Still her rosy lips w[...]ord she uttered.
11 nt busine abiliti s, won the confidence and And the grave and stern old warrior
t m of v ral pr e ding agents. Dr. Henry A. Sharply gazed upon the writer;
Ru 11, th phy i ian, hails from Maine, an[...]. "Oh young white man
joy a g n ral popularity at the agency, as he has at Hide thy pale face neath our war paint;
form r plac s of r sid nee. The "farmer" instructor, Deck thy hair with eagle feathers;
Mr. Hugh S. Campb 11, is a young man of intelligence Strike the wild deer on the mountain.
and industry, and to his care the agricultural depart- Be a warrior of this nation
m nt is entrusted.[...]For a wife take this, my daughter,
The matrimonial relation between the people is[...]s no "kicker''.
strict business principals. Among the more enlight-[...]Thought the words that I should utter.
telligence are factors in the issue, but women are[...]And a "big head" he'd put on me
consideration. The legal tender in trade of this kind[...]should decline his offer.
is horses or mules, and the number given varies from[...]"O, fair Two Horses,
one to a dozen, depending on the attractiveness of
Lovliest of all the women
the coveted bride. Much shrewd bartering generally[...]In this land of braves and warriors;
preceeds the marriage, and any poor unfortunate seek-[...]ur eyes are black as storm-clouds
toothless wreck of a horse or a mule to offer generally[...]Driven cross the heavens at midnight;
gets a wife answering the same general description.[...]Though your teeth flash like the wavelets
At the time of my visit there were several lodges near[...]Rippling over pebbly rapids
the agency, and I was curious to-visit one.
'Neath the full glare of the moonlight,[...]At the cost of two good ponies
To-conduct me to a wig-warn[...]Or a mule that is no ''kicker".
Where the Red Man lolls in comfort.
Then I left her in the wig-warn
Soon we came to a great white lodge-[...]"Rustling" with her raven tresses-
To the lodge of "Stradling Lightening."
Left her with the stern old warrior-
And we entered at the doorway,[...]r "Stradling Lightening".
Took our seats upon the ground floor,
Sat upon a couch of peltries.
And the warrior bade us welcome. (The foregoing was taken from the Barstow scrap-
Bowed was he with years and ha[...]Hugh S. Campbell and is
And his hair was like the hoar frost. the property of his son, Arthur. The article was mere-
At his feet a friend[...]
They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (145)[...]Cf.)

THE STILLWATER BASIN WAS WINTER HEADQUARTERS AND POPULAR HUNTING GROUNDS (Roahen Photo)
FOR THE CROWS DURING THE AGENCY DAYS ON BUTCHER CREEK.

They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (146) Chapter 14
HERE WAS THE DOMAIN
OF THE GREAT "79"
Foreword J:Iere was a land of variety, much desired by a
top a mall hill which jut out betw n two practI_cal cowman. The near-mountain areas of Big Elk,
ul l adin ·nto E t Whit B av r Cre[...]American Fork, Fish and Simmons Creek with the
an pp r ntly rl tin pin tr . It main trunk[...]but r maining from th e small streams; into the breaks of the Mus-
~ran h urvi d. On it low r ba ar thr ring- sellshell where the bunch grass and natural shelter
hk gob of bark and pitchpin , r sin, from which provided wonderful winter feed; the Lake Basin with
pr trud faint fra m nt of barb d wire to betray its blue smage merging into the greasewood flats,
th almo t fatal irdl that w r form d wh n Charley wh re the bluestream afforded the richest fattening
Farl y u d thi tr a th outh ast corn r of a f d available, and the many lakes feed by Cedar
l im that h " quatt d", a quart r s ction of land and Sixshooter, Hailstone and Lost Gr[...]. answered the water problems; then on farther north[...]and east where the hills and sheltering coulees drifted[...]sed as com rs or bearing farther apart, but the grass and some sage remained
tr by th ttl r, ar not uncommon along the lush and abundant.
br ak of th Y llowstone. But some eighty years
ago it tood[...]larg st ·tree on th hill-a mon- Here was the domain of the great Seventy Nine!
arch among th smaller six and eight foot seedlings Here was the working area of Montana's most
that surround d it, and maintainin[...]is significant because it was ~ere was the world where a school boy dreamed
the initial move in land procurement that built a of bemg a cowboy-to have a fast, faithful pony
domain of nearly ninety thousand acres of deeded
land and fifty thousand acres of leased railroad and
school lands. And if it could talk, it would surely
boast not only of its winning battle against man and
the elements with apparently ageless tenacity, but
also of the fact that it is one of the few animate
things that remain of an era beginning eight decades
ago.
For here was the heart of nature's great cow land.
Here was a unit of the interim of fabulous years that
spanned the period from the extinction of the free
Indians and buffalo herds to the coming of the plows
and grain drills, and the homesteaders and land buy-
ers who were to destroy the grasslands and develop
the practices of modern agriculture as applied to this
type of terrain.
Here was the free grass for those who wished to
gamble with do[...]y never
ending quantities. From this tree west to the Crazies,
from the Yellowstone to the Mussellshell; east, in
the early days as far as the Bull Mountains, and later
toward the rising sun to the Big Dry-here was land
to be borrowed from[...]
They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (147) 142 THEY GAZED ON THE BEARTOOTHS

and ride along the wagons that the nighthawk and
the cook drive, and make little forays to either side[...]JOHN T. MURPHY
of the trail to maybe help drive the herd; or better A business institution that grew into uch propor-
yet, to take the twenty-two and shoot enough young tions as the "79" didn't "just happen." It had to be
sagehens or half-grown cottontail rabbits so the cook the product of the lead rship of a man who had faith
could have a nicer supper th[...]sight, courage, honesty and a slight touch of a gambl r.
the soft blankets on a smooth grassy spot, and gaze[...]Such a man was John T. Murphy, organiz r of the
up into the stars to day dream; to let those old coyotes[...]a Missourian, instinc-
slumber came; to arise in the morning, tempt d by
tively heeded the call of th W t with its glamour,
the tantalizing smell of sizzling bacon, and sourdough[...]biscuits smothered in black-strap and a pan full of
who was not afraid to work, nor afr id to fac the
fried spuds and coffee for filler, enough to run[...]hardships and dang rs that w r th lot of th f on-
to the next meal, just as tasty and delicious; to the end
tiersman.
of the round-up and shipping time, and then the
payday![...]a lad of tw nty-on , wh n h h d toil · d and sav d to
com[...]a point wh r h was abl to wh I wagon-train of
Now the pony wasn't so smooth and fast- in fact me[...]g was three or four to be ridden in turn for the booming miner days of 1864, commoditi s that
a day, and sometimes they[...]ld thing for an excuse, even buck
sometimes; and the trail of the herd was dusty and
stinking and sweaty, and a ri[...]ppen to "spook" them; to
wrestle a calf and have the smoke from the burning
hair blow in your eyes, while an irate mother cow
kept you guessing which way to jump; the chow call,
usually pretty fair but not much like home cooking-
could it be that the beans were a little tainted to
upset your stomach, or how come that the "smear"
was rancid; the rough, lumpy ground where you
unrolled your "soogans'' and tarp, (out in the open
if it didn't rain, under the crowded "flys" on the
bed wagon if it did) and a lariat stretched in a[...]uldn't crawl over it to become a bed com-
panion; the final cutting of the beef herd, and the
tension of the night watch, with the knowledge that
even a mild stampede would shrink away many
dollars worth of valuable fat, and the boss might
give you your "time"; and then the paltry pay-off!
Wonder if it's worth it. And the terrible !onliness
and craving for companionship other than the men
who are working with you, fine fellows as the[...]JL
filled with hunger!
Yes, this was the interlude between the old and
the new, when grass was the crop and the stockman
was king, and the cowboy was the guy that swore
he was through but came back for m[...]Organizer and control stockholder of the famous "79",

They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (148)[...]THEY GAZED ON THE BEARTOOTHS[...]names than the payroll) and he also gave the man-
agers a free hand in the selection of men to be hired[...]mismanagement that might be reflected in the profits
of the business.[...]Helena store, that he envisioned the potential in the
livestock business. He watched the Northern Pacific[...]sel ct d the virgin areas here-to-fore described as the
initial field of operations for his newly dreamed em-[...]ver acknowledging defeat, he weathered the
financial threats imposed by the crucifying winter of[...]go broke; he withstood the challenge of the panic of
1893, suffered no ill effects other than the expense of[...]management was proclaimed by the appraisers of his
estate at a primary figure of $1,381,834.75, to which[...]was later added "79" assets of $46,609.66 and $453,-
"UNCLE" NE[...]398.83 equity in the Powder River Land and Cattle
Had fir t cattle in Lake Basin, friend and compatriot of John Company, one of his newer ventures.
T[...]When John T. ·M urphy died at his home in Helena
the initial move in a business career covering a busy in 1914, Montana lost one of her most respected, most
half century of a mercantile business, mining, banking[...]. At his funeral
and his most profitable venture, the land and cattle were many whom he h[...]befriended. More than a few of these friends were[...]boys and men who had been a proud part of the crews
Biographies record that Murphy was pretty sure that had gathered around the camp wagons bearing
of the men he selected as associates in business. In the brand of the "79".
this list are such names as Cornelius Hedge[...]Woolman, Ironically enough, the complications of the distri-
Charley Broadwater, L. A. Walker, W. E. Cullen, bution of ·his estate brought on many legal problems,
and John Turton. All were successful businessmen of and it was not until June 1957, that a final instrument
the territory. Tom Full and John Lienberger of St. numbered 189 was filed, and the clerk of the court
Louis, prominent substantial bankers were his only of Lewis and Clark County put the voluminous file
out-of-state co-partners. back on the shelf for its last review, except for his-[...]But at no time did he ever completely release
the reins of the teams on his business wagons. Partic- Members of his family played a part in the "79''
ularly was this true of the "79." All receipts of sales operations. His brother, Joseph[...]n-
went through his business office; payrolls for the man ager for the first six years of its existance, and as soon
power and supplies were all channeled there. He as he became of age his son, William, was at the helm
gave his managers and foremen a free[...]
They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (149) IH THEY GAZED 0 THE BEARTOOTHS[...]other board members filed an extension of incorpora-
Official records show that Murphy, in partner- tion for twenty years. This wa the last document
ship with a I 1r. Floweree, fir t engaged in the cow filed on behalf of th Montana attl ompany as
business when the[...]orporat unit.
Oregon, and turned them to graze in the Great Falls In 1910, th br nd w r t[...]John T..
area. Later, h interested oth r money in the cattle Murphy, and while th brand continu d to b u d
venture, which gave birth to the "79". He honored in th "79" operation , n in it dying day it can
the , ear hy officia1ly recording the company brands. b assum d that th a t and inv ntori w re th
This was a running 79 on the left rib , and an upside personal prop rti s f John T. Murphy.
clown revers , which reads 6L on the right ribs. (In Which didn't m an th[...]abandon d
1905 was added a left-tipped lazy 7 to the left rib th liv stock bu in s . On O tob r 16 1911, The
brand, an<l th 6L h·ansf rred to th left hip.) Powd r Riv r Land and attl omp ny of H 1 n ,
lt was not until May 1 1 0 how ver,[...]position to file incorporation L. Smith of H 1 na, nd Rolla P. H r n, a form r
papers with the territorial office. This s t up the ''79' mana r a in orporator . Thi r w into a
Montana Cattl Company for a p rio<l of ten years, 16,000 h ad of ttl p ration. In addition to th
with a c:apital ·tock of $100,000. Thi provid d opera- "79', M 1rphy wa affiliat d ith oth r ow outfit ,
tion hl al1 eight of th counties in the stat of Mon- nd at on tim laim d to hav an qui y in 90,000
tana at that time. Th board of truste s included had.
Rus ell B. Harrison (son of President B njamin Harri-
son) as chairman (and office man g r of th com-
pany), Thomas . Hay, Cornelius Hedg[...]d by his poli y in th
ment for additional capital of $50,000 with a pecific land ownership. Fore[...]es. later limit! s range border , h was the first of th big
amendment on June 12, 1883, saw the capital stock stockm n to purchas tracts of land that became key
inerea ed to $500,000. Th report of the treasur r at ba e for his operation. Whil many outfit , like the
the meeting showed that 100,000 of stock had been XIT, leas d or command r d the land n c s ary to
purchased and the liabilities were listed at $17,500. A graze their stock John T. laid the mon y on the
similar item listed, December 29, 1884, brought the
barrelhead for his vital to -hold of home ranches.
capital stock to one and one-half million dollars, and
the report of the chairman of the board three months The first one of record, as far a Stillwater County
later showed paid up capital of $479,00_0 and liabili- is concerned was on Whit Beav r Creek. In 1880,
ties of $220,000.[...]Montana as trail boss of a herd of Texas longhorns.
The records then show that another specific op-[...]This was the first herd of T xans to be turned loose
ration, probably as a[...]on his va t range, bearing the "79" brand. Two years
pany, was organized "to dea[...]later, Wheat became a foreman for the outfit, and
and other livestock and feeds." Thi brought the first
"foreign" capital into the "79" picture, when two St.
Louis bankers, J. R. L[...]Thi tran action was in 1886 and a report to the
·tockholders reads: "Whereas in the year 1883 the
company made large purcha es of cattle on time, and
in exces of it profits of which $............ remains un-
paid, and will fall due during the next three years.
0 0 0
Our beef, on the Chicago market brought the
highe t price of any Montana cattle, during the year.
The branding wa a fair one, and the indebtedness of
the company ha been largely decreased. '
The Montana Cattle Company was given a fur-[...]John T. A prominent landmark in the heart of "79 holdings.
They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (150) THEY GAZED ON THE BEARTOOTHS[...]l'S; Matt Chick.

staked a "squatter's" right on the east fork, near a very the Lake Basin, (the contract finally turning to Bert
desirable spring, and prov.iding the finest of shelter, Shorey) and eighty sections around the three north
winter and summer. Shortly after Montana became a side home bases. At the same time he leased all the
state he applied for final proof and secured his[...]empire, and estab-
in 1891. At this time he sold the property to Murphy. lished "drif[...]ranch headquarters was pur- the government grass, as well as his own. He had this[...]or free a good many years, until Uncle Sam
spread of his own a short distance west of what was cracked down on this type of operation by Montana
known as the Big Coulee ranch. Then in succession stockmen.
he added to his holdings the "River Ranch" on the In the later operations in the Big Dry country, he
Musselshell, near Barber, which has since been in the worked on a rental basis with the Northem Pacific and
hands of the Ecklund family for over fifty years. The the state on an area covering about five townships.
fourth home base was the "Painted Robe" eight miles He[...]nester" homesteads in this
upstream on a creek by the same name, and still part of the country. The "79" at one time or another
owned by the family of 0. C. Richards who purchased grazed over 800,000 acres.
the layout over _fifty years ago.[...]. didn't do too badly on his land trans-
But the major portion of his land came through actions. In 1908, he started a series of contracts to
purchases from the Northern Pacific, during the the Musselshell Valley Land Company, a Minneapolis
pe[...]concern, and revenue stamps on the deeds reveal a
leasing papers into contracts for purchase. This in- profit of seven hundred percent or more.
cluded practically all of the N.P. land from the Big
Coulee to Golden Creek, lying north of the Yellow- The finesse of surveying in the early days is in-
stone divide. More than 100 sections were involved, dicated in the deed which the "7'¥' (represented by
65,000 acres, most of which sold for one dollar per[...]d from a William Cherry
acre. This land consisted of twelve sections in the to what was known as "The Dug Out Ranch" on the
East White Beaver, nine sections in the west end of Big Dry:

They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (151)[...]GAZED ON THE BEARTOOTHS

.JIOL~[...]is numbered l, in a westerly direction one fourth of a
-=-[...]set, marked 3, thence easterly one half of a mile to a
-[...]thence westerly one fourth of a mile to th place of[...]the same land upon which I h v filed a D rt Claim,[...]in the United States land office at Mil s City, Mon-[...]tte'!' or F•brul.17 21, 1962, ngard1DJ ,a1.. to The JtoOtaa.a cattle[...]title to under or by r a on of s id D 1t L nd ntry,
filld that the tollowiJlg aal.11 were lllde to The Montana CatUe Coapan71[...]Area par acre entirely with the d cription h r in giv n. Sign d by
2000[...]29, 31 and
7-29-9$ W of 1,.3,9,13,lS,[...]SUPPLIES A D THE
17,19,21,23,[...]1,3) and
7-29-95 Jll of 19,21,23,2S,[...]The "79" meant a lot to the Annin-DeHart Mer-[...]cantile Co., from 1892 until 1895; and to the successor
2339 1-29-95 i l l of l,3,S,7,9,11,\/[...]00 Columbus Mere. Co., from '95 to the last purchas
23LO 7--29-9[...]6 1,00 made in 1915. When the "79" set up busin ss in the
A COPY OF Oi!E SHEET OF SALES l'O'.: THE!Ul PAC IF IC TO "7$" . E1\:1L 1..:s r s., ,LES[...]n T. Murphy
\!'_ ;:E 1892, L.~ST '.'.l'1UT 1Gsj . THE TOrnL FIGU fl ES AGG r. EGAT[O : 8O,297 AC :JE S[...]om his Helena store, until 1890, when he disposed of[...]dale, with the closing of the orthern Pacific coke
Know all men by these p[...]here, and established a store at Columbus.
Cherry of Jordan, County of Dawson and State of[...]a deal whereby he was to supply the "79" with their
of the sum of One Dollar to me in hand paid by[...]dry goods needs and other
Charles W. Pillinghart, of Helena, Montana, receipt[...]figure, computed by the crafty John T. Murphy. It
and conveyed, and by th[...]was not a bad deal, however, as it gave the A-D Co.
and convey until the said Charles W. Pillinghart, his[...]andise in carload
heirs, and assigns forever, all of the rights, title and[...]s relationship prevailed after
that certain tract of land, situated in the County of[...]the Annin-DeHart merged into the new Columbus
Dawson, State of Montana, described as follows to-[...]the Great Northern went up the Musselshell. Murphy
Beginning at a substanti[...]then used the stockyards at Lavina as an outlet, and
high and set two feet in the ground, about one hun-[...]the Slayton Mere. Co. of that place became a com-
tlred yards northerly from the junction of two small[...]their ever-growing cattle op-
Coulee, which form the head of the Big Dry Creek,[...]erations of the "79" in the Big Dry area.
a tributary of the Missouri River and about midway[...]With a peak load of over one hundred appetites
between the two said coulees, said post being about[...]hands, it required prodigious amounts of food. At one
tion from a large "Rocky Butte" whic[...]time the Mere. shipped in a straight car of evaporated
land rnark in the vicinity, thence from said post which[...]

They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (152)[...]THEY GAZED ON THE BEARTOOTHS 1[...]the dry stuff was stored, while the freezable commodi-[...]the "Seventy-nine Ranch," as the White Beaver spread[...]w.as ~own. From .there the supplies were eventually
d1stnbutd to the Big Coulee, Painted Robe, and River[...]Ranch, usually after the fall roundups were over and[...]the year before,. and the grasshopper scourge had[...]on the "79" in the stricken area. A small panic had[...]five trains had been shipped in the fall of 1903 that
John T. Murphy came into the Mere. store and laid a
$5,000 payment on the line, with the promise that the[...]balance would be paid as soon as he had shipped the
remainder of his beef. By the same token, the whole-
sale house who supplied the Mercantile, had declared[...]a moratorium, somewhat unwillingly, on the usual
Thi buildinir wa de troyed by fire in 18[...]payments.
other bu in buildings, but most of the stock bad been
moved to the new ston store (extreme right).
I:eft to right[...]Although the "79" was the biggest unit to oper-
cann d v getables, half of which was unloaded in the ate in this area, it was by no means the first. In the
spring of 1866, Nelson Story, who had made a "grub-
Columbus warehouse, and the balance sidetracked for[...]ke" during his short time in Montana, took a good
the "79" at Merrill. Other split cars of bacon, beans,
long look at the potentials of cattle to replace the
rice, sugar, coffee in hundred pound bags, corned[...]vanishing buffalo. Then he went to the Texas Pan-
smoked meats, flour and many other ite[...]and
livered on a car-to-wagon basis. Inasmuch as the
started the trail north to Montana. What with Indian
major purchases were made in the fall, the Mercantile
forays, trouble with the Kansas homesteaders and
clerk, who would ride the train to Merrill to check[...]tural losses, he didn't have quite that many,
out the cargo, might find a list to include: twenty 100-[...]when he finally took them over the Bozeman trail to
pound cases of bacon, twenty-five cases of ham, twen-
the Gallatin Valley. He had crossed the Yellowstone
ty cases of "sow-belly" (dried salt pork), ten hundred-[...]a few miles above the confluence of the Clarks Fork
pound bags of peaberry coffee, a ton of sugar in
River, and slowly grazed the fine grassland of the
woodstave barrels, a ton of navy beans, ten bags of
Yellowstone breaks and the Basin. And from that
rice, twenty-five 50-pound firkins of corned beef, one time on until 1882, the Texans that they bought, were
hundred cases of canned tomatoes, another hundred trailed through the Basin and down the Bridger trail
cases of canned peas, beans and corn, ten 50-pound into Bozeman. The portion of the valley near Park
tin drums of lard, two tons of flour, a ton of assorted City was an ideal spot for entry to the Lake Basin,
corn, rye flour and rolled oats or wheat,. and one hun- and a brother and relatives of "Old Man Nels" were
dred cases of evaporated milk, and similar proportions to become important in the development of this coun-
of less used foods. Salt was delivered by the carload; try, where members of the Story family tree still re-
rope in as many as twenty 500-foot coils of hard-twist,
side.
with a few spools of heavy "corral" rope; and maybe
a hundred pound bale of "strap" leather. When the Probably this "quality range" was one of the sev-
"79" started fencing their land, car lots of wire and eral reasons that John T.[...]domain in this region, starting with the White Beaver
Six-horse outfits were used to wheel the salt into and Big Coulee bases. Another reason was that the
the White Beaver storage base, while the other com- N .P. railroad would a[...]mpetition in this
was about an eight mile haul to the warehouse, where area, once[...]
They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (153) 148 THEY GAZED ON THE BEARTOOTHS

"79" RIDERS FROM CROSS S UNIT OF "79"[...](Identification not too sure)

cattle was the string of Oregon steers that he bought and 8,000 sheep. At the h adwaters of Keys r and
in 1879, with the ill-fated Billy Roberts as the boss of Hensley Creek, the Hensley brothers were running
the camp wagon. These were good cattle and thrifty 3,000 had of cattle, even infringing on the south slopes
for this climate, and reportedly weighed over 1450 of the Lake Basin. An average strip of grassland
pounds when marketed. His next venture was in 1881 twenty miles deep paralleling the river, had been lost
when all his purchases were Texas steers. to the "79" operation after less than five years of sweet
By 1882 he had decided on a cow and calf opera- use.
tion in addition to the steers and Charley Farley, the Things weren't much better in the wider spaces
White Beaver foreman helped bring in 6000 head of of the Lake Basin. In 1886, B. C. Shorey developed
well bred Durham cows and heifers from Kansas, the first big ranch in the west end and leased several
which saw him and Dave Fratt divide the drive for sections of railroad land (which the "79'' bought later
their respective locations on the Musselshell and range- on, then turned the contracts back to Shorey.) The
land south of that river to the Yellowstone. Many a Shorey operation turned from a herd of 2500 cows to
dogie wearing the brand of the "79" grazed the Lake a peak of 25,000 sheep and 40,000 acres of deeded
Basin and south to the Yellowstone River. land when he sold out in 1903. East of Shorey and
But the iron horse not only brought a shipping along the east rim of the Basin the Thomas Brothers,
point. It brought valley settler[...]Molt and Lehfeldts established firm footholds in the
of free grass for the "79" faded fast away. As early rich Lake Basin grasslands, ranging as far east as the
as 1879, Olof Lafverson had a homestead in the valley fabulous duck-grass hayland in the Comanche country.
and owned a bunch of cattle that utilized his share of Seeing the writing on the wall, "John T." started
the Yellowstone River breaks. At the loading point his land purchase program as early as 1892, buying
of Merrill, eth Porter and Matt Miller established the N.P. land between the Basin and the Musselshell,
a cattle and sheep spread. Downstream two miles in where the railroad had not yet brought possible en-
1 2, Ed[...]There was
very shortly purchased several sections of N .P. land still grass left in these invaded areas to provide feed
to start a cattle spread of fair proportions. The Miller- for the herds trailing to the Merrill stockyards, from
Cardwell combination required range for 500 cattle which point most of the shipping was done, but 1893

They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (154) THEY GAZED ON THE BEARTOOTHS 149

saw the end of this extensive shipping.
The range crowding was not the only reason for
cutting down his cattle numbers in the fall of 1893.
ationally, there was a severe panic existing, and op-
erating money was scarce. The livestock market was
glutt d with no buyers, and the future looked worse
than th present. Prudently and fortunately Mr.
Murphy hipped over 8,000 head of cattle that fall
from this station, and another s[...]cago. Custer cattle
w nt to Julius Ro nbaum, also of Chicago, who brave-
ly and u c sfully £inane d m[...]h those trying days.
Th nt that clo d the White Beaver ranch to
attl o urr d in 1903. Gra[...]mountains to central Mon- One of the last form en in Big Dry country. Early sheriff of[...]Garfield County.
tana. Pr ss r ports of that particular summer and fall
rad:[...]up from around Billings, Montana, as to the devasta-
"Bi Timb r, Montana, June 24, 1903[...]tion of the hilarious hopper. The harrowing news was
plagu of gras hoppers has fallen on eastern Montana[...]brought in by a stockman from the metropolis of Fish-[...]tail, recently in Chicago to unload a lot of range[...]due the fact that the invading insects had devoured
1 all the provender. According to the stories told by
the citizen of Fishtail, the plagues of Egypt were not
in it with the long-legged and voracious jumpers[...]Many of the "valley" stockmen culled their herds[...]to western pastures. Others got them through the
"79" crew with lady pests at Vaill Creek. 1908[...]The "7ff' rounded up their six hundred cows and
and the ranges are being destroyed with neatness and calves and moved to the Big Dry, but did manage to
dispatch. Stockmen are[...]say that unless hang onto a string of yearling steers which lived
heavy rains, which will destroy the hoppers, fall through the summer and wintered on Big Elk and
within a short time the grass will be entirely ruined. the Coulee. The original "79" ranch on White Beaver
The advance guard of the hoppers appeared two or never[...]John T. Murphy was probably the biggest opera-
in numbers enough to do any materi[...]a "qow and calf" program. It is true that he
that the mistake has been made, the ranchers are did ship in a good many southern cattle, as the sales
trying every known means to abolish the plague, slips of 1893 show, but he used these steers to sup-
which is becoming critical so rapidly, that the cattle plement the better grade cattle that he raised him-
industry of this section is seriously menaced."[...]ot only did he replenish his Durham breeding
The September 2, 1903, issue of the Tri-County stock in Kansas, but brought in some large strings of
News reads:[...]gon. In later years he scoured
"Extract from the American Farmer for Septem- Montana stock ranches for better cows. One of the
ber:-While the rest of the country escaped fairly finest bunches to graze the "79" domain was pur-
well from pests this year, a howl of proportion goes chased from the Flying D herd of Childs and Anceny.

They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (155) 150 THEY GAZED ON THE BEARTOOTHS[...]Cowboys and foremen of the early rangeland[...]were notorious in their boastful claims of how many[...]and command, which makes it hard to obtain the
actual numbers of livestock which the big outfits ran
in the early days. A s arch of the r cord of the vai-i-[...]IN BIG DRY ABOUT 1908. figures given the ass s or may not hav b en comp! t ,
(Courtesy of Jack McNaney)[...]Then th re w s th I way of numb rs whi h follow d
This was one of the early registered Shorthorn herds the typ of op ration. There w re g n rally but two
in Monta[...]compl te talli s mad -wh n th y w r purcha d and
of wonderful cows from the Townsend area about when they w re ship[...]. This bunch complete tally on th numb r of calv th y brand d,
carried the brands of fifty owners. This was a real or r ported to th wagon ho . Th r w r tray in•
job to identify the original owners with nothing more eluded in oth r roundup outfits that w re never of-
than a pocket knife to shave the hair sufficiently to ficially report d, nor counted when r turn d to th ir
read the brands." When the Hereford bulls finally own range by the "reps." Wint r loss s w r hard to
came into use, the resultant brockle-face and mixed ascertain, so there is some justification in the failure
colored cross-breds grew into weighty st[...]inventories.
year olds and commanded a bonus on the Chicago
markets, many of which weighed as slaughter beef. And the "79" was no exception. It is known that
Many local stockmen, especially those with small the first operation near Great Falls was of meager
herds, profited by the quality bulls that Murphy used. numbers, and the assessment figures for Meagher
It was his policy to trade these bulls, at shipping County in the year of 1880 showed 3100 cattle and
time, to any reliable rancher who wanted one or two 23 horses. By the next year the company was pretty
and would take a steer in retu[...]ll organized and purchased some "four trail herds of
either way. The writer recalls that in 1894, my grand- Texas yearlings." In 1882, the first of the cow-calf
father obtained two of these sires, which saw use at operations began, with 3000 head of Kansas Dur-
"Glen Willow" for four years. hams added to the normal import of Texans. In 1883,
The last few years of "79" existence saw more the company increased its capital stock to $500,000,
and more whitefaces in the corrals at shipping time. much of the money used in the purchase of cattle.
In all probability the biggest increase in the cattle
In speaking of the cattle business the Yellow-
numbers came about 188.5 after the company again
stone Handbook reads:[...]anded its capital stock to one and one half
"The customary way of managing a herd of cattle million dollars. In a report to the stockholders that
in Montana is simply to brand t[...]ear, Secretary Russell Harrison reported "a total of
out upon the prairie. In the spring the owners have 32,000 head, more or less, not including calves." A
a round-up, brand the calves, mark the ones they later report in 1890 showed "the biggest livestock in-
intend to sell, and turn th[...]" It might be safe to assume
herd a thousand head of cattle, except for the round- then, that a 40,000 figure would be fa[...]Texas cows and bulls are brought in at a the maximum number of cattle owned by the "7f1' at
cost of $10 to $12.50 per head. Good American breeds[...]and yearlings may be bought for As the rangeland dwindled~ naturally the herds
from $5 to $7 per head. The actual cost of raising of the "79" became smaller. Then sheep replaced
a steer, not counting interest on capital invested is some of the cattle operations. Most of the many cow•
from 60 cents to a dollar per year, so that a four year boys, some of whom are still living, estimated that
old steer, raised from a calf will cost about $4.00. He from 1903 to the abandonment of the Montana Cattle
is then worth $20 at the ranch, or $2.5 if delivered to Company in 1910,[...]bably less than
market in Wyoming or Fort Benton. The average 10,000 head on the range, mostly in the Big Dry
estimated profit on cattle is at least 30% per annum, country, for summer and back to the Big Coulee to
some growers claiming as hig[...]
They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (156)[...]THEY GAZED ON THE BEARTOOTHS[...]The largest horse numbers showed in the Sweet
Grass records of 1895, listing 2240 head.

Taken out of the LIVE STOCK RE.P ORT
of October 6, 1893[...]The present season, which is nearing an end so far[...]ways an unfortunate one for the shippers from Mon-[...]tana and kindred points. After half a dozen years of
prosperity following upon the disastrous winter of
1886-87, the rangemen of the above regions had grown[...]careless of the natural conditions which surround the[...]hedge a king, there is no :Such safety for the cattle
JOHN CLAY-Cowboy, commission man author of "My Life kings whose stock wanders free over the prairies of
On The Range", wrote warning to cow barons-1893. the Northwest. There the winds will blow, the sun[...]will come along so often as the cycles revolve. When
Below is a recap of all the figures that the writer green grass began to peep through the bare brown
could ass em hie from assessment figures. These have plains in the spring of 1887, there were but few cattle
been combined with projected figures arrived at by to eat it. The laws of supply and demand had once
taking the tax valuation and prices of cattle at the time more asserted their sway. The vast herds of cattle
of assessment, applied to Yellowstone county; and per grazing in an overstocked country had to meet the
capita stock inspector fees paid as well as the stock scarcity of feed by almost total destruction. We re-
indemnit[...]One thing does show up, however, and that is the 70,000 cattle had been thrown into a neighborhood
drop in numbers due to the terrific winter of 1886-87. which was already full of cattle. The disaster follow-
The combined assessments of horses in the three coun- ing was terrific, as scarce as two per cent, of the above
ties comprising the "79" rangeland was 1100 in 1886, number ever reached market. The boldest operators
reduced to 624 in 1887, a percentage loss of 43 per- were scared out, and for several years the country
cent. Cattle figures for 1886 were 21,850 and winter was comparatively free of cattle. The high prices ob-
reduced this to 9700 the next year, a loss of 56 percent. tained for all classes of range cattle in 1888, but more[...]especially from Montana, directed the attention of
ASSESSMENT FIGURES AND/OR COMPUTED[...]quence, there has been a great influx of Southern
cattle to these Northern regions. The seasons of 1889,
M eagher Count y H[...]....................... 150 6568 upon the shipments that came to market. Prices on the
1886 ............................ 450 6500 average were fairly satisfactory, but the great profit
1887 ··········[...]····· 305 1500 came, first, from the fact that thethe quality of the cattle
1891 ..........................[...]in flesh was simply perfect. Who will ever forget the

They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (157)152 THEY GAZED ON THE BEARTOOTHS

OLD[...]This was "79" domain at one time.

droves of magnificent cattle that came to hand during[...]to drive orth. They reaped their reward,
we have the reverse side of the picture. With few for their money was safer in the bank than invested
exceptions, the receipts have been of medium quality, in cattle whose bones were bleaching in the summer
and many of the Southern cattle which have been suns of 1887. We cannot always expect to have oceans
double wintered in the orth are selling for little over of grass as we had in the y ars following the above.
what the same brand of cattle are bringing which There will be dry seasons, and the ranchman hould
remained in the South. Over and above the winter never have his range stocked so as to eat up the feed
loss was heavy in many parts of the country. Putting in the driest year. During the past two years the
together a decline in weights, poorer prices and[...]caution and enterprise teach us as a
ter losses, the year that is fast slipping away has not stopping point has been reached and passed. The
been a very successful one for the Northern ranch- result will be another disaster if we continue on in the
men. reckless way we have been doing. The past will repeat
The question that naturally rises to everyone's lips itself, as it has done in every country and clime. The
is, what is the cause? There are no end of answers, more speculative operators will continue to stock up
but our reply is want of feed. We may blame a severe the ranges, while the conservative ones will call a
winter to help along the difficulty, but the primary halt. To the businessman who looks at the question
cause i want of grass, and this comes about from too from the side of dollars and cents, the past year will
many mouths to feed. There were a few men who probably be of benefit. It will teach him the lesson

They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (158)[...]THEY GAZED 0 THE BEARTOOTHS[...]53

that th be t hor e can be ridden to death ·n the
fi Id of cattl bu in just as on the race course. WINTER OF '86-'87
e bu ess a man i not his own master. This was the winter that did a pretty good job
H ontr v r his range. There is a ort of sorting the men from the boys!
of ·y among th old ranchers, but new-[...]o ittl att ntion to these court sies. The th few cloudy days brought normal[...]upon it. Speculators scanned the April skies and the grassland
nc th re gro s up a fe g of j alousy and ithin a few weeks the Montana cattle numbers
hors, and of[...]· mingl going to get an ad- the West Coast and the Kansas cow country. There[...]gs run away with b tt r judg- of the range normally, but this overload was disas-
s om wh n the cattlemen of trous.[...]g th ir Jun came no rain! One of the worst droughts in
ran , tak n from th pa t y ar as a guide the hi tory of the N orthw st was in the making.
f r futur .-John C. Clay, 1[...]atur d early and short and was overgrazed

The winter of 1886-87 was not the only bad one. In 1906, a hard winter caused losse[...]some hay
to be fed. This picture was taken in the Big Dry range. The bull, upper left, is under the pile of snow-six days later. This was the
second biggest loss of live tock ever to hit "79" operations.

They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (159)154 THEY GAZED ON THE BEARTOOTHS

long before winter came. Many stockmen had to go again. Cattle broke through the right-of-way fences
to market, but the cattle were thin, which coupled and crossed to the river banks, presently an ever
with the inferior quality of a lot of the imports, constant danger to the engineers who might damage
glutted the Chicago market, and prices dropped to h[...]engers were
new low , in some cases barely paying the original horrified to see cattle standing on their four legs,
cost plus the freight. frozen stiff. The bottoms along the river banks were
On Thanksgiving Day, 1886, it started to snow, covered with dead cattle; the sheltering breaks of
and howl Within four days it was averaging eighte[...]drifted to giant piles in places. A deep.
few of the ridges were bared by the wind, but were The damage was not over when spring finally
not too accessable, and just the crowns of the plants came, and the "79" had a below-average loss. The thin
left to chew on, if an animal happened to get there. cows lost their calves, and we lost many of the heifers
It remained rather cold, and some bitter winds for calving for the first time. Joe Murphy estimated their
barely two months. Mid-January saw one of those loss, percentage-wise at nearly[...]Murphy was not a man to be discouraged. In 1890,
the West, and old-timers who had seen two-foot snow- when the "79" bought my homestead, the company
banks melt away in 48 hours under the influence of was running about 40,000 head."
this war[...]ecame hopeful again. Their Stockmen of those days, and statisticians differ
dreams were shortlived when 20 degree below zero on the over-all percentage loss of cattle during that
air whistled in from Canada and the soft, wet snow winter. Some say 50 perce[...]s
froze to a crystal ice cover through which even the never fully known. But many big outfits w[...]hat bought fame to artist
Let Charley Farley tell the story of the part it played Charles M. Russell who painted a post card picture of
in the "79" operations, especially at the White Beaver "Waiting for the Chinook" or "The Last of The 5,000"
ranch where he was foreman:[...]in answer to a note from his boss as to how the cows
were making it. This was one of his most popular
"The fall had been nice, but still dry, and the[...]about gone. Luckily, Mr. Murphy had been
holding the home ranch for winter feed for a string
of young cows and heifers, which were in pretty fair
shape. They even held up pretty well, although the
AT SHIPPING TIME
snow was fairly deep, and the weather cold. Every- Although the shipping season brought some sad-
body was praying for a chinook, and in January one ness to the cowboys, many of whom would be fur-
came along. But of too short duration. Below zero loughed, after the last steer was loaded until the
weather transformed the soft snowball surface into a spring work started, it was nevertheless an exciting
glare of ice an inch thick, and then added two or climax to a hard working season. Slowly trailing the
three inches of soft snow that made the glaze so herd to the shipping point, so that there would be no
slipper[...]tion was more or less tedious,
We rounded up the horses as best we could. On but except fo[...]s, was also much easier herding.
hides to protect the legs as much as possible, from the Merrill was the principal shipping point, and the
sharp edges of the broken ice crusts. Thus protected new stockyards there were christened when the re-
we forced the other horses ahead of us to break up mains of the original Oregon herd were put aboard
paths through the snow and make it possible for a the cars. This little station continued to be constantly
cow to get her muzzle through to the stray spear of in use for the "79" until about 1890, when diversions
grass that still existed here and there. We even used were made of a trail from the ast side of the range,
light broadaxes to cut paths to the brush on the creek, with some shipping from Custer.
or to bare spots on the ridges, but at best we could Loading the cattle, and helping cut to carload lots
only get grass for a paltry handful of cattle. Our was the hardest work the cowboy ever did. A hand
scant crop of hay was kept for the saddle stock, and and his horse that could perform magic on the open
that was soon gone. range, quickly developed a sort of panic in the small
Along the river the stockmen were cutting limbs pens and loading chute. The cattle were not too co-
of cottonwood trees, so the cattle could gnaw the operative, either. They didn't know anything about
bark, or cutting paths through the frozen clumps of the noisy, snorting engine, and gave the plank corrals
willows so that they could be devoured. It was hope- a real test of strength , as they mad a last gallant
less! You would meet a cow in one of these paths- break for the freedom of the hills, little caring whether
she would lun[...]

They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (160)[...]TH EY GAZED ON THE BEARTOOTH S[...]::, c=:i

T he small 30½-foot stock cars of those days would lurch ahead and the water would spla h over
would hold 16 or 17 of the longhorned steers, which the end and sid s, so that littl was 1 ft for th dogi[...]that wer late. a re ult the stock was pr tty badly
on how good the range had been during th ir u ual d hydrated by the tim it was unloaded at t. Paul.
four years. Later the car was lengthened to 36 feet , The matter of hay was som what better. five-
and final shipments could be made in 40 foot r . The inch guard rail xtended on both id s of th catwalk
early day shipments were non-stop, except for engin atop the cars; which would keep the baled hay from
and crew changes, to St. Paul, whe[...]lipping from th wood d well. Op nings in the roof
transfer could be made if Chicago was the final desti- from either end, and slic of the baled hay could b
nation. Inside these small cars[...]push d along a rack to th c nter of the car. Th re
troughts, about ten inches de p, parti[...]was one hazard. park from the ngine were not so
and just enough room at the top of th trough for a[...]rink. These vats were the bales would be ignited from burning cinders from
filled from the station wat r tank, and consi ted of a the rnokestack. Mor than once the framework of
spout that was divided to reach both sides of the car these front car[...]nt and cargo. This "cannon-ball" tock train
while the trough was filling, but once full the train was a[...]

They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (161)[...]EY GAZED ON THE BEARTOOTHS[...]mented by legislation promoted by · the humane so-[...]would be established along the route, where the cattle[...]the cars at any one stretch.[...]When the Great Northern was built, Lavina be-[...]came the important shipping point. Later on the 1909[...]entry of the Milwaukee opened up new stockyards[...]where the Big Dry cattle could be loaded with a[...]Drovers Accompanying Train of
CATTLE LOADING, MERRILL, 1893
8,000 head of "79" brand.[...]When October came to the Beartooths, it brought
special guard was hired to[...]a happy part of the years livestock operations-the
hazard.[...]shipment of the cattle or sheep to the eastern markets,
This type of shipping didn't last too long, how-[...]unks, and a small
cent shrinkage was not unusual. The cattlemen pro-[...]cooking could be done. Two cars
tested this loss. The railroad chiefs and their train of stock provided one free round trip for each man,[...]ents would aggregate some fifty
were made between the parties concerned, imple- cars, so a crew of fifteen or more "riders" would make[...]CA TILE MEN IN CHICAGO, 1907
; COPY OF A FEW'" OF THE SHI P~[NT SALES ~AO[ BY "79" TO J OHN.CLAY[...]
They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (162)[...]THEY GAZED ON THE BEARTOOTHS[...]turned over a band of 1000 head of ewes to be
f[...]settlement at the end of four years. During this[...]$6500 for wool and $8000 for the increase. He also[...]got back his 1000 head of the top ewes, which netted
him a profit of 121 percent per year. The partner,[...]had received more than $15,000 for his four years of
~
~q
- ""i.
.....~ .[...], · .; , labor, less expenses in running the band, so he was
~~4~ ~[...]Whether John T. Murphy ever heard of the above[...]ation is not known. He did have a few , not under
the trip. Sometimes a man, wanting to get back east, the "79" banner, in the early 80's in Chouteau and
would "rep" for the owner. In the Windy City of Teton counties, but it was not until 1895 that he re-
stockyards, the shippers often got together for other corded a sheep brand, a figure 7 on the left side just
activities, such as a picture, a big feed at The Stock- under the backbone, in the name of The Mm1tana
yards Inn, or maybe a night on the town. Cattle Co. Mur[...]of which probably one half were "79" stock
SHEEP[...]tician could possibly estimate
The "79" Was in the Sheep the numbers, by a story that was circulated about Bil[...]Murphy, during his managership. The yarn goes that[...]Mr. 1urphy was at some kind of a sheepman's
An article covered in the booklet "Hand-book gathering, and a newcomer in the sheep business was
of The Yellowstone Valley" concerning sheep, pub- doing a lot of talking for the money he was spending.
lished in 1880, reads:[...]Bill finally asked how many sheep he had, and the
"The management of sheep is a different matter young man answer d "80 purebred Rambouillets." To
than that of cattle. A band of sheep containing 1000 which the 79-er said: "I hav more hors moving my
head and u[...]to- who used to run thou and of she p along the Mu 1-
gether at night to prevent raids by marauding coyotes, shell west of the 79 spread. t an early Int rnational
wolves, etc.[...]Show in hicago th n w sh pman boast d of a
per pound, the average daily profit figures about[...], rather scornfully: "I
35 percent. Let's report the case of Judge Davenport. have more than t[...]The sheep operation as originally handled by th[...]"79" was more or less confin d to th w t nd of
the range, going to the foothills of th razi in th[...]more or 1 s the }Part of th wooly busin s . Lat r
they us d the rang leased by th .P. or O\ n d by[...]the go ernment for a f w bands north of u t r[...]and buckboard fixed up to handle the "bum" lambs.[...]he had a milk cow tied to trail behind the wagon,[...]crowded she would drive back to the ranch, unload
"Maggie" Bu teed used to[...]milk cow to keep these fed until she got them to the and get the young sheep on their new way of life.
hom e ranch. Thi wa a source of revenue for many early
homesteaders,[...]Then repeat the trick until she had about fifty young-
They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (163)158 THEY GAZED ON THE BEARTOOTHS[...]and were sheared that spring to wind up the sheep
business in that corner of the "79" domain.
Them days and the fine old fellows are gone[...]reluctance. The "79" was pulling out of the Big Cou-[...]lee operation in 1910, and Bill was assigned the chore
of transferring some 8,000 head of lambs, which had
been wintered in the Norton-Lyons area of Lebo
Creek, to the newer sheep range on the Big Dry and
Phillips Creek. The sheep were split into three bands,[...]and Sutter skillfully directed their trailing on the south
side of the Musselshell, through the private lands, and
state property of quite a few of the "nesters" along
the river. Two bands got through to Hailstone Basin[...]in okay shape, despite a few run-ins with the valley[...]over the matter. "I guess we had almost made an
enemy of every rancher along the route," said Bill.
"But when I got in sight of the Coulee ranch property
SHEEP HEADQUARTERS[...]I turned the sheep over to Pat O'Kane and his men,[...]look after until they were able to graze. This The sight of a string of grazing steers sure looked
deal used to drive Tom[...]good to Mr. Sutter after this apprenticeship with the
an ex-79 cowman at heart. But once in a while he bleating woolies.
could sneak up on Maggie's cache of her pin money[...]n't completely through, however.' ear
and procure the wherewithal to buy solace for his
the Big Dry range the herder of one of the bands got
grief and disgust.
drunk and the sheep scattered in every dirction. Again
It was about 1910 when the Big Coulee books Bill was given the mission of a trouble shooter to get
were pretty well closed to sheep and the bands moved the situation back to normal. This took a harrowing
to the "home ranch" on White Beaver. Here the count week, before order was restored and B[...]head complete his work as line rider on the four townships
remaining when ick Dickinson loaded them for a at the head of McGinnis Creek that comprised the
trip to Idaho in 1915. This spelled finis to the "79". legitimate holdings of the "79" in the Big Dry country.
Pat O'Kane, who was more or less the sheep boss Bill Sutter recalls one minor incident in the fol-
for several months wrote the author in 1962 about his lowing manner:
recollections of the sheep game when he was at the "Cap" Ripley was in charge of the "White Beaver
Painted Robe. It follows:[...]to sheep and Some days later a cowboy from the adjoining Card-
when to get out, but he misjudged once in a while. In well range came into the ranch and reported that
1907, he hit the jackpot during my time with them. movement of a lot of sheep from his boss' range was
We trailed these $[...]mperative and "damn quick!" Ripley rode back with
the Basin, nearly 4700 head in the bunch, got three him, and found a small band of over three hundred
heavy shearings from them, then loaded them at that had estrayed from the careless herder. The herd-
Custer and sold them for more than the original cost. er "drift d" a longs ways farther than the ewes had,
Bill McGee was the winter herder, on Rock Creek and after his carelessnes was discovered."
the north rim of the Big Coulee, and had only a helper Speaking of "Cap" Ripley, who was ranch boss
during the summer trailing. Just two men doing the at the old "79" on White Beaver, John Green, an old
job! In 1910, we didn't do so good. It was the smokey pioneer told us: "I once watched, terror-stricken, the
year and we were short of grass and shorter of water. near death of "Cap" Ripley. He had come down to
We shipped thre[...]o and we didn't Merrill to get mail for the ranch crew, and failed to
much more than pay the freight. Held back four notice a train coming, as he approached the crossing
bands and they were trailed to Big Elk , with ick over the track to the postoffice. My brother, Charles
Dickerson handling the ewe bands. Again th y were and Bill ichol[...]spotted
brought back to winter on Big Coulee and "The Robe," on the siding, with sawdust from the Berry Creek
They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (164)[...]THEY GAZED ON THE BEARTOOTHS[...]erful, long-winded bronc that could stand the wear
of cow punching. And playing a part in this line of
breeding were introduced the maternal blood of the
Indian ponies of the plains and •the closely related
Mustangs of the southland mesas. Add to this the
appearance once in a while of a pony that traced back
to the days of Spanish domineering and eventually[...]for the job. Most of the stallions used were of high
quality of their particular strain. Heavier beasts of
burden came from the Percherons and Clydesdales
that were the foundation stock for the draft animals
that were used, not only for the camp wagons, but[...]When the central states started looking to the
West for mules, the "79'' went into production. The
Murphy men imported a carload of the heaviest, rang-[...]up with the demand for the weaned offspring.
Probably the biggest shipment of horses and[...]mules from Montana' occurred from the Merrill stock-[...]yards in 1897. A contract called for the delivery of
nearly 3000 head in Omaha. This deleted the herds
to such an extent that the next year, when the war
with Spain broke out, •the "7fi' could furnish only 150
"79" LOADS OUT IN 1915-LAST OF WHAT USED[...]tained enough breeding stock so that the "79" had
Left to right : John Feeney, a herder, ick Dickinson. more than an ample supply of cow ponies and camp[...]"The Handbook of The Yellowstone" briefly men-
mill. The engine struck the horses squarely in the tions the h.ors d partment of livestock in the arly
shoulders and they were mangled to bits. The im- '80's. There w r numerous herds b eing e tabli h d
pact stripped all four tugs and the neckyoke in such along the river, but not with a vi w to for ign mar-
a fashion that "Cap" was hurled backwards from the kets. This tock wa of a heavi r type, for u on
vehicle, which in turn was tossed parallel to the track. the futur vall y farm and not th tpye wanted by
o damage to the wagon, nor the driver except his cowhands.
horrif[...]cle!"

HORSES
Horses Were Part of
"79" Operation
At one time horses made up a sizeable part of
the livestock inventory of the "79". The severe winter
of 1886-87 proved that equines could survive a des-[...]9" 1895 assessment figures listed o er 4,000 head
of breeding stock and commercial horses that didn't
include colts. This activity centered on the Big Coule
layout that eventually was referr d to as the "Mule
Ranch."
Cowboys were pretty fussy about the horse that
comprised their "string" and John T. M[...]YP TALLIO
particular to see that th y had the b st, and h bought[...]the French language and it took him ix month to under-
gan horses, the general favorite of the cowboy, which[...]

They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (165)160 THEY GAZED ON THE BEARTOOTHS

" 79" COWBOYS "DO LED UP" TO HA VE TREIB PICTIJRE
THE HAY E T DIO C R O THE ORTHER PA
This is 1895. Upp[...]

They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (166)[...]THEY GAZED ON THE BEARTOOTHS[...]OVERNIGHT STAND AT A LINE CAMP OF "79" HEADED TOWARD THE BIG DRY
L eft to right : Pete Ely, John Woods, "N[...]CHARLEY FARLEY
Early foreman of "79", joined outfit about 1882. Quit 1890. Co boys of the 1909 vintage, "put on the dog" at Billings[...]
They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (167)162 THEY GAZED ON THE BEARTOOTHS[...]
They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (168) THEY GAZED O N THE BEARTOOTHS[...]IN TIIE MOU TAI CA YO A D PLATEA S THA THAT OF THE ROLLING
PRAIRIES OF THE LAKE BASI AND BIG DRY COU TRY-" 79" RANGE
They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (169)164 THEY GAZED ON THE BEARTOOTHS[...]
They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (170) THEY GAZED ON THE BEARTOOTHS 165

SIMUEL BUFORD
ROBERTS
One of ,the most interesting and exciting, as well
as the most publicized of all the riders for the "79"
was Simuel Buford Roberts, known only as "Si[...]oberts' career lead him into many encounters with
the law. He was twice tried for murder. He was
hailed[...]three times for cattle rustling. He
was suspected of a third murder and is alleged to
have killed two[...]he was never convicted! He was once
found guilty of petty larceny, for which he was jailed.
Several c[...]nancial matters.
If ever there was an enigma of a man, "Sim"
would qualify.
Loved, hated, re[...]0 0 0

Mr. Roberts was born in the Texas Panhandle,
near Whiteface, October 16, 1859[...]p without much edu-
cation in school, but world's of experience in the long-
horn business. Before reaching maturity, Si[...]nd gun and h d it to Elia
late in the fall of 1 78, mo ed into Montana, finally y,[...]n y I ft
Montana Cattle Company, or the "79" as it a to loon. Th Rob r[...]and had
be nationally known. Joe Murphy, broth r of the r, r turnin to th ba putting on
"79" organizer wa dir cting the driv for thi first the no bag, and Bill apol uty
import of cattle that had b n purcha ed in r gon.[...]g lazily astward through fourt n month of b in of ag bt a ma
the Gallatin Valley, r aching b dding ground n ar[...]r my If a m anno
Bozeman wh n the baby organization got its fir t again off ring to buy a round of drink .
blood bath.[...]in t ·nting out
Boz man. On the night of Octob r 31, 1 99, th h w in th[...]d fired th bu t hitti c
bri f flurry of words caus d Rob rt to ay " r you[...]

They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (171)[...]THEY GAZED ON THE BEARTOOTHS[...]who had announced his intention of killing Roberts,[...]figured he had the drop on Sim, and reached for his[...]the Roberts revolver. With his hands in the air he[...]said, "Its getting to be a hell of a country when a[...]man can't reach in his pocket for a chew of tobacco[...]bloody affair came to a conclusion as far as the law
was concerned, with the following verdict:[...]"Territory of Montana, vs. Sim B. Roberts. This[...]day the grand jury appeared at the bar of the court
and presented their Bill of Indictment against Sim[...]Roberts for murder in the first degree." "Endorsed[...]TheJ1eupon it is ordered by the court that said de-[...]A reporter for the Avant Courier included the[...]WILLIAM ROBERTS
Foreman for the first bunch of "79" cattle was kiUed in saloon[...]his brother, and is well thought of. He is not in the
fight at Bozeman, October 31, 1879. He was still a minor at habit of drinking or quarreling. He has the sympathy
that time.[...]of nearly all the leading businessmen of Bozeman."
out near the left ear. The fire had extinguished the After Bill Roberts was[...]oil lights, but several other shots were fired in the man for the ''79". He proved an exceptionally fine
dark, all[...]overseer, getting along well with the cowhands, and
his gat. giving the cattle fine supervision and handling. But
Sandborn then tried to arrest the living Roberts his own private[...]be convicted, but Sim tract of land which he "squatted" on East White Bea-
state[...]urphy became suspicious
not be arrested." He held the drop on the deputy, and replaced him with John Collins, who had been
and ran to the Fridley barn where his horse was in a with the outfit from the start. The story then goes
stall for the night, took the mount to the door and that Collins tried[...]Sandborn that he hidden in the hides of a small herd of steers that were
would not surrender. Sandborn fi[...], who purposely ranged near the Roberts homestead. Every-
slipped down the other side of the horse, while San- one though[...]s peculiar that John T. forphy
born ducked behind the barn, thinking that Roberts[...]it, and
may not have been hit, and was just doing the falling an admonition to "don[...]hat Sandborn had money!"
hit the horse, and after riding a short distance, Rob- After being fired by the "79", Mr. Roberts was
erts returned to town and spent the night in a hideout. sent to Oregon for cattle for Conrad Kohrs, which
The day following this shooting Joseph Murphy were delivered to the head of the Beaverhead River,
contacted Sim Roberts and advis[...]ound his outfit about two years. His
self over to the law. His offer suggested a policy[...]gs & Ellis where he handled their
that was a part of the company's operation all through cattle on the Boulder River. It was about this time
the years. "If you are guilty, we will see that you are that the mining activities opened up in the Boulder-
hanged; if innocent, we will put every resource of Stillwater area, and he immediately got busy in the
the "79" to protect you!" Roberts was released on new field. He staked many mines, of more or less
bond posted by John W. relson and el[...]value, but a glib tongue, and use of some "salt" in
await trial. the shafts, kept him in a fair financial condition. In
They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (172) THEY GAZ E D O N THE B EA R T OO THS[...]IN COURT.

fact it was said of "Slick Sim" that he could dig up mighty specimen of a man, ugu t edarstrom, who
a poke of a thousand bucks any time he really had to. was the camp's prid and joy in boxing, wrestling and
Some of his cash wasn't produced by alleged rustling,[...]or events w re staged for athl tic
and mining, as the following story will prove. diversion, and the min r were always willing to dig
The new mining camp of ye City was a busy down in the cache for money to bet on th ir champion.
place in 1887, and among other things its citizens be- H aring of this situation, Sim Robert appear d in
came addic[...]. In their midst was a camp one day and got the word spr ad that his hired

They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (173)[...]THEY GAZED ON THE BEARTOOTHS

While working in the Gallatin Valley, Mr. Rob-[...]July 12, 1863, whose folks came in during the Bannack[...]of the most beautiful girls in the Bozeman area, as[...]followed that she should fall in love with the well-[...]wick was teaching the first term of school in "The[...]irrigated place on the Yellowstone, just east of Reed
Point, and "The Primrose Ranch" was to be a happy[...]The Charles Brumfield
She is astride her favored m[...]"This story is intended to be a short brief of a
trio of men who grew up together, and were friends in
ma[...]reed to crime, even in their youth. The story is from memory,
post $500 that this boy could take the Swede. Before have ridden the range with two of the main subjects
the race, Roberts had cautioned his runner to have and listened to them tell of their exploits, both in
his horse picketed nearby, as some of these miners Texas and elsewhere.[...]nd this writer
might be ill-tempered if they lo t the bet. He also became very well acquainted, and they talked freely
arranged to have the boy go back to Big Timber via of the things they had done, rather in a bragging way,
the Lodgepole-Boulder trail, while Sim would swing or maybe subtle way, to impress me of their super-
on down the Stillwater and cross on the old Bridger man feats. I said to S[...]ne day, "You must
trail, thus avoiding any chance of group vengence. have been pretty fa t on the draw to ·have escaped
The "slicker" won the race handily, and kept on going ever[...]ster!"
away amid some revolver shots fired by one of the
silk stocking gals of the rooming house, who had been horse . . . a common old plug, in reality
suspicious of a "wringer" from the start. Sim grabbed nothing more than a pack horse, proved to be the
the money from the stakeholder and likewise made a tragic climax of a life-long friendship. Sim Roberts,
fast get-away from the miners who were to later learn ate Young and Bill Young w re all born and raised
that the winner was one of the fastest sprinters West in Texas, but because of their ability to rope and tie
of the Mississippi. Where Sim had recruited him[...]ears in Texas were
nobody knew. Arriving in town, the visitor waited cut short, when the Texas Rangers got too close for
around for two or[...]soon decided that they had
got word from a friend of Sim's that his manager had business far to the north.
left on a new mining venture (which he had[...]gh to Montana, he
would be gone for two weeks. So the runner left joined Sim and soon were the same warm friends, fol-
town, which was just as w[...]lowing their questionable career of yore. Sim was the
dress for his share of the money, which was just as le[...]

They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (174) TH E Y GAZE D O N THE BEARTOOTHS[...]Th r sults of th shooting ar b t d crib d in[...]a report appearing in the Big Timb r Expr s , ugu t[...]night were startled by the sound of two shots whi h[...]proved that the cause was mor s rious than u ual[...]for assault alleged to have been committed wh n the[...]with murder and entered a plea of not guilty, and the[...]F ollowing the p reliminary examination, Robert[...]ar before a jury at th
CHARLES H. BRUMFIELD OF LODI, CALIFORNIA fall term of court, starting Monday, ov mber 13,
H e wrote the story about Sim Roberts about 19 02, for publica- 1899. This trial was not only the first in olving a
tion in a western m agazine.[...]was to go down as one of th mo t i ting and[...]controversial in the county's history.
words, what was ate's w as also[...]·
was Roberts' was Roberts' too. T hat's the way it was the night of. ugust 23, 1
until Bill was released from the Idaho pen. Bill saw Burk w r walk[...]p on his brother, and seeing how of th Blak 1 Hot I wh ob rt
the Roberts ruled ate, body and boot , he became[...]and
green with jealousy to the point of contemplating shook hand , off[...]ay t
Roberts had the habit of taking a f w "strays' to night."[...]bit " w
the Crow Reservation and trading them to the Indian n ,[...]rvation ·a1
and trades the nag off for on h could call hi own.[...]ends , but his worst en mie . H k pt on goad-
ing the younger half-broth r until ate got so in-[...]· on
rest for horse stealing. Th n the f ud was on in p
earnest.[...]i
Th Rob rts ranch and that of th oungs join d .
Threats of violenc gr w op nly, and ach ranch b -[...]
They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (175)[...]THEY GAZED ON THE BEARTOOTHS

arose \ hen one of Roberts' hired men put up a tent livestock laws. He was serving in this capacity, when
on the allotment taken up by Young, and the latter he died suddenly in a hotel at B[...]Harry Dmm, a one-time registrar for the Billings
and to pick up some papers to be served[...]he had
and had been most friendly with him until the horse
two encounters with the Bannack Indians. 'On the
stealing deal. He knew he was a fast shot and ha[...]way out to Oregon, Indians sneaked up on the night
to draw quickly, or be killed.[...]corral and run off seven head of horses. Coming east
Character witnesses called by the defense left the with 3000 cattle, they rode into our horse ca[...]gerous when run into a freight , out of which these Indians had
drinking, and moody and[...]heir clothing, whiskey, supplies and horses!
One of the men on the stand stated that Young had Roberts was with the group that finally caught up
made threats to "even the Roberts' score." The fact with the Indians. His own gun killed two and wound-
that since the killing the half-brother, known locally ed one, and they finally recovered their own and the
as "Pistol Bill," had also threatened Roberts li[...]rrested and put under a peace bond, did not
hurt the Robert cause in court. The jury had been Drum said: "My recollection of Sim Roberts is
picked from a econd panel after the first list of 150 that he was a man of pleasing personality and an ex-
men had failed to provide the necessary number. One tra well-qualified cowman. Although along in years
of the jurors later told friends that every member of at that time, I very much enjoyed the days when we
the jury figured that ate had not had a chance to[...]said, "Say what
act in self defense. In any event the necessary unani- you want to about old Sim[...]arge was not forth- sure swell to all the Reed Point kids, giving us rides
coming and the verdict came in "not guilty" for the when it was cold; always willing to lend a hand when
second time in the career of this gunman." his neighbors suddenly needed help; generous and
nd then the Sim-Pistol Bill feud started in earn- jovial[...]armed fully at all times. Friends him."
of either were afraid to be seen with the principals in Ed Runner tells of a hunting trip: "Sim Roberts,
this case, for fear of being involved in a sudden-death who was a[...]ly to pro- time we were duck hunting in the basin with Sim
tect and honor. Mrs. Roberts could[...]ed
live in such a strain, and threatened to leave the area to job on of our gang. Sim went out with the victim
with her sons. Still defiant, still a figh[...]lly, but conscientiously leaving, switched the ten gauge shells, which were
capitulated.[...]needed, for twelve gauges. v hen the hunter couldn't
He mov d his family to Jord[...]an
life mellowed to a much slower tempo, despite the unopened box of lO's. Back at the blind, he opened
fact that he had the law on his trail again. He couldn't the box and found that someon had open d it first
forget the Yellowstone, and its venturesome days so and refilled it with the 12-gauge. Sim, who also was
he once again bought[...]and came forth with a smaller gun, and plenty of 10-
Here he engaged in the livestock business, as a gauge loads, so they were both ready when the flight
grower and trader and was employed by some of the came in , but Sim the more rested of the two."
larger outfits, who recognized his ability[...], (friend or nemy?): " obody
livestock as well as the best. frs. Roberts died here would deny t[...]and too many
His last official duty was on the side of the law cowpokes have made his home a grub-line[...]oberts profited by his Re- would give you the shirt off his back, hut it might
publicanism . \V[...]be his shirt! I"
Sim was assigned a deputyship by the United States s Fritz Haynes wr[...]Ylarshal for 1 1ontana, to investigate violation of the that Sim was quit a boy!"

They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (176) THEY GAZED ON THE BEARTOOTH S 171

The Verdict Was
"Not Guilty"[...]th ere is smoke,
there may be fire is written in The Columbus Express,
July 11, 1895:
"Much interest w as manifested in the case of the
state against S. B. Roberts and H . G . Bostwick,[...]yesterday before William T. H amil-
ton, J.P. and the justice office was filled to overflow-
ing all day. Under an agreem ent by the attorneys the
cases were tried separately, Rob erts b eing arraigned
first. The state was represented b y County Attorney
Allen and the defendant b y Sidney Sanner of Big
Timber. County Attorney Allen is well known and
nothing that The E xpress might say can ad d anything[...]Ed had b :.! en losing 11 { w heu d of fat[...]the n w p f killing nd dispo · of[...]The ca ·e for th ·[...]low : Robert had lau
J STICE OF TH PE CE, COL , ,f8 DISTRICT[...]d Roberts free. lurn bus wher part of it , a,[...]g about a year and has asked Bo twick for the hid t th
his reputation[...]' corral, but , and Park-
hardly of age, he is a much better ]av,..yer nm than[...]istant insp tor went in for it th
scores of lawyer who are twic his age. H over-[...]avorabl to his client . His argum('nts close of the stat 's case Attorney ann r mo d to
were mod ls of language, law logic and common dismis. the complaints, rai . ing the point of juri dic-
sen e, and hi mann r earne t and convincing. He tion, a. the evidence of the tate , itn , proved th
will undoubtedly[...]

They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (177)172 THEY GAZED ON THE BEARTOOTHS

in Sweet Grass County. He also contended that there
was no law, so far as the justice knew which justified
the prosecution. The Sanders edition of the codes, a
copy of which was in evidence, lacking the Seal of
the Secretary of State, which counsel contended was
absolutely necessary in order to give them the weight
and authority of laws. After a lengthy wrangle be-
tween the attorneys Judge Hamilton overruled the
defendent' s motion to dismiss and the case proceeded.
The defense was that Bostwick owned the animal
and that Robert killed it at his request. The hide was
hung on the fence and taken therefrom by parties un-
known. fter arguments by counsel, the justice dis-
charged the defendant, the case against Bostwick was
also dismissed ·on motion of the county attorney."
THE LOG SCHOOLHOUSE BURNED BY JOHNSON[...]With the term shortened by good behavior, the
"Pistol Billy" Johnson[...]his striped uniform for a cowboy
In pursuing the saga of Sim Roberts, it is neces- garb, and joined ate and Sim :Roberts, who had
sary that the life of Wm. M. Young be reviewed. For adjoini[...]ed Point in early 1899.
it was this man that "put the run" on his long-time When Roberts ki[...]y. the bitter feud that ended with the capitulation by
Roberts. With Sim out of his hair, Johnson settled
"Pistol Billy" was[...]ceable life, but still was able to
ar County near the Texas Panhandle and led a life
keep the lawmen on the job.
of crime and danger that branded him as one of the
onriest, most cantankerous individuals that ever graced One night the folks at Reed Point held a program
a home in Stillwater County. The Roberts brothers in the first log schoolhouse, followed by dancing.
and a[...]tended and was turned down a few times.
raised in the same region, but in their late teens went When the crowd had gone home, Bill and one of his
different ways. few friends, re-entered the building, upset the stove
with its burning embers, and the building burned to
While working toward Montana, Bill and the
the ground. Another time he had an argument over a
yo[...]e. He found this neighbors team at a hitch-
which the older man got a severe penitentiary sentence[...]ing rack one day, and sneaked up, and untied the
but ate got loose because he wasn't 18, and furth[...]way, a busted wagon and
more had tried to prevent the attempted holdup.[...]wasn't afraid of him and his reputation.[...]He continued to raise a good many pairs of twin
calves, and used more than his share of the open
range. nd then the law caught up with him on o-[...]was found guilty of butchering a beef carrying a brand[...]sympathetic prison warden who gave the sickly old
man a rather free run of the place as a trustee. Bill
spent a lot of time down in the horse stable area,[...]mores for sale. He also boxed a shipment of harness
WILLIAM "PISTOL BILLY" JOH[...]and a saddle, which he sneaked out through the cor-
Left to right : Tom Burt with team[...]

They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (178)[...]to his ranch home. It was after his release that the
shortage was discovered and traced to "Pistol Billy."
The warden filed a complaint and notified Pat
Reily, the county attorney for Stillwater, to serve
papers,[...]present
known address, I will b e pleased to have the papers
processed. Mr. Johnson died on June 10, 19[...]ars too
late," said Mr. Johnson, "So just pass up the church
and preacher and funeral home when I go."[...]ied and
buried his bloated body in a rough box in the Reed
Point Cemetery.
When Mrs. Wimsett finally straightened up the
death chamber, she was scared b eyond words. A
lo[...]it possi-
ble for his property to be given to one of the few
families who had befriended him, as he had re[...]ith his strength, his delerium, his constant fear of
som.eone coming to get him-what would have hap-
p[...]Write of Rob rt farkel.
Maybe P[...]k was butch rin in th
of Billy Markel bru h h[...]tt ta th w of
(Editor's note: The following is from th myn in his[...]·n
original letter written to Ed Cardwell of the bran J but not y
Bi[...]no Ed h
Washington. Date mark ill gible.) as h[...]ai
Satsop, Washington hor in ·n[...]of timothy h ut[...]: the madam will nt · ·
Th reas[...]n w could a s t
go out on the prairie and sit down and hav a long tr[...]a I it full of T-
im Roberts fi Id & if I want d him I had b tt[...]ht & at 5 I said rar h gr a d th top of th rang put
They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (179)174 THEY GAZED ON THE BEARTOOTHS

a large stake on it left it there[...]you see I
plater & brought it to me hot she had the plater had my Colts 45 on fortunately we dident meet Sim
in the warming closet so they would be hot that when we got to the Boulder we went on up to his
was as good a stake as ever I ate when I had the ranch & crossed roade straight to Sims hou[...]wife give John called Mrs. Roberts came to the door asked where
another piece of his beef he seems to like his own Sim was &[...]Ed how stockmen josch each other saloon the blacksmith ship the hotel livery barn or
that way I said if I had known they were that the store went to all those places & called untill
g[...]e came out all had seen him but dident know
ment-the $ was Sim Roberts brand) all these years ju[...]d that was no josh that that they were at the red light) a fine place for a
was my steer the next morning I rode through the married man to be went back to Sim's house &
cattle in his field very carefull the fence was down called Mrs. Roberts out said co[...]were any tracks in her I was riding back to the roundup tell Sim I
the snow then Ed you remember I met you & want to see him before the sun went down & for
your foreman Thompson in the hills back of the him to look out-The Bouldier was raising verry fast
section house you[...]you said well you they were in some kind of a horse trade so Charlie
are 24 hours too late he[...]steers ground as soon as Charlie was out of earshot Sim
tail & I never did well you can imagi[...]ll find I aint Billey was worried stayed at the roundup that night Sim
Markels oh yes forgot to say you were like my roade back to Big Timber the next day road back &
wife was she told me Sim was killing my steers crossed the Stillwater it was swimming from bank to
. . . . I would trust Sim the same as I would you bank instead of going home I roade down to the
or my brother Bob. ow Ed I will tell you how town of Stillwater you bet I watched the papers
I saved Sims life You remember when I had my leg close dident have long to wait a couple of days
broken Bob saddled up a gentel horse & boosted later when the Big Timber paper came in there it
me on my leg was in a plaster paris ca t & I had was the coroners jury said we finds that Billey
to walk on crutches I went to hunt the roundup Markels was shot & killed by parties or party to this
to have the boys brand my calves & throw my jury unknown later Sim told me how it occurred
cattle across the Stillwater stayed at Tom Kents over that night when Sim was going back the Boulder had
night and next day found the roundup they were raised another foot o[...]g Timber was sit- when about two thirds the way across the water was
ting in the tent talking to the cook and horse-wran- wa bing his horse down ([...]ismounr Billey Mar- he threw himself on the upper side to help his horse
kels steped in the tent with a sharps rifle cocked wh n whang went a rifle the bullet went through
& his finger on the triger I droped my hand on the cantel of his saddle and cut through his rught
the handle of my gun & jerked it out of the scab- buttick he drove his spurs into his horse grabed the
bard when he said hold I dont want you is Sim horn and went down on the offside of his horse the
Roberts here the cook said no Billey said I am first jump the horse threw water so that no one could
hunting hi[...]they
said to myself now John if you are a friend of Sim went high he grabed the reins & steared th horse for
Roberts here is the place to show it so I got on my a bunch of willows shut his eyes & clung to his horse
crutches I had the wrangler boost me on & tied the horse leaped through after a couple of bounds
the crutches on & started for Big Timber Billey turned sharp to the left then he was in the cotton-
mounted and roade along with me said he h[...]r
been sick for 6 years & dident have a friend in the him no one was there He laid down on the floor and
world said not even my wife is a fri en[...]nk and sewed him up. he put his saddle in the woodshed
me or anyone else to kill him but first he wanted & shaved a couple of small pieces of saddel leather
to kill Sim Roberts said if we should see him com- roughed the edges around the bullet hole glued the
ing he would get down on one knee and kill[...]

They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (180) THEY GAZED ON THE BEARTOOTHS 175

it the next evening Sim got on his horse took his
field glasses roade up on a high point where he could
see up the Bouldier shure enough he could see
Billy coming h[...]a grey or rone pacing
horse Sim hurried down swam the Bouldier & start-
ed up the Bouldier road. he was in one track and
Billey in the other of course Billey dident know him
as it was pretty da[...]lley started to raise his rifle & sim
shot him in the eye Billey gave a couple of jumps
off to one side and started to curse Sim ne[...]bed Billeys rifle as he was fallin & shot
through the body as he roade to through suspicion
off then he road across the road & went up a rocky
point took 3 or 4 circles on that benchroad down on
the Yellowstone bottom swam the Bouldier & went
home. he hadet to ride on one side in his saddle. The
authorities dident want to know who killed Billey[...]h zard hi
15 years ago asked who did it I replied the authori- dad tell tM tory many tim e .
ties dont seem to know told Joe Hundley the same
day he said he wasent surprised. If I had kn[...]me a long time to run it down thing about the murder untill th y got to Big Timb r
there was a man lived above Big Timber on the Yel- the n t day am w nt in the jail & mad m dicine
lowstone that had some cattle[...]m lot him
them in his field Sim came along opened the gate testimony clear d im am vVed thou 1ht no mor _.
& drove them out left the gate open & Billies horses of sw aring to a lie than you or I do to drinking a[...]ov "r to
how that for a mean trick Sim delivered the cattle ams 11 big TK 1eldings and v nt -d tl1 'm in a
and got the reward. That steer of myne that im schut at ams ranch am dro e th m to o<ly
killed wasent the first I lossed b twe n 25 & 30 sold th m. I m t th man in Billin rs that was with
head of cattle at Reeds Point that littl T a crook[...]id . Irs. Rob rt. , a to him ju t lik a
I wasent the only one he fooled he fool d you and the childr n w r lik his m n h c.:ould "nt
Br[...]Brigs when Brigs was fath r of tho chilclr n or th hu sband of
paying him $125 per month & expences as for man.[...]r rai cl tog th 'r in T xa. h ,
him over just put the JD on the left sid th next took th train that nig[...]h ,
old Tom Kent he shipp d carload aft r carload of n xt tim I , rite I v ill tell you all about the time
cattle to Deliuth every fall after the stock in. p tors I shot \ d how it o cur d[...]age & say he wou]<lent hear anything again t Sim.
The night Sim shot & killed 1ate Young[...]

They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (181)[...]THEY GAZED ON THE BEARTOOTHS

A Few Yesterd[...]His only conviction was on a charge of petty
larceny in the latter days of his life. It was late fall
by[...]along with his wagon . An Indiana
In a review of some of his experiences during hi~ hom[...]on his way. It started to snow soon after and the
Roberts, portions of which follow:[...]the snow skift. They trailed them to Rosebud and[...]ty (Sim Roberts) there was the stove still in the wagon. Sim said the
was arrested. A young fellow had hired out to him[...]. He collect it after a year of trying. They gave him thirty
placed the hide in a grain sack and buried it in a days in the county jail at Forsyth. He served one
manure pile. The kid was a sheriff "plant." Soon the night. The next morning Sheriff Patterson brought
officers appeared and forthwith started digging for the him over and the old fellow was crying. He said some-
hide where the kid told them it was. They found it one had yelled through the jail window that night
and put Sim under arrest a[...]that his wife was "awful" sick at the Holy Rosary
On the preliminary hearing they took the hide out hospital in Miles City. I confirmed this by telephone.
of the sack and spread it out on the floor. It had We turned him[...]rt back to finish his sentence when
nothing. When the hide was prepared for inspection things cleared up. A few days after, the sheriff came
it wore the brand of Sim Roberts. The kid witness into my office[...], and reported that Sim and
swore that it was not the same hide they buried in this lady had been separated for some time and were
the pile. Sim went free as a result of some magic not on friendly[...]and throw him in jail and make him finish the 30-[...]it, and particularly I didn't want the public to hear[...]tle rustling, and the survelliance of the law was told[...]without the hide, which raised the suspicion of the[...]to the Roberts place for an inspection. In the corral[...]was a compost pile, and a dog was digging at the edge
of it. Triumphantly, the inspector hauled out a fresh[...]hide. ow he had the goods on Mr. Roberts![...]He hurriedly traced the brand. It was the $
brand recorded in his wife's name-the hide came
from his own beef. The $ brand was the object of[...]he took it because he could "run" some of the other
brands in the area into a dollar sign, fairly easily.[...]of his cattle carried Sim's own brand-an inverted V,[...]corded by Mr. Roberts, August 28, 1880; and the $
This county attorney Jet Sim Roberts talk him out of a term brand to Ada Roberts, July 2[...]

They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (182)[...]THEY GAZED ON THE BEARTOOTHS[...]Bill Miller Orders
An incident of the Roberts-} ohnson feud displays[...]Temper
from his Primrose Ranch to the farm where his sister,
Mrs. Phil Hicks was living at the west edge of Reed
Point. He loaded on one of his sons to keep him com-
pany. Passing an old cabin on the road in Reed
Point, he saw some men within and recognized John-
son as one of them. After he delivered the hay, he
told the story to Mrs. Hicks and expressed some con-
cern. On her advice he left the boy in her care, and
went back for another load of hay. As he drove past
the cabin Johnson and Tom Burt jumped from the
doorway and opened fire with their rifles. Roberts
emptied his revolver, one of the bullets grazing John-
son. At the same time he dropped into the "trough"
of the hayrack and whipped the horses into a dead
gallop, as bullets whizzed above him, at least three
of which plowed into the rack.
Ambrose Brumfield told this story! "Ta[...]llie and John Mullen and myself were just
leaving the schoolhouse when we heard rifle fire and
were witnesses to the attempted "bushwhacking."
There was a third man in the cabin, but his rifle
jammed, and he didn't join in the shooting. Why
Roberts wasn't hit with that barrage of bullets will
always be a mystery to me. When Robe[...]Finch Brown tells author the tory of Bill Miller; the H ii-[...]dot appearing in "They
fully armed, on horseback, the cabin was abandoned, Gazed On The Beartooth ."
and the son was taken safely back home."[...]rough-and-ready opponent, kept a lot of p opl from[...]most of hi horn t ad, with a fine corral (and loading[...]chut ), and did most of the work on hi humbl log[...]a small string of ows, and start d to run a but her[...]wagon rout in the community, a 11 a to aise[...]hor s for sal . His first xposur of hi abilit to
tak care of him elf follow d a m I with a couple
of Indians. Bill was running a few of hi broncs up[...]Vall y Creek, h ad d for op n range in the Ba in.[...]both Indian and dragg d
"Brose" was a witne s of this incident and released this auth en-[...]th ir bodies up to a crevic in the sand tone cliffs
They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (183) 178 THEY GAZED 0 THE BEARTOOTHS

where he dumped them. He then adde[...]r molested again flaring temper, a display of which was told the writer
on this ·core. by a pioneer lady of Big Timber. As a girl of four-[...]on an errand, accompanied by her dog,
om of the Park City stockmen figured that Bill "Rags." Sim and his son "Gu" were on the street, and
was elling more beef than he was buying so they when the boy irritated the pup to a point of violent
re orted to the old ruse of placing a coin under the barking, Roberts drew his revolver and shot the dog
hide of an animal for identification purposes, and[...]ther to explain or say he was sorry.
drov a few of those unbranded steers into handy (In ·a sking that her name not be used, this very esti-
reach of th butcher. One day Bill gathered up a[...]nd Mrs.
few too many drinks and stated that one of the ani- Roberts, who was a sweet, gracious lad[...]brisket and bors and in those early days of Big Timber shared
\vondered 'who in hell is put[...]a fine grandson, Jack,
cattle." With this proof of guilt a possee with a long living in Helena, a[...]e to Bill' place, prepared to see justice in the Air Corps, and their mother, a most highly
done[...]ed up behind them, and appeared thought of lady in Helena. I do not want to be
with hi rifle across his knee and the saddle horn guilty of causing any possible embarrassment.)
(which pos[...]for the branding fire, and happened to draw a "snakey"
. to be around." ·With the drop on them, the possee
little fellow who ducked the first lasso, much to Sim's
rode away, while Bill' · rifle swung at the alert.[...]chagrin, who rarely missed, especially in front of
For everal years filler continued his meat[...]added taxidermy to his occupation. After the trickey dogie shied away. Whereup Sim whipped
the "hanging" threat it seems Miller had enough of a out his "gat" and shot the calf between the eyes. He
stake to buy hi b ef animals, and gradually worked then dragged the animal to the camp wagon and ad-
into a pretty sizeable inventory of livestock. Then vised the cook ''to have some fresh meat for a change."
came one of those triangles, wherein a "Doc" Butler
used his[...]The Crows Would Have
to cause a br ak in the Mill r relations. It worked.
In 1 91, Bill Mille[...]Called Him "Many Guns"
a hill abov the ranch. T eighbors didn't like the "Bill dams, an old "79" hand, while he was
looks of thing , and about a year later Bill' body was sheriff of Yellowstone County one made the remark
exhum d and th stomach ontents not d. r enic
had been the dir ct caus of death. "Doc" and Mrs.
Miller wer brought befor a coron r's inquest. "Doc"
naturally knew the pot ncy of arsenic. It wa also a
known fact that Bill u ed[...]processing his
stuff d animal . Ther was no way of knowing but
that he had accid ntaily swallowed ome of the poi-
son. The jurors rend red a verdict "came to his death
by arsenic poisoning." The ca e rest d there, but
"Doc" took off for an unk[...]n. Bill's body
was then buried down on a flat at the dge of Valley
Cre k. Som years later a flash flood washed through
the ar a and completely removed what remained of
Bill Miller, leaving only a sloping hole in the ground.
So this was the man that met Sim Roberts one
afternoon, driving a cow and calf wearing the brand
that belonged to Dan Benedict. Sim said h[...]cattl are
not back at Benedicts before sundown, the "boys"
will know whether you have bought them or not." The SHERIFF WILLIAM P. AD MS
·[...]e sundown!" He claimed the Crow wou!~ have givn:!, Sim Roberts a trih[...]

They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (184) THEY GAZED ON THE BEARTOOTHS 1 79

that "if Roberts had ever been adopted by the Crow named "White Chaps Charlie" Burt, who[...]t, they with Roberts when he was foreman for the "79."
would have named him "Many Guns." Such a su[...]m Roberts, one
picion is related in a story about the famous Old
of Sim's sons, and as he extended his hand, he re-
Stone Barn, in the Columbus News, July 10, 1930:[...]d not
"One night Sim Roberts drove down from the have had this hand, nor probably this arm, to shake
Battle Flat country and his mount was tied to the with. While working cattle with your dad, I got a
hitching rack, while he tried out some of the local bad "dally" on the saddle horn, and my hand got
liquor. A head of prickly pear had been tossed out caught in a loop of the rope. As it tightened I real-
of a load of hay, and a barn hand put it under the ized that the arm could be jerked from its socket by
saddle on Sim's horse. When the noted character re- the straining animal. Your father whipped his gun
mounted, the horse made one grandstand play, and on from the scabbard, and cut the rope so cleanly with
every jump a six-shooter was unloosened from Sim's his perfect shot, that the small remaining strand broke,
person, and fell to the ground, until three lay in the without damage to my hand or wrist. I wouldn't have
wake of the broncho's dust. Apparently not a one lef~ believed it if it had not happened to me!"
on the rider with which to gain revenge on the jok-[...]as one of the best gunmen of the West. The Buffalo
derringer in the watch pocket of his riding britches,[...]as visiting Bozeman, featuring "Doc" Car-
instead of a timepiece![...]him, in the air, or at stationary or running targets.[...]practice at objects tossed into the air, but managed
Another story concerning the shooting ability of to keep within close range of the professional, as he
Sim Roberts comes from Charles Justin Burt, nick- hit the target at the peak break. Somewhat startled[...]at Sim's ability, Bill Cody's boy developed a bit of
nervousness as they tried on the V shot. He was a[...]half inch off target at fifty yards, but Sim took the
three points of the V with bulls-eye precision. They
paid him the prize money with a smile and wild
applause from the sp ctators. They also barred him[...]On of Sim Roberts' propo d jokes didn't xact-[...]form r m mber of th stat staff of v t rinarians, who[...]herd of cattle for scab. Wh n I phon d him he told[...]the b arn on th ranch, and told me wher I could
find the cattle. H regr tt d that he had anoth r ap-[...]pointment, and could not join me. I r ach d the[...]straddled him , found the cattl wh re he had aid they[...]and rode b ack to th ranch, unsaddled the hor e and
CHARLES JUSTI BURT "WHITE[...]

They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (185)180 THEY GAZED ON THE BEARTOOTHS[...]when they had finished the job. Sim said he had
come up and inspected the poles-had given the men
hell because they had piled them in this out-of-the-
way place, and paid them off. The gun looked pretty
big to Iver, and the story could have been true, so[...]he backed away, maybe to forget the whole deal.
But when he reported the condition to Rehm, he[...]they decided to follow the matter up. Trails showed
that the poles had been hauled down the Bridger
Creek road to the Yellowstone, then headed upstream.[...]didn't buck like he orter?"

When I went to the house to report my findings,
Mrs. Roberts was hom[...]ugh when he trots!" I
replied.
"Well, you're the lucky one. That plug was
judged the hardest bucker that was entered in the
Miles City rodeo last month!"
I might have b[...]ble, but I'll bet Sim was disgusted to
think that the bronc hadn't scattered me and my
equipment over the landscape."[...]berts and Who told the story of Sim Roberts and the corral poles.

Corral Poles Searching as they went, the men found a stack of
One of the early nicknames applied to Sim Rob- fresh c[...]n a lot owned by Harvey
erts was "Slick Sim," and the following item, as told Bliss. When Bliss he2[...]y he said that Rob-
by Bryan Anderson, may be one of the reasons for erts had left these poles here to be sold. When the
this title: men showed the identifying notches, Bliss, although
" eeding poles for his fences and corrals, shortly one of Roberts'· closest friends, didn't like the looks
after filing on his Stillwater homestead, Iver Thomp- of this transaction and they went to Sheriff A. T.
s[...]n
into Bridger Creek and cut sufficient poles for the town that day, and when confronted and thre[...]e cut, each pole with arrest he told about the same story that he had
was notched to provide ide[...]d they were furnished to Thompson.
hauled to the top of the divide where the men would "111 bet those crooks found[...]ill" grade to their river farms, and stead of cutting any, they just slipped me the double-
thus haul larger loads.[...]g for delivering them to this
Roberts standing at the pile, rifle in hand, and a big sale yard."

They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (186) THEY GAZED ON THE BEARTOOTHS 181

THE "DUN LOUIE" AND
''THE VIRGINIAN"
The Tri-County ews - March 10, 1894 - "On
Thursday af[...]ren and W. P. Adams squared their ac-
counts with the proprietor of the Dun Louie, bade
their sweethearts an affectionate farewell, boarded
the hurricane decks of four untamed cayuses and hit
the trail north to the Musselshell and the "7c.Y' can;ip
wagons. We hope that they will meet[...]t they will send their reatas circulating
through the air with an unerring aim, and finally
bunch up again in Columbus, when the snow begins
to fly."
Thus one gets the first printed account of the
Dun Louie, which played an important part in the
long winters for the "79" hands who "holed up" in
town from the time the last roundup was over, until
calf branding began in the early spring. Economy was
a necessary trait with most of them, which was the
reason th~t six or eight of them would rent a log shack
with sufficient bunks[...]deer, elk, antelope and game birds provided
most of their meat supply, fuel was plentiful and an
occasional job on an hour basis by one or more of
them, kept them in food. In fact they knew more
than one way "to skin a cat" as appears in a story of "DUDE" JEFFERSON DAVIS W ARRE - "The Virginian"
early days by Col. Allen in which he w[...]ted him. by starting out as a cowboy in the wild and wooly
Four of the "Dun Louie" boys introduced him to a West. He selected the Big Coulee headquarters of
new game called kay-zipp kay-zapp, which he ap- the "79" as his starting place.
parently never learned, for in short order he closed
up, and the "79" cowhands had a hearty supply of Charlie Davison imm diately nick[...]"Dude." He was w aring the loude t shirt purcha e-[...]rilliant-bu d scarf ti d around hi n ck,
One of their early cooks was Lewis Dunn, also r[...]uch as might be worn on a fox hunt,
employed with the "79" camp wagons, hence the and boots that were mor d corative than practical.
name "Dun Louie." Another eccentric handler of the H had purchased a saddl with silver trim[...]t disgusted with ornate design, a pair of massive silv r spurs, and a
his patrons rather easily. His only recourse was to set of Angora chap . H also had load d on a big
go to Wo[...]pply wagon
dozen soft-boiled eggs and half a loaf of bread. In at Merrill, bound for the Big Coul e. Thi item, and
that way, claimed the Dun Louie crew, he didn't have most of its scholastic cont nts nev r found th ir way
to eat so much of his own cooking. back from the Big Coul e. It did produc , howev r,
ot all of the "79" employees were just run-of-the an expensive harmonica on which "The Virginian"
mill cowhands. Once in a while a speci[...], and which, th y claimed, was h ard
would get on the payrolls. Such a person was Jeffer- many times as Dude act d as the nighthawk on a
son Davis Warren, known affectionately to his fellow trail herd.
workers as "The Virginian," or more often, "Dude." On ew Year's Eve, Columbus people were
The way the members of his outfit got the story was staging a hard-times <lane , wh[...]s affair had
ern university, and decided to learn the world ways drawn an overflow crowd[...]

They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (187)[...]THEY GAZED ON THE BEARTOOTHS[...]dress with Charlie Davison. The next and last ever
heard of the "Dude" was a terse note telling the "79"[...]action at the battle of San Juan Hill, during the his-
torical charge of Teddy Roosevelt and his Rough-[...]apparently "all had been forgiven in the area from[...]never revealed, nor did his nephew, Jim Wheat, the
reason for the fictitious cognomen.)

1895 COW PUNCHERS "79" HOME RANCH
All pals of the "Virginian" "Dude" Warren. (Taken by Haynes[...]away as Big Timber and Billings,
as well as most of the "79'' hands, and the valley
rancher families. When "Dude" and the Dun Louie
boys arrived they found that a certain group of the
town's lovely and popular girls, making a play for the
company of the better looking cowboys, had dolled
up in their best "bib and tucker." Suddenly the Dude
disappeared. A few minutes later he came back in
a full dress suit, silk hat and a pair of opera glasses.
He would walk up in front of one of the girls, scan
her closely with the glasses, bow low and gracefully;[...]REMAINS OF CHARLEY FARLEY HOMESTEAD
then go to the next. After repeated pedormances, the FILED O IN 1881
non-conformants got the drift of things, as the other
dancers giggled and cheered, and beat a retreat. They Born along the bayous in Mississippi, September
later returned in the prescribed garb, and after con-[...]ther southern kid
siderable kidding, again became the belles of the who grew up through a civ[...]ally the teen-age period of his life found him drifting
That 'The Virginian" had to be a remittance man West. He learned the cow business in Texas, and in
was an established[...]1881 came to Montana with a trail herd of steers, a
ways exceeded the twenty dollars wages that he got portion of which were turned over to the "79", when
monthly the first year on the payroll. It was known Sim Roberts was foreman at that time. The trail boss
that he had bribed the man who drove the supply gave Wheat such[...]his ability,
wagon to deliver his mail to him on the q.t. Certainly that he was selected by Joseph Murphy, (brother of
"Dude" was the best dressed, and probably the best "J. T.") manager of the outfit, to return to Kansas for
educated and talented of any man who ever rode another herd, and in the spring of 1882, Wheat was
for the "79". trail boss for a split herd of 6000 head, half of which
In the fall of 1897, Jeff made his last ride to the were delivered to Dave Fratt on the Musselshell, and

They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (188) THEY GAZED ON THE BEARTOOTHS[...]tion with the "79".[...]ness , and also operated the town's butcher ship for[...]a couple years. Ironically, it was whil he was in the
meat business that he swore out a warrant for the
arrest of his old associate, Sim Roberts, for illegal sale[...]of beef. As usual, "Slick Sim" was turned free.[...]In 1908, the Wheat family moved to a small stock[...]ranch near ye, where the children, Jessie., Laura,[...]until the death of their mother in 1915. Mr. Wheat[...]spent his last years in the Reed Point area, dying in
1929 within sight of the tree where he had staked a[...]During its life span of thirty-five years the Mon-
tana Cattle Company had a payroll list of more than
one hundred name , despite the fact that the turnover
of employees was light. The "79" was noted for al-[...]ways having thoughtful, considerate managers, the
best of roundup cooks and food and an excellent string
of horses and equipment at all times. And ther was[...]always surety of a payday roll call. For th r asons
the cowhands stuck around for long r periods of
MR. & MRS. A. P. WHEAT[...]ployment than wa · u ·ual among th itchy-footed
the other half went to the "home ranch" on East White nomad of the rang land .
Beaver. John Collins, who had succeed[...]Th "79", lik oth r cow-outfit , had it har of
as foreman, became a t rritorial stock inspector, and the commonplace stockgrm in r, coup] d with many
Murphy named Wheat as foreman of the "79" opera- vagaries and incid nts-a[...]d for five y ars. He then irat ·owboy; two of its loyal famil , "ndin r th trail
surrender d the foremanship to Jack Williams, and for with[...]shot to d ath \ hi] ful-
thr e more years serv d the "79" as director and man- filling his duties as a tm n mar hal· and v n a f ,
ager of all stock shipm nts from M rrill.[...]om cm boy agr d to co- ·i ·t "n , or
B aver, on the advic of Joe Murphy, who want d a
1 gitimate "toehold" in this vast area, close to shipping
facilities. Using the big pine tree as a corner the
160 acre tract included one of the best corral and
building locations along the creek, as well as the be t
spring. The agreement was that if \ heat ev r want-
ed a release, the ''79" would huy the homest ad.
During th later years of his term with the Mon-
tana Cattle Co., " ndy had found more and more
frec1uent trips to Columbus necessary, the reason being
Miss Laura Porter, whose beauty and charm made
her his 16-year-old bride in 1 91. The now Mrs.
Wh at didn't relish the thought of living alone in
town while her husband was working cattl , nor did
the life of the lonely _cow camp appeal to h r. Her[...]IVE BUTTE
wishes pr vailed and , '700 in cash for the claim and "7!) "1.'r · makl' thcir l'hoil·c for a day · ride on the trail.
They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (189)[...]THEY GAZED ON THE B E AR T OO T H S

perhaps an ea tern schoolmarm manag d to lip the
noo e over a love-blinded broncho buster. (There
were a few stray teachers, even in those days despite
the fact that big cow outfits and school houses are
generally not compatable.)
Probably the be t known and most highly respect-
ed and one of the longest years of service with the
notorious outfit, was W. E. "\i\Tild Bill" Sutter. Born
in Butte in 1 3, he was only three years old when
the family moved to a Wolf Creek ranch in Judith
Basin. Here he pent his boyhood in the heart of
a cow-land atmosphere, learning all the tricks pro-
vaded by a hor e, a branding iron, a rope and a
critter. His life was one of thrills and adventure
which found him engaged in every phase of cowhand
activity-trail riding, night-hawking, breaking horses,
branding and shipping and, in the last years of his
association with a cow outfit, was wagon boss for the
T on Powder River. He worked for many outfits
including the LU, the -, C7, T, and even spent
part of one year in rgentina, seeing how they raised
catt[...]erica. During these years he de-
veloped into one of the top riders in Montana, and
rode to uccess in the early Montana rodeo days at
Miles City and elsewhere.
He gave up the active life of a cowboy on the
range, however, in 1917 when he discovered, corraled
and roped Beatrice Hinds, of Olive, and started "rid-
in' double." Mrs. Sutter, herself a product of a stock[...]WM. E . "WILD BILL" SUTTER
ranch of the early days, proved to be a real wagon[...]09 EXTREME WE TER CAMP EAR FOOTHILLS OF THE CRAZY MO
"Wi[...]

They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (190)[...]THEY GAZED ON THE BEARTOOTHS[...]whenever his occupa- herds between there and the Big Dry; and endured
tion called him, at the same time rearing two fine the cooking of camp wagon chefs in th p rsons of
boys. Bill, Jr., is presently following somewhat[...]iams, who wer ·lie p
years in the U.S. Iavy. bosses and more or less frowned on by the cowboys,
Since bidding goodbye to cowboy li[...]to
has nevertheless been closely associated with the live- their boss-man.
stock business most of the time. In 1915, he was In a final intervi w with Sutter, the v nerable
Deputy Sheriff of Custer County, with a special cowpunch[...]1919 be- "I have certainly enjoyed the articl written and
came the first sheriff of Powder River County, serving stories told about the "79" in days gone by, but in
until 1922. His next step was a move to Browning, my opinion none of them came to a satisfactory con-
where he was ran[...]clusion. Certainly John T. Murhpy was on of the
running 17,500 head of cattle on the Blackfoot Reser-· , most prominent, progressive[...]t 1 men that Montana ever had. Certainly, also is the
time as a guard at the state penitentiary at Deer fact that The Montana Cattle Company established a
Lodge, Bill went to work in 1927 with the Montana record of longevity and financial ·tability unexcelled
Liv[...]."
until his retirement in 1948. During this span of Mr. Sutter is said to have acquired the '·\\ ild
years he performed the services of brand inspector in Bill" nickname when a drunk n sheepherder said he
many districts in Montana, to the Union stock yard saw Bill riding a bear u[...]a
in South St. Paul, Chicago, and later in charge of rattle nake as a whip, trying to head a w[...]oux City, Spokane and Billings. sheep back into the "79s" tam " flock!
In 1943 he got his final assignment, the job of chief
inspector for the state of Montana.
But of all his associations, Bill Sutter cla;ms the CHANGING DAYS
·'79", as his first and grea[...]first recalls
this outfit as early as seven years of age, when a
OF THE "79"
herd of "79" cattle wintered alongside th family John Burt - Columbu
ranch north of Stanford. In 1902, he tried for a berth[...]D ar Ike:
on the forphy outfit but they wer fullhanded at
that t;m[...]to h art: I gu · w '11 hav to
lot with the "79" agons until the brand re erted chang our ay -cow punchin is a pa in' art. I
back to the state in 1915. do[...]k p you
C rtainly no man today knows a much of th in th ring, w '11 o to to\J n and buy a "jit" and yo 1
life of th "79" as do s " ild Bill ," much of this can l'arn to run th thing. Just turn th bron ho out
history of thi gr at outfit from 1900 through its final t[...]h n I 1
vividly r calls his roundup chums, a f w of whom whil ing horn from to[...]n , " ottontail" L 1 tting out om honks. The fun had wa
Hurt, Larry O 'Bria[...]ohn v oods am imm ense-it made me think of husting hroncs!
Harvey, P t Elle, Tom Powe[...]
They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (191)[...]THEY GAZED ON THE BEARTOOTHS

end, for Lizzie ·piE><l a tumbl we[...]went 1893, and learning of his qualifications, Joseph Mur-
11p, lier head we[...]phy put him in charge of the horse breeding opera-
('Omplete, and wh ·n at last he hit the ground, I tions, which was a big <leal at the "M ule Ranch" as
" ·asn 't sitting in tlw eat. "[...]me and left her too fond of the long-eared beast that he dealt with. In
thar~ \fy[...]1903 he joined a crew of the ''79" cowhands to move a
a clonkt>y and an ass. You bet when next I drive to herd of cows and calves from the Six-shooter range,
tmn1, l "·on't mi, moon ·hinf' wjth the gas. ruined by hoppers, to the Big Dry, then rolled up his[...]bed tarp and came to Columhus. He roamed the coun-
COYOTE[...]try as far as Seattle for a couple of years, then re-[...]turned to Columbus. He was employed at the quarry[...]Marshal of Coh1m bus.
DAVISON On the night of July 28, 1912, Davison was mak-
Onl' o~ the most popular hands of the "79" during ing an arrest on a complaint filed by the ''madam"
the lat<· '90s was Charles Davi on, horn in Kansas, of the south institution. The offender went beserk
,\lay 27, 1S69. Il e was a n[...]d and ent a .45 slug into the officer's belly. Davison
sacrificed schooling to learn ahont the equines. He made his last display of his renowned "fast draw"
" ·a: pretty much of a ki<l, _till when he landed a[...]ahoo, . 'ehra ka. One day of which proved fatal. The slug had so shattered the
a --79'' repre ·cntutive came to the ranch to purchase officer that the food from his supper spewed over
a coup le carload · of 'tallions, which interested Char- the visera, and he died before a doctor could arrive.
lie :o m11ch that he accompanied the shipment to the His last move was in keeping with the exciting days
,\krrill ·tockyard ·, thenc the Big Coulee. This was of his life. The killer was Homer Porter.[...]His funeral was the biggest Col um bus had ever[...]seen, and the Col um bus ~ ews commented:[...]"The only relative was a cousin, Tom Davis, but[...]there came all the way from Wahoo, ebraska, a little[...]woman who for many years had remained true to the
love sh bore for the man who is now dead. She had[...]faithful , waiting for the time when she could leave[...]her aged mother, and come to him for the fulfillment
of th ir hearts fondest hopes. She arrived in time t[...]drop a t ar on the bier of her bethrothed and as she[...]One of Davison's b st friends was Ed M. dams,[...]country and driv the livery team whil he s arched[...]for a law-breaker susp cted of being out that way.[...]ailing at old haunts in the Big Coulee ranch they[...]found a few of th cowhands kidding Watt McCool,[...]long the kitch n would find a lady at the h Im, and[...]the d eputy , with the hcst interests of his fri nds al-[...]warned him , "\Vatt, that gir1 is from the cat-house in[...]own good the boys in town tell me that sh has a[...]

They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (192)[...]THEY GAZED ON THE BEARTOOTHS[...]Watt McCool feeding.

A bundle of letters in Davison's trunk revealed the
name of the girl in Wahoo. These letters, read in part
by the coroner, in search of statistical information,
proclaimed a deep love and trust and acknowledged
receipts of money orders for what could have been
most of Charlie's wages all these years-saved by her
for the day they would be man and wife. It was Mr.
Adams painful assignment to return these letters to
the heart-broken girl who had written them with hope[...]futile yearning.

BENJAMIN HENRY
BROWN
One of the earliest employees of the famous "79"
was Ben H. Brown, who was born Septem[...]st came to Montana
from Wells, evada in 1882, and the next spring ing the steers from the Big Coulee to th fort, where
helped bring a trail herd of Texas longhorns for the it was butchered."
"79" and worked for them as foreman of their Big
Coulee ranch nearly twelve years, when[...]an incident whil corralling hor s. One
on a tract of land of his own along Big Coulee Creek. of the cowboys mi took a hors h ad for a cattle-
He expa[...]rustling Indian, and killed th b st hors we had.
of cattle before he sold out in 1925. lso at one time on the Mu 1 hell th y lynch d 1[...]not get th lead r "Black" ampb 11. On of th boy
Winkler in their county seat in 1896, and b came the[...]"pull up" a s hool chum. Wh n h r fus d th
father of three sons, Ben H. Jr. , Ollie, and Archie. Mr.[...]h did. This was in the sprin of 1 3. noth r tim
a real estate business, retiring[...]we w r working in the Painted Rob , wh n th In-
He met the "Grim Reaper" on March 14, 1945 ag d[...]for whom
"Went to work as a bronc bust r for the "79" in that town i nam d. When I kn w[...]betw en Billings and Laurel,
working with th "79" the boss' son, Bill Murphy and haul[...]

They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (193)188 THEY GAZED ON THE BEARTOOTHS[...]Williams was destined to lead one of the most tumult-
uous lives of any cowhand associated with the old
"79". "Jack" was a lad of 22 when he first came north
with a string of Texas longhorns for delivery to Nelson[...]Story, turning them over to the new owner, who then
ranged from the Bull Mountains to the Continental[...]as a deputy U.S. marshal for the Territory of Mon-[...]by many incidents, while he was an officer of the law.[...]invaded the wilds of Montana to arrest four des-
peradoes. In the melee that followed Williams was
shot in the neck with a 30-30 rifle, before the four[...]After the battle, the badly wounded Williams[...]snowshoed fifty miles for the services of an army fort[...]hope for him. He sneaked away from the infirmary,[...]The second occasion happened in his later years,[...]when he was in charge of a cattle layout in Utah. He[...]was also declared fatal by the doctors, but he re-
PAT O[...]ring dull winter season.

'While bringing in the trail herd in 1878, we got
snowed in and lived on[...]r cowboy."

ARCHIE BROW
One of Ben Brown's sons, Archie, still lives in
Billings, Montana, where he has worked at the sugar
factory since 1933. He was born on the Big Coulee
ranch, October 8, 1901, and moved to town when his
dad sold the ranch in 1918. On October 7, 1920, he
was[...]

They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (194) THEY GAZED ON THE BEARTOOTHS[...]daughter of a pioneer who had come up the Missouri[...]to Fort Benton in 1865, and homesteaded west of Co-[...]wedded bliss, through a trial period of three fine[...]youngsters, Charles, Florence and Hattie, the call of[...]of the Crow tribe whose husband, Thomas, farmed[...]a choice allotment on the Stillwater until death.[...]down a ranch foreman job for several years. ews of[...]was in the area of Las Vegas that he lived after he[...]had delivered a herd of cattle for the Corn Creek[...]During these 35 years, he lived the life of a her-[...]four teams of burros, and one dog, barely panning[...]ce, Hattie and Charles, ride range with him on the "79" was preparing break-[...]fast for Jack Williams, when he heard a gunshot. The
covered although he was never a well man there-[...]ast engagement with death came had pressed the trigger of his beloved .38 caliber
when he was nearly 70 years old, and was employed pistol for the last time.
by the Apache Hotel in Las Vegas as advertising at-[...]Florence Green, the only living daughter.)
transients and ran away, with the wagon passing over
his body and breaking several[...]THE ARMITAGE
apparently his reason for suicide. BROTHERS
After resigning from the federal service, "Jack" Two sons of a prominent pioneer Montana fami-
returned for a[...]1 9,
searched for employment and found a berth on the and was a babe in arms wh n hi par nts m[...]ss was Charley Farl y, ranch near Billings. The mother was r ally of pion er
and the two became fast friends , although competitive[...]back to her grandfather, who fr ighted
rivals in the art of roping, shooting and handling cat- in early '60[...]at B armouth, Montana,
given a wagon-boss job on the roundup, when Farley even b for th finding of gold in Ald r Gulch-b fore
the vigilante days.
was put in charge of the "79" ranch on East White
Beaver, with complete control of the livestock ship- This older Armitage r c ived his short schooling
ments from the Merrill station. in Billings, but as a kid of 17 truck out on his own
and went to work for the famous "79" in 1906. He
Cowboys of that era didn't have much chance to was wit[...]omancing-schools and cow kingdoms aren't the forest service (until entry into World War I) as[...]oil, and was in various phases
vivaciousness won the love of Annie Albertson, step- of this activity until he retired in 1959.
They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (195)[...]THEY GAZED ON THE BEARTOOTHS[...]as married in Eugene, The Big Dry was their steer country, and no win-
Oreg[...]ho was born in ter feeding. The Big Coulee outfit did all cow and
Cliquot, Missou[...]calf work, horse work, and tended the winter feeding.
dren, and are now living comfortably in Bellingham, The winter cow camp was at the Cross S, on the
Washington. head of Painted Robe. Cattle that had to be fed to[...]survive the winter were held at the Big Coulee, or
Mr. Armitage wrote a short skit of the "79" as
River Ranch on the Musselshell, and the older sheep
he knew and had heard about it:[...]fed on the White Beaver.
"When I worked for the "79" I understood that I believe that I witnessed and was part of the last
at one time they were running 40,000 cattle, 10,000 big roundup in the orthwest. Ten roundup outfits
horses, 1,000 mules and a lot of sheep, but as a with individ[...]trainloads from
"punch r" I was not intere ted in the lowly bah-bahs. Hysham, in 1907. As I remember the "79" had two
I imagine they had less than 10,000 cattle while I camp wagons; the Bar had two outfits; the 2 Bar,
worked for them, and were handling more sheep. had two; the Long S had one and there were three
John Murphy saw the future and in the early days others which I ha[...]at
started buying up railroad land to have a base of in crossing the Yellowstone near Pease Bottom we
operations. This paid off, for when the government run into a colony of bees that attacked and stung
cracked down on thes[...]recluded, although some pede."
of the corn r fences oftimes fell down, permitting
grazing on the adjoining sections. The younger broth r , George T. was born in[...]gs, September 7, 1891, and obtained his ele-
The "79'' shipp d in one or more trains of year- mentary education there, commuting from the family
ling steers very spring, keeping them in the west farm a short distance fr[...]as
end holdings for a year, then trailing them to the Big married to Miss Louise Webber[...]Dry range to fatten and ship as four-year olds to the nois. They had no children[...]
They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (196) THEY GAZE D ON THE BEARTOOTHS 191[...]There were lots of good riders in th e old cow-
boy days, but among the top ten was listed the nam ,
of James Frederick Kirch. This lad was a babe in arm[...]Fred recorded some of his roundup days and some[...]old, I did all kinds of jobs to get money to buy the[...]saddle mare, a pair of hom emade hoots by Pat 1 k-
THE ARMITAGE BROS.- "79" Crea for[...]Cormick. They had, a town herd of ahont 70 head
George, like the author, had a very short hitch of cows, and we would take them from th e corrals in[...]the morning ancl run them out the open range, of
under the "79" colors, but he did write a most inter-[...]around th e village, and 1
esting story entitled "The Dying Days of The Great would herd them all day and bring[...]job lasted two
This article was a condensed story of the hectic life summers. I also p eddled papers , The Saturday Blad
of this cattle spread and his impressions gained as[...]s one cf
spring high school graduate, assigned to the move- my customers. 1 did a lot of errand running, too, a ·[...]ere were no telephones or taxis. Lights consisted of
ment of a trail herd of steers, headed for the heavy,[...]pole
strong grasslands for fattening. His review of the where there w re four outlets on a frame that could
methods of handling the stock, movement of the wag- be raised and low r d and th s w r "load ,d" "ach
ons and crews, location of camps and water supply, night so that th[...]d and other details, including some city.
of the languag and nicknames known only to th e[...]that even in these final days and th horn of th e bigg st wool . bipping in[...]g th e fr ight wagons. lso hor string teams dri n
the great "79" had in operation more than forty camp
wagons for use in the spring branding roundups; or
trail herds during the late summer and early fall, and
the last movement of the fat stock as they were slowly
hazed to the stockyards for shipment.

Mr. Armitage among[...]s, has been
and is a free 1ance writer, and nomad of adventure.
He spent many years in Hawaii where he wrote
numerous booklets and artides about what is now one
of our states, and frequently leav s the "mainland"
to rerww acquaintances and memories of the land of
the lei.
(The author of this volum is grateful to George
and broth[...]

They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (197)192 THEY GAZED ON THE BEARTOOTHS

The Lake Basin saw a lot of horse outfits in the
early days, the "79" the biggest, and it is estimated[...]time. I hired out to the Arrow C in 1899. We had[...]Outfit. The going price was $8 to $12 per head. The[...]Fred Kirch. Cleveland bays and a lot of strawberry roans, blue
with a jerk line. Most of the freighting was done in roans, bays and browns. They would weigh from
the summer when the freighters could feed their 1000 to 1200 pounds and made real strong saddle
tock on the grass along the trail, with a feed of oats broncs as well as good driving h[...]osed During my many years in the saddle I worked
down. I recall those freighters w[...]men . Those lucky cluded a stampede of 1500 steers that didn't stop
enough to be hauling the many barrels of whiskey running one night when the thunder and lightning
n eded for the bar trade evaded the need of bar- spooked them until they w[...]although it was a
fill a jug, add water, replace the hoop, and go on very rare thing as the average camp wagon crew
their merry way.[...]le a herd if they got there fast enough.
In the ·pring of the year many of the state cow as a "rep" for the Long S with a roundup wagon be-
outfits would com[...]s to receive trainload longing to the Chevron (a John T. Murphy outfit, too)
shipment of cattle brought in over the "Q." There One time over toward the Missouri I was on a mis. ' •J 1
would be everal hundred head to a train, and the big or orthwest Cattle Co. There h[...]for a thousand head or more. us on the trail of the two suspects. One night we
Lot of day , one could see two or three hundred heard shooting in the far distance, but nothing ever
head of saddle hor e standing on Montana avenue, came of it. I left the Chevron that afternoon, but at
with bridle rein on the ground. Most of these herds night it got bitter c[...]looked for a better
w nt north to Judith Basin or the Milk River. The tent than a canopy of stars. Just before dark I came
Long alone ran about 20,000 head in the Big Dry to a small shack where a P[...]ing. They didn't want to keep me for the night, but
planned to ship th m as fives, but wou[...]me stay. When I asked for
at roundup time, o ome of them were six or seven food they gave me a bowl of cold rice. I noticed that
years old when shipped. I recall one roan steer one of them stayed awake all night, sleeping in turn
branded C that would slip past the nig1it guards, and if at all. In the morning I had another bowl of cold
g t back to his own horn range. We fin ally[...]rice. I don't think they had another bit of food in the
his carca s on th range-he was 15 years old, and[...]house. I later heard that they thought I was one of
w igh cl about th same as he did when he was five, the killers, and they were afraid to let me out of their
but his horns were longer. sight.
In the spring of 1906, I was riding with a "79"[...]when I became "domesti-
wagon, and we had a herd of 500 h ad. One night cated" although my years with my wife and the kids
w w r to mak a dry camp, but the Big Boss had w re happy and[...]arted to rain as we were making of it with plea ure (mixed with some trag dy). I
cam[...]th aisl , and my wife insists
thing, bedding- ome of the food and all our clothes that I a[...]way to dry them out. However, of organizations-The Masonic Lodge; the first Farm
we held the herd. On the fourth day with the help nion at Dean; a director of the Midland Production
of cowboys on saddl horses helping the regular Credit ssociation; a member of the Congregational
teams move th wagon through the mud, we man- Church; a memher of th Montana Stockgrowers and
ag d to reach drier ground. We really <lid mess up the Bear tooth Stock grow rs; a life mem h r of the
that country, doing all that tramping whil[...]

They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (198) THEY GAZED ON THE BEARTOOTHS 193

But I never forgot "Old Stub." He was a straw-
berry roan that I had wanted from the time I first saw
him perform, but couldn't own un[...]llings ·he fooled, I was riding high and easy
in the stirrups taking care of a touch of pleurisy, when
he doused his head and let loose. Unprepared, I hit
in the middle of a mud puddle and stood there while
some Billings[...]hed as he bucked and
snorted and squealed to keep the stirrups flying and
the bridle reins flashing. When he got through he
gave me the eye, stood still until I mounted him and
rode awa[...]it that
morning buck. We buried him in a grave in the Bull
Mountains and placed a sandstone slab on the mound
and "Old Stub" engraved thereon. He was a g[...]eed, nor such a disposition. He was a cow pony
to the last jump-a real he-man horse. I have oftimes
hoped that my friends saw me as a cowboy at heart
to the end."

(Editor's note: Although Fred Kirch was never
actually employed by the "79" he often rode with their
camp wagons as he helped sort out and turn to their
proper range the cattle belonging to the company he
represented or "repped" as it was called. During his
days with the Lehfeldt outfit he was constantly in
touch with crews from the "79".)

CHARLES E.
GRAY
Among the "79" hands about the turn of the cen-
tury was Charles E. Gray, who was born in Ka[...]a when h
was sixteen y ars old upon an invitation of Chari s E.
Davison, who at that time was handling the horse
section of the Montana Cattl Co. op rations. Gray
was a natural-born horseman, and an xc 11 nt rid r,
so he was assigned the job of hr aking cow poni s
for his n w outfit. Wh n th h[...]hen they separated, he mov cl to town , work d
in the quarry for a while and lat r as a paint r and
paper hang r. In his lat years b for r tirement, he
was one of the town' best bartender . He died on
April 21, 1944.

They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (199)[...]THEY GAZED O N THE B EA RTOOTHS[...]ances in the reported version of this storm, but the
One of tlie few remaining cowboys, who knew general concensus was that it was one of the worst
th cattle land of the turn of the century is Paul Case. to ever hit the region. It was during the short time
.\Ir. Case was born in 1882 in Cedar County, Missouri, Paul Case was a m ember of th e "79" crew and he told
ancl rcache<l a ranch[...]aged 18, where he this w riter of the destructive storm as he saw it:
learned the way of the bovine tribe. Down h ere he
ha<l \,·orked with a[...]"I saw this funnel-like cloud about six in the
wlie11 he came to Montana in 1911, he met his former evening from a mile or more distance . The wind was
pal , \,·ho was then handling th e Big[...]d I could see that it was hail- in fact I had
for the "79", and went to work for th em. He soon got a sizeable storm and plenty of trouble with my horse
better work a · a representative for other outfits, among where I was in the scant shelter of some tall sage-
them being the I\-, CK, an<l XIT. brush . When I reached the wagon I found complete[...]desolation wrought by the wind and hail which was[...]drifts two feet d eep in places, and some pellets the
size of pullet eggs. The string of horses had been[...]stampeded by th e storm and headed for the dry wash,
where they raced over the steep hanks and piled[...]up in a mass b elow, much th e same as the buffalo
clid when crowded by the Indian buffalo hunts over
the "jumps." Most of the boys were badly bruised,[...]some to a point of bleeding from the force of the
hailstones landing on the exposed portions of their[...]horses out of th e tangled mess. Many of the horses
went out the open end of the wash, shortly after[...]in this accident, of which several were killed during
the time and another dozen or more smothered or[...]crippled so as to b e of no furth er value."[...]"Wild Bill" Sutter said that the "79" incident, was
Pau l Case witnessed the 1!)11 hailstorm and near stamped e. as clos[...]had never seen a stampede as pictured in the movies.[...]during storms or other unusual occurrences,
doing the summer handling of 450 head of Woodard
cattle at the Trout Creek Ranch. His range is mostly[...]act and good riding had to be used in handling
in the rough hr ,ak · and narrow canyons that comprise th em, but most cowboys were aware of the dangers
this hig ranch, but Paul says: of a stampede, and were pretty careful not to do any[...]ction."
"Sure it's a lot rougher riding than the prairie,
sagebrush range of the old '79", but it does have its
advantages here. There is worlds of grass, lots of
water, shade galore, and b auty everywhere. It ta[...]NON E. "KID"
a pretty sure-foot d horse to follow the narrow trails POWERS
the mother cows hav surv ' Y ·<l through some of th e[...]Vernon E. Powers was hut a lad of fourteen when
timber and rocky canyons, hut moder[...]he hired out to "Peg" ! lendenhall , manager of the
fair fence ·, <lo s away with night-hawking and[...]sheep operations of the "79" on Painted Robe in 1900.
bedrolls. It's my g[...]erders, when Vern
TJIE JI ILSTOR. 1 OF 1911[...]hee<lled liimse1f into a joh as a flunk cy around the
One of the vagari("s of Dame ,. -atme that brought camp. "Vinegar Jim" was his hoss when the boy
misfortune to the ''79" dates hack to July 7, 1911, worked in the cook ten t, and H enry B. Drum , from
when two of their camp wagons were circulating in[...]neighboring claim, but employed hy th e "79", di-
the Lone Pinc area. One of these wagons, hossed b y rected[...]and on for six years, fr. Powers appeared for the
one of those rosion · of the hadlan<ls type, with steep seasonal summer work at eith er the "mule" ranch on
They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (200) THEY GAZED ON THE BEARTOOTHS 1[...]The hoppers had hatohed by the millions:
The rangeland was fast turning bare.
The "79" had to move to Big Dry[...]Made up the herd for the drive[...]Bill Murphy, son of old "John T."
Directed the route and the trail.[...]"Kettlebelly" cooked for the outfit-[...]ved my first chance at this game.

Big Coulee, or the sheep camp on "The Robe." Charlie Davison, Titu[...], Charley Gray and McGrew,
Tommy Powell, one of the earliest cowhands of
Four others wbose names I've forgotten.
the "79", who later operated the Powell Hotel in Rye-
A dozen in all in the crew.
gate was a great favorite of the young amateur stock-
man. When Powell started tel[...]All of the cowboys (grand fellows),
be real "dillies!" One of his favorite boasts was "See[...]day taught me some trick anew,
those hills along the Musselshell? They were just little[...]Until at the end of the riding,
hummocks when I first came here. Locomoti[...]I was doing the things they could do.
over there, was just a pimple on the flat!" "Tommi
was one of the 79'ers whose bragging almost made the
operations tremendous, and would have embarrassed Cropping an ear-dropping a dewlap;
the owners had an assessor been listening in on the Running a brand with a ring:[...]is kicks didn't mean anything.
When he became of age> Powers filed a home-
stead in Canada; but fo[...]y black In jun pony,
made it a point to return to the haunts of his Mid- With a Crow's foot emboss d on his hide.
night Smith relatives of early Stillwater days, or his A tough, faithful, fast little cayuse
more favorite memories of the spots he knew with Who'd come through in a tough roundup ride.
the "79".[...]That clung to th nd of the lin .[...]"Hey, Kid," peel a pail of potato s;
"Hey, 'Kid ," fill that canteen of mine.[...]"Hey , Kid,'' get a pot of beans r ady[...]le up tho corral pins
Day break; the remuda is in!
Get your horse sadd[...]Before the remuda comes round.

They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (201)196 THEY GAZED ON THE BEARTOOTHS

mess wagon full of good eating A bit rough, pe[...]And sometimes a little too dry.
From the cases of canned foods and products But such lov[...]hine. And hearts just as big as the sky.

Corned beef packed in fifty pound fir[...]ps too soon now,
Hams, salted and smoked to the bone. When I'm called to my fin[...]o long and too far from home. In the earmarks and brands of the Lord.

The cowboys enjoyed their best eating[...]ler, "Hey, Kid!"

One Saturday night, north of Billings -Jim Annin
Most of the boys went to town,
Leaving but three for "night hawking"
To keep the herd safe bedded down.

ig sensed the value of silence,
And barely tip-toed o'er the ground
So quietly his little calf-friends[...]ver guess he was around.

Away southwest in the moonlight
Battle Butte stood in silence alo[...]outline traced so distinctly
You could see the hard edges of stone.

Then dawn and the moonbeams collided.
Calves wakened and started to dine.
I gazed at the fat little rascals.
Gee Whiz, how I wished they were mine!

At last came the sad day of parting,
For here we had hit the new range.
A few fast days back to the homeland.
How ig and I hated that change![...]autumn,
Then came my moment sublime.
The envy of all of the school boys,
I had worked for the "7'¥'.

Since then I've run my own cattle,
And weathered the merry-go-round.
Sold yearlings for two hund[...]cents a pound!

But I've found no clan like the cowboys,
That compares with theJ merit or w[...]Honest, loyal, trustworthy, friendly
Truly the salt of the earth. "Kettlebelly" cooked for the outfit.

They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (202)[...]THEY GAZED ON THE[...]LEGEND "79" LANDS[...]6. The River Ranch[...]
They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (203)[...]In 1898 she had settled down in the Bramble H otel[...]ig Timber, but got angry and moved out. She
The most notorious lady who ever once made[...]w weeks
Columbu her home was Calamity Jane. Reams of until a young lady who claimed to be her daughter,
paper have carried stories of this famous Westerner., came to get her. The writer remembers her shortly
and never has there[...]and persons. A docu- residence in the "pest house" ( log shack where folks
ment purport[...]ases
Princeton, . Missouri, as her birthplace and the year were confined). This spot was[...]e was Martha Cannary, ac- from the path from the narrators home to the school
cording to this paper. Another biography g[...]arently friendly
birth as 1 60 at Fort Laramie to the Dalton family enough, but the tales that we heard about her had us
(he was a cavalryman at the Fort) with the name of "spooked" and we were rather ti[...]ent literature and research pro- of our trek to the seat of learning. She lived very
claims the fact that the 1852 date was the most real- frugally, buying scanty supplies from Dad in the Co-
istic.[...]ercantile Company store, but always paying
The picture presented herewith is about the era cash. Fire that fall had burned out the street between
when she pent two consecutive winters in Columbus. the old Calhoun & Adams barn and the new Mercan-[...]hauled to the pest house for the possible use of in-[...]visited Columbus for her last time. (In the John Simp-[...]are their impressions, also as school kids, of this[...]The most v1c10us crime in the records of the[...]15, 1938, the murderer was hanged in Columbus. This[...]was the only official ex cution of this type ever held[...]a sheepherder was found dead of a bullet wound in
the upper country, and there were traces of a rope[...]ars. 1896.
(Courtesy of Montana Historical Society) A digest of the crime, court proceedings and
They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (204)[...]THEY GAZED 0 THE BEARTOOTHS 199

other factors has been compile<l from The Columbus Occident Elevator, th ey f[...]d t\\'o mur-
ews files, and personal interviews of people who d ered occupants. Kuntz was b ·hind tl1e steering \\'h el
had close contact with the details of the crime. with his h ad. thrown back[...]tween th e seats. Both of the doors of th " ·levator
Frank Johnson was an itinera[...]ing for B . S. for th e Day" and on the oth 'r door "Gone to Colum-
Downer about 1928. He[...]<l mana 1 ed to ·1 ct out tlirougl 1 an-
ment to the ranch of John Melby, from whid1 place other[...]came back to this Robideau was one of those in the· storC' "'hen th<'
region and during the next nine years continued to hoy entered, and cPnter<:>d tlw implication of t" o
follow farm work. He marri ed a daughter of a size- "Okies", :\✓Ir. and ~frs. Hugh Downard who ,,· ' r ·
able family of a neighbor, and at the tim the cdme living at the time in the ahancloncd Hilly ol, hom '
ocurred, was living in the office building of the n 'ar H ensley ,reek, whil<' thl'y[...]ting a job
\Vheat Basin Lumber Yard, as he worked the with the Harris Cattle Company. \ \ ' lwn Ro hid au
lcGreevy-Maerk land on shares. He was the father dairne<l that tlwy had h<'en at !tis hous( • F ri<lay night.
of three children when the ki1lings took place, and a SherHf Fran[...]and lodged. in the olum hus jail. Robideau " ·a ·[...]brought to town and identified th •m as the h o who[...]lished a true alibi through Ross Lacl'y for man of
the cattle company who tat<'<l that he had loan <::cl[...]the Downar<ls a pail of syrup and some flour , and[...]had them for dinner guests the night tl1e mur<lcr \\·as[...]The officers nm turn ,cl tlwir attention to R obi -[...]deau. At the elevator tht•y found stubs of ·ix checks[...]'675, one of , hich had he<'n made out to Robid 'au[...]ut th paye s stat d that th ·y had no knowl cl 1 of[...]fter Hohideau had " idcntifi ,d ' the Downards on[...]p his fomil who had ·pent
The killer and a near-victim.[...]1 , littl arr ha<l r cover cl
tive reasons in the county jail in Billing . suff[...]maintain ·d his innocenc ' until J puty B njamin
the name us cl wh n he w nt b rserk that fata] night. stat ,d that h had good prints on the car, and , h ' 11[...]Robideau blurted out, "I did it. II ' wa yellO\ '
the murder the major on ' being financial str ss. H
was on of the many , ho had xperience<l crop fail-[...]my har , of 1 0 bushels ofThe first general knm leclg ' of th crim , as m , a ch ·k in tlw nam<' of ,moth ·r farmer, and I
brought to a group at the ~(ik' isscr store in \ \ h at ould c:a[...]I e later ·am to my
wh n oung Larry Kuntz cntncd the stor . H • , as p]ace with his[...]stopp ·d the car. ' ,o ahead and shoot me' h said.
The men started in cstigating an<l inside the I ·hot him through the hack of th , head and th •n

They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (205)[...]N TH E B E ARTOOTHS

. hot \I rs. Kun tz through the breas t. T he kid started permit such priests[...]not exceeding five ,
fighting, so I hit him with the gu n handle, a nd drove a· th e defendant shall name, to b e present at the
the car back to the elevator where I lef t it." executi[...]exp edi ent to witness the execution. But no other
The officers que ·tioned this confession, as to some[...]erson th an th ose listed shall b e p ermitted at the
detail , and drew their own conc:lu ions that, "R[...]same." But if th e "le tter of the law " was foll owed that
deau had forced Kuntz to write the checks, and had[...]re many p olice officers in town.
taken them from the hook. threatening Kuntz if he
reported thi incident. The Kuntz fami ly had planned The Columbus ~ews rep ort of the h anging, which
to attend a party at the Teel Lutgen home Friday took place in the W es Handy machine shed, reads:
night, and when Robideau aw the car star t an d turn "H undreds of curious Billings p eople had gath-
toward Columhu , he thought that Kuntz was going ered around the Yellowstone courthouse to witness
to the sheriffs office. He raced to the road, stop ped Robideau's removal. When he saw them he remarked,
the car ancl climb cl in. fter travelling towar[...]olumbus, I suppose. They
Basin. When he refused, the killing occurred . H e are all coyote h unters. W hen they get me in the
then brought the car hack to \\' heat Basin ancl drove trap , they will all go hom e." More th an 600 p eople
it into the elevator, where he heat the child (a part hacl ga thered around the site of the h anging, includ-
of the wooden stock was imhcdded in the hoy's skull) ing offi cer from all over[...]person we re in the b ig machine shed when the trap
Coming to Columbu · aturclay morning, the Emil was sprung. Robideau calmly climbed the 13 steps
\ lelhys found a bloody spot in the road just south to the trap, accompanied b y deputies Benjamin and
of the old tone school on Valley Creek. "There must[...]rect it to my wife and fa mily. I don't need it." The
Emil' reply. On examination they saw that a car[...]erty was proclaimed dead ."
hack to \Vheat Basin. The officers later c ·tablished The Ku ntz couple were not the only victim's of
this a the cene of the murder. (\ Ir. \ lelhy had been the Robideau revolver. fter his fingerprints had
manager of the International Elevator at \ \'heat Ba in been submitted to the FBI , inves tigation reveale d his
for ·ome time. \\'hen the Occident purchased it earlier part in anoth[...]Liberty, 1 , were arres ted
warning him that much of the grain was encumbered, for killing an a[...]shack near Wes t Beek-
Robideau was taken to the Yellow ·tone county mantow n, 'ew Yor[...]Pri on. On Novemb er 30, 1930, Joseph Liberty had
of first degree murdt>r, filed hy County Attorney Pa[...]·ferred to uburn Pri on, and on July 25,
Heily. The JudgP appointed E. \. Rlenkner and \ I.[...]working as a cook for
L. Parcells a attorneys for the defend rnt, who wa a road rang out. id[...]unable to hire paid counsel. Tlu:y entered a plea of \ Vhen confronted with th sc facts the pri oner
"not guilty", and a date for arraignment[...]asked that :\Ir . Robideau he brought to the Bi ll ings
December 11 . . t this time Robideau p[...]s . entenced for a 20 year term at Donnamorra
was the name u. ed in his clc'ath ntencc, which wa[...]usty and became a
following a 30-minute summation of the evidence and cook on the road gang, hut when a camp jealousy
court records. The sentence called for death hy hang- broke out hetwe ·n a couple of us, and it looked like
ing between the hour · of "1:00 , . , 1. and 11:00 P.;\-1., we might he returned to the prison, I made m
January 15, 19.3 ."[...]. horcsman, and later
That January I.5th was the husiest night Colum- worked in a box factory, hut the law was drawing
bus ever saw. The law reads, "The sheriff of the clo ·<'r, ·o I went \, est to \\'yoming. . fter a few
county must be pr sent at the execution, and mmt month<; , I returned to :\"cw York, hut ran into some
invite the presence of a physician, the county attorney folks who recogni,ed me, so[...]and came to thi<i ar<'a.''
him; and he shall, at the rc<111est of the defendant, Emil :\lclhy gave[...]

They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (206)[...]THEY GAZED ON THE BEARTOOTHS 201

pening that was recalled after the murder of the Gary , and the s w r made backwards. Th ro ·k wa
Kuntz couple. He remembered that the early morn- too heavy to carry, so[...]\\' · mov d
ing when "Frank Johnson" returned to the John Melby some of the other stones, however, and th oil s m cl
ranch, t[...]grav ." One
work in Wyoming, and had to walk all the way back possibl an ·w r.
to the ranch.[...]istory records that th r wa a battl in Hail-
The Billings Gazette carried a story that a taxi[...]Indians and som Park
driver had been murdered on the Poly road a few[...]r in on group ngag d in battle against
miles west of Billings during the same night Robideau[...]ng Piegan Indian . This involv d som
was walking. The Melbys wondered: "Could it have[...]mation , and th name
been that a person had hired the taxi driver to take[...]on ou ly.
him to a certain place, and then killed the cab man ,
Indians surely knew of thi landmark which could b
rather than pay the fare? The strange thing was that[...]en for many miles through th Lake Ba in , h cause
the cause of death was from a bullet of .38 calibre,[...]then" have been many Indian arrowhC'ads, som
the same as kil1ed the Kuntzes nearly eight years[...]"medicin rocks" round d out from som of the sand-
later, and this gun which Robideau claimed[...]stone pieces, and other indications that the redskins
was found by the officers where Robideau said he[...]! Th author got the story this way. In th lat
eighties, the stockmen of the Yellowston \ all y[...]for their valley us all the area covered by the drain-
HOW DID BATTLE BUTTE age basin of\\ bite Beaver, Keyser, Hensl ey and alley
GET ITS[...]creeks, and the "prominent andstone butt ahout[...]twenty miles north of Rapids was to form the north
This question has been asked many time[...]arlene Slydcr and myself made a trip Pnd of this "r r e" in 1 9, and th Thomas broth rs
to the top flat of Battle Butte. \ e turned o er a flat start[...]Butt ar a,
rock, which was at one end and on top of a big pile on land th y had purcha cl from the railroad (utiliz-
of sandstone rock , re embling some early day grave ing, of cours th in-h tween s ctions ), om friction
(to keep wild animal from the bodi ). John . John- arose h twe n these intrucl r. and 10-y ar-olcl . tah-
son of Billing had b en told that a battl betwe n two[...]9" operation. Th "79' rid rs saw to it that
tribe of Indians had tak n place here, but I am in-[...]crate' th grass that had h n
din d to think that the gra e was of a \ hit man . n their hPretoforc, and c[...]h re was " riting and number , and giving the h rd r th "hum' ru h," if th y even
hard to decipher, but we could make out the name of approach cl so-called "79" rang<'. \Vh[...]" B TILE B iTTE"'-PR0'-11 'E7'T L "D\I RK OF THE L KE 8 11' RF

They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (207)202 THEY GAZED ON THE BEARTOOTHS

murders, there was constant embarrassment to the
newcomers, and one case of a sheep wagon being
hauled and dragged for nearly a mile at the end of
lariat lines attached to the saddles of four or five
cowboys. The fact that in a final settlement between
the "79" and the sheep men, resulted again in naming
this landmark as one of the determining boundaries,
may have given birth to the name "Battle Butte."
Tom Busteed and Alfred Christensen were aware
of the engraved sandrock and cairn atop the Butte.
An Irish herder by the name of Finney was working
with the "79'' when they were in the sheep business
about 1907 (and he was credited with killing the last
wolf in Lake Basin) and later went to work for Al
Thomas. He used the Butte as a sentry post from
which he could watch his flocks, and by way of en-
tertainment built a big "sheepherder's monument" on
the flat surface of this formation. This was visible for
miles and en[...]ed
that Finney had chiseled his own name and date of
carving on one of the larger rocks, and was rather
proud of his achievement. Which could be answer
number three. When the Teddy Roosevelt Campaign Train visited Columbus[...]of trout for the President's breakfast. This picture was used[...]a month later in "The Youth's Companion" in an ad for[...]AY TO the Stillwater, upstream from the Midnight Canyon
CATCH A FISH! camp. He drove down to visit the lower camp gang,
Smart people have learned that when it comes and saw the fish in the basket and wondered how
to fishing there many times arise questions of doubt they were caught. Annin was chopping kindling and
as to veracity in both the method of fishing, and the said, 'Al, there's nothing to it.' We merely stun 'em,
size of the catches in numbers, and individual di- like the concussion of hitting two rocks together-
mensions. Sometimes the Izaak Walton has a novice can even use an axe to do the job. Come on, I'll
for a listener and can spin a very gullible yarn, as show you.'
witness the following account from The Columbus "They went up the river until they were near
ews of many years ago: the rock where the trout were cached, and Jim sug-
" nother d al that involved the famou Harlan- gested that it was a likely looking place for trout.
Annin corn bination of fishermen, resulted in a fan- He waded out and made a swing with the axe against
tastic story. A group of Columbus sport men had the rock, kicked up a lot of water, and sneaked one
gone for a week-end party at their camp near Mid- of the trout out of the recess, and emerged from the
night Canyon. While breakfast was being pr pared[...]y rod and moved upstream Thrice more did the agile nimrod make this maneu-
to "pre-view the morning fishing, but didn't take his ver, then came to the bank with the four finnies,
basket. Half way in mid tream was a larg boulder, which he gave to his guest with the admonition that
wherein the rosion of wind and weather had hol- trout tast d[...]killed this way, rather
lowed out a deep rec s in the rock. Fishing was than bled and bruise[...]had caught four fi h, which he put "At the Smith camp, Charlie was just bending
in the pocket of the rock, before he decided to ease his lbow when the Chicagoan returned and excitedly
his yen for pancakes and campfire smoke, and stuff. related the incident. Harlan recognized the trout as
He told the boys about the catch and told them to his foursome, di[...]ulbau r's gullibility.
in that area and recovered the four, which just com- "This was, of course, not new technique. When
pleted filling hi[...]1 fose brought th children out of Israel, they found
" . L. Hau]bauer a promot[...]k water and th y chided Mos s
here to investigate the re-opening of the Columbus who cried to the Lord saying 'what shall I do unto
stone quarry. H[...]to tone me.' nd
tation to spend a week at the Dr. Smith cabin on the Lord said unto Moses, 'Go on before thy people,

They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (208) THEY GAZED 0 THE BEARTOOTHS[...]neck. l had the jump on the buck, and h tart d[...]to pa me, hut th whi tie of my winging I riat[...]toward the deeper part of the lak with m in hot[...]and thought I could catch the pronghorn wh n h[...]wat"r, and the big spla h and di tanc had him out
of r ach. I didn't want to chase him a I had too[...]ight a cinch on my horse. But as I look cl across the
lak , I noted a coupl of cowboys on th~ir hors s,
watching the proc edings. They got their rop loos-[...]ened and ready and spread out o that the antelop[...]Which is just exactly what he <lid. The boys do ed in[...]the slippery shore lin in three or four jumps and[...]with his rope, but missed the lusive buck, but they
thought the antelope would he so tired they could[...]John Conant. They ·aid th hath in the lake had ju t
cool d Ir. Ant lop off, and the farther they went,
the more distance he put between them.-Arnott Boyd.[...]THE FOURTH OF JULY
and take , ith thee of the Iders of Isra I and thy[...]AUTO RACE - 1916
rod, wherewith thou smote t the ri er, take in thine One of th mo t promi . ing v nt for excit m nt
hand and[...]tand b fore thee there in th 1916 Fourth of July c I hration in olumbu ,
upon the rock in Horeb; and thou halt smite the wa an auto race which start d at th old I vator
rock, and there hall com , at r out of it and thy building in b arok e and nd d on the traight-away
people may drink.' nd ,. loses did o, in ight of after turning ast at th Jenkin Ranch, to th Y llow-
the lders of I rael. Exodu ; Chapter 17; ers 3-6. t ne Bridg . It wa a m asur cl cour of I.'3 mil .
The board of count comm1 10ner had agr d to
"Jim had mere[...]n hour in orcl r
rod, and deli er cl food in tcad of drink!" to permit a total of 12 car · to ent r th ra , and thu
k ep the track cl ar for th conte tants.[...]a , 50 prize for th winner. Th ra was
OF A A TELOPE[...]n to get th ir watche timed to th
cattl out north of the Big Lak and rode up on a minute, and he wa aL o the judg at th fini h. Ira
knoll for a better view of th water. I aw a big buck Whitney and[...]tart r , and
antelope feeding out on a neck of land that e ·tended three men w re tationecl at thr e mile int rvals who
in to the Jake about a quarter mile long and 200 fe t also recorded the time wh n on of th cars , O\l]d
wid at it<; wide t place. but had one narrmv neck of pas that particular . tation . The road id was pr tty
land about twenty fret acrm . I had alway<; wanted to , 11 . prinklecl hy car. of spectators whil other took
rope' an antelope. and here- wa. my chance. I got vantage point on the rnriou hill. and knoll from
back out of -;ight. cinched the saddle- a little tighter. which the race-track could he se n for on or more
got do,,·n my rope . and ma<lP a nm for the narrow miles.
They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (209)204 THEY GAZED ON THE BEARTOOTHS[...]sday afternoon, Chalk dropped ,£,
the flag and Bob \Vestover roared away from the 1t ;[...]1
starting line in his powerful Packard. ear the Syl- ~p[...]1.,. :~
vester I lalf-Way Ranch, the machine started throwing j

off giant clouds of smoke, and Bob pulled into the
·ide roa<l. . n oil line had broken off, and the hot oil
on the motor was nearly i 1 nite<l, before he finally go[...]Morrison, driving his
racing tutz. I le c.:rossed the finish line at 4:19, ex-
actly 16 minutes for the 13 miles. Tom Mulvihill later
razzed the committee about letting anybody get in the
race. "This ~[orrison had a date to play golf in Bill-
ings" ays "TP'', .. o he paid the $5 bucks rather than
wait an hour. Just sauntered down the road at his
usual speed, won the damn race, and didn't stop to get
the prize money.'' The tutz Bearcat was the only
car to finish.
I Lo t clwr. with Henry Snyder as his riding
companion, was to · ing up lots of dust, and had the
fastest time at the three stations that clocked him. He
negotiated the first treacherous turn on the Shane
Creek corner ·, hut failed at the second. The car, a
big Ca e, werved into the barrow pit, lashed through
a fence, and flattened[...]s computed time would have been 14 minutes.
The '"townie" favorite wa Johnny Calhoun, driv-
ing a souped-up Velie, and had Ru sell Bracewell in
the seat along ·ide him. These boy had thoughtfully[...]h wiJJow poles!
filled up their tail end with all the linotype pigs in
The olumhus 1 • ws shop, plu 400 pounds of and[...]tember l to May 1, no limit.
John wung around the curve near th Kem (Gauthier)[...]y I fountain goats or sheep limited
place to crcn the ditch there, the weight hifted and
to ix for the open s a on ptember 1 to January l.
the rear end skidded, causing a punctur , which im-[...]For bull or mal elk, limited to the killing of two dur-
m diat ly ·ausc<l a broken wheel. The proud Velie
ing the month of eptember and October. Fish may
came to rest on it[...]by youn , nyd r, when th ase w nt
through the fence. Tlw race proved two thin -one
that the roads weren't a · bad as a lot of up-country
folk claim cl inasmu ·h a they tood o[...]a , 50 prize
wa. n't worth tht> wear and tear on the driver and the
car .-Jim nnin, chajrman of the th of July ommit-
tee, 1916.

ccording To Tr[...]l. \V. . Baker. C. rnold (bankeT ),
the season is September 1 to D c mber 1, with[...]

They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (210) THEY GAZED ON THE BEARTOOTHS[...]Dedicated
About the first thing J. B. nnin learned when[...]ilt through
he came West in 1887, was the proper use of firearms. Stillwater ount Poir[...]to use them def nsi ely, but a far as north-of rh cl a ·on-
i[...]got
with a fishing rod, and follow d this type of recr a- busy and wh n th n w hri s n
tion all the years of his life in Montana. He took full little town , things really hoo ·t
advantage of the Stillwater River and the str ams in Very f w cars wer aroun n
the area around Columbus to test his skill as an officially "cut-ribbon ed" for tr
angler. The story from the Tri-County ew on the
preceding page gives some id a of the fishing and
hunting in those days.[...]Lots of oal
\ ith th scarcity of timb r for wood in th Lak[...]ar h for coal. Th y found om of thi fu 1 in v-
eral parts of th n rth ide,, ith th b t quality com-[...]
They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (211)[...]THEY GAZED ON THE BEARTOOTHS

reaching a vein of coal that extended some ten mil s Ray Guthrie Pack Trip
through the l\ ye region. Probably the first vein was 1952
tapped on the south side of the river by the Albert-
ons in tlw early 90s, but later explorat[...]d a While Stillwater County boasts of some fine dude
harder, hottt'r strata on the north side of the stream. ranches, ther are also a few people who provide pack
The Riddle, SerrPtte, Stanley, chwenneker, Garroute, trips and guide s r ice into the rugged primitive area
and other families took turn at mining the coal, and of the tillwater and Rosebuds. Ray Guthrie is on e,
thousands of tons wt-re taken from the mine , for use who outfits at 1\ye. A[...]lly p ro-
in husirn·ss lwust•s, homes and most of th chools of vide "camp meat" (in season), and the guests oftim es
the surrounding area.[...]r in
Columbu to welcome home th ir r turning on . The
hoy , ·till fre. h in performance marched their pace
in clo e order drill ; whil bu 1-Ier sounded all the
army calls. Barhecue, fir orks, raffle , ambling,
<lan -ing-all this.

The hinaman and
Th Bear
J o Kern ·s st:'nse of humor i · po · ·ihly re pon ·ible
for the original story of th hinaman and h ar.
fr. Kern maintains that there were a f w Chine e
min r. in the new minin, ·ettl m nt of 1 y in the
late '80s. Om· day one of them wand red from Cc mp
to look th ar a ov r, fo[...]ar had just
m rged from its winter hib rnation. The Ori ntal
rcver eel tlw fit·ld and took off for c[...]a ambling along lowly, niffin at
th footprints in the ·now. Wh n h looked up and
saw the Chinaman lw started along the path a littl
fast •r.[...]K TRIP,
"You lika them tracks?' thought the mar, , ·TIH.! Il 1[...]

They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (212)[...]THEY GAZED O N THE BEARTOOTHS 2[...]mas Trees picnics. On of th p ak crowds was in 1916, wh n
Instead of Game the population of that ar a was at its heighth, and an[...]Laying of Rail[...]One of the rich st influ nces to hit the Lake
Basin country was the con truction of the orth rn[...]the villag s of folt and Wh at Ba in in between .[...]when the nited tat s got into the fracas , materials[...]and manpower got ev n scare r, so the work was
delayed, and the first train didn't get to Rapelje until[...]Sam Andrew Grove For
Fourth of July Picnics
When the home teaders forced the ''79'' cattle to
other ranges, a favorite recreation ground wa found
on the old Sam Andrews spread, one of the first home-
stead sites on the White Beaver . atural clump of
trees, a lov I spring and running water mad it a
wonderful gathering place for the July ourth , or fall
They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (213)[...]THEY GAZED 0 THE B E ARTOOTHS[...]"Joe Kern is authorit-y for the statement that
graves, some marke<l hut others ca[...]twen ty years ago this winter there was a coating of[...]snow three feet d eep all over the flat along the
he solved st•(-rd of death. One of the identified head- Yellowst one. Several herds of antelope were to be
stonl's is that of Lizzie \\ ylie, whose fa ther was a dirt- fo und in the shelter of the hills, probably unwilling
moving contractor for the Northern Pacific wh n the[...]severe snow since that winter, although the winter
in the vicinity of Columbus. The crews were camped of 18 6-87 was a cattle killer . But this snow was s[...]far melted by F ebruary 17th that the Yellowstone
at I [enslcy Creek when the fiftee n-year-old girl died[...]oke up, and a considerable ice gorge form ed near
of scarlet fever , and was buried in a field half a the site of Stillwater. Great cakes of ice were heaved
mile north of the rai lway track . The tilted tone still several feet into the air and high along the banks
remains alongside a count ry road, carrying the dates by the tremendous pres ure of the gorge. It was this
1867 -188:2.[...]same year that the last buffalo in this vicinity was[...]killed near the present H erman Witt ranch, about a[...]mile east of town."[...]To John Lynch goes the honor of landing the first[...]plane in the L ake Basin area, shortly after World[...]W ar I. Today the Lake Basin country has many "fly-[...]ing" farmers who use the fin e landing strip for their[...]fas t emergency trips to the county seat. The Vance[...]the local airport and some fifteen business and pro-[...]fe ·ional men of th town own their own planes or
011[...]
They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (214)210 THEY GAZED 0 THE BEARTOOTHS

t as THE LEGEND
till Water
on th naming of " tillwater"
OF THE WIRE GOLD
for 'a.~ given ome credence in The "p ot of gold at the end of the rainbow"
the early <lay , hen mall ho t w r u ed in the (more frequently referred to as "an easy buck") has
tran portdtion of upplie ·. When one of these boats been one of man's dreams since the world began.
cap ·iz d, ac:c:or<lin to ol. 11 n's m moir , they Every nook and corner of the universe has been
lot ~ vcral ke , of whi key, which were later found eagerly explored in the search for minerals, oil,
by . ome row Indian on th Stillw ter. One of jewel , coal, timber and other natural products sale-
the braves got the i<lea that there was a fountain able to the human race.
of the fir w t r high in the mountain , so th y started
up ·tr am to the our e of the eli ir. They tasted the Very few areas have taunted and invited man to
riv r liquid ry f w mile , until they reached the the lure of the dim trails that lead to sudden wealth
la t lake wh re the riv r had it , source. There they than ha the Beartooth Mountains. The mining ven-
tried th ir la!)t ample. It wa not their cherished ture of the old ye City and Cooke together with
dr am of firewater: it was "still water." the hundreds of claims staked by seasoned prospectors
from the Boulder to the Clark's Fork; the oil wells
Bapti mal At Molt[...]and West Rosebud; the coal mines above Beehive;
One of the mall tream that drained into the and Picket Pin Lumber Company-all proje[...]ding out
water to pro id a bapti mal cer mony for the anything. Electric railroads, steam lines and better
church goer of the Molt area. Rev. rthun was in routes of transportation have come into the picture
charg .[...]t Red Lodge> Columbus, Reed Point
fter lunch the am crowd a embled to see and Big Timber-all supposed to tap the hidden riches
th Molt " ountry lub" ba ball player take on of the Beartooths and ironically all still in the blue-
and defeat a group from over Broadview way.[...]D Y MOR I G 8 PTI M L OF THE H RCH T MOLT.

They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (215)[...]THEY GAZED ON THE BEARTOOTHS[...]hi fatb r, although h kn 'w that som of th sp i-[...]men pi ces had fallen into th l ands of M j r m1-[...]id a struck him. \ hy not an xpedition of his ownr[...]and J udg oddar<l , an arly attorney of that town ,[...]prosp <.:tor \ ith a good story and in n cl of a grub-[...]learned that a ampl of wir · gold had actu lly come
into the hanch of som row ·, and al o that its source[...]was one of th Ros ,bud canvon . B. F . P arson o-[...]In addition to the two Billings m n, Fr d Inabnit,[...]a Swiss who knew his , ay in the mountains volun-[...]t ered hi ervices. In olumbu , the olumbus Mer-[...]for tock in the cliff of , ire gold. R. 0. Morris, who[...]had al o heard of th fabulou gold wa to pro ide[...]hor s for the pack job. Tommy Jon , a settler in
the East Rosebud anyon was to go along as the man[...].\fountain in background were uppo ed to be the source of the had for many y ar trapp d in thes mountain ,[...]. Pr tty F ather, no, pa t 35, in i ted
One of the mo t fantastic and exciting of the e on a pal of hi · from th rO\ g ncy a a m m b r
day dreams wa Pretty Feather and hi tory f the of the party and a claimant in th pro e<l of th
\. ire gold. Pretty Feather was not th real n m of trike. r tty F ath r wa · to have on -third f the
the Indian a he wa from a lar 1 family of th row arning - h didn't[...]Lat " i
acti e participant should know anything of th plan . ha · camp ong Lak . i i
Pretty F ath r \. a a boy of about fourt en \. h n man along to[...]\. ith th la ting pow of
on a fur-hunting trip. Far up in the h ad at r wh re d na and a manual rock dri1l outfit; Inabnit and
the only trails " re mad by animals, th pair cam[...]o kamp from Bil-
upon an outcropping l <lg of quartzit , through \. hi h Jin ;[...]uck" (a th ian
ran thread-lik 'tr ak ofof th in, laid bar by the lippage of a g- right to cm imag th
ment of the cl po it, \.\. a about ten f t deep and forty tock of upph 1 ju ,''
feet long but it wa · a minut part of the leclg that " hi h prov d t[...]r cl Inabnit who w in charg of th op ration,
s 1f laboriou ly broke off a fe, pound of th a ail- mad , final r port o[...]th
rcser ation h adc1uarter near , b arokee, whcr the ", t the Ro bud Lak cabin, r tty F ath r
old man ponder cl[...]trik s •cmed pretty sure of the 1ocation and wa "~r
known, and of the grcclte ·t financial gain to hims If,[...]y packs- Ilwn.· wer<' no trail. and
,·ened ,rnd the father died betore he did anything with gcttrng t hro11gh the q11,1'king asp thicket and under-
hi secre[...]
They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (216)[...]THEY GAZED ON THE BEARTOOTHS

to he ford cl veral time , due to steep cliffs on either The country was completely unfamiliar!
·id', and fi[...]The wire gold ledge must have been in the
reconnoitering. In pla the trail over projecting[...]West Rosebud canyon!
outbr ak.- of rock wa o st ep, that an emergency
corduroy path had to be built. The men were a week He emptied what was left of a pint of whiskey,
getting to the head of the fourth lake, b eautiful Rain- panicked, and raced off down the trail alone!
how Lake. lier a fine camp was laid out, and the And then it started to rain, as the three remain-
party dcc:idccl to rest and investi[...]ing m en tried to take back to the camp the essen-
Pretty Feather was all exci tement.[...]ain speed was
day ·, he said, would take them to the cliff! And he impossible, a[...]erable early September
guzzled more than his shar of whiskey! rainy days later found them with the rest of the
The next mornin the wrangler came in and party. Pretty Feather and Buck had left the base
rcportPd that one of the horses was down with camp the same night that the former had returned
pneumonia (he died later) an[...]twisted after abandoning the party at Sun Dance Creek.
a ·IIO<.' on the rocky trail. They decided that four of
The trying part of the trip was ahead. First of
tit<.· party would take a light pack and go on a[...]all, the party was sorely depressed with the com-
to find the place, and outline a trail. They could[...]plete failure of the venture, which made every trivial
back-track for[...]chore become a giant task. The rain persisted daily
and acljnst the load of the two horses.
and the loads became wet and soggy, sleep was al-
Inabnit, Jones, Pretty Feather and one of the most impossible, and the two horses under heavy
other Billing · men tarted up the trail. Uncle Billy packs tired on the slippery trails, despite the fact
took hi : gold pan and te ted some of the sands at that the six men, including 75-year-old Uncle Billy,
the head of the Jake, as well as two small streams[...]ights because they did not
that flO\-ved into it. The other three were to try to want to leave valuable materials behind. Some of
get deer, ·ome grouse or other fresh game or fish, the essential supplies were getting short, and fish
f[...]became a staple item on the bill of fare.
The fir t night out the four explorers camped Seventeen days from the time they left, the six
at the mouth of what is probably Hell Roaring, and remaining members of the expedition saw the most
from herP Pretty Feather was quite sure that the beautiful sight in the world-the old Armstrong cabin
e\:posed l dge wa near the confluence of Sundance half a mile away on the East Rosebud Lake.
reek and th e Ea t Ro ebud River. The second
ni 1 ht out he didn't know for ure. Upon arising the And apparently waiting for them was tl1e crip-
next morning he climbed up to the top of a small pled horse who h[...]oking around. at the Rainbow Lake Campi

The tagecoach Race at bsarokee
One of the thrilJing atlra<.tions at n b,, rokee celebration on July 4th in the early -0 wa a taiecoach rut· . \ hat hud promi e[...]e cont tant affair finalJy immered down to two at the fini h line. bout 3,000 sp ctator aw arnie Hud on, who had hooked
up a couple of hi buck-r ke team , win the race by a cant margfo, as Di k Louk wung the bullwhip wM le Earnie handled the line .
Bill Straight and his on piloted the other four-hor e runner .

They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (217) THEY GAZED ON THE BEARTOOTH 213

THE BRIDGER - BOZEMAN TRAILS
One of the most interesting (and sometimes con- of Stillwater i the main tillwat r; mmil' Fork 1.
troversial) subjects of discussion and research is the Bridg r Cr k.
route of the overland trails surveyed and located by
both Jim[...]'s Fork to Rocky reek, 9 mil s. Th ro <l
County. The year was 1866. is[...]e xc pt two dry crossing which
Both men had the same objective-to find a short
and safer route to the western Montana gold fields,
and then on to Salt[...]ine, Utah.
Both men had started from forts along the orth
Platte in 1863, followed the old Oregon Trail into
Fort Laramie. They both then turned north, with Fort
Smith, on the Big Horn, their next objective, but by
different routes. Their competitive paths crossed again
just west of the town of Bridger, and from there to
the Bridger Creek confluence, the same route was
used by both parties. A small party from the Bozeman
group, however, did continue on down the Clark's
Fork to the Yellowstone, and tied into the old Lewis
and Clark, and later Stuart route near Laurel, then
followed up the Yellowstone to rejoin the main Boze-
man crew at the mouth of the Boulder River. (The
Rand-Mc ally map of around 1880, shows the Boze-
man Trail to Laurel.
Quite a few residents of the south side of the
county are familiar with this pioneer trail. The oldest
of these, however, were the kids that used the newer
roads built up the Stillwater River and the Absarokee-
Dean- ye loop about 1885 hen the ye City mining
project was on. At this time the old Bridger Trail
was plainly visible, and even a stretch of it u d by
the newcomers. Even today the trail do n the st ep
hillside where it joined anborn Creek is cl[...]and not s k pt b th
Bridg r party further detail the rout . r port om-
piled from various diari of olonel arrington,
olonel av er, and the odom t r mea ur m nt of
General Haz n in 1 66 with r f r nc to thi county,
gen rall agree ith the timates of the xplor rs.
In submitting that portion of th r port that
appli s to the till\J ater ounty stretch of trail are
the present names of th creeks as compax d to tho
in the r port. Rocky For i Rock reek; B rden'
reek is R d Lodge re k- outh Fork of Ro bud is
Butch r Cr k; Ro ebud Ri r is Ea t Ros[...].OL. J. J.
\: at r Fork of Ro bud i \ t Rosebud; ·orth Fork ol. All n wa an authority on loution of Hrid1wr- Bozeman Trail .

They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (218)214 THEY GAZED 0 THE BEARTOOTHS

are not definitely bad. Clark's Fork i nearly 100 The Bozeman-Jacobs Trail and the Jim Bridger
yards wid ', with a rich valley and abundance of grass Trail parted again near the mouth of the Shields
and water. River. The Bozeman Pass Trail went thru on the route
of the present orthern Pacific to Bozeman. The
Rocky Fork to B ·rclen·s Cre k, 12 mile .[...]Bridger Trail went up the Shields River, turned west
stream i. 45 yards wid[...]at Brackett Creek, thence into the Bridger Fork of the
with good ford. Luxuriou · timber and grass, 10[...]East Gallatin River into Bozeman. This was the trail
from mountain .[...]originally used in bringing the first cattle to the "79"
Hcr<len's Creek to outh Fork of Rosebud, 10 range in this county.
mile[...]The old Bozeman-Miles City stage line followed
,reek[...]very clo ely the original trail of Lewis and Clark. It
ber and gras abundant.[...]was just north of the Yellowstone as it weaved its
·outh Fork of Rosebud to Rosebud River, 8 way through Stillwater County up the valley until
miles. Three mile · up Berden' Creek. Rough road reaching the mouth of Berry Creek, near Merrill,
until the main clivi<lc is reached, b e tween this creek when it veered off into the hills, crossing the two forks
and outh Fork of Rosebud. Stream about 15 feet of White Beaver, over the divide into Sweet Grass
wiclt> and two feet deep[...]Creek, thence on to Big Timber and Bozeman, via the
:rnss good, hut only sufficient timber for fuel. Road John Bozeman Pass. The old stone building now
run· six miles from mount[...]occupied by Burton Smith, over the line into Sweet
Crass County, was the only "fort" on the line from
To Rosebud River camp, 6 miles. D[...]ogh to Living ton, that was actually used as
Fork of Ro ·ehud one mile; thence cro sing a divide.[...]bud four miles to
be 't camp. bout 10 miles from the mountains.

To tillwater W .. W., 6 mile . Road crosses the
main Ro ebud and follows up Stillwater Fork of Rose-
bud. Good road, timber heavy and gras good.[...]J •

rocky ford. bout si'< mile from the mountains.

To Emmil' Fork l mile . The road run · \ .. W.
to ·orth Fork of till water. ra s and timber very
h avy, and cam[...]tone River. Emmil' Fork,
name<l from th ma ·acre of Emmff · party in 1 22
i about 20 f et wide and 1[...]Hebard a co-author, i
thi brief comment: .. outh of th Y llow ton Ri r
no citie of great import nee ha c m into exi t nee.
Ther are[...]ton. Boz man and Li ing ton are th
mo t important of citi along the trail from th
• -orth Platt to irginia City.[...]ITY

mong oth r mall towns in th r gion of the Thi, rod( building i• much tht'[...]t>lt"t1. fn lht· rt'mndt>linl( 10mt" lininl(, on the wall
Boye.I , Fishtail , hsaroJ.. ·c, pringdalC' and Ilot ~• t'rt' l opit>, of nt>w•vapt>r of lht> t•,irlie t fontuna dny•, pur-[...]

They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (219)[...]im . Hor
Long before cars became so popular, the hustling and buggy, hayracks[...]fun-loving homesteaders eagerly sought all kinds of m an of tran portation, and a · upl hun r d ball
enterta[...]d oft n a m I for hm ·h and
and lots of baseball. There were six baseball clubs[...]
They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (220)[...]TH E Y G A ZED ON THE BEARTOOTHS

Park City Boasted of Good Bands

T op (HH O) left to[...]

They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (221)THEY GAZED ON THE BEARTOOTHS 217[...]
They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (222)218 THEY GAZED ON THE BEARTOOTHS

STILLWATER COUNT[...](EDITOR'S OTE)

In the next two chapters of Volume II of "They Gazed on The Beartooths"
there is much plagarism. These[...]t in a diary form, and it was not until 1893 that The Still-
water Bulletin editor prevailed upon[...]might enjoy these writings. Since then, upward of fifty such items have appeared
in The Tri-County ews and The Columbus ews. ln 1929, this hardy and
inter[...]a book, "Jirah lsum Allen," and a limited edition of 200 copies were
printed.
Some 53 years ago, another local author marketed a book of poems, "Rhymes
From The Rangeland," this book being more or less the biography of the life,
emotions and moods of Wesley Beggs. Again the edition consisted of 300 books,
a goodly number of which were never sold and finally destroyed.
tillwater County had a third writer of books, in the person of William T.
"Uncl Billy" Hamilton, who narrated his "Sixty Years On The Plains" to a Park
City new paper couple, an[...]ry few years ago,
thi book was reprinted by the University of Oklahoma Press, and is again avail-
able in many book stores.
The 11 n and B gg books are all but extinct. Copyrights have expired and
the publi bing firm ate not at all interested in revi ing the matter. For this
rea on w hav I ct d what we thought mo t valuable from each of these two
book , fe ling that for a hort tim at least, this literary portion of our pioneer
days, would not b r legat d to the garbag pit of ternity. Our apologi s, if
we are guilty of a crime.

They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (223)[...]ere Columbus, Montana
poetry was a favorite hobby of "Col." Allen, and Rests
some papers date back to the late 1880s. However, (1912)
none of his nearly 100 poems were printed until 1893,[...]It rests in the vale like a b ird in its nest,
when The Stillwater Bulletin used them. With the[...]y hills that in verdure are dress d
establishment of the Tri-County ews they became And evergreen trees and pines tall and grand,
a monthly item-the last appearing in The Colum- That for hundreds of years will guardians stand;
bus ews in 1920. From his vast array the following To shield the fair vale from the thundering foe,
have been selected to show his diversity and poetic When it strikes the t;all guards a staggering blow;
talent. But the vale only smiles in the dark king's face,[...]Beneath a bright rainbow, beholds the clouds fly[...]And lists to the whimsical song floating free,
Of the river's sweetheart on her way to the sea.[...]The buffalo, the elk and deer to the vale[...]But have vanished like leaves the cottonwoods shed
nd here came the Indian illage to camp
Wh re tr line along by the river's low bank,[...]am y Ip of coyote and the hippoorwill cry.[...]In tead of prickly p ar and ag -bru h and trail,[...]Th r ar dw Hing of fram , of bri k and of ston[...]nd quarry of and tone of we t rn r no n
nd hoolhou and id walk th prid of th town,[...]The n w from afar and around wh r w cl, II.[...]
They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (224)220 THE Y G AZE D ON THE BEARTOOTHS

Along The Yellowstone ow, useless res[...]invade, and wild winds blow,
Thro' mis t of the years departed, And thunder rolls[...]With horse and rifle we'd go
Hunting the antelope, They sacrificed his war horse where he died;
Or running the buffalo; Beside the tree and stream its bones decay,
Or ride the hill and coulees, 'Mid sod and weeds, the fragments bleached and dried,
Where plenty of deer would be; Lie scattered and slow mouldering away.
nd bands of wolve and coyotes, When night's gr[...]And stars, like distant camp-fires, dot the sky
nd lowly at eve returning, Comes cry of whip-poor-will, and hoot-owls call,
l[...]range, like phantoms lie.
We'd camp among the willows[...]Above his grave, and chant of deeds he's done;
While thinking was lulle[...]n skins, their dusky shadows creep
By the river's monotone,[...]nd woke at dawn to journey
long the Yellowstone. They've left him, like his fathers were of old,
' ow the iron-hor e goes puffing Bedecked in tribal trappings of his race,
II watered and fired an'[...]trophies, marred by dust and mould,
nd the "Con" punche tickets mid the moss-grown splendor of the place.
Of pa engers young and old; The leafless boughs will bend and sway o'er him
nd sound of engine whistle When winter'[...]d vale, And bleak winds whine around the burdened limb
And the bell rings a warning Where, undisturbed, he waits the Master's will.
To clear the iron trail.
We ride today in a Pullman,
nd eat in a dining car,
While over the rails we roll The Indian Charge
With never a jolt or jar,
nd fields and homes of ranchers, On the plains of Old Dakota,
nd citie of brick and stone, There s[...]Sweet bright grasses waving,
long the Yellowstone. Gay[...]nd the western sky is sending,
I ts treams of yellow gold,
An Indian Grave Far across the wide domain;[...]ble haft, inscribed above low mound,
Records the name and date o'er Indian grave; On the plains of Old Dakota,
In tead, an aged tree, low-limbed and sound, Gone the glory known;
A living temple, wherein sleep a brave. When the broad prairie,
Was the Indian's own
There, ceasele s, flows a mountain stream along, nd the buffalo herds roamed
With drowsy tun , past cottonwood and pine, The wide waste of land,
nd willows bend, as if to list the song, Free as the wild wind;
That ripples on beside the airy shrine. Countless and grand.
Soft golden rays illume the temple fair,
There the Old Missouri
nd shadows flit from limb and[...]By rain and melting snow,
bout the silent form reposing there,
ends a flood of driftwood,
' eath fairest dome upreared above the dead.
winding with the flow;
Hi peopl have en brined him in their love nd the water · of the river,
On couch of boughs, arrayed for spirit land, re sweet a · th y ar free,
\, ar-bonn t on, of eagle feathers wove, But hold! !11 tell a tale,
nd painted robe, with pipe of peace in hand. As 'twas told to me.

They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (225) THEY GAZED ON THE BEARTOOTHS 221

Two hunters fast speeding, On the plains of ew Dakota,
One day o'er the plateau, There fair cities stand,
Saw rise on the prairie, And cottages and h[...]in view; Are dotted o'er the land;
"There are Indians coming," And the iron horse goes rushing,
With spy glass in ha[...]Through summer time and snow,
Said one of the hunters, From east and west where once the plain,
"Best here make a stand."[...]' eath the bright sky of Dakota,
They come, aye they -come,[...]n,
Like a cyclone's cold breath; The farmer looks with pleasure,
That sweeps the fair earth, On his labor and his gain;
In its dark track of death; And the busy housewife gathers,
And the glint from their guns, The children to her breast,
As they swoop o'er the plain, There all is peace and plenty,
Was like a flash of the sun, All is love and rest.
Seen through ribbons of rain.

They come with a rush,
Like a bird in[...]I was born near Boya Sara
Like demons of night;[...]By de name of Brudder Ham;
With war feathers streaming[...]An' I lubs to go a fishin'
They circled the hunters, Way down de ol' Lag[...]ell; An' see de fish co'k bob
And the crack of the rifle, An' pull in de big cat-fish
The shout and the call, rd hear d ol' bull frog;[...]Yo' bla k Ethiopean."
The chief of war party,
Rode brave as a knight, Al' at once I top dat laffin'
Straight for the men who lay, I got a hoodoo scar[...]o I grabb d d string o' fish
nd the rider and hor e, An' struck[...]ounded, Hit mad m think of oj r boys
Rode slow from the fray; Dat run down Ma sa Ben;
T[...]unded, O' Lordy dun out of br f
pon the ide plateau, n' r ach[...]

They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (226)222 THEY GAZED ON THE BEARTOOTHS[...]LEGE ND by "COLO EL" J. I. ALLEN

The warrior, Wolf Bow, who was of the River "The next day was the very coldest I ever re-
Crow tribe of Indian , told me the story of how Froze- membered and although we danced aro[...]gers and feet were badly
derived its name. It was the day after the big hail frosted. Next morning we discovered that the snow
torm, July , 1877, and, as I have told you,[...]e and we endeavored to get out
all busy repairing the damage which the large hail by making hand holes with our k[...]fall back again. All that
a I was anxiou to know the true story of the creek's day and all through the night, although we were
name, I asked him the question and this is the story growing weak and stiff, we kept trying[...]I discovered that the nearer we got to the top the
"Over 40 snows have passed since our village harder the snow was crusted. Finally two of us man-
was camped on Rotten Grass Creek, which is tribu- aged to get out, and the cold wind nearly froze us
tary to the Big Horn River. We had an abundance to death. We shouted to our companions down in
of meat and we were happy and contented. We the hole and told them to follow us, for we couldn't
danced, told stories and smoked the medicine pipe wait as we were freezing and we started off on a
to while away the time. One evening while smoking run over the frozen snow-and it was night.
with my friends one of them proposed th~t we go "Daylight found us near the Yellowstone River
to war-that meant to steal or c[...]we had a hard time getting a fire started. After
the Piegan Indians. We expected to find them on we were fairly warm we shot a ]ack rabbit and waited
the 'Big River,' (Missouri) or some river near by or[...]but they came
perhaps at their trading post. Many of us joined not. I proposed that we go back[...]rty. It was several days before we arrived at the hole we yelled to them-but all
we started for we[...]mrades must all
Eyes,' my girl, made me four pair of moccasins and be dead. We made our lariats fast and left them there,
other girls did the same for their friends who were our hands being so numb and stiff it was impossible
to go with the war party. When everything was in for us to descend into the hole. We finally returned
readiness to start we h[...]home and told our terrible story, and as soon as the
our friend good bye we started out in the night. We weather would allow a party on horseback went back
found all the streams frozen over but the night was with me. When we descended into the hole on the
not cold. Each one of us had a lariat, some buffalo las os we had[...]r friends frozen to
meat, a bow and a quiver full of arrows, and we death. Forty-seven froze to death, five escaped and
traveled afoot. We went down the Big Horn and three were pulled out but died when placed near
cro sed Elk River ( the Indian name for the Yellow- the fire.
stone) on the ice. We walked along single file and[...]k got its name.
Froze-to-Death Creek.
" o far the weather had been good with but little
snow on the ground. Th n we made camp under a
high cut bank on the bottom of this creek. That night[...]A Vi it To Fort Pease in 1877
the weather changed and it snowed hard and long I rode along the valley trail,
and we did not 1 ave camp. e t day[...]. We had but little wood Or saw the flag wave o'er the fort,
and we decided to get out of there at daylight. But s it did two years ago.
during the night the wind came and it blew hard So there, once more, I rode within
and cold from the northwest. We could not sleep and The old fort's burnt stockade,
the snow covered us up; drifted ov r th cut bank[...]here still a few charred timbers stood
and filled the creek from bank to bank, thirty feet[...]going close beside their graves,
and small piece of willow to keep us from freezing. There ro again to me,
Our supply of buffalo meat was gone and to get out The forms of those who lay at rest.
of that hole which the heat and smoke had made[...]

They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (227) THEY GAZED ON THE BEARTOOTHS 223

The Buffalo[...]Sailing home to blue eyes,
Leaving reminders of them on the sod. Over the southern sea,
In valleys, on plains, hills, ridges and dell; Watching the starry skies
They bred and grazed or they roamed[...]From schooner "Jennie Lee,"
Oft earth trembled as the dark shaggy mass, And wonder if she's thinking
With sound like the rumbling of thunder would pass, Of her sailor on the fly,
And darken the land by numbers untold, Or 'round the town go s gadding
As onward they moved like waves[...]d gun, Oh ships that sail the sea,
Chased and shot them in their terrified run;[...]sailed for me
And birds feasted, too, off carcass of prey. Could dress m[...]But what's the use of wishing
The buffalo grass still grows as of yore, To have a load of stuff,
But never a herd is seen grazing o'er,[...]When maybe she's out fishing,
That furnished the meat, the skin and the robe; With a fellow full of guff.
For the Indian's food, dress, bed and abode.[...]So thoughts like waves arise
They fell by the spear, the arrow and ball, And flit across the sea,
Were destroyed by beasts and from cut-banks[...]nd, And sail no more the sea.
In passing over their old feeding ground.[...]The Sabbath Bells
Listen, the Sabbath bells ring out,
Lettering That call the sinner and de out,
To hear the wondrous tale of old
We write and cast the pen aside That 1os and the prophets told;
When task is done and word[...]nd join in hymn and am t prayer
That tell of joy or love or pain For[...]The ab bath b 11 proclaim thi day,
For some[...]in a kindly way
A letter comes like gleam of star To comfort w ary on who[...]rt or min or oil;
To weary, waiting heart of night. For them to take a day of r t[...]lett r will relate
What has happen d them of late Oh ruel ag of long ago
All fresh items so and so[...]Wh n hri t's or hipp r had to go
Is the news we lo e to know. v[...]Wh re rows of d ad w r ay;
Another missive comes[...]n to uff r a martyr's fat
How lonely pass the days unw II For cau of Him th y v n rat .
Still from pain, tho n[...]On unday morn ; and nation h ar
Then let the trail of word gi ch er bout hri[...]

They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (228)224 THEY GAZED ON THE BEARTOOTHS

Marpone[...]Unconcerned
In a valley of Montana Together o[...]A green rose and her lover bird
In the days of buffalo. For her sweet sake sang gay.
There from the lodge of Long Horse
His daughter sped away, Sang of her bright regal beauty
To meet Sarshe, her lover, Fairer than blushes of morn.
Who sang this loving lay:[...]From cruel stab of thorn.
Sweetheart, I love but thee,[...]nd kind you be, Alone on the rosebush rocking
My heart beat true[...]My darling Marpone. The green rose looked unfeelingly
Tonight wh[...]At her pretty minstrel dead!
nd the camp is hushed in sleep,
I start with a war party
For the land of the Blackfeet
We go for scalps and horses,
And I, for love of thee,
\ Vill bring a spotted pony,[...]'Tis embellished with pansies,
The ice and snow had vanished,[...]ne, Has pierced through the center,
\ Vhose heart, tho' broke, still hu[...]A big bleeding heart.
This lay of brave Sarshe.
'Tis not the blood stains
From the red heart above,[...], sing on That I liked the gay valentine,
From woodland and valley and[...]wn yellow with age,
For your ongs remind me of one But these two pretty v[...]me. She penned on the page:
nd a murmuring flow by,[...]"\ hen faintest echoes of the day
cottage and field of grain;[...]wake me from love's dream,
But the joy and hop of the pa t[...]e Ion idol wor hip'd free
Low singing a ong of love, Enshrin d wi[...]p, There happy visions come of thee
1 'eath a vin -clad porch above. \ ith loving voicings of my heart."
nd the farm r follows his plow[...]Soon th re came a lo er's quarrel,
In the furrow , narrow and long.[...]a banker rich and old,
But oh for th sight of a darling one
Who spoke of his ast wealth
And the sound of an old n song.[...]

They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (229) THEY GAZED ON THE BEARTOOTHS[...]A LEGE D by "COLO EL" J. I. ALLE

It was in the early 70's that I became acquainted the dead Indian and with ome of th
with John Johnson, better known as "Liver Eater" skulls decorated the stockad . Wh n th
Johnson. I had known of him on the Missouri River came up in the spring many of the pas
but do not remember of meeting him. It is now many horrified, but som of th m bought scalp and a f w
years since he told me much of his life and I have bought skulls. "Liv r Eat r" told me that th y had
a photograph of him which he gave me in Billings. no more[...]to aid me, I will in part, try to told me the names of the men who wer in th fight,
relate what I remember of his life's story. why the Sioux did not put up a bett r scrap: Their
He said he was born in ew Jersey in the sum- bow strings were w t, which rendered their bows
mer of 1824 and at an early age sailed the seas for and arrows useless, most of them being armed that
many years. Later he was a Union soldier in the way. Their powder also got wet, their g[...]he was wounded and discharged. Then The Indians named "Liver Eater" Johnson "Black
he came to Montana and had a wood camp on the Bear," and it was a good name for him. He was a
Missouri River, near the mouth of the Musselshell large men, with short, black[...]k
was run, I think he said, by Glendenine, and at the as the black bear, for which the Indians named him.
time about 16 white men and a[...]ough in look, in talk and way,
were camped there. The hostile Indians were killing[...]His heart was good as those who pray.
the woodchoppers wherever they could surprise them
at work. The cotton wood trees were cut in suitable "Liver Eater" was not in the Custer fight on the
lengths and piled and dried and sold to the steam- Little Big Horn, but that winter he was attached to
boats going up or down the river. These wood camps General Miles' command at Fort Keogh, and with
were not uncommon along the upper Missouri at the other scouts di cover d the Cheyenn s on the Little
time of which I write. Muddy in February, 1 77. "A chi f of the couts,"[...]d a few In- other m n- ou k mo t of th m , and you know
dians going into a ravine near the post. She ga e the al o that among h out neral Mil alway had
alarm and the men, with their guns, rushed over and a p t[...]ning wh v tarted
tried to get a shot at the Sioux, but the mom nt they out to look for th dian , and in er ing a creek
showed their heads above the cut bank the Indians, th ic broke and I got w t. ft r I[...]and took th m all i ii
the Mus elshell Ri r and went until th y came in[...]ant d u · to go and In-
sight of the ravine wh r the Indian , r in hiding. and I[...]th ir that ind a thou and of told
\ inchesters, the Indians swarm d out and as they ·[...]or iff and b at
account of that fight. it[...]bout
knife cut out hi li er and off r d a pi ce of it to 11 and many[...]ca and , w
in disgu t, t lling the oth r m n about_ me of th if it ha for I v
him[...]ti train in and
I did not eat any of th Ii er, I v a ah ay known hi[...]

They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (230)226 THEY GAZED THE BEARTOOTHS

"LIV[...]

They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (231) THEY GAZED ON THE BEARTOOTHS 2[...]feet below my swimming pony's side, came to view
the traders, Mithoff & Kaufman, who had a trading the head of Johnson. Eagerly I reach d ov r my
store at the Crow Agency on East Rosebud Creek. pony'[...]his hand my hat blew off and went spin-
store on the Yellowstone River, situated about 200 ning down the river. I clung to my fri nd with a
yards from the mouth of Keyser Creek. I was in- grip of steel, towing him through the drifting ice
structed to make a list of the goods required for safely to shore, where I 1 ft him and caught his horse.
trade with the whites and Indians at the "Eagle est" He was o c.;hilled that it was necessary for me to
store. Near the store, on the bank of the Yellowstone assist him to mount. He told me th[...]s nest in its him down and jammed him against the rocky bed
top-most branches; for this the store was named. of the river rendering him helpless. It was only a[...]short distance to the ranch and we soon arrived there,
The wind came cold and clear from the north-[...]soon warm and dry again.
to return the same day if possible. It was a ride of
16 miles, the Hundley shack being the only one of any After borrowing a hat 1 left the Hundley ranch
kind in sight, where now are located hundreds of and was soon on the trail for the Agency. As I rode
prosperous ranches. When I arrived at the Yellow- along that evening this thought ca[...]and found Al Bailey in charge. Congregated the Agency in due time and made my report relative
there were a mixture of all races-smoking, trading, to the goods needed at the "Eagle est" store.
gambhllg and having a good tim[...]"Liver Eater" Johnson, after his icy bath in the
old friend, "Liver Eater" Johnson, who greeted me[...]stone, was very ill for several weeks with a
with the old-time salutation of "How," and a most[...]rash and fever, and was kindly cared for at the Hund-
cordial hand-shake. After I had the list of goods that
ley ranch. f ter he recovered he came to the Crow
were needed, I whiled away the afternoon in watch-[...]ncy and remained there for a year or two. And
ing the trading for buffalo hides, elk and antelope
at the Agency I remained for five years, as a clerk
skins; while ·betting and card games ran on the side.
for the different Indian traders.
Before I was aware[...]year later, "Liver Eater" got crip-
was wanted at the Agency store that evening, it was[...]pled up with rh umati m, and wa sent to the soldier's
time for me to hit the back trail. As I was bidding[...]1900, and \! a buri d th re in the soldier's cemetery.
ways with you." He said he was camping at the lex
Hundley's ranch over the river, so I waited awhile
for him and it was abou[...]e was a condemned go ernment animal
that had been the cau e of the death of t\! o men. Oh woman, lo I woman ,[...]which as not fast but world of jo you bring,
ery sure footed-a duck when it cam[...]'s car you n v r hirk.
place and beheld great cak of gli t ning ice, drift-
ing and grinding by, and t[...]lining Th min tr I , dainty minstr l
the ri er bank. Johnson took the lead and tried That flood th w d ith ong
to pass above or b lo\! the large cak of ic . I no- Do not ompar ith wo[...]dro\! ned by l'v h ard th ·on of bird and rill,
the howling wind and the roar of the ic and , ater. But your , t oi doth ling r till.
All of a sudd n my companion and hi horse went[...]ght, und r th drifting w et lo r of th light·
ice. Quickly I turned and urged my pon[...]For heauty, fre. h an<l bright.
go down, when lo! the horse, ri<lerle s, am e ah a<l \\ ith lo I fac and flo ing tr s ·
of mine and warn for the shore. Then, only a few You are a dr am of lov liness.
They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (232)228 THEY GAZED ON THE BEARTOOTHS

To New Year The Flowers
A beggar comes, ew Year,[...]With bright colored tints of beauty,
Besides his rags and board. To deck the earth again.
That health you'll grant, ew Year, In the meadows, dells and marshes,
nd of wealth make generous gift. '[...]return , never fear, Where the toads for rain are crying,
To help a burd[...]ant this request Tew Year, And the lark goes singing o'er them,
And let a beggar live! A song of love divine.
They are bowing to the zephyrs[...]monitions Where they dot the bright green hillsides
The years troop by and changes bring[...]way.
Unto us all, -like birds on wing
The seasons come and go; although And we look with rapture on them
vVe note the water's onward flow In wood and shady glen,
Through many windings to the sea, Where the bob-o-link is singing,
They ne'er return to you or me- With the robin and the wren.
or winds that blow across the land, And on the sunny days of summer,
or rain that drops upon the sand! The humming bird and bee,
Deep falls the snow to melt away- And gay but[...]ilent fall They are nodding in the gloaming
Are wafted far, -beyond recalll[...]Where the whip-poor-will is calling,
These are the teachings nature tells And fir[...]In her various moods and spells-
Let not the precious hours flow- ' eath the leafy dome of woodland,
O, waste not life in idle show! One hears the hoot-owl call,
Help on life's road your fel[...]Where sweetest earth stars slumber,
Improve the time whene'er you can! When[...]broad and plain Then a sense of light and glory,
By good deeds done and done again- A song of woodland thrush,
F or like the da bing, passing shower, And a sight of fragrant blossoms,
Or like the breath of transient hour That vie with[...]So we gather the frail beauties,
Like fleeting shadow of a day!
The fair and loveliest,[...]To sacred homes of rest.
For nature looks fresh and fair After the wane of summer
After its clouds and tears, The flowers fade and go,
Comes a vision of joy; White and golden and red
Rainbow of promise appears. Are cov[...]Flood valley, hill and plain,
nder the sod, at rest, Then fair and fragrant come
Awaiting the angel's call Earth's lovely flowers again.
Tho not like the flowers come After the storm is over
Will life for us return.[...]And thunder rolls along,
But in the spirit rise Comes hum of bee and brook,
To Heaven's glorious bourn. And the sweet birds joyful song.

They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (233) THEY GAZED ON THE BEARTOO T H S[...]A Leaf of Love
Drifting away without compass or guide,[...]Col little leaf so thin and whit ,
Amid the drift of humanity's tide, With t[...]ting away. Making the forest arches ring,
With song at close of day.
Drifting away, the days ceaselessly go,
In quest of pleasure and vanity's show; Ohl Lady fair , with charming grace,
In the struggle for fame , power and pelf[...]To thy rich crown of golden hair,
Drifting away flows the river of years, Fit emblem for a Queen.
Strewn with the wreckage of joys, hopes and fears;
Strewn with sad memories,[...]Thy dainty hands so soft and white,
And full of regrets while life does remain- Will hold this leaf of love I write,
Drifting away. Poor tribute of that love;
Ah! could I hold that hand of thine,
Drifting away are the ones that we love, While loving eyes gaze into mine,
Passing from sight like the flight of a dove, True happiness would p[...]h l way,
A servile pov er, named the mind, d[...]nd bri
And guid the plo and guard th grain.
It lights the way for progr ion;[...]ht ,
It rolls th v heel of d nc on[...]
They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (234)230 THEY GAZED ON THE BEARTOOTHS

She had her faults as som[...]both maids and men Like the rainbow
While time flies fast and m[...]ive delight;
nd caught a breath of lander, A pleasant chat[...]m with decanter. Will cheer the heart
Of man or maid.
And ordered him to leave h[...]Thus may ever
And often thinks of the old home, True heart[...]And she who was is mi tress yet,
Of the mansion on the hill,
Where lights flash out upon the night
When the city marts are still. All Is Peace
ow she i free the court' decree o burst of smoke or thunder
Allowed a house in[...]Springs from iron throats of war,
And by her lawyer's able plea Or leaden rain, sweeps the plain
Was granted alimony. Of life; mid battle's roar
Or strains of martial music
Moves avalanche of feet,
A We Review[...]Where hostile armies meet.
As we review the past there comes
A herald ounding war's ala[...]banners flutter
And marching hosts to beat of drum- 'Mid a hurricane of strife,
As we review.[...]Where thousands gave up life.
As we review the battle lines o war on[...]tain pine Wher ride the iron fleet
Till "forward march" ounds down the lines- nd wreckag trewn by war's s[...]Upon a rolling deep.
As we revi w the battle's smoke
That pring with roar from cannon's throat, All is peace the grasses grow
While o'er the charge war banners float- 0 r many a field of fray
As we revi w. And flow r nod above the sod[...]Where one dead heroes lay.
As we review the battle plain All is pe[...]In trench d p and long;
There com the roll call o'er again- And 'n[...]All is peace, all lands rejoice
The bursted drum and arms of war,[...]For the nations, arbitrations,
As we rev[...]

They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (235) THEY GAZED ON THE BEARTOOTHS 231

The Veterans A[...]if ed b
From Life's command they go.
To swell the ranks of comrades gone From life of all,
By thinning the lives we know. With preciou · mom[...]e bent, B yond r call.
That followed the flag they flew, ow wint r winds blow[...]and shell And snow flakes fall,
Upon the Gray and Blue.
And o'er the now gay sleigh loads glide
We note them moving slowly now, Mid sounds of mirth;
With crutch or staff or cane; While tim untramm I d moving on
All bearing signs of war or age Brings d ath and[...]as loving brothers do And all of life we note around
Along life's great highw[...]pleasing smile and hearty shake
These "vets" of Blue and Gray. Yet far beyond the reach of man
Behold the light,
"Old Glory" waves o'er land and sea,
Of sun and moon and countless stars
And fleets of iron still roam;
But over all this peaceful land In heavens bright,
The vets are marching home. \Vhence shine afar great rolling worlds
And those we know, of battles tell- In endless flight
Of charges and review- Through space limitless and sublime,
And how the iron hail crashed through Has ages past
The ranks of Gray and Blue.[...]Since earth rolled on replete with life
At rest the true and brave will lie Controlled and va t,
Beneath the sod or sea; hereon we pass life's years away
But on the nation' records still And re[...]re each Memorial Day,
\ e strew bright flowers on the graves
Where sleep the Blue and ray.[...]fri nd u'v be n to m
Ode To The Sun[...]ce. In lif and wh has not:
Embl m of constancy,
Oh radiant, radiant sun. The land \J ill nd, m fri nd,[...]Hand in hand- togeth r.
Flooding the world with joy.
Oh beautiful, beautiful su[...]

They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (236)[...]FEET HIGH
This highest peak in Montana lies over the line in Carbon County,
They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (237)Chapter 17
THE SAGA OF
WESLEY BEGGS
"The Morning Glory Hills" is a name applied ered. One of these animals wore the Y Hanging
by me to the Upper Stillwater Valley from the Red Quarter Circle M belonging to Charles R hm; the
Bridge to the river's source. Here you can see the brand had been cut from the hide of the second
grandest of all scenery, the most inviting-the most animal, but later checked out to belong to the herd
inspiring. Here you can see battlements and domes of George Robertson of Chance, who had been run-
and thrones decorated with nature's beautiful gar- ning his steers with the Rehm bunch. These m n
ments. Around them twines a mantle of leaves of were lodged in the Big Timber jail, December 12,
many colors-tawny a[...]1904, and on March 21, 1905, were found guilty of
the blue and the grey-all are here. Here you can larceny by a jury at Big Timber. Beggs drew a five-
see the rain and the rainbow, the flowers in their year sentence, and Wheat, as an accessory, got a
bloom, the frost king in his frozen form, the mountains year. During his term in prison, Begg[...]ase fourteen months
This is a prelude to one of the poem's written ahead of schedule.
by Wesley Beggs. It is called "The Morning Glory
Hills" and appears in his book "Rhymes From The The six foot one, powerful two hundred twenty
Rangeland", published in 1912. The following is an
article by the author of this volume of "They Gazed
On The Beartooths", written for The Columbus ews.
In the early spring of 1909, the doors of the
state penitentiary were swung open for the release
of a man named \i esley Beggs. s a youth of 18,
Beggs had left his Ohio home to be a part of the
romance of the west. He had many experiences in
Oklahoma, Colorado, Wyoming and Montana, usually
following the trail of a herd of cattle and the un-
stable life of a cowboy. bout 1 90, however, he
returned to Oklahoma where h wa married and
had three children, one of whom died arly in life.
But the call of the Montana wilds was too d eps at d
to resist, and he again came to the Beartooth to
homestead on a small tract n ar th old tockad
at th head of Bridger r k where h rai d a f w
head of cattl , and orked as a hired hand v h n v r
he co[...]s er hard and money scare ere
lots of cattle grazing around hi horn tead and ov r
towar[...]ed v orking wh n an al rt herilf car
Falling of Big Timb r and Jake L on , hi d puty
act cl on the "tip" of a tillwater alle tockm an am]
caught B 1gs and his partn r, Jim \ heat, in th act
of dressing out tv o st ers that had just been butch-
They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (238)234 THEY GAZED ON THE BEARTOOTHS

pounder was a different man than the rather jovial "Why did you not bring this writing to the office
one hi neighbors had known before poverty[...]read?"
him to crime. Begging for employment, many of the "Because that was not my business.[...](He goes to the phone.) "Mr. Conley, I can't[...]if it takes two months."
secured a divorce; sold the relinquishment of the Tewey-"You will have to go and leave it here."
home tead to a party named Dunn; peddled the small[...]I tell you I will not go and leave it here.
herd of stock and whatever other chattels were con-[...]spent five years here.
vertable to cash, and with the two remaining children,[...]an life anew in a place unknown to Beggs.
D spite the divorce the felon never failed to profess "You must go."
a deep love for the mother of his children, as well as "But I don't go until my writings go with me.''
the youngsters themselves, and vowed that as soon[...]"Come, look across the old cow range,
search them to the end of the earth.[...]sickly and advised that Before the range was all fenced up
a higher climate was the only salvation. He was A[...]refore failed ow, as we look we view the sight
to get an education beyond the sixth grade. But he As thro[...]These fences do exist."
about a wide range of subject matter. In a gay mood
one day he told Mr. nderson that he "had plenty of Tewey-"Oh, that isn't bad. It is all right.''
time for poems in the big stone corral." "Certa[...]few pages and reads again.
nd he had made the most of it for this purpose!
Beggs found it almost harder to get out of the (Written on Mt. Pisgah, Cripple Creek, Colo.)
pen, than it was to get it. Let's check some of the 'Although I stand on Pisgah heig[...]I see no promised land,
tedly from his own story of same: But Cripple Creek, the mining camp[...]Lies off to my right hand."
"I had gone into the office to dress and put on my
fine suit of clothes which the Deer Lodge prison "I don't see anyt[...]furnishes to everyone who leave that institution of "Certainly you don't. I knew what to write and
crim , when in come Dan Tew y, the deputy warden. what not to write.'
peaking to the office man, he say : '\i h re' all this
writing B[...]ad.' ' nd it makes the teardrop start[...]ind these prison guards so wise,
I unlocked the p te and laid out my writings.[...]nd I am not so smart. '
With a look of amazement and surprise, he
asked: "Is that all wr[...]"The Old Calf Pants Washed"[...]The only ones I got.
"I can't read that in a mo[...]t in less time.'' ntil they got the rot.

They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (239) THEY GAZED ON THE BEARTOOTHS[...]them in, you know, During the years Beggs worked for Art Anderson,
Th[...]he worked with this vast file of written pages,. as-
They cover my long limb[...]it into shape for publication.
Whereon the calves do lick." He claimed h[...]three-volume deal-the first to be called Rhymes of
the Rangeland-the other a two-volume issue of Away
"But I am here to tell you I don't go."[...]Out West Behind The Bars or The Shadows of The
Tewey still keeps turning some pages, then re[...]nd headed west to Oregon. His
You can't bluff the donkey, it's no use to try. first mission[...]to find a publisher who would put out the book
He picks up a package, looks long and re[...]your optic not good, ing $600 for a printing of 300 copies of his first book.
I see you are shaking, I thou[...]. His early sales were sufficient to repay the loan, but
But, pardner, be careful as you search the resort, he didn't have his cherished grub stake when he
For it's not at all subject to this kind of sport." tearfully said goodbye to his friendly[...]these were never published, but the manuscripts did
"No, sir. I will not go. Do y[...]actually exist, and were read by the Andersons, who
me inside, for I will never leave[...]While Bryan Anderson was working in the Land-
"I will save you all that trouble. Take me inside. er area in .1929, he heard of a man named Wesley
I am in no hurry. I am attached to the place. I have Beggs, and curiously started out to see if it was the
an interest here. Take roe inside."[...], take them and go, and you have only a of a thirty-man crew of tie cutters, getting out the
few minutes until train time." timber for the Chicago orthwestern Railroad at
"Oh, I can make it." Lander, the end of their line. In the ummers th y
So I pulled off my old prison suit. A guard would cut the ties; in the winter a k leton crew
searched them. I put on my new ones, and they would treat th m in the Lander rail yards. Years
were dandies. A guard went with me to the depot, later Beggs topped in olumbu to vi it the assessor,
and with my gate money-$5.00-bought me[...]enough to do a r al job of family s king, still know-
ing nothing of their whereabout . t this time h
So now I am h r at the depot, wa a shrunken old man, badg r gray and shuffling
And I hear that the train is some late. in gait, but ye still bright and hining as he talked
I think if the trainmen don't hurry of hi writing; ye that bowed r gr t and r · morse
My clothes will soon go out of date. for hi crimes; eyes that b tray d l[...]l apart before
I got to Bozeman. A $2.50 suit and the state pays This wa th last anyon of this ar ver aw
Conley 25.00 for the suit.
of ley B ggs, the If- tyl d " o ho Poet of
There is grafting in the prisons ontana." Rumor had it[...]ways, he did find hi ife in the Oklahoma town wh re
And the system of th graft rs th v ere marri[...]1 • obody in th se pruts had the detail or th
(Bring on another prison r)[...]o 1t if th tory wa tru or h ther
"\ hile the mills of th gods Beggs turned out to b an Enoch rd n, or the
Grinds out another toll." weetheart of E angelinel
They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (240)[...]C/)

THE GRANITE PEAK DISTRICT AT THE HEADWATERS OF THE ROSEBUD
The first recorded ascent to the top is recorded in 1916.

They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (241)[...]237

FROM THE PEN OF WESLEY BEGGS
Following are some of the poems which appeared Here the cheery old sun with its bright shining ray
in "Rhymes of the Rangeland" by Wesley Beggs, to- Warmly kisses Montana's gr n sod,
gether with the authors preface: And wh[...]'Midst the fragrance of swe t sc nted air,
So I have reasons why thi[...]Whil ature a mantle of beauty spr ads out
its appearance. I do not claim[...]ems. Consequently, I have no apologies to
make to the public. I will say very few of them
have ever been published . Quite a number ha[...]all brimming full
written and handed around among the boys. To water the green growing crops,
1 ow, I leave out many of the Cowboy phrases,[...]ned with luscious fruit
or slang words, believing the book will be better Are crying alou[...]e useful book without them. The wild gooseberry bushes are loaded[...]here that's brimming full, Growing down b y the creeks and the gulleys
And some that's not so fl[...]ing old cowtrails are hid as from view,
Some of these verses were written on the range- Creeping out of the tall, wavy grass,
land where I camped; some were written in the And swift mountain streams so pleasing to see
homestead shack; many of them within the confines Are full of the trout and the bass.
of prison walls, when memories of freedom were so Here uplands are rich as[...]nd her valleys as rich as the He,
And the big bumper crops when re ponding
Here[...]ce a great smile.
That I wrote on the trail.
They grew in the sunshine; Here swe test wild[...]r tty gay dr s
They were fanned by the gale. In bewildering profusion[...]. cros h r wid bord r is fo md.
To the tune of the saddle H re i · beautiful sc nery, r spl nd nt and grand,
nd the rhyme of the west." In gann nts of purpl and green,[...]thi · gr at state to b n.
Montana, The Gem of The We t[...]ot a bronk ha bucked off hi bag age
I willsing of Montana, the gem of the est,[...]w that ha nipped h r gr en gra · ·e
I will sing of the charm th crops and the soil But i · waiting to do so again.
Of th mar elous gr at Treasur tate.[...]t tod do t nd rl arn
h re th hand of the laster doth r st, ot an y that has vi w d her rr n all y
Wher th ng 1 of Peace plants th flo\J r of love But ar longing again to return .
T o bloom on the trail of th \ est.

Of course we ar proud of thi great Tr a ur tate, To ·pend their f w day ·,
nd proud of h r man ion and spire ; In a countr so wond rfully bl t,
It sp ak out th throbhings of our frail hearts \ \ h r th , ngel of P ac plants th flower · of lo e
nd fill u ith great r desir s. o bloom on the trail of th \V st.
H ere dreams of th future v ill come and will play, Then p[...]tone , ill re, t, In a land , here the long gra. , <'- , ave ,
nd there they , ill cir[...]that are stnrn_ and hlul' ,
Clinging fast to the core of your br ast. In an earth[...]

They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (242)238 THEY G A ZED ON THE BEARTOOTHS

Montana, Montana, th fairest of land ! The
Montana, the bright gem of the West!
Let m live all my day in your beautiful lan[...]There's a thousand gems of beauty
Give me home, peace and plenty, give me su[...]Take a tip and be alone.
Ke p the gaunt wolf of hunger away from my door,
Go up the far-famed Yellowstone,
Then to all oth r regi[...]Or the Stillwater valley stream,
Look aero h r wide bord[...]sweet, juicy grass; Where the mountain crystals gleam;
ee her thou ands of horses, her timber fringed When a beauty from the mountains
stream Over all the landscape spills,
live with the trout and the bass.
And the sun shines in her splendor
e the rotten old bones, the horns and the hoofs,
The remains of that great buffalo herd On the Morning Glory hills.
That the white man pursued till he slaughtered them
all,
While the government said never a word.

ee her home and h[...]and their vigor, their push and their go
And the rich, golden harvest they reap.
Come gather her h[...]ht and a guide.

incerely I love this sweet land of Montana,
To me she's the climax of year ,
nd as I look to her rainbow of promi
I tnile through my season of tears.
Her m adow and her hills are th gr nest
nd h r mountain peaks crested with snow;
a park of gr at beauty, charming with plendor,
pread o[...],
o charmingly and b autifully dr d,
And of all the gr at tates of th nion
Montana i th on I love b t.
Its a wonderful country urpa in ly fin
Wher th hand of the t r doth r t,
Where the Ang 1 of Peace plant th flow r of love
To bloom on the trail of th W t.

Then come to this Eden and thi wond rl n[...]r good rain .
Come gather her harv st, com at the oo<l hr ad ,
Where the hand of the Mu t cr <loth r . t ;
C ome fen ce in a gard n, come plant out a tr ,
To grow in the g m of the West.

They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (243) THEY GAZED ON THE BEARTOOTHS 239

Yes, a thousand gems of beauty A Happy Home, 1892
Lie sparkling by your side,
When the autumn leaves are falling We in[...]Our absent ones may see,
Here you'll see the brilliant rainbow While loving arms about us twine
Gleaming out above the storm, Like tanbark to a tree.
And the frosty king of winter 'T would be a sad,[...]eauty Our happy dream of long ago
Over all the landscape spills, Would give but burning pain.
When the sun shines in her splendor
On the Morning Glory hills. The flight of tim rolls on, dear wife,[...]And in the happy dream of night
From the rough and rugged mountains S[...]den chain is spun, How quick the times does pass, dear wife,
To the highest peaks that glisten The evening and the day,
From the bright uprising sun. They seem[...]e they stand serene, majestic, The storms have often threatened us
When the sun begins to spill And t[...]es Our boats were just the thing, dear wife,
On the Morning Glory hills. Goo[...]Which safely rode the angry waves[...]ing died.
Take a trip to old Montana,
And see the sweep and swing; Our riches are not great, dear wife
Where the people are true as metal, Yet hard we'v toil d and work d,
And the metal has the ring; o matter what di courag ment
Where the stars at night are glistening We never play d the hirk.
From the dome of heaven's blue; We ar not a poor[...]If sometime ju t a littl care
Where you can see the sunrise lose pickin[...]y just to spill,
Her rosy blushing blushes
On the lorning Glory hills. Our hon[...]nd th bridal v il put on.
Go up the far-famed Yello, stone- But no[...]nd what do you think of that?
And up the Still at r valley Tl ro low of outh i gone
Is another not far b hind.[...]Lik Thomp ·on's pott d cat.
Here you can trac by the light of day
The freaks of a aster hand, ago, d ar wif ,
And you can see by the tarlit sky r[...]nd form d the marria hair.
When a spla h of my tic b auty
nd in the good old chair , c.1 ar wif ,
Over all the land cape pills, Tog ther[...]\ hile pa ion torm struck oth r har<l
On the forning Glory hills.[...]

They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (244)240 THEY GAZED ON THE BEARTOOTHS

Our children, too, we love,[...]And the grande t little brooklet, just as jolly as[...]mciing manner sings its lullaby
B neath the outhern tree.[...]I can hear it in the twilight , in the sunset
When with the silent dead[...]I can hear it im tthe moonlight , a s the fire-fly
Until the sea have fled.[...]and to sleep, When the banquet meal is ready and you are
Until the sea gives up her dead[...]. Floating 'round about the tabl e comes the breath
The weetest flowers you know, dear wife,[...]and die, H appy are the l ittle children reare d in a home
Th y com[...]on they fly. Eating in the mountain fastness, sleeping in their[...]lled to part, H ere' · the place for nature lovers, in this far-
For D[...]secluded spot
nd love to pierce the heart. With nature cll!tting antics where the Master"s
They say it come to all, dear wife[...]appreciate iit worth,
And fall the evening dew. Drinki[...]of Mother E:arth.
The gilded cords of love, dear wife,
By age they ay will br[...]e OM Round-Up Days
s Hermon loved the lake.
The sunny days of youth, dear wife, I left rny[...]e, And bound to ee the world,
But till we11 hold our honeymoon[...]ve a moth r, old and gray,
While walking up the hill, dear wife, A father[...]d I roam, Th t lights the
But fair sw t flowers will I seek[...]The Red Man llD hi home,
Home 'Twas then l t.hom ht of mother d ar[...]\i hen far v ay did roam
On The Rangeland
ly home i on the rangeland, far away from any In this wil[...]Wjth th rnUJndupi and the range
In the shelter and protection of the Rockie ' lofty And h re I' e rode and liere I[...]~c.
When th moon is playing check rs with the nd th po r olcl rn asl locoed h ep
shadows of the night.[...]

They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (245) THEY GAZED ON THE BEARTOOTHS 241

I found the boys good riders there, They say the wild Cowboy is passing,
And the bronchos rather rough, But I[...]limber as an eel, I know that the world's a delusion
And made of Western stuff. And thing[...]But go to it, old brook, I am with you,
And the athletic exercise, Though the buttons roll off of my pants;
But give me a bronk for the real old stuff, I will ride you today and tomorrow,
And the dust from the rangeland flies. And ride you at ver[...]untain, hill and plain, They say the wild Cowboy is passing,
My feet have trod the hunting grounds But I seen one[...]. He was there with both feet in the stirrups
My eyes have viewed the roundup camp, nd his pockets well filled with the dough.
Where punchers had full sway,[...]ronky, I'll answer,
And many a bronk would buck the game Though the buttons roll off of my vest,
In those old roundup days. For I'm here on the woolly old rangeland
To ride the wild brook of the West.
I now extend a friendly hand
To the boy of long ago,[...]They say there's no more pitching horses,
To the old range land and the old range man
And this is the way they decide,
When the roundup wasn't slow.[...]Who will give them a high crooked ride.
To the boys of then and now,
They will need both their feet in the stirrups,
To the old-time days, to the old-time ways,[...]nd then a through ticket to town;
To the long-horned steer and cow.[...]I've Called You The Cowboys are still thick and plenty,
Co to it, old[...]ave called you! nd are monarch of all they survey;
Let the buttons roll off from my vest, They are still on the rang of the cattle,
For I'm here on the woolly old rangeland nd here they ar going to stay.
To ride the wild bronk from the West. Th n shut up on thi wild sp culation
They say the wild Cowboy is passing, nd gi e u a mom nt for rest,
But he lingers still here on the Plains; nd w '11 how you w 'r in from th rangeland
He still wears the schapps and the Stetson, To ride the wild bronk from th We t.
And he still holds the old bridle reins.

He still loves his old occupat[...]om look ick
He still loves the old chuck wagon You know th 11 lo '
nd follows it ov r the range. nd of cou ·I tty ~uick.
Then, go to i[...]ui m t,
Till I get both my feet in the stirrup , g im[...]h ur and th h at.

He till ride the gra y old rangeland, ·o, I don'[...]T n go to it, old bronk I ha
Though the ater gu h out of my e Though th 1tton.[...]o1l ol<l ran land
\J h n you reach th gate ay of th ski o ri<l th ild bronk of th W ·t.

They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (246)242 THEY GAZED ON THE BEARTOOTHS

The Old Stockade Corral
Ther ' a happy time a-c[...]And it's coming pretty soon,
When the calf i up a-sucking A warm chinook is blowing
nd the chi kens bust the hell. And has kept it up since noon.
When the fire is ju t a-popping It's coming, yes, it's coming,
nd the coffee moking hot, The happy time of spring,
I want to t 11 you fellows When the doves will be all mating
It' a regular garden spot. And the whippoorwills will sing.

The old tockade's exploding Soon the mountains will be humming
With her agriculturing wealth; With the happy song of spring,
The air i oft and balmy, And the chickens will be hatching
Very dry and full of health. In that incubator thing.
But the wind it k ep a-blowing So we'll keep the fire a-heating
Like it did down in the strip. Tiil the eggs begin to pop,
nd prairie dogs a-sneez[...]wings a-growing
Like they all have got the grip. Till their big enough to flop.

Thi is at the head of Bridger, The old stockade's a-booming,
Far from the county seat, All we lack[...]bsarokee, She is coming to the front
town that's hard to beat; Like the Dutchman on the mule.
Where the golden stars do twinkle We'll have incubator chickens
nd the rattlesnake abound, nd hoppers by the peck,
nd where the pitching broncho If we only had a railroad
t the old stockade is found.[...]

They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (247) THEY GAZED ON THE BEARTOOTHS 243

We can hear the dog wolf hollow Here we have no city beauties,
In the foothills for his mate, or w have no city crooks,
And see the shy kioolee But we have a great plantation
When the day is getting late.[...]ng And th clouds of melan holy
At the old stockade corral.[...]Here the bright and smiling unrise
Van Sagendorf is coming[...]another chum, or the crazy city swell,
I think I hear him yell,[...]together At the old stockade corral.
At the old stockade corral.
The old stockade is lovely
In the good old summer time,
I'm glad that Jim is coming[...]When the doggies are a-browsing
And rowing up the tide,
'Mong the flowers and the vines.
For I feel sort of lonely like
So come along cowpunchers,
Since the old gray pony died.[...]At the old stockade corral.
So now I have no circus hors[...]The Cowboy' Wild Song
We will have a cowboy picnic[...]To Hi Herd
When the Fourth it comes around, One beautiful night when the moon was full,
And we'll have some pitching bronc[...]nd th air was cri p and cl ar,
That will shake the very ground. cowboy lay on the starlit plain
The tablecloth for dinner nd thought of hi horn o d ar.
Will be white as any sheet, He thought of hi moth r he loved o well,
And the fiddle will make music nd th slumb r of leep a blurred.
For the cowboys' willing feet. · ot a sound to b h ard but tho e of th night,[...]A h ang as wild ong to hi h rd.
We will whiten up the cabin floor
And rosin up the bow, Th attl · qui
While the mavericks join the roundup On[...]from of night
Cowboys and girls a-dancing[...]ong rd.

The old stockade's a stunner, H[...]m . . ·
She has plenty of room and air, Wh he
Plenty of good, clear, cold ater He i[...]t in
And plenty of grass to pare. fl k
Of course, we hav no wond rs H[...]1 n •r a word,
But lots of bear and bobcat , land of mira mo and pl in ,
And sometimes cougar tracks. \ here the bo low to hi h rd.

They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (248)244 THEY GAZED ON THE BEARTOOTHS

The Cowboy's Last Ride They had that night at the cabin
A couple of pretty tough girls;
A young Cowboy rose early one[...]his bronk for a ride, Soon got the boys' heads all awhirl.
He hit the high hills and the valleys
With Jimmy, his Pard, by his side. The fracas then started in earnest[...]ey pulled out their old forty-five,
It was out on the Little Missouri, And Billy was shot through the body,
Where they went to look after some strays, And never would go back alive.
And where the old mountains of Killdeer
Loomed up a short distance away.[...]Has often led Cowboys astray,
They rode the high hills and the valleys, And then their handy six-shoot[...]they find; Would put someone out of the way.
They searched the deep coolies and washouts,
Where many a cowtrail did wind. Quite often we talked of young Billy,[...]d cowcamp Who early left camp in the morning,
And stopped to fill up on some chop, But never went back there at night.
For the Cowmen are always big-hearted
And will give you the best in the shop. There we planted young Billy next m[...]While the tears quite tenderly fell,
And when they had eaten their dinner And we left him to sleep in the bosom
They started again on the range, Of the West that he loved so well.
But a cloud rolling up from cloudland
Said the weather had taken a change. The raindrop kissed the lily
By the morning glory vine,
So they took from behind their old saddles And the lily kissed the ivy
A slicker to keep themselves dry, And the ivy kissed the pine.
A protection from rain, wind or weather,[...]d, as it sometimes does, For the golden sun was setting
That the wind blew the rain all away And her jewels were at play.
And 'the boys still rode the prairie
A-trying to look up the strays.
Just To Be A Rancher's Wife
But just as the sun was a-setting
A saloon and store cabin they struck. When the rosebud greets the lily
"If we can't find the strays," said Jimmy, And the lily greets the dew,
''We have found quite a rich streak of luck." And the sunshine and the shadow
Have the shine a-woven through,
So up they rode to the store cabin And your heart is kind and tender,
And unsaddled th ir bronks for the night, Beating free and full of life,
nd a great big smoking hot supper There's a happy conso]ation
Filled the boys with a happy delight.[...]way until late, But when the days are cloudy
And for wild, reckless, careless Cowpunchers And the rain begins to pour,
Could play at a pretty good rate. And the fro ty stars to glitter
And the winter wind to roar,
They had at the cabin strong whisky, And the fearful cold has reached you,
And it got all the boys in a row, K[...]

They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (249) THEY GAZED O N THE BEARTOOTHS[...]ohnny eats green apples Give Me The Woman Who Loves
And you're forty miles from town, The Fresh Air
No matter what the hurry is Oh, give me the woman who loves the fresh air,
The doctor can't be found. Her cheeks will be rosy and her countenance fair;
When the baby gets the colic, She will rise from her slumber[...]fully disgusting She will raise up the windows and open the door,
To be a rancher's wife. She will polish the stove and scrub up the floor.
In the far away West where love has its source,[...]This little brave woman will ride the wild horse;
When the wife is worn and weary
Let him rear on his haunches or twist in the air-
With four kids on her knees,
Three cheers for the woman who stays with him ther ;
And the bed bugs are a-fighting
See him go to it, now watch her ply to the quirt,
In the kitchen with the fleas ,[...]With exasperating strife, Oh, give me the woman with a warm loving heart,
And you feel it i[...]ch a woman with natural endowments is blest,
When the milk is strong with garlic And here they will sparkle like gems in the West.
And the butter it is too, Her children, like rosebuds, will be sweet and as fair
And the taste has got the flavor As the sunbeams and moonbeams that falls on their
An[...]She'll be clean, neat and tidy, her teeth like the pearl-
And you're almost sick of life, Good natured, good mannered like the real Western
You know it's aggravating[...]To be a rancher's wife. So give me the woman who loves the fresh air,[...]You will find all the women who love the great West
When Tutie has the measles, Have a sense of wild freedom that throbs in their
And Katie has the mumps, breast;
And the old dog Watch is threatened They'll run you a footrace - did you see how she
With a fearful case of thrumps; grinned ?
When green apple J[...]See her hair hanging down keeping time with the
'Cause he's got the stomach ache, wind.
And his mother wet and chilly Yes, give m the woman who loves the fr h air,
'Cause she fell into the lake. Her cheeks will be rosy and her cou[...]So here's to the brave woman of mountain and plain,[...]I give her my hand and rejoice in her r ign;
When the chickens they won't cackle, In danger she's f arle s and in lov sh i tr ng,
And the roosters they won't crow, Her path is all sun hine and her horn i all ong.
And the snow is still a-falling o give m the woman who lo es th fr h air,
In a way that is[...]'t you know that you can't cut it Oh, give m the woman who 1 v ith a z t
With that[...]knife, Her chick ns and turk y in a horn of th W t·
For your little strength has vanished[...]uch a woman a thi i a d ar to my h art
And the goose is flying high, A th joys of my boyhood hi h cannot d part.
And a thousand little hies ings hes th pride of the ranch in h r up-to-dat gown
Along your pathway lie; nd the qu n of th cit wh n h g to th to n·
When the children are a-romping h 's as fair as a ro ebud hen n ircl d ith d w,
And crowing full of life, nd a g m of p rf ction both pric le s an<l tru .
It is[...]
They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (250)246 THEY GAZED ON THE BEARTOOTHS
They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (251) THEY GAZED ON THE BEARTOOTH S[...]rd, Have eaten every blade of grass
Where I rode years ago; And every weed in between.
I gazed upon the landscape there, ot long wil[...]Until they reach their home corral,
The feed was once immense The asylum for insane.
From here each way a hundred m[...]The Sheepmen and the Cattleman
Some twenty years ago, old Pard, Have had a dreadful muss,
The land was full of game; But the sheep have got the range, old Pard,
Many of them not very wild,[...]Go round them sheep and bring them in,
The deer, the elk, the antelope, The range is dry and bare,
Together there did ro[...]_ The noble Red Man, too, old Pard,
Some twenty years a[...]They drove him far away,
The grass stood waving high; An[...]They took away their hunting grounds,
The rotten sheep has eaten it Where the buffalo loved to roam,
As bare as my old boot[...]hem there today ot fit for the Red Man's home.
A-eating out the roots.

The white man did it all, old Pard,
The long-homed steer is gone, old Pard, On him I lay the wrong.
But very few remain; In forcing the Red Man's heritage
They crowded in their stinking sheep To sing the white man's song.
And drove them off the range. They cheated and delud[...]ow I couldn't sleep But the d vil he will d al with you
Until I would stamped[...]u have dealt with them.
Right through a band of sheep.

And then I'd keep them going,[...]uld never let them stop, The Indian ation Ii .
Till every sheep was under[...]All d ck d with lo ly foliage
And the bronchos were on top. B neath a sunlit sky.
I would run them up the valley And th r among the sun-ki s d hills
And would chase them from the hills, The Indian ar corral d
And despoil the old range robbers Caught in the hit man' round-up
Till every one was still. nd dro to a far -you-w ll.

The owners, too, you know, old Pard,[...]Th white man's hand hav made;
At the end of a strong old picket line Th ha[...]you know th y have, old Pard.
And when I'd freed the range of th m, They ha gath r d in the mountains
Then I would strut and crow, nd ha fen d the· riv r , too; '
And the grass would grow, I know again,[...]

They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (252)248 THEY GAZED ON THE BEARTOOTHS

The railroad spoiled our hunting grounds[...]hem wide in two; The Road
The buffalo, deer and antelope
From it then[...]Hy home now is here in prison,
Then came the pale-faced hunter The lock me up tight every night;
s hard a[...]For I feel the barbed arrow of sorrow
A few old rotten bones, old Pard,[...]breast.
Is all that now remains
Of that vast herd of buffalo
That covered all our plains.[...]Locked up in this cold house of stone?
To think it must be so,[...]Oh, why am I here serving sentence?
That the Red Man and the buffalo Oh, why am I not a[...]would that I only could lift it
I have seen the fairest valleys And bring back the smiles of relief.
Spoiled by the white man's hands,
And ature was mutilated[...]'t very grand. Were both of them living today,
One would start to plowi[...]And wandered so far from the way.
And one a-building a cabin, But the seed of transgression is certain,
And in it all would dwell. And I'm reaping the crop that I sowed;[...]For they sent me right over the road.
They would put a fence around it,
Fence half the road at that, As I think of the home of my childhood
And in their old sod shanty[...]s poor as bats. But gone like the buds of my childhood,
The one cow on a picket line,[...]thin and poor Dear mother, and the love she bestowed.
To really make good soap. Oh, the burden of grief would be heavy
If she knew the wild seed that I sowed.
o more the scouts upon the plains
Old Sitting Bull will py;[...]tepee And courted the smiles of her face,
Will light the evening sky. And why am I now taken from her
o more the Western rovers nd l[...]My children they sadly do miss me,
For the great Siou Chief, you know,[...]s killed at Wounded Kne . Oh, the burden is heavy, dear children,
The burden on you and on me.

Gone are the elk and antelope, ow will y[...]nd banish me out of your mind,
Gone are the savage Red Men B cause I[...]When inful and s lfish and blind?
Gone are the shaggy buffalo The hues of the rainbow hav fad d ,
That roamed about s[...]Its lustre no mor can I se ·
From the sunny plains of Texas Oh, could I but fe I the great fullness
To each far-off s[...]

They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (253) THEY GAZED ON THE BEARTOOTHS 249[...]But I trustingly look to the Master,
That my happiness greatly is marred,[...]loving and kind;
And I've proved it right here in the prison I will ask Him to strengthen and lead me
That the way of the transgressor is hard. And not let me[...]ems all my friends have forsook me,
A-reaping the crop that I sowed, With bit[...]it all here in prison, And away in the silent night watches
For they sent me right over the road. I ask why I ever was born?[...]arly each morning, As I feel the distress and the pain,
And loneliness stands by my side; And I wish I was out in the moonlight,
Such cellmates as these are not pleasant, And I wish I was out in the rain.
But yet they forever abide.
My sorrow seems deeper and fiercer The shadows fall darkly, my loved ones,
Than the waves of the angry old sea, ot a ray where it lingers and rests;
As I think of my long, dreary sentence o day star of brightness revealing
And wonder how long till I'm free. The love that is hid in my breast.
Oh, why don't you value the living,
My sadness is sickening and painful, While yet the Great Reaper is stayed?
And the burde~ is heavy to bear, Oh, why don't you help up the fallen
As I think of my friends who have left me Before his short life is decayed?
And none of sorrow will share.
In a cold, damp cell of a prison
Is where I must smother my shame, You all used to write to me often
While the great high wall that surrounds me When I was away from the home,
Throws the shadow and blot on my name. But now yo[...]And branded a criminal toda .
You can breathe the pure air of the mountains
And your troubles to each other tel[...]Wh n the wif of my bo om doth fail.
My home and my wife and my ch[...]ould sta ith me
Those sweet little blossoms of childhood nd s a kind wor[...]a k from my brov .
This great cruel wall of this pri on Oh, o[...]th o bright?
And it brings me no tidings of fr dom, Oh, why ou d[...]cau 'm r t ?
There's no rainbow of promise refl ct d
By this cruel and r vengefu[...]But no r
It seems that the balance is tipping ow[...]
They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (254)250 THE Y GAZE D ON TH E BEARTOOTHS

My[...]to her dreary old badlands
To anchor in the hav n of rest; Farewell to her mountains and hills,
He will wa h from th tain of the pri on, Farewell to her lakes and[...]ge and her cactus,
nd nd it far out on the sea, Farew ell to all[...]and Hi mercy For I've heard of a range that is better
Has saved a poor[...]Farewell to the old bucking cayuse,
\-ly cheek ar all s[...]d twisty and nervy,
nd nt it today in the mail.
And knows how to deal you the stuff.
~lay the Father of Mercy give confort[...]r. Outlaw, I quit you,
nd prot ct all the path that I trod,[...]For I've heard of a range that is better
To walk on Hi gr[...]I am tired of the western roundups
F arewel1 To My Saddle an[...]W e have on the ranges of sin,
I will now quit th range of the cattle Through the storm, the blizzard and sunshine,
To ride through the garden of love, Cold, hungry and wet to the skin.
For Je u to me has just whispered So I'll now quit the range of the cattle
Of a wonderful mansion above. To ride in the garden of love;
o far wel1 to the wild pitching broncho, It's as dear to my soul as the circling blue
Farewell to my addle and rope, That arches the world above.
For I've heard of a range that is better
nd my heart[...]Farewell to the wild western outlaw,
Farewell to the merry old roundup, Who always goes crooked and high;
\ here all the wild punchers would meet o use for side-s[...]ll off my saddle and blanket,
Far w II to the barb d wire fence , Throw[...]h cattl within, · F or I've h ard of a range that is better
Fare, ell to all m[...]illed with its hope.
\ ho feed on the ranges of sin.[...]all you wild, jolly punchers,
I am tired of eeing good rid r Who circl around the big herd ;
Ride do. to th whirlpool of hell, I hold up to you a great Sa[...]you to God and His Word.
Back home to the old corral. nd you, boys w[...]r turn round and go back,
Farewell to the ho s and hi oap, For I've se n across the sad valley
For I've h ard of a rang that i b tt r Where or[...]ocky-ribb d mountain , To turn from the trail of the maverick
\\ her h r peak o maj ticaJl rear. nd put on the upp r rang brand.
Farewel1 to her flm er-[...], and plenty, nd he a bright light at the roundup
To gracefully circle[...]

They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (255) THEY GAZED ON THE BEARTOOTHS 251
Farewell to the wilds of Montana, Farewell To Montana,
Farewell to the gem of the West, The Gem of The West
For I guess I'm in time with her motion,[...]ve set deep in my breast. Farewell to Montana, the gem of th W st,
But farewell to her plains and her m[...]d you adieu, turn quickly away
For I've heard of a range that is better For sorrow co[...]To journey the road that is drear,
The parting is painful and stifles my breast,
So[...]hen I fancy your voices I hear.
Remember the words I have spoke,
And tum from your sins to[...]Farewell to Montana, bright jewel of years,
Come quickly, step under the yoke.
And far well to its prison of shame,
For I now quit the range of the cattle[...]alls, with iron-grated cells,
To ride in the garden of love,[...]I have stood on the summit of mountain and hill,
Of a wonderful mansion above.[...]prison, home-trouble, and sin
Come now, heed the words of the Saviour, Has furrowed my brow with your care.
Come ride in the pasture of love,
Come with me to a range that is better Farewell to Montana, sweet land of the West.
And a mansion prepared up above.[...]ll are as dear to my heart
So farewell to all the cow-punchers, As the day of my childhood, around the old home,
Here I pull off my saddle and r[...]e where e er I go
As I drift to this land of my hope. And o'er my sad bosom will[...]to my soul.

Perhaps you have run on the ranges of sin ot a friend have I left in this great trea ur state,
And fed where the pastures were dry, here I once was so happy and free;
Perhaps you have sat in the scoffer's great seat They are gone like the snowflake that ki sed th
While the old gospel rider went by. proud w[...]As it danced on the sparkling blue sea.
Perhaps you have gone all the days of your life Gone like the sweet flow r wh n bitten by fro t,
With no knowledge of God and His love, Or d wdrops by the ray of the un.
Perhaps you have turned from the shadowless So I'll wander in gloom, wit[...]on arth will be don .
Streaming down through the archway above.
Perhaps you have traveled the rough mountains Far w II to Montana, w t land of my liking,
of sin Wh r winds of mi fortun hav blo n;
And rode the black canyon of doubt, Wh n harv t is ov r, th n I[...]ld all alon .
Till you're puzzled and lost on the rout . t th cabin on Bridg r I hav tarri[...]now \) ould go 'way,
But why should you dwell in the dark swamp But th gra now i growing, th un hinin bri ht
of sin nd I ha not much long r to ta .
And eat the sad bread of despair,
When in the green pastures of life there is f d
Far " 11 to Montana, thou P arl of great pric ,
For a soul that is famished on care. Farew 11 to th trail of the vV t;
Then why sit like a statue so lifeless and[...]ing down by your With th flow r of p eac in my br a t.
side,[...]But far, far away, to a land w t of thi
To a land where you long may abid[...]

They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (256)252 THEY GAZED ON THE BEARTOOTHS

May their slumber be 'Weet in the stillness of night, So he greased his griddle from bottom to top,
When the stars in their glory look down. And poured in the batter with a flippity flop;
nd recall in bright vision the joys of their youth, When the griddle got hot, why the batter did too,
While the blessings of love did abound. And the hotter it got the faster it grew.
May the silvery moon in her journey of night>
peak gently to her of the past, It grew out of the griddle in a very short round-
n<l cover with ma[...]and parted at last. It lay on the stove and rested quite well-
He crammed in the wood, it grew and it swelled.
It is hard to be pa[...]rtune has cast her dark frown; ·when the pancake was done it reached to the door,
It is hard to be happy, when despondency come On the right and the left it covered the floor;
nd throw her dark shadows around. And of all the great pancakes that ever was baked,
But when storms of great fierceness sweep over None ever equalled the Irish pancake.
my soul
And clangers my pathway beset, He ran for the door but he could not get out,
Yet heyond the dark cloud shines the rainbow of hope Then he started at once for a different[...]ll with me yet. With his foot on the floor and his arm on the cake,[...]t he couldn't quite make.
Farewell to Montana, to the land of the gold,
Farewell to the gem of the West; He succeeded, however, in making his escape>
I'll cheri h sweet memories of thee when away, But he sprained his ankle in making the leap;
nd mantle them deep in my breast. \Vith wondering eyes he peered in at the door,
Your mountains and hill tops, rivers and ri[...]strength to my muscles and light to my eyes, The pancake loomed up like a ship in a fog,
Giv[...]places like knots on a log;
Farewell to Montana, the great smiling land, The inside was juicy with very large holes,
n<l[...]er rich and her poor; And looked for the world like there might be some
Jay her soil in g[...]So he broke off a chunk and carried it away,
The ·oil that in childhood my footsteps has pressed[...]To the assayer's office to see would it pay;
Shall nourish the flower that blooms in the West,
The assayer took it and put on the test,
nd I'll cherish weet memories of thee when away And said that the chunk was one of the best.
nd mantle them deep in my breast.[...]One thousand, said he, it would run to the ton-
Flanigan' Pan Cake The finest gold ore found under the sun;
The experience of an old school teacher Ore like this c[...]ve in my soul it came from Hahn's Peak.
Flanigan, the bachelor, liv d up in a hall, While the old assayer was testing the ore,
s a bak r of pancakes h was the pride of them all; Flanigan was laughing his sides r[...]et to his head, But he made him an offer for the cake as it lay-
nd greas 11 the way from tove to the bed. Forty-fiv thousand and all in[...]about madly and h wish d for a mate· But the old assayer was the one that was done;
He said to himself when a mans[...]no more. nd fifty brave Irishmen to work by the day.
I am up every morning exactly at seven, t the mouth of th canyon th y thought it the b st,
nd when breakfast is ready it's half pa t leven; For the light-hearted Irish to put on the t st;
nd he stamped down his f t, it's the pest of my life- They blew it wide op n and. oh, uch a[...]soul I had a good wife. nd the Irish were cov red with hatter from the cake.
h, said Flanigan, it is usel s to fret, long train of Irish soon started for tm, n,
I will bake a big f[...]d never he found;
I'll dress myself up like a bit of a fairy For the hold witty Irish were hea y with \: oe,
111 drive away trouble or play the old Harry. For Flanagan's panc[...]

They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (257) THEY GAZED ON THE BEARTOOTHS[...]Some wheat among th tar s.
I've left the land that gave me birth Dear wife[...]time since then has rolled its years The depth of f eling in your h art
And marked them on my[...]uld change to grow mor kind.
Yet I do often think of thee,
I'm thinking of thee now.
Oft in the dreams of night, d ar wif ,
I'm thinking of the day, dear wife, Your ch ris[...]Amid th old familiar s en
And watched the dawning of my youth Wh re once we used[...]love was then lit up Along the wa te of years,
With hopes of future joy, My heart fill[...]Yet still I look to the , dear wif ,
I'm far away from thee, dear wife,[...]I've seen you sultry summer ·un
The follies of this wicked world For m[...]e wander d o' r the world, <l ar wif ,
I'm lonely and forsakened now,[...]<la ,
Yet still I think of th , d ar \J ife, Our trou bl <l rt ir throhbin c a ,
Of moth r, home and child.[...]I go, dear wif , Th 7od of lo ma guide u. t-
In rror pleas[...]
They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (258)254 THEY GAZED ON THE BEARTOOTHS

It is with tender love, dear[...]I think you need some fixing,
The e line to you I send,[...]'Till you find this weed of virtue
I dedicate this page, You are Johnny on the trot,
To thee, thou lover of my youth, And like[...]Stand grinning at the spot.
It's very hard to write, dear wife,
When the wings of hope are clipped; You had better go out fishing,
How hard it's been to drink the dregs Away up in a c[...]And your chariot rumbling loud.
May the world to you be kind,[...]If you had a lasso rope,
To the one you left behind.[...]And looking 'round for dope.
The Locoed Sheep
(Song)[...]will be, And like the old booze drinkers,
cha ing squirrels[...]ing worse and worse.
nd barking at the tree. If you could only reason
funny way of walking I would take you by the neck
nd looking 'round for dope,[...]Go sideways as they lope.
The coyotes, they won't kill you; You will fight this weed of loco
They think you are too tough.[...]your life will end;
Your m eat has got the flavor A dope-fiend and snag-rooter
Of loco, sure enough.[...]you'll go star gazing
dancing on the plains, Out on the loco flat
nd scare th dry-land farmer[...]To The Public
I wish to say that I have thre quit large books been released from prison or any of the children. I
ready for publication: "Rhyme From the Rangeland trav led through Idaho, Utah, evada, California and
nd r the Sunny Blue kies of the W e t m Plains, Oregon, with the hope of finding her and being with
i: fountains and F oot[...]no avail. I did not succe d , so I returned
hind the Bar , Or th hadow of th Gr at tone again to fontana. But somewhere toward the sun-
Corral at D eer Lodge Mont." (in two volm11es), each ki s d hills of th Pacific slope roams the wife that
one compl t in it If.[...]at
You will notic that I have be n up against the great stone corral. I tell you of th divorc evil and
real thing. I was s nt to the p nit ntiary for five what it did to me; how I hate the cru I monst r, tc.
years, charged with killing a[...]prose and poetry.
gathered up th stuff and, like the Prodigal Son, went Yours v[...]ine I have THE THOR.[...]

They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (259)THEY GAZED 0 THE BEARTOOTH 255
They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (260)[...]' ¾,. ,, .

THE STILLWATER EMERGING FROM BOX CANYON, CATHE[...]

They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (261) THEY GAZED ON THE BEARTOOTHS 257

A Hunk of That Old Pumpkin Pie ow[...]te and to ye.
And hard have I tried to forget
The joys and charms of my childhood, Then give me a hope of th futur ,
But I cannot-I have not as yet. And teach me a pi ce of a rhym ,[...]d my h art overflowing with mu ic
I cannot forget the old homestead, Will measure away at the time.
No matter how hard I may try;
I cannot[...]her, Then tenderly point to the pathway
Nor the taste of that great pumpkin pie. And guide[...]th childhood and song.
Just one solid inch in the pan;
So yellow, so rich and so golden, So I'll gather the flowers of childhood
With a "Come, eat it all, if you ca[...]m and my sadness, While the wav s of adv rsity roll.
I fancy I'm back there to roam
Around the old garden and homestead, Yet a heavy, sad feeling comes o'er me,
In the joys of my sweet boyhood home. And you[...]As I fancy I see in the cupboard
Let the scenes of my childhood uncover, A hunk of that old pumpkin pie.
And the mist from my eyes roll away,
Till I fancy I see that log cabin
Where no shadow of trouble could play. To My Indian Friends
In the shade of that old apple orchard God made you,[...]n no reservation comp lled you to stay;
And I see the old moss-covered bucket But through the wide world you could rove at your
From which I would drink at the well. ease,[...]I see myself there eating peaches
And storing the apples away, s free as the wind o' r th plains of the We t
And picking some ripe, juicy cherries,[...]o tra el or to top, to rid or to walk.
Then after the cows in the evening,
To hurry them home on the fly,
Then into the kitchen and cupboard But on no vati u to tay;
For a hunk of that old pumpkin pie. To hart n ye[...]ou a on h r n t,
Then up in the morning quite early, To lo and to[...]aught ou and gath r d
And tart d right off on the fly or gr d and for profit for your alp and
To locate that little tin buck t
For a hunk of that old pump in pi uffalo ar gon
Then show me the ch ery old fir place ug baggy[...]Where father and mother ould sit, The whit man h did it, no bl on you,
Surro[...]Your wig, am
Gone are the days of my childhood, Lik ka[...]h br u and loyal to th cor of th ir
And fancy them tanding quite near.

They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (262)258 THEY GAZED ON THE BEARTOOTHS

When Lillie Roundup Throws Her Ro[...]The circus then began,
When Lillie Roundup thro[...]her if you can.
s it goes whirling through the air She walked up to Mr. Bron[...]e, sweet little girl,
And a it drops around the steer Swung herself into the saddle
It is an amu ing sight, As the bronk began to whirl.
For Lillie with both[...]Up hill, down hill, everywhere, I guess;
The estimation of h rself The bronk has his baggage, Lillie has the game,
In her own eyes are great;[...]Five dollars, ten dollars, she rides him all the
She ays she's champion roper, same.
The be t that' in the state.
Young Lillie is a pretty girl[...]Ten dollars, twenty dollars, plank the money[...]Forty jumps, fifty jumps, riding all the time.
I believe that I could rope and tie[...]ittle sorrel out there Lillie's in the saddle, the rei"ns in her hand,
Somewhere by Buzz[...]Riding Mr. Broncho just to beat the band.
I'll go and catch him up tonight,[...]you plumb to death,
When you first swing in the saddle Eighty jumps, ninety jum[...]onk ides begin to thump,
nd th peach of all th range. ' 11 in and called[...]h you would ow Lillie Roundup i the girl
nd hav him in on tim[...]Come beat her if you can.

The little sorrel n t morning row Lilli itb h r unny y
Was brought into the string, We call her Li[...]1h nd fan cy Is just the Petest little flower
To the tune of th e f lighland Fling. That blo[...]do, If you are on the pike
And Lillie was a-watching th em[...]ttle Lilli Roundup.
With her great eyes of blue. \i ill ri[...]

They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (263) THEY GAZED ON THE BEARTOOTHS[...]ely Grave Out West The Merry Old Round-Up Gives
Away out on the high divide between Yellow- Best Exhibition of All
stone and the Stillwater rivers lies sleeping in Mother Great exhibitions on th rang land,
Earth the remains of a young boy about 14 or 15 In the spring, th summer and fall,
years old> who was killed by the Indians in the early But the on s on th merry old round-up[...]Are th best exhibitions of all.
days of Montana. I fixed up his grave with stone[...]See th m go high, and go crook d!
and wrote the following verses and put them on his S[...]Ahl Yes, the merry old round-up
Gives the best xhibitions of all.
A lonely grave, a sacred spot,
On the old Jim Bridger trail; See the wrangler come in with the bronchos,
A mother's son is sleeping her[...]They have come all the way from the East.
A boy of rather tender years And they all, from the least to the greatest,
To roam so far away, With their stock of unlimited gall,
Out in the wild and woolly West Have declare~ that the merry old round-up
Where Indians kill and slay. Gives the best exhibitions of all.

The Red Man knows his resting place, They m;iy show you the sights of the city,
Their arrows reached the mark, And take you along down the row;
And here he lies now deep in dust, You may pass through the door of the opera,
In house that's cold and dark. And may pass through the· door of the show.
But follow the merry old ,round-up
Through the cold fro ty mornings of fall,
He died alone away out West,[...]Gives the b~ t exhibitions of all.
The Indians in their thirst for blood
Soon shot him to the ground.
The ild how isn't in it,[...]ar sorry and tam ;
ext day the father, ·in his grief,[...]o and go crook d,
The gem of all the West.[...]an, moan and the bawl.[...]ry old round-up
ot in the city of the dead t xhibition of all.
He fills a yawning gra e;[...]rit s hi fam ; of o
But I will place a bouqu t th re[...].
In honor of his nam . I[...]t b i n of all.
ow should you pa thi Ion ly grave,[...]OU
neon ciou of his r t; i un[...]to rr old round-up
The flower of th \ st. The b t xhibition of all.

They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (264)260 THEY GAZED ON THE BEARTOOTHS
They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (265) THEY GAZED ON THE BEARTOOTHS 261

Malugian at Great Falls Goes To The Well, I crawled into the circus and I saw th merry[...]ircus and Tries To Ride a The funniest of the funny men that ever cam to town ;[...]yellow,
Well, wife, I've landed here at last, and the town it And when he would unwind hims If you[...]to bellow.
The streets are wide and handsome and fills me with Roar after roar of laughter went around that circ, 1s
delight[...]another fling;
Many of them two stories high, and some are more The funny clown in funny dr ss th n sung a funny[...]blue-eyed sweeth art, who he called
I went out the other day, dear wife, to take in all his Lucy Long.
the sights,
I walked along quite proudly, too, I gues[...]ung it, oh, so nice, d ar wife, I wish you had
the right; been there;
I walked out to the city park, and then and there It brough[...]the start,[...]und me and called
So I steered right straight for the circus, and the ele- me your weetheart.
phant he was[...]en soon th y brought a mul , dear wife, into that
The people they went nearly wild, you ought to have[...]d asked for a man with nerve enou 1h to ride that
The parade it started early, and it surely was immense, ornery thing;
It reached from the Park hotel, dear wife, out to Lick I hollere[...]ot thinking of hi treacherous soul, nor of the other
I was bound to see the elephant, but they had shore.[...]old fool';
He left thre hundred pounds of fl sh just piled upon I took a glanc around th ring and n th hood-
the ground.[...]h n I ju t s oot d up my I and boldly
Well, the p opl they just hoot d m e you ought to[...]m to mak that
I tell you d ar wife, I f It the sham , I can't tell critt r qu al·[...]I land d quick upon hi back, the p op] hout d .. 70.'
nd pull d my red bandann r[...]round hi n ck
And h ard the ladies laugh and ay, "Old 'Lugian n[...]ow." the burning d k.

They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (266)262 THEY GAZED ON THE BEARTOOTHS

He went around that circu[...]changed his method quick, but found the fool;
it wouldn't work,[...]While big Malugian, the old cow, will ride the mule[...]Ol1t
afar,
It seemed I almost then could see the gates that· stand[...], Away out in the country on the far f acific slope
But I was still a-staying ther[...]As she swings into the saddle with the reins in her
Then up again into the air he circled, churned and ·, hand
twist, ·she's the picture of old Ireland to grace the Beulah
But spurred him with my old brogans and fa[...]ended like, and to earth again ow what's the matter, Hannah, are you going to
did shoot,[...]I thought he had you buffaloed, I really did, of course;
a toot. You may swing into the saddle with your courage and[...]your gall.
His eyes seemed now to be of fire, his heels seemed But something ·will be doing when that bronk begins
full of danger,[...]on his back, you know, three hundred
pounds of stranger; I am sur[...]old On a cold and frosty morning when the saddle cinch
out so long,[...]p for fifteen Though your feet are in the stirrups and the reins are
hours strong.[...]Raven locks are beautiful, with eyes of sunny blue,
Apd flashed around that circus ring l[...]he went a-twisting through squall,
the skies An[...]nah, it ain't no safe retreat
When we got back to the circus ring, there nothing To mount a wall-eyed broncho when he's laying for
looked the same, you[...]band,
The mule got back that very day with eyeballs big[...]lah land.
He landed in the circus ring, but I away outside.[...]so fop
I gathered up myself, dear wife, the very best I could, For your tub of joy is brimming and is just about
But no doubt left some flesh and bones in the place to slop;[...]a call,
Then noticed I had lost a leg and part of my big toe. And oh, an awful parting as the bronk begins to bawl.

They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (267) THEY GAZED ON THE BEARTOOTHS 263

Yes, some morning while at breakfast the flapjacks Tutie then just wrote it down,[...]John Wesley Stewart Kime.
Then you'll swing into the saddle with the reins in
your hand,[...]on end.
Now come all you jolly cowgirls who ride the West- .If it isn't a prize taker
ern p[...]You can have that pup of min ,
Come stay with the wall-eyed broncho till he breaks 'It is little young Joe Lucifer
the bridle reins;[...]are goers,
And some girl will find a landing when the bronk Like hubby on the dock,
begins to bawl.[...]We are hastening 'now to Tutie's,
Then swing into the saddle, boys, when you hear an We are[...]To see little young Joe Lucifer
Yes, swing into the saddle, boys, with the rope in John Wesley Stewart Kime.
your hand,
For the bronk has thrown his rider away out in Beu- Oats and eggs are just the stuff
lah land.[...]t a drive they will endure.
Naming The Baby Two strong miles[...]w calico Says Paddy on the Rhine,
And grease my Sunday boots,[...]tch little young Joe Lucifer
And dim b onto the wagon, John Wesley[...]to Tutie's We are turning now the corner
And have come home awful quick,[...]We are hitting hard th road
For Tutie named the baby, We are reaping now th harv t
And the baby now is sick. That[...]We are g tting th er lik Eli,
I'll feed the mules some oats and eggs, nd g[...]littl young Joe Luci£ r
And you shall hold the whip, d ar wife, John We 1 y t wart Kim .
The ribbons giv to me.
For Tuti named the baby, Only ju t about[...]nd ding at th gat
Of all th nam I' e r ad about,[...]·
I think this on will tak the 1 ad, f that lit[...]

They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (268)264 THEY GAZED ON THE BEARTOOTHS

The Boys at Billings There's[...]rals, No broncho gets the game.
But the Billings boys can ride them
To a sweet[...]He keeps his spurs a-digging
Ifs out across the Yellowstone, And his qui[...]And he rides Sir Mr. Broncho
You'll find the Conway old Corral Till the stars begin to shine.
And all the boys thereat.[...]ys, I've had my say,
Jack Herford, he is in the swim, Now I must jump the fence,
With Lowther, too, his chum,[...]found I've just commenced.
And isn't on the bum.
There is Lanky Jake, the wrangler, He Was Going Some For A Preacher
From somewhere in the state,
He swings into the saddle I put my hat upon my[...]And rides them all first rate. The night was light, the moon was bright, the air was[...]I walked out to a stylish church in the western part
And the pulling not be slow, of town,
But he'll fan them with his quirt The preacher was dressed up so fine he could not
And ride them for the dough. well sit down.
There's Albert Caton, you all know, The preacher was a gifted one, not timid, weak or shy[...]s might to make good angels
And when he got the saddle on cry;
He[...]his coat,
Then shot into the air, So stood he there upon the floor and praised the Lord
Turned over before he hit the ground, by note.
But lande[...]The sky was clear and cold that night and showed no[...]on again he took a start, sign of storm,
And bucked toward the sun, But he could preach of hell so hot it sure would keep
He met some[...]But dodged them one by one. Of all the men I have ever heard portraying the
wicked' s lot
The way he smashed that saddle up With a[...]loquence could paint a hell
Showed well the bronk was game, so hot.
But Albert kept the old hull on
And rode him just the same. He said there was a lake of fire, a seething, burning
hell,
If you think the Billings boys can't ride[...]seething flames and hurled them
Beneath the earth and sky.
through the room,
There's Wesley Cagle, the old boy, In burning coals and fiery flames he cried the sin-
You never hear him squeal. ners' doom.
But pours the music from his throat
When he puts to the steel. Eternal and eternally the circling flames would roll,
To torture and torment the lost, the weak and help-
He rides them in a circle,[...]prodders for him?
Till the ~ronk goes fine. The devil was rejoicing with a most becoming grin.

They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (269) THEY GAZED ON THE BEARTOOTHS[...]they always would exist within that burn- The graceful antelope and d r I us ,c] to get with[...]ten thousand years to torture Could rope the wild st broncho and rid<:> him wit ' I'<'
just the same; I pleased.
With cries of pain ascending up through all the count-
less years, It's away down in the nation, hoys I know \\'t'll all
A cruel God, a heartless wretch, would have his time the trail,
of tears. And away across Wyoming, the land of storm and
hail;
He did not preach the love of God, nor from the[...]rest,
But talked of fearful punishment dealt out to the
I wandered to Montana, boy , to roam out in the
wicked dead;
West.
All through the vast eternity while circling years
shall roll
The flames of hell will surge and throb upon the These old Montana roundups I think will take the[...]They'll call you in the morning with th , starlight in
That gifted preacher, too, may here depart-depart the sky;
from me,[...]will start you on a circl full forty miles away.
The heathen and the harlot shall nter before thee; And you are[...]if you g "t two meals a day .
You have not taught the love of God, but spite, re-
venge and hate,[...]It's here I met a Southern boy, from the old Texas
While the people for salvation did hunger, long and[...]by profession , which I will now n"latc:
I think the worst men that we have are preachers He[...]and child,
For when they see the simple truth they turn away To follow the long-horn d steer around in the ~fon-
their eyes; tana wilds.
They'll stamo the floor and make a fuss and preach
eternal fi[...]Dec mber day, jut a little aftt'r noon ,
And then the fair and supper comes to pay the \i e rounded up a bunch of steers and roundc•d th ,m
preacher's hire.[...](Song) The sh riff and his dep 1ty just happ ned to he nea[...]nc 'r shall
B fore I leav old \ et Gra s to go to the pen to forg t
ch 11.[...]r·
Till I ] ft my d ar old horn t ad to rid upon the o ar in sh ho ·, I[...]To bond a man h hind har · for killing of a steer.
They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (270)266 THEY GAZED ON THE BEARTOOTHS

Th heriff and hi deputy they did not do us right, The jury quickly hastened, boys, its verdict for to g[...]law and I would always fight; They thought the old-time Cowboy was hardly fit to
Th y aid to tak[...]To labor hard for five long years in the penitentiary.
Of cour , a bad report like this may send me o'er the The sheepmen and the cattlemen have had a dreadful
road,[...]Western clime;
But if I have to wear the stripes and make a prison But the sheep have got the range today, the herder's
hand got the grippe,
You11 never hear me fret or whine-I still[...]Just as they had long years ago away down in the
man.[...]How Are You Fixed For Straw?
-pacing up to the jury seats in their orwegian[...]in his walk.
While each one had his mind made up, the seed
already sowed,[...]Reuben come to visit us
To turn the old-time Cowboy down and send him[...]From where he used to roam;
o'er the road.[...]at Deer Lodge,
But there wa Lawyer Barbour, a man of low Far away from ho[...]p his hate nd forgot to swipe the horse;
on me;[...]I cannot well forget, Got a year, of course.
He was the blackest of them all-I thing I hear him
yet.[...]He says he took a chance once,
Thus spread the great R. R. Purcell like a cyclone_ Got a solid year;
o'er the skies, It looks mighty funny
He made the courtroom ring aloud with falsehoods[...]How are you fixed for straw?
the road."[...]Reub n g ts up early
H aid up at the old stockade I had no house nor[...]How are you fi ed for straw?
blush to hide.

The foreman of my jury, boys, Louis Guthrie was his He goe from the table,
name,[...]ing high falutin slang,
sh pman with the wool all on and both hands in Out upon th sid walk
the game;[...]

They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (271) THEY GAZED ON THE BEARTOOTHS 267

He goes to the loafing shack, We have the biggest rascals here
Looking sorter glum[...]ng some. They got it in the neck.
Divy to the jackpot,
Something I can chaw;[...]Can play his game of peas.
Reuben goes to dinner,[...]ll drive out to your dwelling
Slim around the girt; With a spanking team of bays;
Comes out from dinner[...]And he talks so very smoothly
A-playing with the greyhound While the other rubs it in,
Or fooling with the cow. And they tickle the old farmer
Reuben's up against it,[...]They are working on the farmer
Reuben goes to breakfast, Just to do the funny thing.
Flapjacks mighty hot; ow they have the farmer moving
Going to fill your pockets? And a-coming up the stream,
Guess you better not. And the agents they are tickled
Reuben starts a-singi[...]nd the farmer is a-blooming,
See Reuben coming[...]a littl sw etheart Wh re the hair i rath r hort.
Down in rkansas;[...]in -c and d ath,
He com from the loafing shack To b p bl[...]-looking mighty fin , Of d t h' · ath.[...]

They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (272)[...]iddling late. Right down into the ditch.
As he thought of all the suckers
Who were willing to be caught[...]feeling at his throatway The sheep began to scare;
Like a flapjack when it's hot. The shepherd dog began to work[...]Upon his master's hair.
Oh, the different kinds of people The way he pulled his master round
This old world can show up, Showed well the dog was game;
The wolf in his sheep clothing You bet he towed this herder man
And the drunkard with his cup. Til[...]We h ave them all at Deer Lodge,
The walls are high and strong, You ought to have seen this herder man
The farmer with his whiskers In mud and water deep,
And the agent with his song. A-pranc[...]As crazy as his sheep.
A-musing on the past; I left him ther[...]With all his fuss and roar,
But the musing long will last. And nev[...]a great world after all. The birds began to sing,
The cattle feeding on the hills
ow you horny-fisted farmers[...]hay seed, Had went across the bridge
Your horses and your herd, Beyond the rocky point divide
Just be a little skittish Across the stony ridge.
In believing all you hear[...]ents tell some whoppers And now the range looks good to me,
And they sound[...]ld potato raisers, The glorious rangeland share.
Who have always took the prize, Say Sheepman, listen now[...]F or if you do my bucking bronk
Let the smart insurance agents[...]With their cute and funny ways,
Work the hills and wooded valleys I ha[...]oom to go and come,
way out West upon the range And joy to meet the puncher boys
Where cattle used to s[...]n they are scattered some.
I saw a band of sheep, old Pard,
I saw-the herder, too, So now 111 pi[...]his stinking sheep, Beneath the Western sky,
Just like all herders[...]Have bid the range goodbye.
It nearly took my[...]
They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (273) THEY GAZED ON THE BEARTOOTHS 269

Written in The County Jail at ow while he's[...]Big Timber, Montana The work is never done,[...]ail For when we get a streak of lean
Because accused of crime. We'll get a streak of fat.
We're laying in Big Timber jail,
And surely feel the curse, Say, won't you kill the fatted calf
But in our hearts we're thankful, boy[...]orse. With ham and eggs along the side-[...]'Twould be a perfect treat.
This jail outfit's the laziest gang A pullet, too, with[...]A turkey good and ripe,
They're rather small of caliber, Would suit us poor o[...]s what we get,
In weather hot or cold,
'Cause the sheriff is too lazy, boys, Although we're in this lonely cell
And the jailer is too old. For[...]'t strike us with your fishing pole
Jake Lyons is the turnkey man, Until we a[...]own every morning late, In the good old summer time.
Stands up and walks aro[...]. For their friendship in the past[...]taking just another chance,
When Jake comes from the boarding house We hope it still may la t.
With hot coffee in the can, And when we swim old Jo[...]to know, my boys, Cross o'er the Gr at Divid ,
That Tucker is the man We hop to e fri nd[...]In a way that won't be slow. The Old Slop 1ule at Deer Lodge
ow Jake, our jailer's out of town, I am a good old orking[...]But my lif ' b n ry hard
Of course it made us all f l bad,[...]om y ars ago th trip s w nt off
The pie and cake don't come;[...]ack Th y mad a tru ty mul of m
So he can bring us sorn .[...]ha are, too;
And bring u · lots of pi and cake, Th y l[...]

They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (274)270 THEY GAZED ON THE BEARTOOTHS

Of drivers I have had a few,[...]re or less; And of the poorest grade;
Jim Doodle is my driver now,[...]My mouth can sing a tune;
And when the ladies come around I'll ro[...]ll right now and feeling fine
And done the best of work; To knock that Du[...]d me, To chase him round the opera house
I never played the shirk. And hear the ladies shout.
But now when old and stiffene[...]me with a stick; I'm on the highway route;
But I will show that Dutchma[...]ne that Dutch hog warden up,
He jerks me by the bridle bit[...]Two Dutchmen left the burning deck,
The way I'll fix that Dutchman yet[...]The old mule got his dander up
I hate to have t[...]They thought to make a fool of me,
And then I overturned the cart In this they both did fail.
And spilled out all the soup. For if you treat a mule that way
The hog warden come a-butting in[...]e's laying for your meat.
He landed in the tub.[...]that horrid stuff. Upon the boneyard route,
I started them a-going some, Where all the Dutchmen in the world
A gait I couldn't stop; Will never bawl me out.
And run the cart into the creek
And spilled out all the slop.
The Cowboy's Last Retreat[...]d pard, cold, druel fate
But it was all the same; Hath dealt us both a blow;
The old mule had his dander up,[...]e sadly know it's so.
And while they fished the old cart out, The days! How long they do appear,
I stood so good and still; The nights appear the same;
They also got the barrels again, H ere we have time to view the past
But had to leave the swill. And try t[...]

They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (275) THEY GAZED ON THE BEARTOOTHS 27[...]few more days, dear friend ,
Have often found the snare[...]And prize it to retain.
With storms upon the sea of life[...]May the world to you be kind,
Rough billows toss our empt[...]As you give the last, long ling ring look
To try our cowboys'[...]To the ones you l av b hind.

There is a way that seemet[...]d when outside, among your fri n<ls ,
To man of woman born, Be honest, true and straight,
It leads him to the door of death- And lend a hand to a[...]And help him find the gat
Oh, why will we poor mortal men That opens up to the oth r range,
Forever court distress, Where the round-up herd will feed;
While on we ride at breakneck speed Where the roundup boss with lo e an<l life
Great evils[...]a better way to live, The Horrors of A Prison Cell
And a better way to die;[...]Well, Pard, old boy, cold cruel fate
The stripes we wear today, old pard,[...]Doth often seem unkind,
Make plain the reason why.[...]nd more severe to those who leave
Prepare to ride the upper range,[...]Their loved ones far b ehind.
Where the round-up herd will feed,
A term of years in prison garb
Where the grass is rich with juice of life[...]Is sure to meet you there.
There the round-up boss is good and kind,
And the flower of love doth grow; Gaunt Terror meets you at the door
You'll find some old-time cowboys there,[...]With all its helli h glare;
Who rode on the range below The iron door with bars of t l
And were caught by the gospel round-up, Will deal you out your shar .
On the range where they long had sinned 'Tis here you fell th galling pain
And the brand of life now glow and shine Of sorrow's bitt r tear;
With a luster there undimmed. 'Tis here the tim i slow and long-[...]ach day se ms lik a year.

Come, put your name on the big brand book,[...]Man's inhumanity to man
Ere you pass to the great divide;[...]s re mo ly hown,
Come spread your bed by the river of life,
nd h th ·n hi trip
Where the range is big and wid .[...]M r ap has o n.
There you can roam the sun-lit plains-
The mills of all grind on
The cowboys' last r treat·[...]a lo d la nt,
There you can stay with the round-up herd,[...]ntil th y grind your mea u har
Where the wat r is clear and sweet.[...]You cannot s th on ou lo
Away from the child of sin; You can but e th \ rong;
And drink from the clear, cool stream of life Whil you can see and that quHe w 1[...]a on ict in hi trip s,
When the sun i setting low pictur of our fate·
On rosy clouds or rainbow hue,[...]fter-glow. Th fruit of sham and hat '.

They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (276)[...]C/l

THE PLATEAU LOOKING SOUTH TO MOUNT WOOD (Cente[...]

They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (277)THEY GAZED ON THE BEARTOOTHS 273[...]
They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (278)274 THEY GAZED ON THE BEARTOOTHS

I know, Old Pard, and that quite well, It takes the tender words of love
And you do know the same, To thaw the ice-cold heart,
That every stone in this Co[...]ell with shame. And make the hate depart.
See that old stone box, the prison cell,
Is barred with iron and st[...]I truly sympathize with those
To hide the prisoner from the world, Whose home's a prison[...]he feels. For I have seen the prison chain
That binds the prison men.
It's here you may forgotten be Pride, hate and envy is the chain
By wife and children kind,[...]your dreams you visit them, Unless the love of Jesus Christ
The ones you left behind, Sh[...]I point you now to Jesus Christ,
Unless the golden cords of love The Lamb for sinners slain;
Will draw them[...]And soon will come again.
Man's rule of cruelty to man Oh! Come to[...]d from you will not depart.
And here within the prison pen
His life is marred and blur[...]n you leave this prison pen
To breathe the prison air; I shall often think of you,
It seems that whether good or bad[...]have a large place in my heart
You get the buzzard share. For one so[...]we have to stay, old Pard,
And dark will be the blot on one Till freedom s[...]to our fate.
They come to this great school of crime And if we ask for anything[...]ccord For convicts only wear the stripes
Man's cruelty to man. And the guards they wear the shoes.
Some are here whose time is life,[...]ull well, old Pard,
nd some outside are on the road That fearful passions burn,
To reach the same resort. That grow and[...]vain may you expect reform The school of crime here flourish well,
Where teacher[...]Each one tries to betray;
You cannot change the cruel heart Ohl What a long great roll of crime
But with words of love. For that great[...]ye mighty gate,
Hate and revenge both mark the road And set this prisoner[...]Soon do the same for me.
o good can come to cruel hear[...]with evil pant, Along the path of fame,
But like a child when whipped at scho[...]nt. I know you'll be the same.

They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (279) THEY GAZED ON THE BEARTOOTHS 275

The Wife That I Loved So Well[...]But no answer is r turned,
Across the hills of sorrow Like a dead lea[...]ner toiled one day, Or the ashes from the urn.
He had felt the curse of Eden
Since ere he'd went astray.[...]rit was depressed, For I love the flow rs of friendship
In rain or storm or sunshine[...]My hope once strong as an anchor,
He thought of his dear old mother But now it ha been slain,
And the wife he loved so well, And I feel the hard, cold pr ssurc
He thought of his own dear children, Like the wind through a broken pane.
What a story of life would tell.
He thought how his friends forso[...]ot a friend on this old plan t,
When the day of trouble came, ot a chil[...]But still there's a consolation
He thought of life's great purpose Comin[...]That with me in all my roving
He thought of his old-time sweetheart Goes the wife I loved so well.
And he thought of his wedding day.
He thought that his life was use[...]g with a broken shell, Where the Western sun reclines
But with him in all his rovings I know the spark would brighten,
Goes the wife that he loved so well. I know the fire would shine.
Cursed be the gate of a prison
I know my days are numbered, And cursed · be the prison cell,
For I feel quite frail and weak,[...]uld like to see my sweetheart, The wife that I loved so well.
And I want to hear[...]and scorning My mother in the churchyard
The doom of a prison cell, Where a stone of marbl rears.
For it tore from my own bosom My wife away out yonder
The wife that I loved so well.[...]But I'll me t h old dr amland
And I think of her as of ten,
Till I cro r at Di id
As often as the sun go s down.
For I know my years are wasted[...]. \/
Like the strand of a brok n thr ad,
of p ac:e
Feeling void of all ambitions,
nd I know that my hope is d[...]rt
But the echo from th hilltops But[...]ring on a broken harp. o th fo of man ar lurkin~,[...]l pain I've suffer d Lik the froth an<l foam of the oc ·an ,
nd the lonely night of wo , r a riv r u[...]

They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (280)276 THEY GAZED ON THE BEARTOOTHS

The springtime brings her beauty[...]So I'm lonely and forsaken,
And the winter brings her sleet,[...]Like the strands of a broken thread.
Oh, could I only meet her[...]Goes the wife that I loved so well.
But my lips[...]Getting My Old Calf Pants Washed
When the heart and mind is shattered
By the thoughts of a ruined life, I send you in my old calf pants,
When the strings of hope are severed The only ones I've got,
By folly's cruel kn[...]three long months I've cherished them
When the lamp of life is feeble Until they took the rot.
And it's flame is dim and low, Of course I hate to send them in
There's a cloud of solemn sadness They are[...]Where on the calves do lick.
Oh, if she would only answer I think the guard is stuck on them,
And bid me hope once more, I see him give the wink,
Oh, if she would send me greetings[...]fe's checkered journey And all the guards with one accord
With the one I loved so well. To[...]So wash them clean, take off the smell,
I would gather the children round us And fix t[...]ok up, my brother, do not fear
Blotting out the faults and failings To face the withering blast,
Of all the cruel past. For gr[...]These dark and cruel prison walls
The clouds would roll away,[...]Is shadowed deep in shame.
The wind would carry the tidings,
The sun would brighter shine,[...]Do seldom reach the spot,
On that sweet wife of mine. But leave behind[...], From those who wear the chain,
o one shall hear my groans,[...]g as ever, May he who made the brilliant sun,
Though a thousand miles apart, The golden stars to shine,
And would lik[...]

They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (281) THEY GAZED ON THE BEARTOOTHS 277

When The Bronk Begins To Bawl When the rider goes to shaking, turning pale
around the gills .
It is out here in Montana, which we call the
Treasure sfate, ·[...]chills;
Where we raise the bucking bronchos, with the[...]b egins to go
Where the rich, nutritious grasses gives them
There is not a bit of danger he will pocket
muscle, strength and n[...]up your dough;
To go up high and crooked and make the
When he's left the royal palace and is looking
proper curve;[...]sick and small
Where we have the best of riders-some are
The horse will drop his baggage when the
Short and some are tall-[...]to bawl.
But there's always something doing when the
bronk begins to bawl.

When the bronk has gone a-fishing somewhere
It is out here in Montana, in the wild and up in a cloud,
wooll[...]nd is coming like a thunderbolt and feeling
Where the bronk grows to perfection and the mighty proud,
Cowboy's at his best; You may have a pair of rollers as large as
From the murky picturesque Yellowstone away motor wheels,
up to the line With shanks as long and ugly as a fork of
You will find those pitching bronchos and[...]plain and valley they will amount of gall,
answer to the call For there's always something doing when the
To show you something funny when the bronk bronk begins to bawl.
b[...]It is out here in Montana, in the wild and
You may gather in your punchers, you may[...]Where the bronk can shake a diamond or the
And every one will answer with a record of his[...]ld have
They will tell you they are twisters from the
you all to know,
little town of Fisk,[...]afety is some distanc off and danger
And can ride the twisting bronchos, no matter[...]So I warn you, g ntle fellow, if you b short
But the dust cloud rolling yonder says there's[...]n th bronk
And some gent will find a landing when the[...]e a gallant rider and can turn your When the bronk goe off prosp cting t nt
broncho loose[...]to his call
But something will be doing when the bronk nd th addle drop its baggag wh n the
begins to bawl.[...]

They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (282)[...]Cl)

GREAT NUMBERS OF MOUNTAIN SHEEP FIND WINTER REFUGE IN THE Roahen Photo
BEARTOOTH PRE[...]

They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (283) THEY GAZED ON THE BEARTOOTHS 179[...]But she hasn't got the stuff;[...]ky horse They have plenty of protection
When you leave dear old Montana And they're asking none of us,
And strike out another course. And they're reaping now this harvest
It is the one great rangeland Of feathers and of fuss.
That now is up to date,
Where the long-horned steer is feeding Chorus:
In the Golden Treasure State. The[...]it's here I want to bel Where the grass is rich and sweet,
You may go down to T[...]And where Jature is enchanting
Where the morning glory vine And tu[...]isting and a-twining It's the only range that's open,
Round the cypress and the pine. Where a puncher now can rest,
But the doggies they get ticky, Is the range of old Montana,
And they die upon the spot; The fair gem of all the West.
There they pine away the summer,
Chorus:
And the winter's just as hot.[...]ve up to Kansas She's the Bingen on the Rhine;
On the old Dodge City trail; She's a-d[...]and fences And a-coming up the line.
And a free delivery mail.[...]And unwilling to be numb red
And the farmer with his whiskers With the dying and the dead.
Is the only one you meet. Chorus:
Choru[...]But if you go to · bra ka
In the summer it is drouthy, I , ill bid you all goodnight.
In the winter it is snow. But when you lay m out to r t,
And the only place that's open, B[...]Plant m in old 1 ntana,
Is the range of old Montana That's sunny, lone and wide.
The fair jewel of the West.[...]
They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (284)280 THEY GAZED ON THE BEARTOOTHS

A Notice on The Lone Cabin When Your Hull O B[...]d that I could ride him
Well, boys, I .have the cabin done, And would show them that I could,
But the fellow isn't here; But the way I'm pulling leather
But when the grass starts on the hills Looks as though I won't make[...]ny other riders found
So I will measure off the land They could not reach the goal
And set the corner stakes, When the steer became a circus
And try to whistle up[...]And their hull began to roll.
For the ranch on Bridger Brakes.[...]good, In a frantic sort of way,
But a boxcar roof is better,[...]o saddle up a long-horned steer,
But what's the use of either one If on him you can stay.
If the weather is no wetter? It's a cinch he'll come a-jumping,
Here's plenty of good water, -boys, And you'll find the badger hole,
To quench your thirsty pai~; When the steer's a flying circus
Walk over to the spring out there And your hul[...]t But a steer will take the prize,
And things are looking glum-[...]Say, what are you about? The steer will be a winner
Only twelve miles to Whiting's store, And will drop you on the spot.
Does your mother know you're out?[...]I don't begrudge the jackpot,
or the wager on the side,
But admire the long-horned Texas
The Gems of Old Montana That put up the hardest ride.
'Cause we live here in Montan[...]'re tough; But you cannot reach the goal,
We are just as good as they are, When the steer becomes a circus
We are diamonds in the rough. And your hull begins[...]0
We are the kinds of diamonds "Hull," old saddle.
That will ease your troubled breast-
The gems of old Montana,
The pride of all the West. The Rustler Gets The Blame
Here Montana sage is plenty,[...]And I see he's made a kick,
Here we sell the short-horn feeder, He speaks about s[...]we sell no gilded bricks. Who of late are very slick.
When the weather's dry and dusty As he stands in his old cabin
Our crops all grow the best, And looks out upon the bluff,
In the soil of old Montana, He says the weather has been fine,
The pride of all the West. But now it's awful rough.
Don't leave the land of plenty, ow he steps from out the cabin,
Where happiness is found, Views the archway of the sky,
But stay here in Montana, And he sees the pesky doggies
Where they have a heap of ground. Have been climbing awful hi[...]With a woe begotten frown-
And board at the penitentiary I wish that bloomin' critter
A great share of your life. Would qui[...]

They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (285) THEY GAZED ON THE BEARTOOTHS 2[...]other down to feed, That the brain of the human soul reels;
But I never will go after him, And as they look down in the deep, dizzy gorge,
He's got the loco weed. The band of solemnity feels.
When feed's put out next morning There are beautiful streams in the Yellowstone Park
The critter still is there, That tumble through mountains of snow;
And the other hungry doggies That plun[...]e awful thinking, A beautiful sight in the Yellowstone Park
Acts though about to cry, Are the geysers when seen in their play;
But he doomed it to- destruction, The Giant, Old Faithful, Artemesia, The Fan,
So alas, ~e calf must die.[...]Are awful and grand in their way.
This is the way in many a case You will surely feel weaker in your effors of strength
Where the rustler gets the blame, When the Fire Hole and Hell Hole you see,
Their carcasses grace the hilltop And think when these wonders their swaddling bands
And likewise the public lane. burst,[...]And no longer will detain, The transcendant beauty of the Yellowstone Park
But look up a bloomin' carcass, Bedazzles the far-seeing eye;
And perhaps it will explain. Where the blankets of beauty over ature is spread
And the hand of the Master is nigh.
So go on, put up your cabin[...]arden seed, o beauty in city, in the village or town
And drive those hungry critters down With the Yellowstone Park can compete;
From off the loco weed. Here rivers and cr[...]There is something inspiring in the Yellowstone Park[...]hat fills with a silent delight;
Go Chum With The Geysers Awhile And when I refle[...]and sorrow takes flight.
You no doubt have heard of the Yellowstone Park,
The great Wonderland of the world; The natural scenery in the Yellowstone Park
This great Wonderland, the pride of the West, Is lovely, majestic and grand;
Has its flaglets of beauty unfurled. Such scenery I love,[...]For it is of no mortal man' hand.
The greatest of wonders in the Yellowstone Park
Are the wonderful mammoth hot springs It is sur[...]Your canvas to pr ad on th gr n,
While the waste away water most beautifully And spend the wift hours in !aught r and ong,
sings. And talking of what you ha e
There is ravishing beauty in the Yellowstone Park,[...]And driv from your oul ;
The mountains and hilltops, rivers and rills,[...]eath in th pur air.
There's canyons of beauty in the Yellowstone Park,
Outshining the jewels of queen; It is h re in their beauty the gey rs do pout
Where sapphires of beauty are hidden from sight, And tos[...]ful diamonds between. nd gleam in the light of th brilliant old sun
Like show rs of j w I at pla .
There's the Yellowstone Canyon in the great
Wonderland,[...]e to this great Won<l rlaml
Grows there in the dark cedar shade. nd chum with the g y ers awhil .
They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (286)282 THEY GAZED ON THE BEARTOOTHS

Where ature, with beautiful garm[...]and Red Horse fought fearful there that
And the geysers do spout at their best; day,
Where the ngel of Peace plants the flowers of love, And thick on the Little Big Hom did the dead and
To bloom on the trail of the West. dying lay-[...]Bull close by their side where Custer
To look on the ravishing beauty of earth, fought and fell.[...]bled,
nd take a glad look at the pile, The redskins rushed upon the scene to cut and scalp
nd hit the old trail to this great Wonderland the dead;
nd chum with the geysers awhile. But did not t[...]always fight.
Indian's Story of
Custer's Last Battle No more will those wild savage braves ride o'er the
Western plains,
The Indian ' tory of Custer's fight has never been For Sitting Bull at Wounded Knee now with the dead
remains;
told in full,
or the ma sacre of all his men by the braves of And now no more brave Yellow Hair on In[...]will ride,
Sitting Bull;
It wa in the Big Hom country, in the year of For in eighteen hundred and sevent[...]the Great Divide.
seventy-six,
On the twenty-fifth day of June, no other date we fix.[...]To mark the last long resting place of heroes great
Custer left Fort braham Lincoln in the spring of[...]o more they'll hear the bugle call, or yet the muffled
And with the Indians on the warpath he expected[...]But will answer to the roll call when the judgment
He had six hundred cavalry men and every[...]ntry to Custer did belong.

You know it is a part of life's great mystery of fate
That keeps men ever pre sing on until it is[...]ar a story deep in Early Days of The Cherokee Strip
shame,
Or from the dark night of the past a star leads forth The e verses I have written I hope you all
to fam[...]give heed·
Till Death's cold silent shadows o'er the Little Big My name i nothing extra,[...]I have no gold dust I am always
But when in sight of the enemy he straight for them on the go.
would go.
We now will leave the thirsty strip for twenty
We will hear the Indians' story of Custer's last great day or more,[...]Go to the tate of Kansas, wher we have
On the Little Big Hom river, the bloody Sioux delight; been b fore;
There were little chiefs and big chiefs and the braves We have lots of heat and sun hine, but it's
of many moons, hard to live on wind,
Rough pictures, too, of Indian life to mark the soldiers' I se the boom rs of the Strip ar getting
tombs.[...]

They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (287) THEY GAZED ON THE BEARTOOTHS 283

The Strip has got the measles and we'll pull The yellow spotted pussy cat is running to
out for the mumps, the south,
For I hate to see poor hungry men a-wrestl[...]nd our little kids have got a running at
with the dumps; the mouth.
So we'll harness up the dear old mules and
go off on the fly, Everything is moving with power, love
For when we leave the Strip, you know, it's and will,[...]g or die. For the Strip has got its sweetness and the
Strip has got its swill;
We have lots in the Strip to be thankful for, See them com[...]Eastern lanes,
For when the weather isn't hot 'it's mighty A-gal[...]d wet; the game.
We have rattlesnakes and centipedes, but
cannot name the rest, ow we are back again, and thankful , too,
And when the sun shines out the day it soon for that,
goes down the west. Our cattle[...]mighty fat;
But we are coming back again when the geese The ducks are all good swimmers, but the
begin to flock, creek is nearly dry,
When the frost is on the pumpkin and the But it's big pit or little pig, it's root hog or die.
fodder's in the shock;
We'll tie up here on White Horse and have[...]ar apart we never hear Or a monkey in the kitchen or a kitten in
them whine. the cream;[...]her little tongue a-clickin' like a tickin'
Where the sandburs are a-booming and the
of a clock.
wolves are mighty bad;
We will whistle for the monkeys and we'll[...]dress,
While the dog has got ·the opossum and the
And the rolling plains a-shining with springtime
coon is in the tree.
loveliness;
Oh, the crowning of the roosters and the barking Oh, I tell you that she's spinning like a
of the dogs, pickaninny top,
And the hiking of the rabbit as he hikes And our tub of joy is brimming and it m
into a log; about to slop.
The bawling of the cattle and the braying
of the mules, Our sorrow's turned to gladn and our gloom
And the rattling of the wagon and the clinking is put to route,
of the tools. Our[...]to sprout;
It sort of makes us boomers feel it good The prairie dogs ar barking and a- n zing
to be alive, with the grip
And can watch the little honey bee a-humming Oh, I tell[...]; in the trip.
When we can eat our dinners with an appetit[...]we could·
Everything is booming like a ri er in the And if you want to call a hile an<[...]on the floor ,
For the Strip is now a-coming and a-trying[...]sing; the cabin door.

They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (288) THEY GAZED ON THE BEARTOOTHS 28[...]Oklahoma, The Land That I Love, or
Meaning Beautiful Land The Roundup Coming Through
Oh, let us look back to that country again I am going away to the land that I love,
Far away to the sweet sunny South, In sweet sunny southland I'll roam ,
Where the mocking bird wakes us so early each day, And there under skies that are sunny and blue
With the sweetest of songs from his mouth. I will build me a snug little home.

Where the redbirds whistle in the cottonwood groves Where the redbirds do whistle and the mocking bird
That skirts the Canadian shore, sings
And the whippoorwill's song we will hear once again, And the stars their glory do shine,
As we heard long ago from our door. Where the oak and the ash and the willow tree grow
To stand with the hemlock and pine.
Where the peach and the apple both flourish and grow
In the beautiful land far away; Where the sweetest wild flowers bedeck the green sod,
Come, let us go, let us go to that bea[...]autiful land let us stay. And the song of the woodland compels you to stay[...]nd red, Oklahoma, Oklahoma, is the land that I love,
And strawberries, too, that wil[...]go? I will go, I have said. And the Red Men well named you "the beautiful land,"[...]more or less- Oklahoma, Oklahoma, "the beautiful land,"
And nice sweet potatoes so sappy[...]at a full dozen I guess. For the leaves of your forest and the grass on your[...]plains
Dear wife, let us go to that land of thy dreaming, Grow under a sunny blue sky.
Where the summers are tinted with azure and
gold;[...]Your leafy old woodland is a joy to behold
Where the winters are soft with life's music throbbing,[...]with its moonlight has glory untold. But the cloud of despondency soon pass away[...]As they rove through your sweet scented air.
Land of the Sooners and the boomers of old,
Land of the Cheyenne and the Arapahoes, too; Oklahoma, Oklahoma, I love thy fair land
Land of the cotton, the wheat and the corn, And you have a warm place in my breast,
Basking in sunshine where the skies are of blue. I can n ver forget you nor your sunny[...]As I rove through the wild woolly West.
What's the use living in a land where we're freezing,[...]our old rangeland, though mangl d and tore,
Where the storm and the blizzard both feel for your nd the wound is still bl ding today,
life,[...]But I can't r ally s e it that way.

It's a land of great orchards where the fruit is the best Yes, I lov d th old long-horn a h u d to appear
That grows in the sunshine or wet; To gaze on your gr n grassy od,
Oh, land of great promise, fair land of my dreams, But th happy dr farm r has come with the y ars
How can I, how can I forever forget[...]And over your thr hold will trod.

Here the meadowlark sings in the cottonwood trees, Lik th old Indian t p your cowboys hav gon ,
When the leaves by the zephyrs are stirred, o mor will they circl the h rd
And the howl of the coyote is heard in the hills, o more ill th y list n to th song of th wind
Where the cowboy sings low to his herd.[...]go? and there let us stay o more will the t nd rfoot h av a long igh.
In that country[...]As th old pitching bronk wins the cup.

They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (289)286 THEY GAZED ON THE BEARTOOTHS

Your sunny old rangeland is mangled[...]big country
nd your riders have lost both the reins, And a thousand sort of things,
Your chuck wagon's empty, your saddles uncinched, An easy road to travel,
Since the long-horn is gone from the plains. So we have no use for ki[...]Our president is a stunner
Like the Indian and buffalo they have gone the long
With a mighty sight of gall,
trail[...]For he's up against them all.
But a feeling of sadness sweeps over my soul
When I see them today as of yore. Here we have the grandest country
When I first seen your rangeland great joy filled my Beneath the shining sun,
heart[...]In science and inventions
As I came o'er the old beaten trail, We only have begun.
ow the city club boosters, dry landers and all, Here we have the flag of colors,
Come into the country by rail The red, white and blue,
The good man and the bad man,
Oklahoma, Oklahoma, bright jewel of years, The loyal and the true.
Where the corn and the cotton both grow,
Where the rainbow of promise spans the archway So you better stay with[...]poor mortals below. Ifs the· foot that gets the pinching
Your archways as blue as pretty blue bells When we're putting on the shoe.
That twine in some grass bedded dells, But of course I'm not dictating,
That speaketh in langua[...]For I know it is no use,
Its love for the land where it dwells. You may[...]And may also spit the juice.
Oklahoma, Oklahoma, sweet dreams of the past
re oftimes awakened by thee,[...]nd will use you well, I know,
While the old roving spirit throbs strong in my heart[...]You can get the coon and opossum
I can but remember you st[...]If you only get the dough.
Where the sweetest wild flowers grow o'er your green[...]When Aunt Dinah pats the juba
Like they do on Erin's green isle, And all am feelin' fine,
n<l the song of the warblers so sweet to the ear Oh, what a happy people[...]r whole soul with a smile. As the stars begin to shine.
See the pickaninnies prancing
Yes, I'm going away to that[...]By the dim light of the moon,
Where the skies are so sunny and blue,[...]When the fiddle is in tune.
For the old roundup coming through.[...]For th darkies am a gwine
The Darkies Are Leaving Oklahoma[...]But they better stay with uncle
Oh, the darkies am offended[...]grate, They sure can do the pickin',
They are leaving Oklahoma If th y'v only got the bone.
To find a better state.
But you better stay with uncle But of cour I'm not dictating,
n<l get you[...]For I know it is no use.
You sure can do the pickin' You may chew your own tobacco
If you've only got the bone. And may also pit the juice.

They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (290) THEY GAZED ON THE BEARTOOTHS 287

In The Bad Lands Talk about yo[...]It surely was a sight
I used to love to ramble in the dreary old
To see him yonder in the air
Bad Lands,[...]And urged another trip.
I oould chase the nimble antelope and round
them up for you. To the north side and the south side,
I had a buffalo pony and he seemed to love And all about the town,
my gun,[...]as in Had done his level best,
the land, And that reckless Texas puncher
If I was in the saddle and the rein was in Was there to stand the test.
my hand.
When he could not throw his rider,
The other day while hunting away off on Then he tossed around his head,
the flat
To pull him from the saddle seat
I saw a nimble antelope and flagged h[...]Then all about the town, my boys,
He played another tune-
The Bucking Broncho, It was[...]son, North Dakota or the ragtime of a coon-
There was a bronk in Dickinson[...]But Bill was in the saddle sure
In the world could not be found.
They knew they had a[...]To the east side and the west side,
That not a man in Dickinson
Could ride him for the dough. Then all about the town,
He rode that pitching broncho
But the woolly West has riders,[...]ng broncho Then h sprung from out the saddle
In a way that won't be slow.[...]." If you have a furious pitch r
Then the dollars they were counted, That has n v r y t b n rode
And soon the fun begun, Call on that T xas punch r,
And Monroe, the Texas puncher, H has n ver yet be n throw d.
Took a trip toward the sun. So h re's to that old-t[...]Long may h liv to ride
Monroe soon took the saddle nd find the trail to th horn corral
With a wild Comanche yell. Across the Great Divide.

They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (291)288 THEY GAZED ON THE BEARTOOTHS

A Stampede in North Dak[...]you' re riding on the plains
Talk about your milling cattle and stampede And the chilly damps of morning starts your
on the plains,[...]Your stomach's empty, too,
When the heavens are black with darkness, And there ain't no smell of coffee to change
frowning like the child of sin the grey to blue."
nd heavy hailstones falling with a fierce, When you shiver to the marrow as you crawl
terrific wind.[...]from out your bed
When the lightning vivid flashes shows up[...]to tie your head,
nd you see the long-homed cattle going It is t[...]e at breakfast I will bet
past you on the fly, a horse you'll eat
When the peals of mighty thunder seems to An oven full of biscuits and a whole hind leg
shake the very dome, of meat.
It is then the old cowpuncher lets his thoughts
drift[...]inking you have For us fellows on the ranges know what
hardly time to think,[...]rides all night,
Fall in behind the outfit, you may jump or Keeping track of running cattle with the
swim the streams,[...]find And he's sick and soaked and sleepy riding
them in your dreams. hard all through the night,
So swing into the saddle with your slicker Would you grudge the poor old puncher one
buttoned tight[...]good big honest bite?
nd dodge the breakneck bagger holes by[...]down to breakfast and I'll bet
flashes of the light, a hors[...]An oven full of biscuits and a whole hind leg
of meat.
n oven full of biscuits and a whole hind leg
of meat.[...]Well you see those cattle grazing near the
It was up in orth Dakota and a-way late in top of that divide,
the fall, They're the ones we punchers rounded after
We had a lively stampede as the wind set up forty miles of ride;
a squall;[...]ers from have seen
the little Missouri range,[...]A-1 aving old Knife River as the sun began
nd they ran for nearly forty mi[...]lean, wildeyed doggies fl w;
On the river flat we lay that night with rain[...]anywhere about us An oven full of biscuits and a whole hind leg
could be found. of meat.

They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (292) THEY GAZED ON THE BEARTOOTHS 289

Where storms come hard and swooping I have On The Belle Fourche Far Away
roamed for many years,
But to look about on the old-time range, it Talk about your pretty countries and a climate
almost brings the tears; all superb,
For the sheep have eat off all the grass till Where the ranchers are all wealthy with their
bare as[...]horses and their herds,
And today the robbers still are there a-gnaw- Where every one is welcomed and they want
ing at the roots; a thousa[...]It's the Black Hills lovely region, where the
And the stinking old range robbers cover[...]nearly every ridge; In the South Dakota country on the Bellefourche
You will hear the sorghum peelers as a storm far away.
upon the ground
When the crazy old sheepherder with his
stinking sheep comes round. The red men loved this hunting ground-it used[...]Where the elk and shaggy buffalo around them
Cowpunching now is done away and the land there did roam;
is all co[...]their heart's desire;
The long-homed steer has gone away, they And from the Black Hills highest peaks this
could not stand the scent, valley could survey,
They crowded in their stinking sheep, and off In the South Dakota country on the Bellefourche
the range they went. far away.
Well, we've had our time of riding through
blizzard and the storm,
So I guess you'll not begrudge us a smack of The noble red man now is gone from where
somethi[...]hot, smoking biscuits, and 111 bet Caught in the white man's roundup and drove
a horse we'll[...]They cheated them out of their land and to
A yard of apple butter with a whole hind leg[...]this you say, ·ahem,
of meat.
But the devil he will deal with you as you[...]The tomahawk and scalping knife are not in
Just a lit[...]In the South Dakota country on the Bellefourche
While cowpunchers ride the grub line and far away.
have[...]me, I'm done, The red men with their mighty chief are
For I'm like an old cow pony that's forgotten for d from off the land,
how to run. Caught by the white man's roundup and drove
to the barren sand.
I'll trade off my rope and saddle an[...]kill d at Wounded Kn e.
And dream of the old-time cow songs and the o more the Siou that country raid, rev nge
ones I have[...]I forget you then, old pard? Well, o, In the South Dakota country on the B llefourche
I reckon not.[...]

They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (293)[...]b eauty hung,
The white man took away their land and That m y vivid imagination to the highest pitch
forced them then to figh[...]nd calping knife then p layed And I see the great Creator sitting on the
an active part,[...]In H is hands h e holds the colors of the rainbow
nd many a pale-faced soldier fell[...]nd decay, In the South D akota country on the Black
In the outh Dakota country on the Bellefourche Hills far away.[...]valleys shine,
Rain-in-the-Face, once mighty chief, has gone W h ere[...]g stock forth the scent of pine;
On the big hssouri River at the old p lace- Where sapphire hues are blended with the
tanding Rock.[...]d happy And mystic b eauty linger s in the sunshine and
with their lot, the stom 1;
Forgetting all the old-time raids and battle Where moonlit n[...]In the South D akota country on the Bellefourche
Th old war bonnet and war shir[...]far away.
are u ed today,
In the outh Dakota country on th Bellefourche[...]So Many Years Ago
The outh Dakota country is a land that's[...]'Midst the green fields of Ohio as the western
lo t of her braves have crossed the ridge to sun reclines,
meet the others there; When the evening b reeze is p laying with the
nd may th y r ach their hunting grounds[...]so many
May h who gave them pow r to wi Id the years ago.
tomahaw[...]m mor p ace and happiness than Wh n the silv ry moon was dim bing and the
th y ever had before.[...]Down the d ar old dusty road the buggy w h eels
would hum,
The Black Hills ar so lov ly wh n th w ·t rn[...]my soul be all aglow,
Wh n the w0od d hills and all y throw forth \ h n Lo ina wa my sweetheart so many
the scent of pin. years ago.[...]\ hen the summer days were over and the
great and grand,[...]cool autumn cam ,
With the sun t throwing ki s s that western[...]
They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (294) THEY GAZED ON THE BEARTOOTHS 291

Ohl the fragrance of the breezes where the Love, you know, is beautiful that sta[...]and shines;
With my lover sitting 'neath them as the Love, you know, is beautiful that h[...]twists and twines.
The curtains of night are lovely and the Just now it sends its signals to the p1ace I
moonlight tells you so, '[...]used to know,
When you were out a-strolling with the one When Lovina was my sweetheart so many
of long ago.[...]g, rambling nature takes me Lovina, the green fields of Ohio, have you
back to the dear old State, forgo[...]ee that charming lover standing at And the promise that you made to me-I can't
the roadside gate;[...]m
swift onrushing trains,
And have gazed upon the mountain tops while Oh! Thost Days in North Dakota
on the western plains,
But the most inviting lover and who haunts Away up in orth Dakota, in the year of
me where I go,[...]a as my sweetheart so many years When the game it was plentiful, oh, that was
ago. the place to be;
Away up in that country the skies are[...]y, too, was plentiful, but our neighbors
all the time, · they were few.
Will we ever meet together where the western I am thinking now of Dickinson, my old-time
sun reclines?[...]far away.
Will we talk the many happenings and the
changes that have come?
Will we whisper love[...]where sweet place just to my notion as the orth Dakota
wild flowers grow,[...]Wher th curl ws and th plo rs in the wavy[...]ra s could hid .
Oh, if I was only with her where the western H r a bout and h r coolie ar om[...]gr at and grand
Out where the western breezes get their In th littl Missouri country wh r th
fragrance from the pines; Killd[...]

They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (295)292 THEY GAZED ON THE BEARTOOTHS

Talk about the graceful antelope, they truly Oh, y[...]are so slow,
In the orth Dakota country where the With your prima donna round[...]Where ature's tumbling over, it's the place
good old land.[...]them as of yore,
Just figure with a hunter who has lived a life When you wandered through the meadow field
out West.[...]far from your cabin door;
When the joints were all throwed open and I am sure you'll look more beautiful when the
no sheriff had his say, the bloom of health returns,
In the orth Dakota country, near the Bad Lands By romping round with Nature 'midst the flowers
far away. and the ferns.

With a roving disposition that wo[...]olks and noise,
I drifted for my fortune in the underveloped With ature just a-hugg[...]gives me joy;
I learned to set the beaver trap when earth Then I feel[...]a better rhyme,
And when the fur was sold or shipped I'd So[...]be a-living out with Nature
pocket up the dough. all the time.
Oh, for those bright days back again when the I wish that I could always look out from the
buffalo used to roam misty haze
Across the dreary old Bad Lands so close U[...]days;
Oh, those days in Torth Dakota, where the Where the joints were all throwed open and
skies[...]In that orth Dakota country, near the Bad
neighbors they were few.[...]to speak of him;
In the camp on Old Heart river in the year He was not built like old Dutch John, but he
of eighty-three; was tall and slim.
The very recollection of that buffalo steer Charley, do you remember the northern lights
and fries[...]so bright,
Bring a heaving at my bosom, and the water How the stars would shine and sparkle like
to[...]great electric lights?
With a cup of good hot coffee in the Do you remember Mrs. Smith, how[...]she was scared,
The way that we would relish it, indeed, it She thought the judgment day had come and
was not slow[...]Oh, those days in orth Dakota, when the
the skies are fair and blue, the moon was full and bright,
When big game it was plentiful and the When the stars would shine and sparkle like[...]

They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (296) THEY GAZED ON THE BEARTOOTHS 293

And there's the Cowboy Artist, too, he's one There's Morgan Frank, a friend of mine, an
I do esteem, old-time honored friend,
Some of his paintings almost speak, so true I hav[...]had a great big Western heart that beat
up in the air, his bos[...]his back with quirt a-fanning A true child of the Western plains, of blizzard
of him there. and of storm,
They are so very true to life, the bronk And in the Black Hill's early day he was
a-coming high,[...]away up there
You see an exhibition between the earth A-hunting elk and buffalo, likewise the deer
and sky; and bear.
Long may he live to use the brush, immortal If he is dead, sweet be h[...]ering gold to live and shine on And may the Coming King with love place
the firmament of fame. laurels on his[...]-souled man who meets Oh, there's a host•of old-time friends , I reach
you with a smile,[...]lls I now look back on happier days and see the
is his home,[...]familiar places.
Death-on-the-Trail, another friend, a hunter, And I ofte[...]ier man who knew To give me a reprover of a letter I never
well all the route; wrote
He no[...]Where big game once was plentiful and the
him of his rest. hunte[...]ry Snow, another friend, in ow some of thes old pion ers lay with the
Oklahoma's land,[...]until their breath had fl d;
There sunlit fields of golden grain and vineyards And in th city of the d ad ther Ii the
do abound, last remains
And where the apple, peach and plum on Of men as bra as r Ii d or tr d the
every ranch is found.[...]r that shines Wher tender hearts still think of you and m n
away up there.[...]

They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (297)[...]THEY GAZED 0 THE BEARTOOTHS

· ow the antelope and buffalo gone, oh, The sands of time are running,
what a mighty change, The years go quickly by,
nd mo ·t of the old-time pioneers have gone Tomorrow we'll be old folk,
aero · · the range; Quite ready then to die.
way acros the Great Divide, beyond the Then when our earthly spirit
peaks of snow,[...]t go.
Oh , <lo you dream in your last sleep of how The Lone Star state is coming,
yon used to[...]Marching right up to the front,
When bi gam e it was plentiful and the
f[...]She whispers soft and low,
And may the Coming King with love place[...]. 'Mongst the friends of Alamo."[...]And friendly hands the same,
Down At The ·Alamo With frie[...]er me, So here's to the state of Texas,
s I stand gazing round, _ To the men of long ago,
To think that I have wandered[...]und. Down at the Alamo.
I love old sunny Texas
nd the days of long ago, I love the state of Texas,
When those brave heroes fought and[...]e fills my heart with pride,
Down at the Alamo. I love the state of Texas,[...]she's sunny, lone and wide.
Away down on the Brazos, I l[...]I love all her wide border
The dead were piled in heaps. Out .to the Rio Grande.
way down in this southland
Sleep the m en of long ago, Hurrah[...]Let it ring from sea to sea,
Down at the lamo. F[...]Is where I want to be.
The flow rs bloom as sweetly, Hurrah for Sammie Houston,
The grass grows just as green,[...]t what a n awful chang has been
Since the day of long ago
Since thos brave h ro s fought and fell
D own at the lamo. A Stampede in Texas
Long years ago the must ng W e startPd from Mobeetie up to the northern
Made the ra ngers' fi e ry steed , rang .
\\ h er one the shaggy buffalo With a lively hunch of cattle and a boss called
n<l the long-horn ed stt'cr did feed . Jim MaLange;
Th ose were the days of long ago c a[...]

They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (298) THEY GAZED ON THE BEARTOOTHS[...]e finally stopped those frightened steers
for the night and brought them to a stand
On the sunny plains of Texas, it was a lovely Just as the morning sun arose upon that
sight;[...]Western land;
A jollier band of Cowboys you never well Many a[...]ere loyal, to a stranger we And one of our noble boys that night lay
were kind. numbered with the dead.

We early left that bedding ground just at the o more he'll saddle up his bronk beneath
break of day, that sunlit sky,
We traveled o'er the sunlit plains all dressed No more he'll hear the clinking hoofs of cattle
in Nature's way; on the fly;
And listened to the W estem winds and songs No more he'll ride at breakneck speed across
of the curlew, the trackless plains,
And whiled away the hour of noon where A surging host of cattle will trod over his
sweet wild flowers g[...]Who herd the long-horned cattle and the
The mocking birds were singing where we[...]s health to you, my jolly boys, who roam
But from the west there came a cloud as black the W estem wilds,
as raven night, And luck to all the frontier men who love our
And we boys made things[...]Leaving The Old Farm For The City
The rain it fell in torrents and the lightning[...]freely flashed,
Every Cowboy on his broncho to the front home for the city, and are led away by fashions, and[...]become gay, but at last r turn to the old farm.
he boldly dashed.[...]0 0 0 0 0

The stampede it was sudden, every steer was[...]y, d ar wife, we'll pack our trunks and to
on the fly, the city go,
Their heads were lifted upwards and thei[...]mov o low,
They leaped, they ran across the plains for You know, dear wif , I[...]aft r fashions.

Every boy soon got the saddle, every bronk W hav b n h r in th backwood just
was on the fly,[...]h t, the world i lik ,
W d t rmin d not to leave th[...]

They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (299)[...]HY G ZED 0 THE BEARTOOTHS

ru ·ll yo u ha w ·11 d[...]I think Th y ar ju t the thing for ladies, if they
it for the b · · ,[...]W ,·11 mov, right off tc th ' ·ity , nd l t the old nd th irl that ride the pr tty wheel often
frnm n st.[...]om nd go.

W v ill l 1, h ·s t of v r ythin th, t It'[...]on th h ad of oth r ,[...]t ' of day[...]ri nd old lo c bin for the city bright[...]

They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (300) THEY GAZED ON THE BEARTOOTHS[...]For if I don't this stealing cur
up with the fashion. Will[...]rip and snort,
And on my chin I grew a bunch of whiskers And you may reach the dark, dark hole
coarse and sandy;[...]0
more or less,
And at the ball that evening I entered in A few[...]ess. hung up by the looking glass, with the following[...]nced all night in great delight and swift
the hours flew, "You say there was a him around
And through excitement of the night the And that there was no her,[...]ly drew; And that's the very reason why
But my old wife just took the cake, for she You made use of word cur.
was pert and spry,
And none of the younger ones could swing "Your lac[...]In an idle sort of way,[...]selves so much that night we Was the reason they did not stay.
had to sleep ne[...]ed out again as flowers "In speaking of the dungeon,
do in May;[...]ke regular sport,
But then we soon grew tired of this and longed And the same about your holler
again to roam[...]And your cheap old rip and snort.
Along the old white picket fence around our "No[...]I bring the laces back to you,
We left our dear old cabin home because life And hope you have the gumption
was so slow,[...]To acknowledge favor, too.
And went to the horrid city and started in for "Your par[...]Why, then my labor is ended."
Leave the fashions and the follies for the city[...]In reply I wrote the following verses and hung
them up in the same place:
Stolen Shoe Strings[...]RA TED
After having my shoestrings stolen out of my
shoes in the loafing shack I wrote the following I want to say to you, dear s[...]I saw upon the looking glass
NOTICE[...]er about Like peach buds in the morning dew,
I think it must be[...]
They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (301)[...]TII Y G ZED ON THE BEARTOOTHS

our v ·rs ·s, too, w ·ll[...]"I do not think that lace shoes
Lik' the fish ·r's old hornpip ; re the proper thing to wear,
\Vith thanb to you '[...]ay o I will w ar the rowells
Th · writ ·r i: no nip . If I climb the golden stair.[...]1 r pli d to him in the following ver es, but
That i11l111manitv t[...]H E LACE
. s h ··wtiful u: the ainhO\, , o[...]Ju t lik the e d that' cast abroad
, nd when I crns: ol[...]\ Vhich we poor mortal ow.
Hey on l the Gr nt Divid ',
hop ' to find you th 'rt[...]~n Th gilded p th of fame.
f mm a little[...]

They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (302) THEY GAZED 0 THE BEARTOOTH[...])ti
of the W st
I m t youn H nry ramm r, with pur and[...]chapp was dres ed,
nd a we talked tog th r of hard hips on[...]\) · th c T • ·. h
For it as th tat of T as that ga e to me m[...]Four hundr d rr.il of . unli pl ai n , h u n<l
And thou[...]n o oft n on h r
lawn,
But now I i h to think of them , for tho e bright
da , are gone,
nd I[...]a than an
place on earth
For it \ a th at of T , th t a to me
m birth.[...]a, om of
They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (303) THEY GAZED ON THE BEARTOOTHS 301

The Knot That Hands Have Tied The Cowgirl
When loves goes thumping through your hea[...]ly terms
And ask you to restrain
That current of magnetic love To The Warden, Deer Lodge
That's thumping through yo[...]Would it be against the prison rul s
And be sure the marriage knot is made[...]I'd like for wife to call to mind
For the divorce can soon undo The fields we used to roam.
The knots that hands have tied.[...]is small request to me,
o human courts will feel the pain, nd send them down the line,
o human hands the stain, nd you shall ha e the kind regards
But there upon life's record sheet Of this frail heart of mine.
A blot will long remain.[...]So charge the same to me;
njust indeed would b the thought[...]s topmost crag, The Work of Good owbo
We stoo 1d looked from it afar Go tell them the d ath cru I erp nt
Beyon the sagebrush sag. For a[...]To arou e in th Io, of th mornin
way b yond this great divide[...]Are mountain deep with now,
To water \ 11 the fruitful fields o put on th[...]o h d th loud call of rd,[...]h n.

h \ ork of Bad o b
h r Da b r of h d n
Put[...]Th pm for 1 ou to 1 nd
To the pth of a r a) hum n h ll.[...]ing , ham it , a
o hurrv th m out of th ir bed To tr[...]

They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (304)302 THE Y GAZED ON THE BEARTOOTHS

Mei· amara n eel th dynamite, Three cheers for the stage line,
Th' hacly Bend the tar, And a nickel for the show,
But Ju ·tice with her own right hand[...]ll a car. They call the N .C.O.
. pros cutor rallied forth They fire up the little engine
nd hurried to the field, And then she steams away,
l I cinched the guilty triflers up To get stuc[...]or California, From the little drift of snow,
The land of orange bloom, And wheel him to the round-house
Where th orchards and the gardens Of the little .C.O.
re filled with sweet pe[...]ow, goodbye, Mr. Agent,
Who in the pen reside, To fo[...]in But it takes a quart of vinegar
To cro the great divide. To ca[...]wer state, But sent him to the round-house
But hame upon tar daubers Of the little .C.O.
Who are trembling for the[...]I have met some cranky agents,
Ye , change the name of hady Bend But none to s[...]cour up your town s the cranky little agent
ncl by your clean and spotle s lives Of the little .C.O.
May live your candal down[...]Farewell Titanic
To The Cranky Freight gent Proud Ship of The Sea
lturu alifornia 1911 Con is the great Titanic gone to the home
I thank you for your photo raph of the brave,
m to b quit good- Con are the i teen hundred , down to a
Th v ry ima of your If watery grave;[...]tood Con ar th kind and the lo ing under the
nd pok in ultin cranky word[...]rom th man ion and p alac ne er
r mp n of no r ward again to[...]loth r and on now drifting, n er again
Of th 'ttl . .O.?[...]Con and daring, do~ n into the
·ow, it ur ly i
I am willin[...]n v r b r ked,
Becau y u k d about the rat s h wa larg , trong[...]But h could not contend ,vith th troop of
·w hen h get in such a stew.[...]

They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (305) THEY GAZED ON THE BEARTOOTHS[...]husband till d ath did th m part,
Like a group of brave warriors with a star on B ing tr[...]reast~ of h r heart.
They had heaps of great treasures, but the
summons had come, Oh, how f ble are th g niu of fr il, fl ting
Their journey now ended and th ir[...]' ainst the fore s of natur as it prov d t[...]white- rested foam,
But out with the seaweeds in the midst of the With no clasp on th ir cask t and no d[...]Farew II, proud Titanic, farewell now to
' r eath the foam of old ocean they must sleep th e,[...]Thy pride has b n humbled by the troops of
th sea;
But of all the brave women in that ocean- Farewel[...]ere were To mingle with s aweeds in the trough of the
none quite so true,[...]
They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (306)[...]the day
(Written in letter to Gus Iverson, fr[...]Kinda like thi land of au rkraut, b r and land -[...]Though th beer is mo tly wat r - the oth r little bit
Dear Gus: 'Tm "sittin' pretty" o[...]Like the hill , the woods, the valleys and th tr am[...]Gue the Kaiser had no say-so wh n th y laid thi[...]ooti n w to drag m off h for th hr ak of d y.[...]• ·or the hu y, huning bullet. ea h one whi p rin'[...]
They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (307)306 THEY GAZED ON THE BEARTOOTHS

Yes, I'm f eling quite contented and there isn't much The Flowering Helmet
I lack,
But till my feet arc itching to be on the homeward A helmet in bloom on a cottage wa[...]Its nodding flowers kissed by the evening sun,
[ look out through the window and my eyes gaze Ivy in trail o'er its battered rim
toward the West A tell tale relic of World War I.
While the tus above are <lancing and old Luna's A dent in the helmet recalls the day
at her be t. Two buddies crouched in the Argonne Wood[...]The blood ran red through the tom oak leaves
I can see the old town ·leepin' where it ne tles by From the lad who laid on the slimy moss.
the ·tream, One helmet came home as a souvenir-
Hear the Yellow tone a murmurin' in a moon-kis ed The buddy's hung on a crude, rough cross.
silv r[...]a er akjng, crinkly coldnes a you're crunch- The soldier's soul felt distress, despair,
ing thru the now To know that the war was soon to cease,
Yet the leigh b 11 are a jingling ven though it's Before the battle was soundly won,
ten below. And hands of greed wrote a hopeless peace.[...]ated ermine. Ice floe breaking He knew the fruits of self enterprise
down tream wing And the joys of profit that labor yields.
It's ju t l',;ature' sleeping ea on waiting for the In school his children were taught anew
breath of pring. That the goal of man is liberty.
When the chinook come noofin' and the nows to To pray and play, sing, speak[...]le free.
When creek crack their cry tal cover and the cattle
eek the rang . 1an[...]Our boys meet the challenge of war's wild din.[...]Each on hu band n ph w and Dick or Jim.
When the earth pring into living; flow rs, gre n[...]r l n mu t b fr el For thi they fight!
The air filled with balmy fragran · and th bird[...]There are ond that fetter the h lpl s slave,
That' · the tim when life' \.vorth knowing. Then you nd hond that back the boy in the fray·
hear th out-door c 11[...]tion's de tiny!

Ju t l ave me in th , mountains of my de r old Tr \\ hen the war i ov r nd the boys r turn,
ure tat[...]r mil and mile By the hond. we hought~ b th hour \ 'e ga e.
With[...]

They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (308) THEY GAZED ON THE BEARTOOTHS[...], be- ur . Th y wil1 ca11 on you by wa of M nrmans ,
cause you are the one man America is thinking of Oslo and the lowlands of D m ark and Holland .
most this year. You have changed our way of living, Th y wi11 visit you via th c1iff of Dov r and alais,
and disturbed us o much, that the people of the through th Iberian penins 1]a, and from the shore.
Unit d States are unanimous in th ir wish that to- of TripoH, Malta and r c . . triking f .arl . sly,
morrow will be the happiest day in your 1943. fi rcel[...]going to strive to make it such. And of a right ous cau e.
every successive day will see[...]That melody you h ar i a hymn of hate; it mu ic
written in a spirit of fr <lorn for all m n; its word
Can you hear that hum overhead? It is the hum are the \ ords of promi to a . orrm ing \ orld. It
of industry, geared to maximum production making chant i the recall of the spirit of hri. tma , who
aircraft that will bomb your factories, bla t your legends were horn in the ver land that you now
plants, raze your shipyards and drive your aunted b foul-of Kris Kringle and , · oel and "P ac on Earth,
air-power from the kies. ood v[...]tian world a Yuletide to mak up for the one you
Do you hear that drone and c1inking of ste I?
denied la t w ek. I it, after a11 a hymn of hat •?
That is the voice of many ship ards , here hard-
working merican men a[...]window · of m rican horn . by virtu of our boy
the \ ay , and into th even a wher th wil[...]ort-1i cl an<l incr . -
long r a menac to hipping of troop and[...]ing1 f \: r.
\ h n ·our invincibl armada of battl hip
or has taken r fo e within your shor lin Have you got the gut to fac cl f at? W doub
·ou dare not mak a e[...]ealiz \ ·hat that dron and clinking fore of alli d mi 1 ht~ to comp t , ith th r . entm nt
of . te =>} m an .[...]the intern I r vo111tion of th• ]av s you hav mad
That dulJ thump. th[...]and now ·uhjugat .
it? It is the ound of fi P million , mPrican hoy in
ervice on the march-directing th ir foot t p · to\: ard[...]ar thic;; y , r. hut 1943 i th•
·ou .. o th t the c< mp. the, ]Pave may he fill d with[...]turning point in favor of th alH d , orld. Th lion
notlwr fi\'e million .[...]jaC"kal; and the ag] will I l1 h ra n to flight.
tank and truck. -[...]1943 " th hcginnin~ of t1 n<l of di tator. hip,
Coming with rifle.'-. tommy-g11n.,[...]r nacle. and tr nch too) . They he ve
a . 11pply of ga. that Nil) meet your , ·or t, with plea -[...]-Jim , nnin

(The for going prophcc_ y written on . ·ew Yca[...]

They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (309)308 THEY GAZED ON THE BEARTOOTHS

Where the Lime tone School Was Built
Its fir t ro ter includ d th kids from the Hudson, Lowe,
Wright, Fry and Hawkes families mentioned in the poem.

LI[...]

They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (310) THEY GAZED ON THE BEARTOOTHS 309

Buildings of Limestone Schoolhouse Your h art at[...]ded ubscrib d not ' n a nt,
By the Creator' mighty hand H aid[...]Much mon y I h v ·p nt.
With an allotted piece of land. Oh, Dudl y Whit I gu you'r right,
Up the river let us wander E onom[...]That a schoolhouse they'd erect The choolhouse which you now d mand
And, of course, they were divided May materialize, aft r all.
On the location to select
There's Hicks, Hawks, Lowe, Br[...]Lime tone, Mont.
of them
Bob Hudson said now I'll subscribe a twenty
spot
And deed an acre of the land I've got[...]" b aroka"
Then up spake Hicks so loud and bold
The same will come from me. C[...]Hawks, said when his beep \i ere the black mountain rav n.)
sold[...]ifty mil a th b aroka fli v ith
Would do the same, said he. rav n wing
The neighbors Ii ing on the er k To the wickiup wh r "\ hit D r" Ii
All tried to help it,[...]• . i . . 'fl .
load of logs that ay[...]t r
On the choolmam e ery da .[...]Th ,
For the choolhou ought to b at ye Th pal[...]Th north v i p d
But Low of cour e, h could not pay n "\ rhit[...]_ rro kn v,m)
nd both of ou do ur I try[...]

They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (311)310 THEY G ZED 0 THE BEARTOOTHS

TH DEDI[...]

They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (312)[...]THEY GAZED ON THE BEARTOOTHS 311

The Stillwater County Historical Gallery

Perhaps the most outstanding attraction in tillwat r County i the till-
water County Historical Gallery. This di play is hous d in the olumbu ivic
Center, which is one of the rooms in the city hall. 900 pictur ar placed
upon the walls of the 24 x 60 r creation room and another 1200 are secu[...]mes, twelve in number each carrying 100 picture . The subjects
have all been enlarged to a uniform[...]is encased in
a plastic, near dustproof envelope. The 2100 sel ction , as made from an e ti-
mated 10,0[...]rawings and even
daguerrotypes. ome of these originals were ov r 100 years old. Endl ss varieties
of subjects are on exhibition - individuals, family[...]ands, roundups, scenery, etc.

Three sons of the pioneer enator J. B.[...]proj ct
possible. nd by way of celebrating the 50th birthday of tillwat r aunty,
which was 1963, the gallery wa pr ented to th r ident of th county
through the board of county commi ion r July , l , as birthday pr nt.
The City of olumbu urr nd r cl thi[...]o to fi o'clock in th
afternoon of ach \ k • Ionday throu ,h[...]ran f rr d to th count library
in the court hou .

r l of th pictur ha b n u d in th[...]im
nnin . n profit from th al of boo . ab th of printin nd di tri-
bution, will b[...]land out ide th ounty, but lying within the

They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (313)[...]THEY GAZED ON THE BEARTOOTHS[...]Index
For the purpose of aving space, the names of child en in school, church or[...]name; and maiden name
of girl , in the identifications.

" BRO C TO BRE KF ST" ----[...]_ _ _____ ______ _ _ __ _ _ _ ______ 3S
B G LI IT OF G E[...]

They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (314)[...]THEY GAZED ON THE BEARTOOTHS[...]
They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (315)[...]THEY GAZED ON THE BEARTOOTHS

DIX SON. L. Doane -------------[...]·-··◄·····-··--·-·--3 9
DUNN. Loui (TheOFof -----··-----·--··--·-·-·--···--[...]

They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (316)[...]THEY GAZED 0 THE BEARTOOTHS[...]
They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (317)[...]THEY GAZED ON THE BEARTOOTHS

LU E . Lee ······[...]5 - 7 5 · 7 8-7 9. 8 6- 8 7 MOLT , Town of ···················-·····[...].... ....... 25 -227 P RK CITY . Sketch of -······· ·--···-······-·[...]

They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (318)[...]THEY GAZED ON THE BEARTOOTHS[...]-----· _ 99
R PELJE. To n of _________________________________ 43 -4[...]
They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (319)[...]THEY GAZED ON THE BEART OO T HS

' L\ I ON O:'\. . ive rt ---[...]________ . ____________ 101-174-175
" TRIKE -O t -THE -HE D' ' _ .. . _ --·--·-·· ... _____ 13 5 ' 'WEELU . THE LITTLE MOO " ___________ 111 thru 114
,' TRO ER .[...].... -·----·-·- 203
T BLF OF r.o TENTS[...]156
' 'THE VIRGJ IA "[...]

They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (320)[...]THEY GAZED ON THE BEARTOOTHS[...]

MD

Volume 2 of 3. Stillwater County history, stories, legends, e[...]rks projects, important events, and excerpts from The Columbus News, including photographs and index
Local Histories of Montana
Local Histories of Montana
MHS County Histories PDF/They Gazed on the Beartooths_V2.pdf
They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 1
They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 3

Annin, James T., b. 1890, They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (1964). Montana History Portal, accessed 13/03/2025, https://www.mtmemory.org/nodes/view/5613

They Gazed on the Beartooths, Volume 2 (2025)

References

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Recommended Articles
Article information

Author: Delena Feil

Last Updated:

Views: 5714

Rating: 4.4 / 5 (45 voted)

Reviews: 92% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Delena Feil

Birthday: 1998-08-29

Address: 747 Lubowitz Run, Sidmouth, HI 90646-5543

Phone: +99513241752844

Job: Design Supervisor

Hobby: Digital arts, Lacemaking, Air sports, Running, Scouting, Shooting, Puzzles

Introduction: My name is Delena Feil, I am a clean, splendid, calm, fancy, jolly, bright, faithful person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.